In communities across the United States, innovative approaches are emerging to combat food insecurity and promote healthier eating habits. Among these, the healthy food club model stands out as a promising solution. Food clubs are nonprofit, membership-based grocery stores that provide affordable access to nutritious food in a dignified and community-centered environment. This article delves into the benefits of healthy food clubs, exploring their unique features, impact on individuals and communities, and potential for growth.
Addressing Food Insecurity: A Multifaceted Approach
Food clubs tackle the critical issues of access and affordability that contribute to food insecurity. Traditional food pantries and banks play a vital role in emergency food assistance, but food clubs offer a more sustainable and empowering approach. By operating as membership-based grocery stores, food clubs provide a sense of normalcy and choice, allowing members to select foods that align with their preferences and dietary needs.
The Community Food Club in Grand Rapids, Michigan, exemplifies this approach. As a food bank on Division Avenue, it serves around 9,000 people each month. Perla Douglas, a mother of two, relies on the Community Food Club and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) to feed her family.
The Membership Model: Access and Affordability
The cornerstone of the food club concept is the membership model. Households pay a modest monthly fee, often on a sliding scale based on income and household size, to gain access to the store. This fee grants them a certain number of points, which they can use to purchase groceries.
Alma-Jean Fossel, executive director of the Community Food Club of Grand Rapids, explains that most members pay around $13 a month. Once they pay that fee, they receive points to shop with, and these points function like dollars in the store. Food clubs typically enroll members living at or below 200% of the Federal Poverty Level. For instance, a single individual with an income of $29,160 or less, or a family of four with an income of $60,000 or less, may qualify for membership.
Read also: Community Food Programs
The sliding scale membership fee ensures that the food club remains accessible to those who need it most, while also providing a sustainable source of revenue to support operations.
Point-Based Shopping System: Promoting Healthy Choices
Food clubs often utilize a point-based shopping system to encourage healthier food choices. Healthier items, such as fresh fruits and vegetables, are priced lower in points than less healthy alternatives, such as processed foods and snacks. This inverted pricing strategy incentivizes members to prioritize nutritious options and make informed decisions about their purchases.
The Saginaw Community Food Club in Michigan, which is based on the Grand Rapids model, will also use a point system. Fruits and vegetables will be labeled with the lowest point values, while snacks and processed foods will be listed higher.
Dignity and Empowerment: Restoring Choice and Autonomy
One of the most significant benefits of food clubs is the sense of dignity and empowerment they provide to their members. Unlike traditional food pantries, where individuals may feel like recipients of charity, food clubs offer a shopping experience that resembles a regular grocery store. Members have the autonomy to make their own choices and select the foods they want to feed their families.
Scott Rumpsa, chief executive officer of Community Action House in Holland, Michigan, recounts the story of John, a frequent pantry customer who regained his mobility after the organization transformed its emergency food pantry into a Food Club. John's transformation highlights the powerful impact of healthy food access on an individual's well-being and sense of self-worth.
Read also: Healthy food access with Highmark Wholecare explained.
Candace, a member of a food club, shared with Gronstal, "You have allowed me to be a fun mom again," emphasizing how the food club restored her ability to provide for her family and enjoy their time together. Her children perceive the food club as their favorite grocery store, unaware that it serves food-insecure families.
Community-Centered Operations: Building Resilience
Food clubs are deeply rooted in their communities and foster a sense of belonging and shared responsibility. Many food clubs are member-run, with members actively participating in the store's operations and decision-making processes. This collaborative approach fosters a sense of ownership and investment in the store's success.
Sourcing Food: A Multifaceted Approach
Food clubs employ a variety of strategies to source food, going beyond traditional food bank partnerships. They often collaborate with local farmers, producers, and retailers to obtain fresh, high-quality products. This approach not only supports local food systems but also reduces food waste by rescuing surplus food that would otherwise be discarded.
The Lakeshore Food Club in Ludington, Michigan, for example, purchases fresh fruits and vegetables from farmers in Mason, Oceana, and Muskegon counties. It also has a special relationship with Campbell Crossings Farm, which plants its crops based on the food club's customers' needs.
Community Action House in Holland has developed a large facility equipped to serve as a food hub for the region. In the last year, it rescued, sorted, and shared 3.7 million pounds of rescued food.
Read also: Healthy Eating on the Run
Beyond Food: Addressing Social Determinants of Health
Many food clubs recognize that food insecurity is often intertwined with other social determinants of health, such as housing, financial stability, and access to healthcare. To address these interconnected challenges, some food clubs offer co-located services, such as financial counseling, job training, and health screenings.
Community Action House in Holland, for instance, has developed an "Opportunity Hub" that connects members to services for housing, financial empowerment, and other social determinants of health.
Impact on Health Outcomes: Evidence-Based Results
Emerging evidence suggests that food clubs can have a positive impact on health outcomes, particularly for individuals with chronic diseases. By providing access to nutritious food and nutrition education, food clubs can help members manage their conditions and improve their overall well-being.
The Nutritional Options for Wellness (NOW) program in Kent County, Michigan, provides healthy foods, healthy living classes, and connections to other community food resources to low-income adults with chronic health conditions. Participants in the NOW program have reported improvements in overall health and healthy behaviors.
Connie, a NOW client with type 2 diabetes, shared that she lost 28 pounds and lowered her A1C levels after participating in the program. She also reported having more energy and less depression.
The Growing Food Club Landscape: A National Movement
The food club model is gaining momentum across the United States, with new clubs emerging in diverse communities. Organizations like The Bread and Butter Thing are bringing together key players in the affordable food club sector. While food clubs are seen as a positive step in addressing food insecurity by academics and supporters, they’re still under the radar for the food industry, government, and the general public.
In Michigan, the Food Club Network, which launched in 2023, provides resources and technical assistance to new and existing sites. The Health Fund supports the efforts of Michigan's food clubs and is helping the Food Club Network become an independent entity.
Challenges and Opportunities: Scaling the Impact
While food clubs offer a promising solution to food insecurity, they also face challenges. Securing sustainable funding, recruiting and retaining volunteers, and ensuring access to affordable, nutritious food are ongoing concerns. However, with continued innovation, collaboration, and community support, food clubs have the potential to scale their impact and transform food systems across the country.
Emma Garcia, co-executive director of Access of West Michigan, emphasizes the importance of listening to the community and building strong, trust-based partnerships. She also acknowledges the need to adapt and make changes based on evidence-based research and expertise from the medical field.