Many people seek rapid weight loss, leading to the creation of numerous dietary interventions. These interventions often involve reducing caloric intake, with some diets excluding macronutrients or specific food groups altogether. While rapid weight loss might seem appealing, it is crucial to understand both the potential risks and benefits associated with crash diets.
Understanding Crash Diets
A rapid weight loss program is generally defined as a diet where you lose more than 2 pounds a week for several weeks. These diets often promise fast results, but are they really helping your body? Crash diets tend to look appealing because they’re inexpensive, short-term, and (usually) give quick results.
Common Types of Crash Diets
Several types of diets fall under the umbrella of crash diets, each with its own set of restrictions and potential risks:
Starvation Diets: These plans promote fasting and severely limit food intake. An example is the "master cleanse" diet, consisting of water, lemon juice, maple syrup, and cayenne pepper.
Very Low-Calorie Diets (VLCDs): These diets, often medically supervised, involve consuming a very low number of calories (800 or less per day). VLCDs are often used before weight loss surgery and under the guidance of a doctor and are usually recommended for 12 weeks or less.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
Ketogenic Diet: This diet restricts carbohydrate intake to less than 50 grams daily, forcing the body to use fat for energy.
Atkins Diet: Similar to the ketogenic diet, it restricts carbohydrates and promotes increased fats and proteins, gradually increasing carbohydrates through different phases. The first 2 weeks of the diet constitute an induction phase, with <20 g of carbohydrates consumed daily (even less than the ketogenic diet).
Paleolithic Diet: This diet focuses on eliminating processed foods and only consuming lean meats, fruits, nonstarchy vegetables, nuts, and seeds while restricting dairy products.
Intermittent Fasting: This involves abstaining from food for a given amount of time followed by a meal, aiming to improve metabolic and glycemic control.
Why People Choose Crash Diets
The desire to achieve results quickly and notice changes in your body can be very strong. For many of us, it’s easier to think about severely restricting what we do to see rapid gains in a short period of time, than it is to think about making long-term sustainable life changes. People may turn to crash diets for various reasons:
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
- Short-Term Goals: To fit into a specific outfit or look good for an event.
- Quick Results: The promise of rapid weight loss is appealing.
- Perceived Ease: Some believe it's easier to severely restrict intake than make gradual lifestyle changes.
- Deadlines: Anyone with a deadline for losing weight can take advantage of a crash diet for fast results.
Risks of Crash Diets
While crash diets may offer rapid weight loss, they come with a range of potential risks and adverse effects.
Physical Health Risks
Gallstones: Rapid weight loss (3 pounds or more per week) can significantly increase the risk of gallstones. Up to 25 percent of individuals who use diets that are very low in calories (800 or less) develop gallstones. Experts think this is from changes in fat metabolism that happen with very rapid weight-loss. Rapid weight loss creates physical demands on the body. Gallstones, which occur in 12%-25% of people losing large amounts of weight over several months
Nutritional Deficiencies: Restrictive diets can lead to deficiencies in essential vitamins and minerals. When following a restrictive diet for an extended period of time, your body doesn't just lose calories, but also the minerals, iron, sodium, potassium and other important nutrients that you get from those calories, explained diet and weight-loss journal Fit Day. Risks include vitamin and mineral deficiencies. For individuals undergoing a 12-week ketogenic diet, magnesium, calcium, iron, phosphorus, and potassium levels were found to be less than the recommended values.
Electrolyte Imbalances: Rapid weight loss, especially through fluid restriction or intense dieting, can cause imbalances in electrolytes like sodium, potassium, and magnesium. “Crash diets can cause heart arrhythmias due to change in potassium and magnesium levels. They can also cause dizziness due to fluctuating blood pressure,” Dr. McFarland said.
Dehydration: Insufficient fluid intake during rapid weight loss can lead to dehydration. Dehydration, which can be avoided by drinking plenty of fluids
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
Malnutrition: Not eating enough protein for weeks at a time can result in malnutrition. Malnutrition, which usually results from not eating enough protein for weeks at a time
Side Effects: Other side effects of rapid weight loss include: Headaches, Irritability, Fatigue, Dizziness, Constipation, Menstrual irregularities, Hair loss, Muscle loss
Acute Kidney Injuries: Fluid restriction can lead to elevations in serum creatinine, potentially causing acute kidney injuries.
Decreased Athletic Performance: Athletes employing fluid or calorie restrictions over short periods to induce rapid weight loss may experience decreased athletic performance.
Hormone Imbalance: Rapid weight loss can disrupt hormone balance, affecting various bodily functions.
Metabolic and Hormonal Effects
Slowed Metabolism: Crash dieting can slow down your metabolism, making it harder to lose weight in the long run and potentially leading to weight regain. Perhaps one of the biggest problems with crash dieting is that it can slow your metabolism, which in effect will give the opposite result that you are looking for. Though you may initially drop several pounds very quickly, if your metabolism is slowing down in the process, it will only lead to more weight gain in the future.
Metabolic Adaptation: After weight loss, the resting metabolic rate slows, likely to counter weight loss and return to homeostasis. It is hypothesized that due to this phenomenon of "metabolic adaptation," weight regain is likely even after weight is lost.
Hormonal Imbalances: Weight loss can cause shifts in anorexogenic and orexigenic hormones, influencing satiety and hunger. During dieting and caloric restriction periods, orexigenic hormones increase, and anorexogenic hormone levels decrease. Even after weight loss, the drive to eat remains heightened, potentially indicating the risk of weight regain.
Psychological and Behavioral Risks
Obsessive Thoughts About Food: Going on a crash diet can make you have obsessive thoughts about food, your body or your weight. These obsessive thoughts can, in turn, lead to poor mental health and disordered eating.
Social Isolation: Food restriction can often lead to isolation from others because social life tends to revolve around food (and drink). However, isolating yourself from friends and family can have a very negative effect on your mental health and may lead to harmful thoughts and disordered eating patterns.
Addiction to Starvation: Extreme dieting can be a risk factor for the development of anorexia. The dangers of rapid weight loss increase with the time spent on the diet. Eating a no-protein diet is particularly risky.
Binge Eating: Often, a period of starvation and under-eating then leads to a period of bingeing and over-eating.
Emotional Eating: When you’re full and satisfied, if life throws you something stressful, you may cope by talking things through with your partner, going for a walk or hitting the gym. However, if you’re hungry and stressed, you’re much more likely to reach for food when things don’t go your way.
Eating Disorders: “There are a variety of disorders that come from crash dieting such as bulimia or anorexia. Often, crash diets and extreme weight loss plans can either cause eating disorders or ultimately result in weight gain.
Weight Cycling
Weight regain: In one study of a VLCD, 40 percent of participants gained back more than they lost. When you drastically reduce calories, even if you need to lose weight, your body thinks you are starving. As a protective mechanism, your body slows your metabolism - but this makes it harder to keep losing weight. It also means that when you start adding more calories, you can regain weight very quickly.
Detrimental Effects: Termed "weight cycling," this method adversely affects physical health and performance. Other detrimental effects include emotional lability with increased tension, anger, and confusion.
Potential Benefits and Medically Supervised Approaches
Despite the numerous risks, there are situations where rapid weight loss may be considered beneficial, particularly under medical supervision.
Medically Supervised Very Low-Calorie Diets (VLCDs)
Specific Health Conditions: A very low-calorie diet (VLCD) may be the right choice for some people with obesity who are already facing serious health problems, such as diabetes, high cholesterol, or high blood pressure. These are people with a body mass index (BMI) greater than 30.
Pre-Surgical Preparation: VLCDs are often used before weight loss surgery to reduce the patient's weight and improve surgical outcomes.
Significant Weight Loss: VLCDs can safely result in a loss of 15%-25% of body weight in 12 weeks.
Considerations for Medically Supervised VLCDs
Multidisciplinary Team: When considering bariatric surgery for patients, multidisciplinary team members should counsel patients on the benefits and the risks of surgery and do a thorough preoperative physical examination, laboratory evaluation, and medical history to identify appropriate candidates.
Nutritional Monitoring: Follow-up laboratory evaluation is provider-dependent but is often performed in routine postoperative follow-ups to ensure no significant abnormalities are present.
Supplementation: Some of these specialists include nutritionists and dieticians who provide assistance with supplementation as needed, primary care clinicians who manage underlying comorbidities, weight-loss coaches, and exercise trainers.
Weight Loss Medications
FDA-Approved Medications: Medications, including orlistat, phentermine and topiramate, naltrexone and bupropion, liraglutide, and semaglutide, have obtained FDA approval for weight loss in the United States, and all are effective for weight loss.
BMI Criteria: FDA guidelines recommend that consideration for these medications include a body mass index (BMI) >30 or ranging from 27 to 30 with an obesity-related comorbidity (type 2 diabetes, hypertension, or any other disease secondary to obesity).
Lifestyle Modifications: Sustained results are demonstrated when individuals actively engage in lifestyle modifications such as dieting and exercise concurrently with medication.
Potential Side Effects: Despite weight loss medications effectively causing >5% body weight loss in most individuals, undesirable adverse effects are common.
Bariatric Surgery
Eligibility: Surgery may be appropriate for individuals who have a BMI >40 or >35 with an underlying health condition, such as diabetes mellitus.
Types of Procedures: The 2 most common bariatric surgeries performed worldwide are the sleeve gastrectomy and the gastric bypass.
Significant Weight Reduction: Bariatric surgery has become a method for rapid weight reduction exceeding 20% of total body mass in some cases.
Potential Complications: Aside from immediate postoperative complications, chronic long-term complications include nutrient deficiencies secondary to anatomical changes that can be present for life.
Sustainable Approaches to Weight Loss
Given the risks associated with crash diets, sustainable approaches to weight loss are generally recommended.
Healthy Eating Habits
Wholesome, Natural Foods: “Moderate weight loss can lower your risk of diabetes, heart disease and certain cancers. The three pillars of weight loss include eating wholesome, natural foods, exercising regularly and maintaining the health of your body and mind.
Minimally Processed Foods: On the Pritikin Diet and Eating Plan, the focus is on consuming minimally processed, whole foods low in calorie density.
Balanced Diet: Fruits, vegetables, whole grains, starchy vegetables, legumes, lean sources of protein and lean, calcium-rich foods are the key highlights of the recommended eating plan that helps keep you satisfied and nourished, without feeling hungry.
Moderation: Healthy eating focuses on moderation.