The quest for effective weight management strategies is a long-standing pursuit. While conventional approaches like diet and exercise remain foundational, emerging research explores alternative and complementary methods. Among these, cell salts, a type of homeopathic medicine, have garnered attention, alongside studies investigating the impact of sodium intake and novel compounds on weight. This article delves into the science behind cell salts and other related research, examining their potential role in weight loss and overall health.
Understanding Cell Salts
Cell salts, also known as tissue salts or biochemical salts, were introduced by Dr. Wilhelm Schuessler in the 19th century. These micro-doses of minerals are believed to support the body's natural healing processes by regulating mineral levels in cells. The theory is that imbalances in these minerals can lead to various health issues, and restoring balance can promote overall wellness.
The 12 Primary Tissue Salts and Their Purported Benefits
According to "The Twelve Tissue Remedies of Schüssler," there are 12 main tissue salts, each associated with specific health benefits:
- Calc fluor (Calcarea fluorica): Claims to strengthen tooth enamel and bones, restore tissue elasticity, and help with hemorrhoids and hernia pain.
- Calc phos (Calcarea phosphorica): Believed to restore cells, heal fractures, and aid the digestive system.
- Calc sulph (Calcium sulphate): Purported to purify blood, reduce infection, treat skin disorders like acne, and prevent sore throat and cold.
- Ferr phos (Ferrum phosphoricum): Used as an anti-inflammatory, to reduce fever, accelerate healing, and reduce bleeding.
- Kali mur (Kali muriaticum): Claims to purify blood, treat infection, reduce swelling, and aid digestion.
- Kali phos (Kali phosphoricum): Believed to support nerve health, lessen anxiety, irritability, and fatigue, aid memory, and relieve headaches.
- Kali sulph (Kali sulphuricum): Purported to heal the mucous membrane, heal skin, balance metabolism, and condition the pancreas.
- Mag phos (Magnesia phosphorica): Used to ease cramps and pain, reduce spasms, and relieve tension headaches.
- Nat mur (Natrum muriaticum): Claims to balance bodily fluids, reduce water retention, aid digestion, and treat eczema.
- Nat phos (Natrum phosphoricum): Believed to neutralize acidity, relieve seasickness, treat arthritis, and aid digestion.
- Nat sulph (Natrum sulphuricum): Purported to cleanse the pancreas, kidneys, and liver, and treat cold and flu.
- Silica: Used to condition skin and connective tissue, cleanse blood, and strengthen hair and nails.
Administration and Safety
Cell salts are typically available as tablets containing a small amount of the chosen mineral, often dissolved under the tongue. They may also come in creams, gels, and liquid drops. While generally considered safe, it's crucial to consult a healthcare professional before taking cell salts, especially if pregnant or nursing.
Scientific Scrutiny
Despite anecdotal evidence, the scientific community remains skeptical about the effectiveness of cell salts. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) advises against using homeopathy as an alternative to conventional medical care. Concerns exist regarding the lack of rigorous scientific research supporting the claims made about tissue salts. The FDA warns that homeopathic products may contain measurable amounts of active ingredients, potentially causing side effects.
Read also: The Science Behind Stem Cell Skin Rejuvenation
The Sodium Paradox: Blood Pressure vs. Weight Loss
The relationship between sodium intake and health is complex and sometimes contradictory. For decades, reducing sodium intake has been a cornerstone of managing high blood pressure. The rationale is that sodium promotes thirst, leading to increased fluid intake and, consequently, higher blood pressure.
Challenging the Conventional Wisdom
However, some recent studies have challenged this notion, suggesting that higher sodium intake might actually promote weight loss by altering the body's energy needs. This counterintuitive finding prompted further investigation into the effects of sodium on thirst, fluid intake, and metabolism.
The DASH-Sodium Trial Revisited
A study led by Stephen Juraschek, MD, PhD, revisited data from the DASH-Sodium trial, a randomized controlled-feeding study published in 2001. The researchers examined the effects of three different levels of sodium intake (low, medium, and high) on blood pressure in participants following either a typical American diet or the DASH Diet.
Key Findings
The study found that reducing sodium intake in adults with elevated blood pressure or hypertension decreased thirst, urine volume (a marker of fluid intake), and blood pressure. However, it did not affect metabolic energy needs. These results support the traditional view that decreasing sodium intake is crucial for managing hypertension, contradicting recent studies suggesting a potential link between higher sodium intake and weight loss.
Implications for Hypertension Management
Juraschek's study reinforces the importance of sodium reduction as a means to lower blood pressure. It suggests that while sodium may influence fluid balance and thirst, it doesn't directly impact the amount of energy required to maintain a stable weight.
Read also: Understanding Giant Cell Arteritis
Ketogenic Diets and Ketone Salts: A Metabolic Approach to Weight Loss
Ketogenic diets (KDs), characterized by low carbohydrate intake and high fat consumption, have gained popularity for their weight loss potential. KDs induce a metabolic state called ketosis, where the body primarily uses fat for fuel instead of glucose.
The Role of Ketone Salts
Exogenous ketone salts (KS) are supplements that enhance ketosis by providing additional ketones, along with minerals like sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium. These salts have been explored as a way to support muscle anabolism during a hypocaloric KD.
Preserving Muscle Mass During Weight Loss
Studies have shown that intravenous infusion of sodium BHB (beta-hydroxybutyrate), a type of ketone body, can preserve fat-free mass (FFM) during very low-calorie diets and starvation. Ketone bodies may also protect against muscle loss in catabolic settings.
A Randomized Controlled Trial
A randomized, controlled-feeding, double-blind study investigated the composition of weight loss in individuals following a well-formulated KD with and without KS supplementation. The study aimed to determine whether KS could improve the preservation of lean body mass during weight loss.
Study Design and Methods
The study involved 28 participants with a BMI between 27 and 35 kg/m2, who were randomized into two KD groups: one receiving KS supplementation (KD + KS) and the other receiving a placebo (KD + PL). All meals were prepared in a metabolic kitchen, with precise macro- and micro-nutrient calculations. The KDs provided approximately 40 g/day of carbohydrates, with the remaining non-protein calories derived from fat. A control group followed a hypocaloric low-fat diet (LFD).
Read also: Diet for Mast Cell Disease
Key Findings
The study assessed body composition using advanced imaging techniques, including MRI, to measure visceral adipose tissue (VAT), subcutaneous adipose tissue (SAT), and mid-thigh muscle cross-sectional area (CSA). Urine samples were collected to measure nitrogen excretion and 3-methylhistidine (3MH), markers of muscle protein breakdown. The results of this study could provide valuable insights into the effects of KS on body composition during weight loss.
Importance of Adequate Protein and Sodium
The study highlighted the importance of adequate protein and sodium intake during KDs. Consuming protein at a level of at least 1.5 g/kg of ideal body weight appears optimal for maintaining lean mass, while sufficient sodium intake can counteract the natriuretic effect of KDs.
Novel Approaches: Liquid Salts and Fat Absorption
Researchers at Harvard's Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering and John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) have developed a novel approach to weight management using a liquid salt called choline and geranate, or CAGE.
CAGE: Limiting Fat Absorption
CAGE, administered orally, can physically limit the absorption of fats from food without causing side effects in rats. In studies, it reduced total body weight by about 12 percent.
Mechanism of Action
CAGE was initially created to improve the body's absorption of medicines. However, researchers discovered that it could also prevent the uptake of certain hydrophobic molecules, such as fats.
Experimental Results
When mixed with an omega-3 fat called DHA and water, CAGE caused the DHA to form large particles that were poorly absorbed by the intestines. In rats fed a high-fat diet, a daily dose of CAGE resulted in 12 percent less weight gain compared to rats that did not receive CAGE. Importantly, no side effects were observed in the treated rats.
Potential for Obesity Therapy
These findings suggest that CAGE could be a potential therapy for obesity, offering a novel way to reduce fat absorption without adverse effects.
Korean Solar Salts: A Regional Approach to Weight Management
Research has explored the potential anti-obesity effects of Korean solar salts, which differ in mineral composition and processing methods from purified salt and other types of sea salt.
Solar Salt Composition and Processing
Solar salt, obtained from seawater through natural evaporation, contains various minerals, including potassium, magnesium, and calcium, in addition to sodium chloride. The mineral composition of solar salts can vary depending on the salt field, duration of aging, and manufacturing process.
Anti-Obesity Effects in Mice
A study involving mice fed a high-fat diet investigated the effects of different Korean solar salts on body weight, food efficiency ratio (FER), tissue weights, and serum concentrations of lipids, leptin, and insulin.
Key Findings
The study found that certain Korean solar salts (SS-T and SS-S) significantly reduced body weight gain, FER, and weight of epididymal adipose tissue (EAT) compared to the control group. These salts also decreased serum levels of triglycerides, total cholesterol, leptin, and insulin.
Gene Expression Analysis
Gene expression analysis revealed that SS-T and SS-S suppressed the expression of adipogenic and lipogenic mRNAs in the liver and EAT, while promoting the expression of beta-oxidation-related factors.
Mineral Composition and Ratios
The study also examined the mineral composition of the different solar salts, finding variations in sodium and potassium concentrations. The salts with lower sodium content and Na/K ratios (SS-T and SS-S) exhibited stronger anti-obesity effects.
Implications for Obesity Management
These findings suggest that well-processed Korean solar salts may have anti-obesity effects, potentially due to their unique mineral composition and processing methods.
CNS: Cube Natural Sea Salt, A Novel Approach
CNS (Cube Natural Sea Salt) intake reduces the basic parameters of obesity compared to NaCl and GS intake in high fat diet induced obese mice.A high fat diet (HFD) group of animals gains more weight than those fed a normal diet. Because this study focused on the interaction between HFD and salt samples, only the HFD and HFD + sample treated groups were compared; a normal diet group was not included. As shown in Fig. 4A, a significant decrease in body weight was observed in the CNS treatment group as compared to the NaCl (Reagent, Sigma-Aldrich Co., St. Louis, MO, USA) group at 12-16 weeks (P < 0.05). At 17 weeks, the reduction in body weight was significantly different in the CNS group (36.2 ± 4.9 g) than both the NaCl group (42.5 ± 3.5 g) and GS group (41.5 ± 5.0 g) (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4B). No significant difference in the AFI was observed between the groups (Supplement Fig. 3A). On the other hand, the CNS group had a significantly higher FCR than the HFD group at 16 and 17 weeks (Supplement Fig. 3B). At nine weeks, all mice inadvertently showed a decrease in body weight with a reduced AFI and enhanced FCR. After nine weeks, however, the body weight, AFI, and FCR of all the mice returned to normal conditions.
The measured serum lipids profiles revealed a significant reduction of triglyceride (TG), total cholesterol (TC), and low density lipoprotein (LDL) in the CNS group as compared to the NaCl group (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4C). In addition, the CNS group showed significantly reduced leptin levels (a serum obesity related hormone) as compared to HFD, NaCl, and GS groups (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4D). The liver enzyme concentrations showed significant reduction of aspartate transaminase (AST) and alanine transaminase (ALT) in the CNS group as compared to the NaCl group (P < 0.05) (Fig. 4E). On the other hand, the Na concentrations and glucose level in the serum remained unaffected with all salt treatments (Supplement Fig. 4A,B), indicating that the type of salt has no effect on the glucose metabolism, and 1% salt intake does not influence blood homeostasis in mice.
These observations showed that the CNS group had the lowest body weight at 17 weeks. Although the AFI or FCR were unaffected by 1% NaCl and the sea salt intake, the CNS group showed enhanced FCR at 16 and 17 weeks. In addition, the serum examination revealed reduced lipid accumulation, leptin and liver enzymes in the CNS group. Overall, NaCl intake increases obesity, but the CNS intake results in decreased obesity compared to NaCl intake in HFD-induced obese mice.