The quest for effective weight loss solutions has led many to explore various dietary approaches. Among these, the milkshake diet plan has gained attention for its convenience and potential to promote weight loss. This article delves into the milkshake diet plan, examining its benefits, risks, and how to follow it safely to benefit overall health.
Understanding the Milkshake Diet
Following a milkshake diet encourages weight loss by curbing appetite and reducing the total calories a person consumes in a day. The idea is that replacing meals with protein shakes can improve weight loss and muscle gain. While these diets can be effective in the short term, healthcare professionals do not recommend living solely or primarily on meal replacement shakes.
Liquid diets are nutrition programs that require you to get either some, most, or all of your daily calories from liquids, rather than solid foods. Some programs simply replace certain meals with liquids, while others replace all solid foods with liquids. While there are many liquid diets, most can be grouped into one of the following categories. Some liquid diets involve meal replacement shakes, which are consumed in place of solid foods. Numerous companies sell these shakes for weight loss purposes. Meal replacement shakes are often lower in calories than typical meals. They can replace one or multiple meals each day. Some weight loss programs use these shakes to account for your entire calorie intake for up to several months.
The Role of Protein
Protein helps build muscle and plays a vital role in cell function across the body. Protein needs will vary from person to person based on their weight and activity levels. Generally, however, the 2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines for Americans suggest that males over the age of 18 consume 56 grams (g) of protein per day, and that females consume 46 g. A person can easily obtain this amount from the diet by consuming beans, lentils, nuts, meat, eggs, and dairy products. Protein shakes aim to provide as much protein as food but with fewer calories. Some can even provide more protein than food. Protein shakes offer more than just protein. Manufacturers typically fortify them with a range of vitamins and minerals. They may also contain fruits, vegetables, and other nutrients. A 2016 meta-analysis linked protein consumption to increased feelings of fullness. People who include enough protein in their diets may therefore have fewer food cravings and eat less. Some may choose to get this protein through shakes.
Most protein-rich foods provide a wide variety of vitamins and minerals. Several of these nutrients - including B-complex vitamins, iron, choline, and zinc - are more difficult to get in adequate quantities from other sources. Other vital nutrients that some protein-rich foods provide significant amounts of include: vitamin E, magnesium, omega-3 fatty acids.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
Protein supports numerous vital functions in the body, including building and repairing the bones, muscles, and skin. It also helps the body create hormones and enzymes and metabolize vitamins. It is an essential part of a well-balanced and nutrient-dense diet that encourages good health.
Types of Protein Shakes
Protein consists of amino acids, and the best proteins are “complete.” This means that they contain all nine essential amino acids. Most protein shakes use one or more of the following six varieties: whey protein, casein protein, egg white protein, soy protein, plant protein, beef protein.
Benefits of Milkshake Diets
Weight Loss
Replacing some or all meals with liquid meal replacements can promote weight loss. Meal replacement shakes offer easily digestible nutrition for healing after illness or surgery when appetite is suppressed. They deliver precise calorie control (typically 150-400 calories per serving) and help create calorie deficits needed for sustainable weight loss.
Convenience and Time-Saving
Meal replacement shakes eliminate time spent on grocery shopping, cooking, and cleanup, while providing quick meal solutions for busy schedules. Preparing healthy meals can be time-consuming, which is a common barrier to losing weight. Meal replacements offer a simple, time-saving solution.
Nutrient Density
High-protein meal replacement shakes are effective, convenient and nutrient-rich and can help control hunger while supporting a balanced diet. Research shows that meal replacement diets, especially those rich in protein, can improve diet quality for individuals who are overweight or obese. For those struggling to maintain a balanced diet, meal replacements can help improve overall nutrition.
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
Appetite Control
Protein is the most satiating macronutrient - meaning that it keeps you feeling full for longer than carbohydrates or fats. Consistently getting the right amount of protein each day is crucial for controlling hunger. Satiety: Protein helps suppress appetite by reducing hunger hormones like ghrelin while increasing hormones that signal fullness. Calorie Burn: Protein has a high thermic effect, meaning that your body burns more calories digesting protein compared to carbs or fats. Lean Body Mass: When paired with resistance exercise, high-protein meal replacements help maintain or build lean muscle, which supports fat loss.
Risks and Considerations
Nutritional Completeness
Meal replacement shakes should not completely replace healthful, balanced diets. This is because it is difficult to get every nutrient from a single food source. Furthermore, a body that does not receive enough nutrients may experience problems with metabolism. This may slow or disrupt a weight loss plan. In fact, one 2015 study found that people who eat a varied diet are less likely to have obesity.
Sugar Content
Some protein shakes also use large quantities of sweetener to improve flavor, which can trigger blood sugar spikes. Even if they say they don't include artificial sweeteners, check the ingredients because they very often include plant-based sweeteners that are 350x sweeter than sugar! When tasting something sweet, the body automatically releases the hormone 'insulin' which prepares your body for the sugar it's about to digest. When that sugar doesn’t come (because you're consuming sweeteners in powder shakes), the body ends up with too little blood sugars due to the over production of insulin. Insulin resistance is caused by too high levels of insulin being produced over a long period of time, leading your body to become resistant to insulin and unable to use your blood glucose for energy. This leads to higher levels of blood glucose in your body, causing your pancreas to create more insulin and ultimately leading to type 2 diabetes. This is why the World Health Organisation recommend avoiding foods with sweeteners, such as meal replacement shakes.
Potential Contaminants
It is also important to avoid consuming too much protein powder in one day. A 2013 review of studies found that consuming more than the daily requirement of protein may lead to problems in the kidneys and bones, as well as increase the risk of cancer. A Consumer Reports analysis also found that some protein drinks have unsafe levels of contaminants. Three of the drinks that the consumer watchdog tested had high levels of the following contaminants, among others: mercury, arsenic, cadmium. People who drink three servings of these drinks each day could experience serious health consequences. In an additional eight of the drinks tested, lead levels were high enough to need a consumer warning in California. As nutritional supplements, protein shakes are subject to fewer regulations than medication in the United States. Consumer Reports argue that marketing materials for these products may also be misleading. Instead of protein shakes, they recommend eating protein-rich foods such as milk, lean meats, and eggs.
Digestive Issues
Many users experience stomach pain after protein shakes or meal replacements, particularly when first introducing them to their diet. Whey and casein proteins can trigger discomfort in people with undiagnosed dairy sensitivities. Plant proteins like pea or soy may cause similar reactions in sensitive individuals. Drinking shakes too quickly overloads your digestive system with concentrated nutrition. Many formulations contain added fibers that can cause gas and bloating when introduced suddenly. Ingredients like sorbitol and maltitol (common in low-sugar formulas) frequently cause digestive issues from meal replacement shakes. Using less liquid than recommended creates an overly concentrated mixture that can overwhelm digestion. Most digestive issues resolve as your body adjusts to the formula, typically within 1-2 weeks.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
Long-Term Sustainability
Meal replacement plans are effective tools for weight loss and improvement of various clinical characteristics but not sustainable due to the severe energy restriction. If you use meal replacements for weight loss, you may lose weight, but as soon as you start eating your old diet again, the weight will return.
How to Follow a Milkshake Diet Safely
- Consult a Professional: To get the most out of a protein shake diet, it is best to talk to a doctor or registered dietitian first.
- Limit Consumption: People should only consume one or two protein shakes daily and for a short time only.
- Choose Wisely: It is also best to choose a protein shake that fulfills part of a healthful diet. For instance, a person who does not eat many vegetables might choose a meal replacement protein shake that contains vegetables. Select meal replacement shakes with adequate protein (15-30g), complex carbohydrates, healthy fats, and a comprehensive vitamin and mineral profile. Avoid products with excessive sugar or artificial ingredients. Check for third-party testing and reputable manufacturers.
- Eat Nutrient-Dense Foods: The best way to enhance weight loss when following a protein shake diet is by eating nutrient-dense, low-calorie foods between shakes.
- Incorporate Whole Foods: For optimal results, consider using meal replacement shakes strategically rather than as a complete meal solution. They work best when combined with a balanced diet of whole foods and regular physical activity.
- Monitor Ingredients: Start slowly and monitor your body's response, choosing products with minimal artificial ingredients.
Liquid Diets: More Than Just Weight Loss
Although liquid diets are often associated with weight loss programs, there are other reasons why you may follow one. For example, clear liquids are typically easy to digest and do not leave much undigested material in your intestines. As a result, your physician may prescribe a clear liquid diet before certain surgeries, such as colonoscopies and bariatric surgery. They may also be prescribed after certain surgeries, such as gallbladder removal and bariatric surgery. Additionally, liquid diets are advised for those who have digestive problems, including diarrhea and vomiting. However, some evidence suggests that solid food diets that leave minimal undigested materials may be superior to liquid diets.
Meal Replacement Shakes: A Closer Look
Meal replacement shakes are drinks formulated to substitute for a complete meal while providing essential nutrients. These products typically contain protein for muscle maintenance, carbohydrates for energy, healthy fats for hormone function, and vitamins and minerals for overall health. These shakes eliminate time spent on grocery shopping, cooking, and cleanup, while providing quick meal solutions for busy schedules. Meal replacement drinks deliver precise calorie control (typically 150-400 calories per serving) and help create calorie deficits needed for sustainable weight loss. For individuals managing gastrointestinal conditions like Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS) or Inflammatory Bowel Diseases (IBDs), meal replacement shakes can be a helpful alternative.
Who Should Avoid Liquid Diets?
Several groups of people should not consider a liquid diet, such as pregnant or nursing women, children and adolescents, and those who are underweight. Not to mention, there are financial considerations. Commercial meal replacement shakes can often be more expensive than traditional solid foods.
Safety and Side Effects of Liquid Diets
The safety of liquid diets depends on the type of diet and the duration of the program. Diets that replace one or several meals per day with meal replacement shakes are generally considered safe in the long term. Most meal replacement shakes are designed to contain the nutrients needed by the human body, including carbs, fats, protein, vitamins, and minerals. Yet, replacing only some meals with liquids ensures that you still get nutrients from solid foods as well. One side effect of a liquid diet is constipation, which may be due to the low fiber content of most liquids. Additionally, very low-calorie diets (500 calories per day) may lead to a higher risk of gallstones than low-calorie diets (1,200-1,500 calories per day). However, there is a low incidence of side effects overall with weight loss programs that include low-calorie meal replacement liquids.
Meanwhile, medically prescribed liquid diets are considered safe for short-term use, but they are typically ordered by a physician. If this type of diet was not prescribed to you by a medical professional, it is probably unnecessary. Following a liquid diet over the long term could increase your risk of nutrient deficiencies, particularly if you are only consuming juices or other beverages that do not contain all essential nutrients. Overall, it is probably a good idea to include some healthy solid foods in your diet, even if you are considering emphasizing liquids.
The Importance of a Balanced Approach
As idealistic as it may sound, meal replacements should not be relied upon as an alternative to food, especially in the long term. There are many nutrients in food that are not classified as ‘vitamins’ or ‘minerals’, and therefore not included in meal replacements. These nutritional compounds include phytoestrogens, fatty acids, flavonoids, anthocyanadins, carotenoids and many other compounds which are needed for our optimal health, but are all missing from meal replacements. Digestive enzymes ensure that food substances and nutrients are broken down properly for optimal gut health - our gut is our 'second-brain', connected to our brain by the 'gut-brain axis', so our diet and our gut are the start point for all health goals. Chewing is also important for the release of stomach acid. If your stomach acid is too low, you can find yourself with indigestion and other gut issues, including bloating. If you have gut health issues, it's advised to avoid drinking liquids at meal times, and to avoid liquid meals such as shakes, soups and meal replacements so you don't dilute your stomach acid further. Although some meal replacements and powder supplements add fibre, the majority do not, or they do not add enough fibre. A healthy diet contains lots of fibre, both soluble and insoluble, and this is necessary for the health of your gut and to aid the body's natural detoxification process.