Obesity and overweight are significant global health concerns, contributing to a substantial burden of chronic diseases. Primary care physicians are uniquely positioned to address this issue, yet their involvement in weight management remains surprisingly low. This article explores the reasons behind this disparity and examines various approaches to weight management that can be implemented in primary care settings, drawing upon existing guidelines and research.
The Disconnect: Why Aren't Primary Care Physicians More Involved in Weight Loss?
Despite the clear link between excess weight and numerous health problems, several factors contribute to the reluctance of primary care physicians to actively engage in weight management. These include:
- Perception of the role: Physicians may not view weight management as their primary responsibility.
- Fear of offending patients: Raising the issue of weight can be a sensitive topic, and physicians may worry about damaging the patient-physician relationship.
- Lack of clarity on effective strategies: Physicians may be unsure about the best approaches to assist patients in losing weight.
- Time constraints: Routine consultations often last only a short time, making it difficult to address weight management comprehensively.
- Weight stigma: Clinicians are aware of weight stigma as a social process that can be internalized by their patients. They identify addressing obesity as a priority in their work but describe wanting to care for their patients by avoiding unnecessary suffering, which they were concerned could be caused by talking about weight. The practice of 'caring by not offering care' produces the outcome of an absence of weight management advice in consultations.
The Importance of Addressing Weight in Primary Care
Despite these challenges, there is a strong case for integrating weight management into primary care. Preventative medicine is a standard component of a physician's duties. Weight loss significantly improves health outcomes, including reduced mortality, improved lung function, lower blood pressure, and better lipid profiles. Even modest weight loss (5-10% of initial weight) can substantially reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes.
Given the high prevalence of overweight and obesity, primary care physicians encounter numerous patients who could benefit from weight loss interventions. In England, a physician with a patient list of 2000 adults will typically have 520 (26 %) patients who are obese (BMI ≥30 kg/m2), and 840 men and 640 women (42 % and 32 %, respectively) who are overweight (BMI 25.0-29.9 kg/m2).
Approaches to Weight Management in Primary Care
Several strategies can be employed to address weight management within the constraints of a primary care setting:
Read also: Personalized Weight Loss Programs
Brief Interventions
Brief interventions are opportunistic and delivered during a consultation about something else and where the practitioner takes the opportunity to raise a topic that is either unrelated to or not directly the topic of the current consultation. They take only a few minutes.
Brief Advice: This involves a single session aimed at increasing awareness of health risks. Survey data suggests that advice to lose weight by a physician is strongly associated with future weight loss ‘attempts’ for overweight and obese patients. The odds ratio for the association between physician intervention and an attempt to lose weight was 3.85 (95 % CI 2.71, 5.49; p < 0.01). Two studies suggested that people who received some kind of advice lost about 1-2 kg more than people who did not. Five other studies suggested that weight loss was more common in those who did receive an intervention.
However, it's important to note that these data are observational, and causality cannot be definitively established.
Motivational Interviewing: This collaborative, person-centered approach aims to elicit and strengthen motivation for change. It incorporates collaboration between the patient and physician, evoking the patient’s thoughts about behavior change, and encouraging the patient’s autonomy. While motivational interviewing can be effective for weight loss, it requires specialized skills and expertise, including training and ongoing supervision.
A systematic review of RCTs investigated the effectiveness of motivational interviewing versus control in overweight or obese adults. Follow-up ranged from 3-18 months. In the nine interventions tested in eight trials with weight change as the outcome, the mean reduction in weight was −1.47 kg [95 % CI −2.05, −0.88) kg.
Read also: Comprehensive Weight Loss
Primary Care-Led Weight Management Services
- In-house Programs: Physicians may refer patients to non-specialist healthcare professionals, such as nurses or healthcare assistants, for one-to-one reviews and behavioral weight management support.
Referral to Commercial Weight Management Companies
- Evidence of Effectiveness: Several randomized trials have demonstrated the effectiveness of referring patients to commercial weight management companies.
The Challenge of Patient Refusal
Guidelines recommend that clinicians should offer patients with obesity referrals to weight management services. However, clinicians and patients worry that such conversations will generate friction, and the risk of this is greatest when patients say no.
Some clinicians responded to refusals by delivering further information or offering referral again. These actions treated patient refusals as unwelcome, and acted to pursue acceptance instead. However, pursuit did not lead to acceptance. Rather, pursuing acceptance lengthened consultations and led to frustration, offence, or anger. Patient refusals have the potential to create negative consequences in the consultation and clinician responses were key in avoiding these.
Oxford Primary Care & Weight Loss Center: A Model for Integrated Care
The Oxford Primary Care & Weight Loss Center exemplifies a model for integrating weight management into primary care. The center offers a range of services, including:
- Annual Physicals
- Sports and Employment Physicals
- Full Laboratory Testing
- Adult Immunizations
- Preventive Health Care
- Weight Loss
- Non-Invasive Lipo
The center accepts most major insurance plans and offers special pricing for cash-paying patients. They emphasize personalized care based on individual health concerns.
Read also: Is the Carnivore Diet Right for You?