For many, the concept of weight loss seems simple: "Why don't they just eat less and exercise more?" However, this simplistic view, often based on the calories-in-vs.-calories-burned equation, fails to account for the complex biological and psychological factors at play. Research and real-world experiences reveal that the body fiercely resists weight loss, and the key to success lies in personalized strategies and a shift away from restrictive dieting.
The Biggest Loser: A Revealing Study
Kevin Hall, a scientist at the National Institutes of Health (NIH), was intrigued by the dramatic weight loss of contestants on The Biggest Loser. These individuals lost significant weight through punishing workouts and restrictive diets. However, Hall's study of 14 contestants revealed a disheartening truth: the body fights to regain lost weight.
Over time, 13 of the 14 contestants regained an average of 66% of the weight they had lost during the show, with four becoming heavier than before the competition. This phenomenon can be discouraging, leading to a sense of futility. Yet, understanding the underlying mechanisms is crucial, especially considering the high prevalence of overweight and obesity in America, which significantly increases the risk of serious health problems.
The Shifting Landscape of Weight-Loss Research
The weight-loss industry is a $66.3 billion market. Leading researchers now agree that exercise, while vital for overall health, is not a reliable method for long-term weight management. The simplistic calories-in-vs.-calories-out model has been replaced by a more nuanced understanding of the importance of diet composition in sustaining weight loss.
Individual responses to different diets vary significantly. Some individuals thrive on low-carb diets, while others find success with low-fat or vegan approaches. Frank Sacks, a weight-loss researcher at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, emphasizes the importance of understanding these individual differences to better assist people in their weight-loss journeys. The key to weight loss appears to be highly personalized strategies rather than trendy diets. While weight loss is challenging, it is achievable with the right approach.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
A Historical Perspective on Dieting
Dieting has been a long-standing preoccupation in America. In the 1830s, Sylvester Graham promoted a vegetarian diet devoid of spices, condiments, and alcohol. Horace Fletcher, at the turn of the 20th century, advised chewing food until it liquefied. During global food shortages, the American government introduced its first "scientific diet," emphasizing calorie counting.
The emphasis on low-calorie meals became prevalent as thinness gained popularity. Jean Nidetch, a New York housewife, founded Weight Watchers, a company that turned her and her co-founders into millionaires by 1968. The core principle remained: eat fewer calories to lose weight. Even the low-fat craze, based on the idea that eating fat leads to weight gain, relied on calorie counting.
However, the low-fat trend coincided with weight gain in the population. By 2010, most states reported obesity rates of 25% or higher, which has now swelled to 40% of the adult population. Research is beginning to explain why.
The Body's Resistance to Weight Loss
Hall's research highlights that more than 80% of people with obesity regain lost weight. This is partly due to the slowing of resting metabolism after weight loss, a possible evolutionary adaptation to food scarcity.
What surprised Hall was that even when contestants regained weight, their metabolism remained low, burning approximately 700 fewer calories per day than before their weight loss. This metabolic adaptation also occurs in individuals who lose weight through more conventional methods, with most regaining pounds at a rate of 2 to 4 lb. per year.
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
These findings suggest that biology, not just willpower, plays a significant role in the difficulty of losing weight and maintaining weight loss. However, a slower metabolism is not the only factor at play.
Success Stories and Personalized Approaches
Despite the biological challenges, many people successfully lose weight and keep it off. The key is that success varies from person to person.
Hall notes that when individuals are randomly assigned to low-carb or low-fat diets, the average weight loss is similar between the groups. However, within each group, some individuals experience significant success, while others see no change or even gain weight.
Understanding what makes a diet effective for a specific individual is the ultimate goal of weight-loss science. Rena Wing, a professor at Brown University, runs the National Weight Control Registry (NWCR) to study individuals who have successfully lost weight and maintained the loss.
To be included in the registry, a person must have lost at least 30 lb. and maintained the weight loss for a year or longer. The registry now includes over 10,000 people with an average weight loss of 66 lb. per person, maintained for more than five years.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
A significant finding from the registry is that individuals achieve weight loss in different ways. About 45% of participants followed diets independently, while 55% used structured weight-loss programs. Most had to try multiple diets before finding one that worked.
Common strategies among those in the registry include modifying their diet, reducing daily food intake, and increasing physical activity, with walking being the most popular exercise.
Wing emphasizes that there is no magic formula. Some people prioritize exercise, while others follow low-carb or low-fat diets. The common thread is making changes in everyday behaviors.
Most participants eat breakfast daily, weigh themselves weekly, limit television viewing to less than 10 hours per week, and exercise for about an hour a day. Motivation often stems from health concerns or the desire to spend more time with loved ones, rather than solely focusing on a slimmer waistline.
The researchers at the NWCR believe that success is not due to genetics or personality traits, but rather high motivation and persistence in trying different strategies until finding what works.
Hill states that losing weight and keeping it off is challenging but achievable. The encouraging lesson from the registry is that no two individuals achieve weight loss in the same way.
The Bariatric Medical Institute: A Personalized Approach
The Bariatric Medical Institute in Ottawa adopts a personalized approach to weight loss. Individuals start with a standard six-month diet and exercise plan but are encouraged to customize it with the help of a physician to discover what works best for them. The program considers behavior, psychology, and budget, not just biology.
Dr. Yoni Freedhoff, the clinic's medical director, emphasizes adjusting the plan based on individual struggles. Jody Jeans, an IT project manager, lost 75 lb. over five years by focusing on portion sizes, meal tracking, and frequent, smaller meals. She avoided relying on bland diet staples and ensured she consumed enough protein and fiber.
A March 2017 study revealed that internalizing weight stigma can hinder weight loss maintenance. Experts recommend focusing on health goals rather than just the number on the scale.
Natalie Casagrande followed a similar program, highlighting the importance of personalized support and strategies.
Autumn Diet Traps and FDA Recommendations
The fall season can present challenges to maintaining a diet. Michele Promaulayko, Yahoo Health’s editor in chief, offers tips to avoid weight gain during this time.
Shorter days can lead to lower serotonin levels and increased cravings. Instead of reaching for bread, opt for starchy vegetables like sweet potatoes and squash. Seasonal drinks like pumpkin spice lattes can contain hundreds of calories. Choose flavored teas or order smaller lattes with less syrup and no whipped cream. Tailgating during football season can lead to overconsumption of beer, chips, and chicken wings. Setting smart limits is crucial.
The FDA emphasizes that losing weight requires burning more calories than consumed. Very low-calorie diets are dangerous and should only be followed under medical supervision. Gradual weight loss is healthier and easier to maintain.
The FDA recommends consulting a professional, eating smaller portions, consuming a variety of foods, eating fiber-rich foods, and reducing high-fat foods.
Perfectionism and Cognitive Behavior Therapy (CBT)
Perfectionism in health and dieting involves the belief that actions must be performed perfectly or not at all, leading to extreme responses after slips. Dr. Lucy Burns and Dr. Mary Barson advocate for avoiding restriction or fasting after overeating and instead ensuring adequate nutrition with protein, fat, and greens.
They recommend rewarding positive choices with non-food rewards and transforming experiences into learning opportunities through self-reflection with compassion.
Dr. Burns uses the "Fluffy" metaphor to explain sugar cravings, noting that low carbohydrate intake quiets mental noise. Managing emotions without food is essential. Intentional eating involves choosing to have something without emotional response and being able to intentionally not have it the next day.
For unintentional slips, avoid restricting the next day and instead focus on protein, fat, and greens. Address underlying emotions and reward the brain for making healthy choices with non-food rewards.
Mental Health Considerations
A study published in BMJ Nutrition, Prevention & Health found that calorie-restricted diets can negatively impact mental health, particularly in men and overweight individuals. The study revealed that calorie-restricted dieters scored higher on depression scales.
The researchers caution that the mental health consequences of dietary restriction should be considered, especially for men and overweight patients.
The Diet Trap Solution: A CBT Approach
The Diet Trap Solution focuses on CBT psychology to address the behaviors that cause overeating. It identifies common traps such as emotional eating, stress, food pushers, family issues, travel, holidays, psychological factors, and getting off track.
The book guides readers to become aware of their situations and decisions and make better choices to avoid sabotaging long-term weight loss goals. It encourages readers to analyze situations and create reminder cards with advantages, sabotaging thoughts, and strategies.
The book emphasizes the importance of a reasonable, flexible, and nutritious diet for long-term success.