The paleo diet, inspired by the eating habits of humans during the Paleolithic Era, emphasizes whole, unprocessed foods. This article explores the intricacies of the paleo diet, particularly focusing on the contentious issue of whether beans and legumes are permitted.
What is the Paleo Diet?
The paleo diet is an eating plan based on foods humans might have eaten during the Paleolithic Era. A modern paleo diet includes fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish, eggs, nuts, and seeds. These are foods that in the past people could get by hunting and gathering. It doesn't include foods that became more common when small-scale farming began about 10,000 years ago. The purpose of a paleo diet is to eat foods likely eaten by early humans. Farming made foods such as grains and legumes more easily available. And it introduced dairy. Also, farming changed the diets of animals that people ate. The paleo diet idea is that these changes in diet outpaced the human body's ability to change, or adapt.
Core Principles
At its core, the paleo diet promotes the consumption of:
- Unprocessed meats (beef, lamb, chicken, turkey, pork)
- Fish and seafood (salmon, trout, haddock, shrimp, shellfish - choose wild-caught if you can)
- Eggs (free-range, pastured, or omega-3 enriched)
- Vegetables (broccoli, kale, peppers, onions, carrots, tomatoes)
- Fruits (apples, bananas, oranges, pears, avocados, strawberries, blueberries)
- Nuts and seeds (almonds, macadamia nuts, walnuts, hazelnuts, sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds)
- Healthy fats and oils (extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil)
- Salt and spices (sea salt, garlic, turmeric, rosemary)
Foods to Avoid
Conversely, the paleo diet typically excludes:
- Processed foods
- Added sugar (soft drinks, fruit juices, table sugar, candy, pastries, ice cream)
- Grains (bread, pasta, wheat, cereal, spelt, rye, barley)
- Most dairy products (especially low-fat dairy)
- Legumes (beans, lentils)
- Some vegetable oils (soybean oil, sunflower oil, cottonseed oil, corn oil, grapeseed oil, safflower oil)
- Artificial sweeteners (aspartame, sucralose, cyclamates, saccharin, acesulfame potassium)
The Great Legume Debate
One of the most debated aspects of the paleo diet is the exclusion of legumes, which include beans, lentils, and peanuts. The reasoning behind this exclusion stems from the belief that legumes contain "antinutrients" like lectins and phytic acid, which can potentially harm human health.
Read also: Paleo Granola Recipes
Antinutrients in Legumes
Lectins: All beans and legumes are concentrated sources of lectins. Lectins are potent antinutrients that plants have evolved as toxins to ward off predators. Remember, raw or undercooked kidney beans cause severe cases of food poisoning in humans and were lethally toxic in rats. Although several kidney bean antinutrients probably contributed to these poisonous effects, animal experiments indicate that a specific lectin found in kidney beans was the major culprit. Kidney beans and all other varieties of beans (black beans, kidney beans, pinto beans, string beans, navy beans etc.) within the Phaseolus vulgaris species contain a lectin called phytohemagglutinin (PHA). The more PHA we ingest, the more ill we become. This is why raw beans are so toxic - they contain much higher concentrations of PHA than cooked beans. The trick with lectins is that they must bypass our intestinal wall and enter into our bloodstream if they are to wreak havoc within our bodies. So far, no human studies of PHA have ever been conducted. However, in laboratory animals, PHA easily breeches the gut barrier and enters into the bloodstream where it may travel to many organs and tissues and disrupt normal cell function and cause disease. Human and animal tissue experiments reveal that PHA and other food lectins can cause a “leaky gut” and enter circulation. A leaky gut represents one of the first steps implicated in many autoimmune diseases.
Saponins: Saponins are antinutrients found in almost all legumes and have soap-like properties that punch holes in the membranes lining the exterior of all cells. As was the case with lectins, this effect is dose dependent - meaning that the more saponins you ingest, the greater will be the damage to your body’s cells. Human tissue and animal studies confirm that legume saponins can easily disrupt the cells lining our intestines and rapidly make their way into our bloodstream. Once in the bloodstream in sufficient quantities, saponins can then cause ruptures in our red blood cells in a process known as hemolysis which can then temporarily impair our blood’s oxygen carrying capacity. In the long term, the major threat to our health from legume saponins stems not from hemolysis (red blood cell damage) but rather from their ability to increase intestinal permeability. A leaky gut likely promotes low level inflammation because it allows toxins and bacteria in our guts to interact with our immune system. This process is known to be is a necessary first step in autoimmune diseases and may promote the inflammation necessary for heart disease and the metabolic syndrome to develop and progress. The other major problem with legume saponins is that cooking does not destroy them. In fact, even after extended boiling for two hours, 85-100% of the original saponins in most beans and legumes remain intact.
Phytate: Because phytate prevents the full absorption of iron, zinc, calcium, magnesium and copper present in legumes and whole grains, then reliance upon these plant foods frequently causes multiple nutritional deficiencies in adults, children and even nursing infants. Boiling and cooking don’t seem to have much effect upon the phytate content of legumes, whereas sprouting and fermentation can moderately reduce phytate concentrations. Also, vitamin C counteracts phytate’s inhibitory effects on mineral absorption.
Polyphenols: Polyphenols are antioxidant compounds that protect plants from UV sunlight damage as well as from insects, pests and other microorganisms. Just like sunscreens protect our skin from UV damage, polyphenols are one of the compounds plants have evolved to escape the harmful effects of ultraviolet (UV) radiation from the sun, along with damage caused by animal and microorganism predators. Polyphenols come in many different varieties and forms and are common throughout the plant kingdom. When we eat these compounds, they seem to have both healthful and detrimental effects in our bodies. Tannins are similar to phytate in that they reduce protein digestibility and bind iron and other minerals, thereby preventing their normal absorption. Some, but not all tannins damage our intestines causing a “leaky gut”. Isoflavones are some of nature’s weirder plant compounds in that they act like female hormones in our bodies. Certain isoflavones which are concentrated in soybeans and soy products are called phytoestrogens - literally meaning, “plant estrogens”. Isoflavones from soy products can cause goiters (an enlargement of the thyroid gland), particularly if your blood levels of iodine are low. Two phytoestrogens in soy called genistein and daidzen produce goiters in experimental animals. In a study of elderly subjects, Dr. For women, regular intake of soy or soy isoflavones may disrupt certain hormones that regulate the normal menstrual cycle. In a meta analysis of 47 studies, Dr. Hooper and co-workers demonstrated that soy or soy isoflavones consumption caused two female hormones, follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH), to fall by 20%. In one study, seven of nine women who consumed vegetarian diets (containing significant quantities of legumes) for only six weeks stopped ovulating.
Protease inhibitors: When we eat any protein, we have enzymes in our intestines w…
Read also: Paleo Diet Delivered: What You Need to Know
Counterarguments and Considerations
Despite these concerns, there are compelling arguments for including legumes in a healthy diet:
- Nutrient Density: Legumes are packed with essential nutrients, including fiber, protein, iron, zinc, and copper.
- Fiber Source: Legumes are an excellent source of fiber, which promotes digestive health and helps regulate blood sugar levels.
- Plant-Based Protein: For vegans and vegetarians, legumes serve as a primary source of protein.
- Preparation Methods: Soaking, sprouting, fermenting, and cooking can significantly reduce the levels of antinutrients in legumes, making them more digestible and their nutrients more bioavailable. Cooking legumes for as little as 15 minutes or pressure-cooking them for 7.5 minutes almost completely inactivates the lectins they contain, leaving no residual lectin activity in properly cooked legumes.
- Individual Tolerance: Some individuals may tolerate legumes better than others. Factors such as gut health and digestive capabilities can influence how the body responds to these foods.
- Evolutionary Evidence: Recent analysis of Neanderthal tooth plaque revealed that they consumed wild varieties of peas and fava beans. This research suggests that legumes are, in fact, “Paleo.”
Modified Paleo Approaches
Recognizing the potential benefits of legumes, some proponents of the paleo diet have adopted more flexible approaches:
- Primal Diet: This variant of the paleo diet allows for the inclusion of properly prepared legumes in moderation.
- Personalized Paleo: Some individuals tailor the paleo diet to their specific needs and tolerances, incorporating legumes if they are well-tolerated.
Paleo Diet: A Critical Look
While the paleo diet emphasizes whole foods and may offer health benefits, it's crucial to consider its limitations:
- Nutrient Deficiencies: Eliminating entire food groups like legumes, dairy, and grains can increase the risk of nutrient deficiencies.
- Digestive Issues: The high fiber content of the paleo diet can cause bloating and gastric distress in some individuals, especially when transitioning from a low-fiber diet.
- Sustainability: Sourcing wild game and grass-fed animals can be expensive and environmentally unsustainable.
- Historical Accuracy: There was no single Paleolithic diet. Diets varied wildly. Also, the plants and meat we eat today differ from those available to our ancestors. And the paleo diet bans legumes and grains, which some Paleolithic people did eat.
Sample Paleo Menu
Here is a sample paleo menu for one week, which can be adjusted based on individual preferences:
Monday
- Breakfast: Eggs and vegetables fried in olive oil, one piece of fruit
- Lunch: Chicken salad with olive oil, a handful of nuts
- Dinner: Burgers (no bun) fried in butter, vegetables, salsa
Tuesday
- Breakfast: Bacon, eggs, one piece of fruit
- Lunch: Leftover burgers from the night before
- Dinner: Baked salmon with vegetables
Wednesday
- Breakfast: Leftover salmon and vegetables from the night before
- Lunch: Sandwich in a lettuce leaf, with meat and fresh vegetables
- Dinner: Ground beef stir-fry with vegetables, berries
Thursday
- Breakfast: Eggs, one piece of fruit
- Lunch: Leftover stir-fry from the night before, a handful of nuts
- Dinner: Fried pork, vegetables
Friday
- Breakfast: Eggs and vegetables fried in olive oil, one piece of fruit
- Lunch: Chicken salad with olive oil, a handful of nuts
- Dinner: Steak, vegetables, sweet potatoes
Saturday
- Breakfast: Bacon, eggs, one piece of fruit
- Lunch: Leftover steak and vegetables from the night before
- Dinner: Baked tilapia, vegetables, avocado
Sunday
- Breakfast: Leftover salmon and vegetables from the night before
- Lunch: Sandwich in a lettuce leaf, with meat and fresh vegetables
- Dinner: Grilled chicken wings, vegetables, salsa
Read also: Paleo Mayonnaise Recipe