The world of diet soda is vast, with options constantly vying for the attention of health-conscious consumers and those simply seeking a sugar-free alternative to classic favorites. Diet Coke, ranking fifth among all top-selling sodas, holds a significant place in the market, following regular Coca-Cola, Dr Pepper, Sprite, and Pepsi. Given Diet Coke's popularity, it's no surprise that other companies attempt to replicate its success. Aldi's Summit Diet Cola has emerged as a contender, sparking curiosity and claims of being an even better, cheaper alternative. This review delves into a detailed comparison between Summit Diet Cola and Diet Coke, examining taste, price, and overall value to determine if it lives up to the hype.
The Quest for a Diet Coke Alternative
The search for the perfect Diet Coke substitute is driven by both taste and budget. Many seek a similar flavor profile at a more affordable price point. The allure of a "dupe" that tastes even better than the original is a strong motivator for adventurous soda drinkers.
A Brief History of Diet Soda
In the early 1960s, the Coca-Cola Company embarked on developing a diet soft drink, resulting in Tab, which remained available for decades. Diet Coke eventually surpassed Tab in popularity, leading Coca-Cola to discontinue its first diet drink in 2020. The debate continues whether diet soft drinks aid weight loss. Some research suggests that diet soda drinkers are more likely to gain weight.
Summit Diet Cola: An Aldi Regular Buy
Summit Diet Cola is an Aldi Regular Buy, consistently available in stores. It comes in 6-pack of 7.5-ounce cans and 12-pack of 12-ounce cans. Smaller cans are a recent trend among soft drink makers, and they have been a sales boon for soft drink companies.
Price Comparison
Price is a significant factor for many consumers. The 7.5-ounce cans are currently $2.69, or 6 cents an ounce, while the 12-ounce cans are currently $3.49, or 2.5 cents an ounce. The 12-pack of 12-ounce cans is more expensive in total but cheaper per ounce, while the 6-pack of 7.5-ounce cans is more expensive per ounce but cheaper in total. When working on this piece, Summit Diet Cola was available at my Aldi for $4.69 for a 12-pack of 12-ounce cans.
Read also: Summit Chiropractic: Holistic wellness solutions.
Diet Coke's price varies depending on sales and retailers. At a local Kroger, a buy two, get three free weekend sale resulted in a price of $4.39 per 12-pack of 12-ounce cans, based on a regular price of $10.99. Walmart had 24-packs of Diet Coke cans for $13.78, making a 12-pack $6.89. Costco had 35-packs of cans for $19.85, which would leave you paying around $6.60 per 12-pack.
Nutritional Information
Nutritionally, Summit Diet Cola contains zero calories, 20mg of sodium, and zero carbs. Instead of sugar, the cola contains aspartame, a common sugar substitute sold under brands like NutraSweet and Equal.
Taste Test: Summit Diet Cola vs. Diet Coke
The ultimate test lies in the taste. A taste test was conducted, comparing Summit Diet Cola and Diet Coke in various conditions: chilled, over ice, and straight from the can, with side-by-side sips for accurate comparison.
Summit Diet Cola Flavor Profile
The initial impression of Summit Diet Cola is a sweet cloud covering the palate, accompanied by strong carbonation. An overly obvious citrus taste, reminiscent of lemon and lime with a hint of vanilla, is present. The sweetness tastes artificial and lingers long after the citrus, spice, or carbonation fades. While not offensive, the sweetness is more pronounced than necessary, making it a generic interpretation of a familiar flavor.
Diet Coke Flavor Profile
Diet Coke offers a layered experience with flavors and carbonation cascading across the taste buds. A blanket of caramel provides a soft, lush, and slightly sweet base. A hint of citrus complements the spicy aesthetic without overpowering it. The sweetness is a welcome guest, balanced within the flavor journey. The flavors of Diet Coke appear deliberately refined, balanced on rich fizz that teases the taste buds. The flavors and slight burn of carbonation linger momentarily before fading.
Read also: Medical Weight Loss Guide
Comparative Analysis
Summit Diet Cola's flavors are more audacious compared to Diet Coke. They go too far, becoming too artificial and sweet. While both sodas share a citrus component, artificial sweetness, and caramel aesthetic, Diet Coke remains subdued in all its flavors and maintains a refreshing quality.
Expert and Consumer Opinions
One tester, a big diet cola drinker, found the Aldi version to be a good, close approximation to name brands, with minimal discernible difference. Joshua, the Co-founder of Aldi Reviewer, considers Summit Diet Cola a viable alternative for a diet cola fix without name-brand prices.
However, another reviewer found Summit Diet Cola noticeably different, with flavors that were too artificial and sweet compared to the refined and balanced taste of Diet Coke. This reviewer stated that Diet Coke remained subdued in all its flavors and maintained a refreshing quality that was enjoyable rather than complicated.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet