Diet soda, the seemingly guilt-free alternative to sugary soft drinks, has a history far more intricate and fascinating than its zero-calorie label might suggest. From its humble beginnings as a beverage for diabetics to its rise as a cultural icon and the center of health debates, the story of diet soda reflects changing societal attitudes toward health, weight, and indulgence.
The Genesis: A Soda for Special Needs
The concept of diet soda emerged from a need to provide sugar-free options for individuals with diabetes. In 1952, Hyman Kirsch and his son Morris, who ran The Kirsch Bottling Company, recognized this need through their involvement with the Jewish Sanitarium for Chronic Disease (now Kingsbrook Jewish Medical Center). Witnessing the dietary restrictions of diabetic patients, they were inspired to create a sugar-free soda. The result was No-Cal, the world's first diet soda, initially available only in ginger ale flavor. No-Cal replaced sugar with cyclamate calcium. The Kirsch Bottling Company soon expanded the No-Cal line to include root beer, cola, and black cherry.
While No-Cal was created to cater to diabetics and those with cardiovascular problems, its appeal quickly broadened. Actress Kim Novak became the brand’s spokesperson, and No-Cal became popular with dieters.
The Rise of Diet Soda
The late 1950s and early 1960s saw the rise of diet soda. In 1958, Royal Crown Cola introduced Diet Rite, a cyclamate and saccharin-sweetened beverage. Like No-Cal, Diet Rite was initially marketed to diabetics, but it soon became clear that the real market was dieters. Diet Rite's success demonstrated the broader appeal of low-calorie sodas. Royal Crown began marketing Diet Rite nationwide for the general public in 1962, following successful trials in Chicago and North Carolina.
Coca-Cola and Pepsi soon followed suit. In 1963, Dr. Pepper released a diet version of its soft drink, "Dietetic Dr. Pepper" (later renamed Sugar Free Dr. Pepper, then Diet Dr. Pepper). The Coca-Cola Company joined the diet soft drink market with Tab, followed by Pepsi with Patio Diet Cola (shortly renamed Diet Pepsi). Tab's story is one of perseverance. The brand survived initial low sales, artificial sweetener scares, lukewarm corporate enthusiasm, and intermittent consumer availability to become - for a brief period - the most popular diet soda in America.
Read also: Weight Loss in First Month Post-Surgery
Sweetness Without Sugar: The Artificial Sweetener Saga
The key to diet soda's appeal lies in its use of artificial sweeteners to replicate the taste of sugar without the calories. From saccharin to aspartame to sucralose, the history of diet soda is intertwined with the development and regulation of these sugar substitutes.
Cyclamates and the FDA Ban
Early diet sodas relied heavily on cyclamates and saccharin. However, this combination soon proved disastrous. In 1969, an experiment revealed that a cyclamate combination caused bladder cancer in laboratory rats. The FDA immediately announced a ban on cyclamate in food and drink products, effective in 1970.
The cyclamate ban forced companies to reformulate their diet sodas. Tab, for example, initially contained both saccharin and cyclamate, with cyclamate being the more important of the two. After the ban, Tab reformulated to use saccharine as its primary sweetener. Despite these obstacles, Tab became the bestselling diet cola of the 1970s and 1980s.
Aspartame and the Rise of Diet Coke
The introduction of aspartame, commonly known as NutraSweet, in 1982, marked a turning point in the diet soda industry. The 1982 introduction of aspartame-sweetened Diet Coke accelerated this trend. Diet Coke's success demonstrated the potential of diet soda to appeal to a broad audience.
Sucralose and Stevia: Newer Alternatives
Recently, two other sweeteners have been used with increasing frequency: sucralose (marketed as Splenda) and acesulfame potassium ("Sunett" or "Ace K"). Advocates say drinks employing these sweeteners have a more natural sugar-like taste than those made just with aspartame and do not have a strong aftertaste. In 2005, The Coca-Cola Company announced it would produce a sucralose-containing formulation of Diet Coke known as Diet Coke with Splenda, but that it would continue to produce the aspartame version as well.
Read also: Eden Weight Loss Program: Benefits, risks, and what to expect.
Some companies have explored natural sweeteners like stevia. Initially launched in Argentina in 2013, Coca-Cola Life is made with a mix of stevia and sugar as its sweeteners.
Marketing and Cultural Impact
Diet soda has been marketed in various ways, from targeting diabetics to appealing to weight-conscious consumers. The rivalry between Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi, played out in $100 million advertising campaigns, further solidified diet soda's place in popular culture.
Diet Coke enlisted supermodel Cindy Crawford for their iconic 1991 commercial, while Diet Pepsi countered with Ray Charles singing "You Got the Right One Baby." Both brands introduced new flavors: Diet Cherry Coke in 1986 and Diet Wild Cherry Pepsi in 1988. Caffeine-free versions hit shelves soon after.
Health Concerns and Controversies
Despite its zero-calorie appeal, diet soda has faced increasing scrutiny regarding its potential health effects. Studies have suggested associations with weight gain, increased diabetes risk, and other health problems.
Some studies suggest an association with weight gain and increased diabetes risk. A meta-analysis published in Frontiers in Nutrition observed a significant association between artificially sweetened beverages (ASBs) and an increased risk of type 2 diabetes. Another study suggested a higher risk of diabetes with diet soft drinks compared to sugared soft drinks.
Read also: Risks of a Protein-First Diet
The World Health Organization has declared aspartame, a sweetener found in diet drinks and other food items, as a potential cancer-causing agent.
The Current Landscape
Today, the diet soda market is diverse, with a wide range of brands and flavors available. While traditional diet sodas like Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi remain popular, newer options like sparkling water with fruit essences have gained traction.
According to a survey conducted by Statista, in the United States, diet soda made up more than a quarter of soda's total market volume during 2020. A great deal of this market volume was (and is) driven by Diet Coke.