For many health-conscious individuals, choosing diet soda over regular soda seems like a better choice. With no calories and no sugar, it appears to be a guilt-free way to enjoy a fizzy, sweet beverage. However, the safety and health effects of diet soda, particularly concerning the artificial sweetener sucralose, have been subjects of ongoing debate and research.
Understanding Sucralose
Sucralose, commonly known by the brand name Splenda, is a zero-calorie artificial sweetener widely used as a sugar substitute in various food and beverage products. It is approximately 600 times sweeter than table sugar (sucrose).
How Sucralose is Made
Sucralose is derived from sugar through a multi-step chemical process. This involves replacing three hydroxyl groups in the sugar molecule with chlorine atoms. This alteration intensifies the sweetness and prevents the body from metabolizing it like regular sugar, making it virtually calorie-free.
Regulatory Approval and Usage
Sucralose received its first approval for use in Canada in 1991, followed by approvals in Australia in 1993 and New Zealand in 1996. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved sucralose for use in 15 food categories in 1998 and as a general-purpose sweetener in 1999, under specific conditions. The European Union (EU) approved sucralose (E 955) in 2004 for various products.
Sucralose is used in thousands of food, beverage, and pharmaceutical products globally, including baked goods, beverages, chewing gum, gelatins, and frozen dairy desserts. Its high solubility in ethanol, methanol, and water makes it versatile for both fat- and water-based applications, including alcoholic drinks.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
Safety Assessments and Regulatory Stances
All sweeteners in Great Britain undergo rigorous safety assessments before they are approved for use in food and drink. Approved sweeteners are considered a safe and acceptable alternative to sugar.
FDA's Position on Sweetener Safety
The FDA regulates sweeteners like aspartame, acesulfame potassium, sucralose, neotame, advantame, saccharin, steviol glycosides, monk fruit extract, and thaumatin as food additives. To market a new food additive or use an existing one in a new way, manufacturers must seek FDA approval through a food additive petition. Some ingredients, like those Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAS) by qualified experts, do not require pre-market approval.
The FDA establishes an Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) for each approved sweetener, which is the amount considered safe to consume daily over a lifetime. The ADI is determined by evaluating toxicological studies, identifying the highest experimental dose in animal studies that causes no adverse effect, and applying a safety factor.
Examples of ADI Levels for Various Sweeteners
Here are examples of how many packets of each sweetener a person would need to consume daily to reach the Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI):
- Aspartame (Nutrasweet®, Equal®, Sugar Twin®): 75 packets
- Acesulfame Potassium (Ace-K) (Sweet One®, Sunett®): 23 packets
- Sucralose (Splenda®): 23 packets
- Neotame (Newtame®): 23 packets (sweetness intensity at 10,000 times sucrose)
- Advantame (Advantame®): 4,920 packets
- Saccharin (Sweet and Low®, Sweet Twin®, Sweet'N Low®, Necta Sweet®): 45 packets
Ongoing Monitoring and Reassessment
The FDA continuously monitors the latest scientific data on sweeteners. FDA scientists reassess the science regarding the exposure and safety of a sweetener each time the agency files a food additive petition or a GRAS notice for that sweetener.
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
Potential Health Concerns and Controversies
Despite regulatory approvals, several studies and reports have raised concerns about the potential health effects of sucralose and diet soda consumption.
Metabolic Syndrome and Cardiovascular Issues
Studies have shown a link between diet soda consumption and an increased risk for metabolic syndrome, a cluster of symptoms including low HDL (good) cholesterol, high blood sugar, increased belly fat, high triglycerides, and high blood pressure.
Drinking just one diet soda per day may increase the risk of cardiovascular problems, including AFib (irregular heartbeat) and high blood pressure.
Weight Gain and Disrupted Hunger Signals
The artificial sweeteners in diet soda might trigger the same response in the brain as real sugar. The moment sweetness is detected, it signals the body to release hormones to process the sugar. Because diet soda is hyper-sweetened, it can trigger cravings for more sweet, high-calorie foods, potentially leading to weight gain and belly fat.
Dental Problems
Diet sodas often contain phosphoric and citric acids, which can erode tooth enamel. Weakened tooth enamel can lead to tooth sensitivity, pitting of the tooth’s surface, and changes to the color of the teeth, giving them a chalky appearance.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
Neurological Issues
Consumption of artificial sweeteners like aspartame has been linked to an increased risk of neurological problems like stroke and dementia.
Gut Health
Some studies suggest that artificial sweeteners may disturb the balance of bacteria in the digestive tract, called the gut microbiome. Saccharin and sucralose, in particular, have been shown to dramatically alter healthy bacteria levels in the gut and may affect blood sugar control. Changes in the microbiome caused by artificial sweeteners may also inhibit some aspects of the immune system’s ability to respond to infections.
Kidney Disease and Liver Issues
Excessive soda consumption, diet or regular, may increase the risk of chronic kidney disease and the formation of kidney stones. Research has established a strong correlation between diet soda and Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease (NFLD).
Thyroid Function and Joint Pain
Some studies have found that drinking diet soda can cause the thyroid gland to work less efficiently, potentially leading to increased fat storage and weight gain. The artificial sweeteners in diet soda can trigger an inflammatory response in the body and may worsen joint pain.
Effects on Glucose Transport and Body Weight Regulation
Sucralose can modulate physiological parameters involved in normal body weight regulation, including faster intestinal glucose transport via interaction with sweet taste receptors in the gastrointestinal tract (GIT), increased insulin secretion via activation of sweet taste receptors on pancreatic β cells, and altered sweet taste receptor expression in the hypothalamus.
Impact on Bioavailability of Therapeutic Drugs
Sucralose ingestion has been shown to increase the expression of the efflux transporter P-glycoprotein (P-gp) and two cytochrome P-450 (CYP) isozymes in the intestine in rats. P-gp and CYP are key components of the presystemic detoxification system involved in first-pass drug metabolism.
Potential Toxicity from Habitual Sucralose Ingestion
Numerous studies in rodents have reported that sucralose modulates physiological processes involved in nutrient absorption and body weight regulation via its interaction with sweet taste receptors.
Conflicting Research Findings and Nuances
It's important to note that research findings on sweeteners and health are mixed.
Weight Management
Evidence from short-term trials on drinks sweetened with no-calorie sweeteners shows that when they are consumed instead of sugary drinks, they can support lowering energy intake and weight gain. There is no evidence that sweeteners stimulate appetite in humans. However, evidence from longer-term observational studies on weight shows conflicting results, and this type of research is limited, making it difficult to directly link findings to sweetener intake.
Blood Sugar and Insulin Levels
While most research suggests that sucralose is unlikely to increase blood sugar or insulin levels, some studies suggest that it could have negative effects. For instance, one small study found that daily consumption of sucralose had no impact on sugar metabolism or insulin sensitivity in healthy adults. Another study had similar findings, reporting that consuming sucralose with each meal for 12 weeks had no effect on insulin or fasting blood sugar levels.
Gut Microbiome
One 2-week study found that consuming 20% of the acceptable daily intake for sucralose per day had no effect on the beneficial bacteria in the gut. However, animal studies on long-term sucralose intake have found that it could have negative effects. For example, one study in mice showed that 16 weeks or 4 months of low-dose (lower than the recommended amount) sucralose consumption disrupted the balance of the gut microbiome and increased inflammation.
High-Temperature Cooking and Baking
While Splenda is considered heat resistant and good for cooking and baking, recent studies have challenged this. One 2010 study found that heating sucralose with glycerol, a compound found in fat molecules, produced harmful substances called chloropropanols. These substances may raise cancer risk. On the other hand, a more recent study reported that sucralose doesn’t form these compounds when heated and is safe for cooking and baking. However, it's important to note that this study was funded by the manufacturers of Splenda.
Advice and Recommendations
Moderation and Variety
Even though drinking a moderate amount of diet soda isn’t likely to hurt you, it has no nutritional value and offers no benefit to human consumption. If you choose to occasionally indulge in soda, it’s better to choose one made with real sugar instead of diet versions with all the chemicals and additives.
It is advisable to be mindful when it comes to artificial sweeteners and to read the labels of products you regularly eat, drink, or use to see if they contain sucralose or other sweeteners. Changing up the sweeteners that you consume now and then can also help avoid any potential risks that artificial sweeteners may have. If you enjoy adding Splenda to your coffee or baked goods, try using other sweeteners or real sugar once in a while. Remember that sugar in small amounts is okay.
Considering Alternatives
If you’re looking to decrease or eliminate soda intake but still crave something “bubbly,” try flavored sparkling water without added non-nutritive sweeteners (NNS).
Consulting Healthcare Professionals
If you have concerns about the effects of diet soda or artificial sweeteners on your health, consult with a healthcare professional. They can provide personalized advice based on your individual health status and risk factors.