One of the most frustrating aspects of exercising, particularly for women, is when stubborn belly fat persists despite daily sit-ups or crunches. Sit-ups are a common physical activity performed to strengthen abdominal muscles. However, the effectiveness of sit-ups for weight loss, specifically in the abdominal area, is a topic filled with misconceptions. This article aims to clarify whether sit-ups contribute to weight loss and what strategies are more effective for reducing belly fat and achieving a toned core.
The Myth of Spot Reduction
Forget what you heard about that miracle machine, exercise, gadget, or gizmo designed to rid you of belly fat once and for all. Put simply, targeted fat loss - also known as spot reduction - isn’t possible. Despite the proliferation of all kinds of belly-busting contraptions and workout DVDs, there’s no getting around the fact that diet and nutrition are the key to experiencing the noticeable weight and fat loss necessary to display flat, washboard abs. The only way you can lose fat from your belly is to lose fat from your entire body.
This fact is widely backed by scientific studies. For example, a 2011 study followed 24 participants over a 6-week training period. They were split into two groups. The first group completed 7 abdominal exercises (2 sets of 10 repetitions), while the control group did not complete abdominal exercises. All participants followed the same diet through the study. The study found that while the exercise group experienced increased muscular endurance compared to the control group, they did not lose any more belly fat than the control group. Another study followed 40 overweight or obese women for a 3-month period. All followed the same diet. One group combined this diet with abdominal training, while the control group only followed the diet. Both groups experienced weight loss, but there was no significant difference in belly fat loss between the two groups.
The Role of Sit-Ups in Muscle Strengthening
In reality, classic sit-ups are proven to be ineffective at reducing belly fat. While sit-ups might help increase strength in the abs, they don’t provide stability, which is more important. The short answer is no; sit-ups and crunches, or any abdominal exercise for that matter, does not burn belly fat. However, abdominal exercises can help to tone the belly. Sit-ups and crunches are particularly effective for strengthening the core and toning the rectus abdominus, transverse abdominus, and oblique muscles.
Unfortunately, in a misguided effort to burn belly fat, many people over-engage in abdominal exercises. Excessive crunches and sit-ups can actually put stress on the lower back and neck, leading to injury.
Read also: Estrogen's Impact on Weight Management
The Science Behind Fat Loss
To shed the curtain, you need to burn calories. To burn calories, we need energy. Our bodies source energy from fat, carbohydrates, and protein; which source your body draws from will depend on the activity you’re doing and the food you’re consuming. Many people assume that using fat for energy means more fat loss. However, using fat as your energy source doesn’t necessarily mean losing more fat. What matters is how many calories you burn, and ultimately the harder you workout, the more calories you’ll burn. To burn calories and therefore lose fat, our body temperature needs to increase - this triggers our metabolism. In other words, if the muscle group you’re working is small, the amount of heat being generated will be small, too.
Understanding Different Types of Belly Fat
It's also crucial to understand the different types of belly fat. Subcutaneous fat sits just below the skin, meaning you can grab it with your hand. Visceral fat, which is also known as abdominal fat, lies deeper in the stomach. It wraps around our abdominal organs and can directly impact our health. So, maintaining a healthy belly fat percentage, whatever that may be for your body, it’s important for your overall health.
Effective Strategies for Overall Fat Loss
As mentioned, to lose belly fat, you need to reduce your total fat percentage. Unfortunately, no abdominal exercise will do this for you. In fact, for overall weight loss, including belly-fat burning, diet is just as important - if not more important - than your exercise regime. Combining an effective high-intensity exercise program with a balanced, calorie deficit diet is the key to burning belly fat.
Calorie Deficit
To be in a calorie deficit, you need to burn more calories than you consume. For people assigned female at birth, the recommended daily maintenance calorie intake is around 2,000. For people assigned male at birth, the recommended daily maintenance calorie intake is about 2,500. To implement a calorie deficit, you should decrease your daily calorie intake by 500 to 1000 calories per day. While you may be tempted to drop your calories significantly to lose weight quicker, this is not an effective or safe approach.
Low-Carb Diet
This study found that, compared to a low-fat diet, a low-carb diet was associated with higher reductions in abdominal fat. The low-carb diet also proved to benefit overall body composition, fat distribution, and gluclose metabolism function. You don’t need to switch to a no-carb diet - it’s essential to maintain a well-balanced diet no matter your exercise goals. A low-carb diet will also encourage your body to use fat instead of glycogen for energy.
Read also: Nutritional Benefits of Chlorella
Reduce Sugar Intake
Sugar directly increases the amount of visceral fat on the body. Research has shown that sugar also has a negative impact on our metabolic health. Consuming excessive amounts of sugar, particularly fructose, can lead to a build-up of fat around the liver and abdomen. This is because when you eat a lot of sugar, your liver becomes overloaded with fructose, ao ir converts it to fat.
High-Fiber Diet
A high-fibre diet can assist with weight loss, but not all types of fibre are made equal. Soluble and viscous fibres can help to promote weight loss by increasing the feeling of satiety (fullness). When ingested, these fibres bind with water and form a thick gel that sits in the stomach. This gel substance helps to slow down the movement of food through the digestive system, and slow the absorption of nutrients through the body. This means you’ll feel full for longer, and therefore reduces your appetite. Research has shown a direct link between high-fibre diets and a reduction in abdominal fat. This study found that an increase of 10g of fibre per day can reduce the risk of gaining belly fat by 3.7%. This evidence suggests that soluble fibres can be particularly helpful in reducing belly fat. So, how can you incorporate soluble fibres into your diet?
Increase Protein Intake
Protein can help to reduce overall body fat, and therefore belly fat, because it helps to increase satiety and speed up our metabolisms. Increased protein intake has also been directly linked to reductions in abdominal fat. One study showed a moderate to strong correlation between the consumption of high-quality protein and reduced central abdominal fat. Similarly, this study found that over a 5 year period, women who increased their protein intake had a reduced chance of gaining abdominal fat.
High-Intensity Training
As we know, to burn calories and lose weight, we need to generate body heat. That’s why high-intensity, full-body training is effective for fat loss. HIIT training, running, playing soccer, hill sprints, and swimming are all great exercises for fat burning. Remember when we mentioned that sit-ups don’t generate enough heat to burn calories? Compare the heat generated by sprinting up a hill with the heat generated from doing sit-ups or crunches. The difference is clear. So, any workout that involves multiple muscle groups and elevates your body temperature will promote calorie and fat burning.
Strength-Building Exercises
It’s also a good idea to add strength-building exercises to your workout routine. Squats, lunges, bicep curls, and abdominal exercises will help to build muscle, which is what gives your muscles a toned, shapely appearance. Building muscle mass also increases your metabolism. The more muscle you have, the more heat your body will generate during exercise sessions.
Read also: Does Baking Soda Help You Lose Weight?
The Importance of Core Strength
However, this doesn’t mean you should skip out on these abdominal exercises altogether. Incorporating abdominal exercises into your workout routine will help to tone your abdomen and strengthen your core. Aside from providing that shapely look (which is really just a bonus), the main benefits of strengthening the core are functional.
- Better posture and balance: A strong core can improve your posture and help you sit straight, which in turn improves your balance and reduces the likelihood of falls. This is particularly important as you age, when falls can result in both non-fatal and fatal injuries.
- Improve performance: Core strength can improve overall athletic performance for all exercise and improve quality of your movements.
Combining these core exercises with high-intensity training and a deficit, well-balanced diet will help to reduce belly fat and tone your abdominal area.
Effective Core Exercises
- Crunches: Bicycle crunches are one of the best exercises for the core because they target all 4 abdominal muscles, including the notoriously hard-to-engage lower abs. Start off with 3 sets of 15 repetitions and build from here.
- Sit-ups: Sit-ups are particularly effective in targeting the stabilising muscles; the obliques, transverse, and rectus abdominus muscles. They also work the hip flexors, lower back, and chest. Target obliques, transverse, and rectus abdominis. Go for 2 sets of 20 to 25 repetitions.
- Full Plank: The full plank is an essential exercise for strengthening the core. It is a full-body exercise, but it focuses primarily on the abdominal muscles. Planks can help to improve posture and balance muscle strength throughout the body. Though you may not notice your core burning as much as with these other exercises, your core is very working hard! Aim for 3 sets of 1 minute (beginners can start with 3 sets of 30 seconds).
- Side Plank: The ‘thread the needle’ side plank is very effective for working the obliques, improving the function of the core, and increasing the body’s range of motion. Start with 3 sets of 30 seconds on each side.
- Burpees: We love to hate ‘em. Burpees are the ultimate full-body, fat-burning, high-intensity exercise that focuses on strengthening the core. Challenge yourself and see how many burpees you can get through in 1 minute!
- Mountain climbers: Mountain climbers target not only your core but also your entire body. They are also a form of cardio, which means they increase your heart rate when you do them. To get started, place yourself in a plank position. This means elevating your body off the ground with your arms (think of the “up” position of a pushup). Remember to keep your body straight and your pelvis tucked slightly. Your arms should be shoulder-width apart with both palms on the floor. Your legs should be extended behind you, feet together. Once in this position, slowly move your right knee to your chest then back again. Next, draw your left knee to your chest and back again. This is one repetition (rep). Increase your pace and move quickly to exercise the rectus abdominis - a pair of muscles that run down your belly and form the bulk of the abdominal muscles. You should repeat this exercise several times for the best results. Professionals recommend 15 to 20 reps on each side for beginners.
- Lying leg raises: This exercise strengthens your lower abs but doesn’t require you to hold yourself up while you do so. Instead, lie on your back with your legs extended and feet together. Rest the palms of your hands on either side of your body. Raise your legs together slowly. Be sure they’re perpendicular (at a right angle) to the floor for better results. Hold for one to two seconds before bringing both legs back down to the floor. Do this for 10-15 reps or more for best results. If you want to make the exercise work better, don’t let your feet touch the ground. Also, be sure not to arch your back - it can lead to back problems if you do. If you have a bad back, talk to your doctor before starting this exercise.
- Crunches: When people think of lower ab exercises, they often think of crunches. These low-impact exercises target both your upper and lower abs. They likely won’t help you lose weight because they don’t make you burn a lot of calories. But they’re a good place to start if you want to strengthen your abs. To do a standard crunch, begin by lying on your back with your knees bent and your feet on the ground. Slowly lift your shoulders off the ground, tucking your arms behind your head. Curl your upper body toward your knees, tightening your ab muscles as you move up. Then lower back down to the ground. That’s one rep. Try to do 12-20 reps in a row. If it’s easy, continue. If it’s too difficult, start with fewer reps. If you’re feeling serious pain, stop. If the pain continues for hours or days, talk to a doctor. Other types of crunch exercises that are ideal for your lower abs include: Reverse crunch, Bicycle crunch, Runner’s crunch, Bird dog crunch.
- Scissor kicks: This exercise is similar to lying leg raises, but it involves lifting one leg at a time rather than both together. Start by lying on your back with both of your legs extended and feet together. Rest your hands palms-down on either side of your body or under your buttocks for support. Lift your shoulder blades and head off the ground. Then, bring your legs up off the ground. With your legs up, take turns lifting and lowering your legs, one after the other. Make sure your feet hover above the ground after you bring them down - about 6 inches. You can repeat the exercise as many times as desired.
- Knee tucks (with sliders or exercise ball): For this exercise, you’ll need towels or sliders. Assume a plank position and place both of your feet on the towels or sliders. Pull both knees to your chest and gradually move back to the starting position. Do this as many times as possible, or at least 10 times if you’re a beginner. Avoid leaning your upper body forward too much or hunching your shoulders - this can lead to problems if done too much. If you want to make it more challenging, use an exercise ball. Instead of placing your legs on sliders or towels, balance your legs on top of the ball. Draw both knees toward your chest and return to the starting point.
- Toe touches: The toe touch is a great lower ab exercise for people who’re comfortable with beginner workouts and want more of a challenge. It uses movements from different lower ab exercises listed here, making it easy to transition into other lower ab exercises. Start by lying on your back on the floor, exercise mat, or towel. Your knees should be bent and your feet planted firmly on the ground. Rest your arms at your sides. Stiffen your abdominal muscles. Try to keep them this way throughout the entire exercise. Next, bring your legs up off the floor, straightening them to be perpendicular to your body. Point your toes away from your body. Then, lift your hands toward your toes, lifting your shoulders and head off the ground as you do so. Lower your hands and upper body back down. This is one rep. Repeat this process several times, keeping your legs perpendicular to the floor and your abs engaged throughout the exercise.
Additional Exercises to Reduce Belly Fat
All exercise will help you burn excess fat around your body and gain muscle mass. With enough consistency, that will include tummy fat. Luckily, as you gain more muscle mass, your body burns more energy, even when you’re at rest.
There are many exercises out there, but not all are created equal when it comes to getting rid of belly fat. But scientists and doctors agree that adding physical activity to your daily routine is a great way to burn off unwanted belly fat.
Aerobic or Cardio Exercise
To burn off visceral fat, your first step is to include at least 30 minutes of aerobic exercise or cardio into your daily routine. Studies show that aerobic exercises for belly fat help reduce belly fat and liver fat. Some great cardio of aerobic exercises for belly fat include: Walking, especially at a quick pace, Running, Biking, Rowing, Swimming, Cycling, Group fitness classes. When choosing a cardio activity, make sure it’s something that you enjoy doing. This way, you’re more motivated and will look forward to your exercise routine.
HIIT or Interval Training
High-intensity interval training (HIIT) and interval training are exercise routines that use short bursts of intense exercise mixed with lower-intensity moves and rest periods. Research shows that HIIT exercises for belly fat help control weight and improve your overall physical condition. These routines don’t take a lot of time but still get your heart pumping and work your entire body. Each routine has a selection of activities that include the following movements: Pushing, Pulling, Squatting, Deadlifting, Carrying weights. Typically, an HIIT routine uses 30 seconds of intense activity followed by 30 seconds of rest right, before moving on to the next activity. The sequence can be repeated a few times to get the maximum benefit. Some HIIT exercises that people of all fitness levels and ages can try are: Jumping jacks, Burpees, Pushups, Jump squats, High knees. To get started, choose a handful of HIIT exercises for belly fat. Perform one activity for 30 seconds, then rest for 30 seconds. Do the next activity, and then rest. When you finish all the activities, you can repeat the cycle a few more times.
Weight and Resistance Training
Weight training is also an important part of burning off belly fat. Since muscles burn off more calories than fat does when the body is at rest, having more muscle tone can help you burn off more fat. Researchers have also found that resistance training, which includes weight training, can increase lean weight while decreasing fat, and it can boost metabolism at the same time. Some weight training exercises for belly fat to include in your routine are: Bicep curls, Lunges, Squats, Tricep kickbacks. With these exercises, you can do 12 repetitions with lighter weights (5-8 pounds). Another option is to use heavier weights with fewer repetitions and rest time between sets.
Important Considerations
While it’s important to get at least 30 minutes of moderate exercise a day, you don’t want to overtrain and push yourself too hard. Sometimes, when you overtrain, your body can produce too much cortisol - a stress hormone linked to belly fat. So, overtraining may actually make it harder to burn off belly fat. It’s important to start new exercises slowly. If you feel sharp or prolonged pain, talk to your doctor or another health care professional, such as a physical therapist. Follow the recommendations for moderate regular exercise, and talk with your doctor if you have questions about how else your exercise routine can benefit your health.