The quest for effective and convenient weight loss solutions has led to the development of various technologies and devices. Among these are heat-based treatments, which claim to target and eliminate fat. This article explores the effectiveness of heat weight loss machines, examining the scientific evidence and providing a balanced perspective on their potential benefits and limitations.
Can Heating Pads Burn Fat?
Manufacturers of heated pads, belts, and wraps often promote their products as a way to target belly fat through increased temperatures, leading to weight loss in the midsection. However, scientific evidence supporting these claims is limited.
According to Fatima Cody Stanford, MD, MPH, an obesity medicine physician scientist, educator, and policy maker at Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Medical School in Boston, there is no solid data indicating that heating products can alter fat mass. While these products may appear to have a short-term effect by shrinking the water content within fat cells, the effect is temporary, and the water content returns quickly. Dr. Stanford does not recommend these strategies for her patients due to the scarcity of supporting data.
Similarly, there is scant evidence to support the use of electronic muscle stimulators (EMS) for belly fat loss. EMS devices send electrical currents to the stomach muscles, causing them to contract. However, they are not approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for weight loss or body composition changes.
Clinical Heat Technology for Fat Reduction
Medical offices offer several nonsurgical heat treatments that aim to reduce belly fat and may be more effective than over-the-counter heating pad products. These clinical heat technologies include:
Read also: Heat & Massage Loveseat
- High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU): This technology heats up fat to cause cell death.
- Laser lipolysis therapies (e.g., SculpSure): These therapies use an applicator to heat and destroy fat cells with laser energy.
- Radiofrequency lipolysis treatments (e.g., Vanquish): These treatments use radiofrequency energy to heat and destroy fat.
These technologies can help reduce unwanted fat gradually over three to six months, according to the American Academy of Dermatology Association (AADA). However, results can vary from person to person, and more research is needed to understand the long-term effects of such treatments. Side effects may include swelling, bruising, and tenderness around the treated area. These therapies also tend to be quite expensive.
Whether these technologies lead to permanent results is also a topic of debate. The AADA suggests that killing some fat cells with these treatments may leave you with fewer overall. However, Dr. Stanford says that these novel heat technologies don’t actually destroy fat cells. According to Dr. Stanford, fat cells can shrink and expand, but they don’t disappear.
It's also important to note that these heat treatments are meant for spot reduction as opposed to dramatic fat loss, according to the AADA.
Novel Technology Combining Radiofrequency and HIFEM
A novel technology has been developed that combines radiofrequency heating and high-intensity focused electromagnetic (HIFEM) treatment simultaneously in the same application area. This technology aims to improve body appearance and support patients’ efforts for improved self-image. Tissue-heating devices work with electromagnetic waves in the medium to very high-frequency spectrum (range of megahertz), whereas HIFEM treatment’s energy is positioned in the very low-frequency spectrum (3 to 30 kHz).
The simultaneous delivery of synchronized radiofrequency and HIFEM treatment is more beneficial than just reduced treatment time in comparison to consecutive treatments. Radiofrequency is considered an effective procedure for inducing adipocyte apoptosis, while HIFEM treatment increases metabolic activity in adipose tissue. The simultaneous application of HIFEM treatment and radiofrequency leads to enhanced muscle hypertrophy and increased fat elimination compared to individual or consecutive treatments.
Read also: Comfort Foam Neck Massager
Study on Combined Radiofrequency and HIFEM Treatment
A multicenter, single-blind, two-arm study was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of the combined treatment. Seventy-two patients were enrolled and randomly assigned into one of two study groups: an active group and a sham group, at a ratio of 2:1, respectively. The procedure consisted of three 30-minute treatments delivered once a week for three consecutive weeks.
In the active group, the intensities of HIFEM energy were set to maximum tolerable levels, and the intensity of radiofrequency energy was set to 100 percent. Muscle and subcutaneous adipose tissue changes were evaluated by ultrasound imaging. Measurements were taken at 2 inches right and left of the umbilicus. Patient weight was recorded, and adverse events and patient experience of pain or discomfort were documented after each procedure.
Results of the Study
The results of the study showed that in the active group, the thickness of subcutaneous adipose tissue reduced significantly at the 1-month follow-up. The fat thickness was further reduced at the 3-month follow-up visit. The sham group did not show any statistically significant changes at any of the follow-up visits compared to the baseline.
The muscle thickness measurements in the active group showed statistically significant thickening at all follow-up visits compared to baseline. The 6-month data obtained from 21 patients of the active group showed that the results were maintained at the level seen at 3 months, although showing a slight insignificant improvement.
In the active group, 93.9 percent of patients reported satisfaction with the treatment results, whereas in the sham group, only 40.0 percent of patients were satisfied. The treatments were found comfortable, with an average score of 2.9 on a 10-point visual analog scale questionnaire (0 = no discomfort, 10 = unbearable discomfort) in the active group.
Read also: Can Heat Help You Lose Weight?
Conclusion of the Study
The study concluded that the combined effects of simultaneously applied synchronized radiofrequency heating and HIFEM modalities are effective for abdominal fat reduction and muscle toning. Ultrasound measurements detected significant changes in both adipose and muscle tissues in all active group patients.
Alternative Fat Reduction Technologies
Besides heat-based treatments, other technologies are used for non-invasive fat reduction. These include:
- Cryolipolysis: This noninvasive technology uses extreme cold to dismantle fat cells and help reduce a fat pocket.
- Ultrasonic Cavitation: This procedure involves applying pressure on fat cells through ultrasonic vibrations, breaking down the fat cells into a liquid form.
- Exilis: This device uses radiofrequency energy to heat up targeted areas of the body, causing fat cells to shrink and eventually die off.
- Laser Lipolysis: This body contouring procedure uses laser energy to remove excess fat from various areas of the body.
- Photonic Lypolysis: This technology delivers specific wavelengths of light through the skin using a specialized lamp. This light triggers selected fat cells to create small openings and release some of their contents, thus helping them shrink in size.
Better Ways to Burn Belly Fat
Given the limited evidence that heat treatments permanently destroy fat, Stanford suggests that these quick fixes are not the answer. Instead, consider the following lifestyle changes that support healthy weight loss:
- Tweak Your Eating Habits: Focus on enjoying plenty of whole foods, and try to take in fewer calories overall. Consider trying the Mediterranean diet, which is low in refined carbohydrates, sugar, saturated fat, and trans fats and rich in lean protein, fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and healthy fats.
- Try High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT): HIIT is one of the most effective cardio workouts in terms of fat loss.
- Get Enough Sleep: Sleep deprivation can reduce the amount of the satiety hormone, leptin, and increase the amount of the hunger hormone, ghrelin, in your body, leading to increased calorie intake.
- Manage Stress: High stress levels can influence appetite and eating behavior in ways that increase body fat storage.