Losing weight and maintaining a healthy lifestyle can be a considerable challenge, especially with the fast-paced nature of modern life. Meal replacement plans, incorporating shakes, soups, or bars, have re-emerged as a popular strategy. These plans offer a quick and simple way to manage calorie intake, but it’s important to understand both their benefits and risks before incorporating them into your diet.
The Allure of Meal Replacements
Meal replacement diets first gained popularity during the early days of space travel. The public became fascinated with the idea of a nutritionally complete meal in a single drink or bar. Today, with over 42% of adult Americans classified as obese, the appeal of a convenient and effective weight loss solution is stronger than ever.
How Meal Replacements Work
The fundamental principle behind weight loss is consuming fewer calories than you burn. Meal replacement shakes help control hunger, making it easier to stick to your eating plan. This calorie control is a key feature of any successful weight-loss diet. High-protein meal replacements can aid in weight loss by creating a calorie deficit while providing essential nutrients. Studies show that meal replacement-based diets are significantly more effective than diets based on food intake.
Our latest systematic review on the effectiveness of meal replacements for weight loss included 23 clinical trials that compared weight loss in people who followed a meal replacement diet with a weight-loss plan that didn’t include meal replacements. We combined similar trials into groups for analysis. On average, people who followed a meal-replacement diet lost 1.4kg more than people using other diets after one year.
Benefits of Meal Replacement Plans
- Convenience: Preparing healthy meals can be time-consuming. Meal replacements offer a simple, time-saving solution, reducing the temptation to indulge in unhealthy foods.
- Calorie Control: Meal replacements provide a precise and consistent way to meet calorie goals when prepared as recommended. They can help you lower your daily calories, which can help you lose weight.
- Nutrient Density: High-quality meal replacements are designed to be nutrient-dense and are often fortified with essential vitamins and minerals, ensuring you’re still meeting your body’s needs while cutting back on calories. Research shows that meal replacement diets, especially those rich in protein, can improve diet quality for individuals who are overweight or obese.
- Appetite Suppression: Meal-replacement products are formulated to be high in protein and fiber, both ingredients that have been shown to suppress appetite. Protein is the most satiating macronutrient, keeping you feeling full for longer than carbohydrates or fats.
- Improved Diet Quality: For those struggling to maintain a balanced diet, meal replacements can help improve overall nutrition.
- Blood Sugar Control: Meal replacement shakes often have a low glycemic index (GI), meaning that they cause a slower, steadier rise in blood sugar, helping to curb appetite.
- Muscle Mass Maintenance: Some meal replacement shakes are high in protein, so they fill you up but may not load you with extra calories. This aids in weight loss without giving up muscle mass.
- Digestive Health: In addition to protein that helps you feel full, meal replacement shakes are often high in fiber. This helps healthy digestion, so you don’t get bloated or have constipation.
- Effective Weight Loss: Research has found that meal replacement shakes can help with weight loss. One study tracked two groups of people as they tried to lose weight over the course of 3 months. At the end of the study, the group that did not use meal replacement shakes lost only 1.5% of their initial body weight. The group that used replacement shakes lost 7.8%.
- Accuracy of Calorie Estimation: Accurately tracking calorie intake can be challenging. Meal replacements provide a precise, consistent way to meet calorie goals when prepared as recommended.
- Positively Affects Self-Monitoring: Tracking your dietary intake improves awareness of eating habits.
Risks and Considerations
- Nutritional Deficiencies: When you reduce your calorie intake, it becomes harder to get essential nutrients. Meal replacement shakes are usually fortified with vitamins, minerals, protein and fiber to help fill these gaps.
- Artificial Ingredients: Shakes are often made of highly processed or artificial ingredients that don’t offer the balanced nutrients of whole foods. Many shakes also include added sugars so they taste better. Be sure to read labels carefully.
- Fiber and Protein Content: Many meal replacement shakes are low on both fiber and protein. Look for at least 3 grams of fiber in an 8-12 ounce shake.
- Low Calorie Content: Meal replacement shakes are typically between 150 and 200 calories, which is probably nowhere near what you would eat during a meal. Be sure to make up calories with other meals and snacks. Cutting out too many calories is dangerous.
- Allergens: If you have a dairy allergy or lactose intolerance, check labels before purchasing.
- Taste and Variety: Taste can vary by brand, and some shakes may feel bland or overly artificial, especially if the flavor options are limited to just vanilla or chocolate.
- Cost: Consider the cost and time it takes to prepare a healthy, nutritious meal. When bought in powder form, a single serving becomes more affordable than the average meal, factoring in the cost of ingredients, preparation and time.
- Sustainability: Eating solid food may cause excess weight to return if you don't make smart food choices.
- Over-Reliance: Meal replacements are designed to support weight management and balanced nutrition, typically as partial replacements rather than total replacements for all meals.
Making Informed Choices
Given drawbacks associated with premade shakes, it’s better to make them yourself to avoid the synthetic ingredients found in most store-bought ones. Vavrek adds that making a shake yourself also means that you’re controlling your own diet and learning how to make healthy choices for yourself. When making a shake, be sure to include plenty of fruits and vegetables, such as fresh or frozen bananas, berries, peaches or mango and a handful of spinach or kale; they are good sources of fiber and natural vitamins and minerals. But if you’re pressed for time, be sure to check the labels on any shakes you might buy.
Read also: Meal replacement guide for women
When selecting a meal replacement plan, consider the following:
- Read Labels Carefully: Look for shakes with at least 3 grams of fiber and a protein content higher than or equal to the amount of carbohydrates.
- Choose High-Quality Ingredients: Opt for shakes with natural ingredients and minimal artificial additives.
- Consider Your Needs: If you have dietary restrictions or food allergies, be sure to check the label for any allergens or ingredients that may not meet your needs.
- Consult a Healthcare Professional: Those who are pregnant or have specific medical conditions should consult a health care provider before using them.
Long-Term Success
Meal replacement diets can have a lasting effect on weight loss. If you’re looking to achieve and maintain a healthy body weight over the long-term with a partial meal replacement diet, it’s important to pair it with balanced nutrition and a healthy, active lifestyle. Small daily changes can make a big difference.
Alternatives to Shakes:
Vavrek recommends fruit and nuts, crackers and peanut butter and vegetables with hummus as on-the-go shake alternatives.
The Role of Protein
Makers of protein shakes may say that their products help lower body fat or promote weight loss. Some studies find that consuming a higher than usual amount of protein in your diet may offer benefits. For example, eating or drinking products that are high in protein may help you lower body fat, keep lean muscle, feel full and lose weight. But evidence is limited. Since protein has calories, consuming too much can make it harder to lose weight. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans state that an average adult needs about 46 to 56 grams of protein a day. This amount depends on your weight and overall health.
Protein helps suppress appetite by reducing hunger hormones like ghrelin while increasing hormones that signal fullness. Protein has a high thermic effect, meaning that your body burns more calories digesting protein compared to carbs or fats. When paired with resistance exercise, high-protein meal replacements help maintain or build lean muscle, which supports fat loss.
Read also: Low-Carb Meal Ideas
The Importance of a Balanced Diet
“They simply don’t offer the same nutrients that a full meal would on its own, which means your other meals will need to be especially balanced to compensate,” says Vavrek.
Incorporating Meal Replacements into a Weight Loss Strategy
Several clinical guidelines around the world now support incorporating meal replacements into weight-loss treatments. While GLP-1 medications become increasingly popular, studies have found that weight regain is common after discontinuation. Meal replacements can support this strategy.
Read also: Vegan Diet for Bodybuilding