In the realm of dietary patterns, the Mediterranean diet and the paleo diet stand out as two popular choices, each with its own set of principles and purported health benefits. While both emphasize minimally processed foods, they differ significantly in the specific food groups they encourage and restrict. This article delves into a detailed comparison of these two diets, exploring their foundations, similarities, differences, potential health effects, and practical considerations.
Understanding the Mediterranean Diet
The Mediterranean diet is not a rigid set of rules but rather a way of eating inspired by the traditional cuisines of countries bordering the Mediterranean Sea, such as Greece, Italy, Southern France, and Spain. It emphasizes flavorful, whole foods like vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains, seafood, nuts, seeds, and olive oil. Animal products like dairy and eggs are consumed in moderation, and red wine is often enjoyed in small amounts. Conversely, the Mediterranean diet discourages red meat, refined grains, added sugars, and ultra-processed foods.
The Mediterranean diet is associated with a range of health benefits, including promoting heart health, supporting brain function, and stabilizing blood sugar levels. The Mediterranean diet emphasizes foods and general eating guidelines, rather than numbers and calories. Remember that choosing an eating pattern rooted in the principles of the Mediterranean diet doesn’t have to mean giving up your cultural foods. In fact, it’s important that your eating habits incorporate foods that are easy to access locally and meaningful to you culturally or personally.
Exploring the Paleo Diet
The paleo diet, also known as the Stone Age diet, caveman diet, or hunter-gatherer diet, encourages individuals to model their eating habits after what some believe our Paleolithic human ancestors consumed thousands of years ago. The basic concept is to consume whole, unprocessed foods and avoid foods that require processing. A paleo diet consists of lean meat, fish, vegetables, fruits, and nuts, while restricting grains, dairy, legumes, vegetable oils, added sugar, salt, and ultra-processed foods.
The paleo diet has gained traction in recent years. While their diets would have differed based on where our ancestors were located in the world, the basic concept is to eat whole foods and avoid foods that require processing. However, since Paleolithic humans thrived on various diets depending on geography and time, their eating patterns are hard to decipher. In fact, review of the paleo diet in 2018 found 14 different definitions of “paleo”.
Read also: Paleo Granola Recipes
Similarities Between the Mediterranean and Paleo Diets
Despite their differences, the Mediterranean and paleo diets share some fundamental similarities. Both emphasize the consumption of minimally processed foods, including fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and some meats. These diets fall into the same end of the NOVA spectrum, which classifies foods based on their level of processing, encouraging more unprocessed and minimally-processed options.
Another similarity is that neither diet requires strict tracking or calculation of portion sizes and numbers.
Key Differences Between the Mediterranean and Paleo Diets
The most significant difference between the two diets lies in their allowance of certain food groups. The paleo diet strictly excludes grains, legumes, and dairy, while the Mediterranean diet encourages the consumption of whole grains and legumes and allows for moderate amounts of dairy products like yogurt and cheese. Dairy, whole grains, and legumes are not inherently unhealthy - in fact, they contain important nutrients like calcium, vitamin B12, iron, magnesium, zinc, and protein, to name a few.
Cooking oils also differ, with the Mediterranean diet prioritizing olive oil while the paleo diet includes butter, lard, and coconut oil in addition to avocado and olive oil. The Mediterranean diet discourages saturated fats like lard, coconut oil, and butter.
Potential Health Effects
The Mediterranean and paleo diets may have different effects on health due to their varying food group restrictions and recommendations.
Read also: Paleo Diet Delivered: What You Need to Know
Blood Sugar Control
The Mediterranean diet has been extensively studied for its potential to improve blood sugar levels and reduce insulin resistance. Research suggests that it may be beneficial for preventing diabetes and metabolic syndrome. In comparison, a review of studies concluded that the Mediterranean diet was more effective at reducing fasting blood glucose and A1c in those with type 2 diabetes than the paleo diet. It’s important to note that those who followed a paleo diet experienced significantly lowered blood sugars as well.
However, the evidence for the paleo diet's effect on blood sugar is mixed, with some studies showing positive results while others find no significant changes.
Heart Health
The Mediterranean diet is widely recognized as heart-healthy due to its emphasis on whole grains, legumes, nuts, seeds, fruits, and vegetables, which are all high in fiber. A diet rich in whole grains and legumes is shown to reduce heart disease risk and improve metabolic health outcomes.
For the paleo diet, the results are unclear. A review of studies found a link between the paleo diet and improvements in heart health markers like blood pressure, cholesterol, and triglycerides. However, researchers emphasized the studies were not well-designed, so more evidence is needed. Research also suggests that those who followed the paleo diet for more than one year experienced unfavorable gut microbiota changes. Specifically, TMAO - a metabolite derived from gut bacteria and a predictor for future risk of heart disease - was found to have increased. This could be from the lower overall fiber, since the paleo diet restricts legumes and whole grains.
Inflammation
Despite popular claims, there is limited evidence to support the idea that either diet significantly affects inflammation levels. Some studies suggest that both the Mediterranean and paleo diets are linked to lower levels of inflammation and oxidative stress. However, other research has found mixed results or no significant effects on inflammatory markers.
Read also: Paleo Mayonnaise Recipe
Restrictiveness and Potential Drawbacks
The paleo diet is more restrictive than the Mediterranean diet, which can lead to potential drawbacks. Restrictive diets can increase the risk of disordered eating habits, bingeing, and an unhealthy obsession with eating "clean," known as orthorexia nervosa. Food restrictions can also cause social isolation and loneliness, as eating with others is a bonding experience across cultures. Finally, food restriction reduces food variety, which may be important for ensuring adequate nutrient intake.
Practical Considerations
When choosing between the Mediterranean and paleo diets, it's essential to consider individual health goals, needs, preferences, and access to foods. For example, someone who prefers plant-based eating may find the paleo diet unsuitable. Conversely, someone with a legume intolerance may find it challenging to follow the Mediterranean diet.
The Mediterranean diet covers all the major food groups, making it more nutritious and wholesome than the paleo diet. The Mediterranean diet prioritizes olive oil, a source of heart-healthy fats. The Mediterranean diet is considered safe and is recommended by physicians to patients. The Mediterranean diet allows grains, legumes, dairy products, and moderate amounts of alcohol. The Mediterranean diet has several proven health benefits. “This program is a way of life, one which I have adopted successfully, and more importantly one which I have sustained for over one year now. My weight remains steady at 160 pounds (down from 216).
Following the paleo diet is more expensive than following the Mediterranean diet.
tags: #paleo #diet #vs #mediterranean #diet #comparison