For individuals seeking a supportive and budget-friendly approach to weight loss, the TOPS (Take Off Pounds Sensibly) diet plan presents itself as a viable option. This non-profit organization distinguishes itself through a community-based support system and a flexible approach to dieting. Let's delve into the details of the TOPS program, exploring its features, benefits, and potential drawbacks, to help you determine if it aligns with your weight loss goals.
What is the TOPS Diet Plan?
TOPS, an acronym for "Take Off Pounds Sensibly," is a non-profit, low-cost weight loss program that has been around since 1948. It operates through a network of local chapters, primarily in the United States and Canada, providing a community-based support system for individuals striving to manage their weight. With approximately 10,000 local chapters worldwide, TOPS offers weekly support meetings where members can weigh in, share experiences, and exchange recipes.
Membership and Structure
Becoming a TOPS member involves a nominal annual fee of $24, in addition to local chapter dues. This grants access to weekly meetings and a subscription to TOPS News, a monthly magazine featuring contests, weight-loss incentives, self-help articles, and recipes. Although the membership base primarily consists of older adults, TOPS welcomes individuals of all ages, including children and teenagers.
The organization's structure relies heavily on volunteerism, with chapter leaders emerging from the TOPS membership. This grassroots approach fosters a sense of community and shared responsibility. TOPS also extends its reach through online resources, providing members with convenient access to support and information.
Support and Incentives
TOPS distinguishes itself through its emphasis on group support and incentives. Weekly meetings commence with a confidential weigh-in, followed by programs that often include presentations by volunteer health professionals. These meetings provide a platform for members to connect, share challenges, and learn from one another.
Read also: Practical Considerations for Compression Tops
To further motivate members, TOPS incorporates weight-loss competitions at both the national and local chapter levels. These contests add an element of fun and friendly competition, encouraging members to stay committed to their goals.
Dietary Approach
One of the defining characteristics of TOPS is its lack of a rigid diet plan. Unlike many commercial weight loss programs, TOPS does not prescribe specific calorie intakes or meal plans. Instead, it empowers members to chart their own course toward weight loss, emphasizing the importance of making informed dietary choices. While this freedom may appeal to some, it also carries the risk of ill-informed dieters potentially cutting back too far on calories or following an unbalanced diet. It is always a good idea, however, to take a calcium and vitamin D supplement, since it's tough to include enough calcium-rich dairy foods in a 1,200- or 1,500-calorie diet.
Many members follow the Food Exchange System, created by the American Diabetic Association.
Effectiveness and Safety
Due to the absence of a standardized TOPS diet, experts find it challenging to definitively assess the program's safety and effectiveness. However, there is no evidence to suggest that the program is inherently unsafe, and it may prove beneficial for certain individuals.
Research suggests that consistent participation in the TOPS program can lead to modest weight loss and maintenance. One study indicated that individuals who participate in TOPS for at least one year can lose up to 5-7% of their initial weight and maintain the weight loss for up to seven years.
Read also: Is TOPS Right for You?
TOPS vs. Other Weight Loss Programs
Compared to commercial programs like Weight Watchers (WW), TOPS offers a more affordable and less structured approach. While WW provides a comprehensive points-based system and structured meetings led by paid staff, TOPS relies on member-led support and a flexible dietary approach.
The choice between TOPS and other weight loss programs ultimately depends on individual preferences and needs. Those who thrive in structured environments and appreciate detailed guidance may find WW or similar programs more suitable. Conversely, individuals who prefer a more self-directed approach and value community support may find TOPS to be a better fit.
Additional Weight Loss Programs
For comparison, it is useful to consider some other weight loss programs available.
WeightWatchers (WW)
WeightWatchers assigns every food a "Point value" based on calories, protein, added sugar, saturated fat, unsaturated fat and fiber. Foods higher in protein, unsaturated fat, and fiber will be fewer Points, while foods higher in calories, added sugar and saturated fat will be more Points. All members receive a personalized Points Budget, calculated based on their individual metabolic rate, determined by age, height, weight, sex assigned at birth and goals. Participants need to stay within their points budget to lose weight.
Pros:
Read also: Comprehensive TOPS Review
- No food or beverages are off limits
- Easier than other programs to sustain long term
- Personalized nutrition counseling with dietitians and in-app social network
- Food scanner and recipe analyzer
- 24/7 virtual chat to share tips, recipes and solutions for common challenges
Cons:
- Weekly recommended weight checks may feel stressful
- Possibly too lenient for some people struggling with self-control
- Food-tracking and counting points can feel time-consuming
- Regular changes to program due to changing science may feel frustrating
Mayo Clinic Diet
The Mayo Clinic Diet focuses on eating healthy foods by teaching how to estimate portion sizes and plan meals while increasing physical activity. The diet is divided into two phases: The first is called “Lose It!” and the second is called “Live It!” In the two-week ‘Lose It!’ phase, participants change 15 habits, and in the ‘Live It!’ phase, people take these habits and turn them into a long-term change program. The program now offers eight meal plans to personalize the weight loss journey, including a “freestyle” plan, as well as Mediterranean, protein, keto, vegetarian and one for those on GLP-1s. One new feature is the Mayo Clinic Diet Score, a 100-point scoring system based on your current habits and behaviors. The higher your score, the more potential for weight loss over the long term.
Jenny Craig
Jenny Craig users first choose among several meal plans, including: Jenny Craig plan: two-week shipments of meals under 300 calories, including 14 breakfasts, 14 lunches, 14 dinners and 14 snacks and deserts. You can either customize or choose from customer favorites. Club Jenny: a “DIY” choice that gives full access to the Jenny Craig plan, complementing those who choose their own weight loss methods, like intermittent fasting and low carb. Meal Delivery Plan: 14 breakfasts and 14 entrées every two weeks, plus full access to Club Jenny for six months.
Nutrisystem
Nutrisystem delivers meals and snacks to your home. You then follow their app to know exactly what to eat and when (usually six times a day, which includes “grocery add-ins,” like low-fat plain yogurt and apple slices. They have three plans: Nutrisystem Program, with the option of “chef choices” or a more customizable option. People get meals (breakfasts, lunches, dinners and snacks) five to seven days a week. Meal Delivery Plans, including four main options: high protein (up to 30 grams of protein per meal), low carb (less than 25 grams carbohydrates per meal), menopause and balanced (by Jenny Craig - each meal is less than 300 calories). Each plan includes 14 ready-to-eat meals every week plus expert support. Club Advantage Membership, the most personalized option. People can purchase any amount of meals that fits their approach to weight loss.
Tips for Success with Any Weight Loss Program
- Choose a Program That Appeals to You: Look for plans that include foods you enjoy, but make sure the plans are balanced with enough nutrients, according to Mayo Clinic guidelines.
- Set Goals and Track What You Are Eating: Effective programs provide nutrition skills, and help you set weight, activity and energy intake, and make it reasonably easy to track your behavior against your goals, including tracking everything you eat.
- Consider Counseling: Research shows that the most effective programs come with counselors who can help you build new diet and exercise habits.
- Make sure Registered Dietitians and Certified Obesity Specialists are Included: Programs should include guidance from licensed, registered dietitians - not just generic nutritionists.
- Include Physical Activity: Exercise helps to maintain a healthy weight and counters the loss in muscle mass that accompanies weight loss, according to Mayo Clinic.
- Consider GLP-1 Medications: Any legitimate medical weight loss program today should offer FDA-approved, brand-name GLP-1 therapies - like Wegovy or Zepbound - when appropriate. Only a qualified provider should prescribe these mediations, and they should be paired with structured monitoring and care.
- Have a Maintenance Plan: A comprehensive weight loss program aims not just for weight loss, but for sustainable weight management.