The carnivore diet, characterized by the exclusive consumption of animal products, has recently gained traction in the health and wellness community. This radical elimination diet emphasizes red meat, fish, and poultry, with some variations allowing eggs and certain dairy products, while typically excluding high-lactose foods. Proponents often cite evolutionary biology, suggesting that humans are optimized for processing animal proteins and fats. While some claim the carnivore diet can boost fertility, scientific evidence remains limited. This article critically examines the available research and potential impacts of the carnivore diet on fertility, considering both male and female reproductive health.
Diet and Fertility: A Complex Relationship
Numerous studies have demonstrated a link between diet and human fertility. However, the complexity of our diets makes it challenging to isolate the effects of specific food types on reproductive outcomes. Lifestyle factors, including dietary habits, significantly influence fertility. Rapid changes in dietary behavior, marked by decreased consumption of antioxidant-rich foods like fruits and vegetables and increased intake of trans fatty acids, saturated fat, and sodium, have impacted reproductive health.
Potential Benefits and Risks for Male Fertility
Sperm Quality and Meat Consumption
Research on the association between animal flesh foods and semen quality is limited. One cross-sectional study involving 400 infertile men investigated the relationship between animal flesh food consumption and sperm quality indicators. The study defined total meat consumption as the sum of red meat, poultry, fresh fish, canned fish, processed meats, and organ meats in the diet.
Fish Consumption and Sperm Motility
The study revealed that canned fish consumption was inversely related to sperm immotility. Men in the highest quartile of canned fish intake had a significantly lower sperm immotility compared to those in the lowest quartile. A similar trend was observed for fresh fish intake and sperm immotility, though this relationship was not linear across quartiles. However, fresh and canned fish intake was unrelated to other sperm quality outcomes.
Other Meat Types and Semen Quality
No association was found between the consumption of processed red meat, red meat, poultry, and organ meat, and semen quality indicators in the aforementioned study. These findings contrast with some previous studies.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet: An Autoimmune Solution?
Conflicting Evidence and the Need for Further Research
Several studies have explored the relationship between meat consumption and semen quality parameters, with varying results. Some studies suggest that high consumption of processed meat is associated with reduced sperm count and motility, while organ meat consumption is linked to higher sperm count, concentration, and motility. These discrepancies may be due to relatively small sample sizes and ethnic differences in previous studies, highlighting the need for further research to draw reliable conclusions.
Micronutrients in Organ Meats and Spermatogenesis
It has been suggested that nutrients concentrated in organ meats, such as vitamin B12, iron, animal fat, animal protein, manganese, and copper, may play a role in spermatogenesis. However, the lack of association between organ meat consumption and semen quality indicators in the Iranian study contradicts this hypothesis.
The Role of Fatty Acids in Fish
The study's findings suggest that canned fish consumption may positively impact sperm motility due to the amount of available omega-3 fatty acids. Polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) in fresh fish are unstable and may oxidize rapidly, potentially explaining the trend towards an inverse association between fresh fish consumption and sperm motility in the Iranian population.
Heavy Metals in Fish
Another possibility is that some pollutants, such as heavy metals, are highly stable, toxic, and not easily degradable in some fish which are not selected for canning by manufacturers. Fish and its products contain higher levels of heavy metals than other food groups, especially lead and cadmium, which can be harmful for sperm quality indicators.
Recommendations for Male Fertility
While the carnivore diet may not directly improve sperm health, decreasing processed meat consumption can be added to the list of recommendations for men prior to fertility treatments. This list includes stopping smoking, decreasing alcohol consumption, and losing weight.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet's Impact on Sleep
Potential Risks for Female Fertility
Menstruation Disruption and Hormonal Imbalances
The carnivore diet may pose specific risks for women's reproductive health. Extreme dietary restrictions can lead to hormonal imbalances.
Nutrient Deficiencies and Reproductive Health
The carnivore diet may lead to deficiencies in key nutrients important for reproductive health. Obtaining a full spectrum of vitamins and minerals requires consuming a wide variety of animal products, including organ meats.
Long-Term Effects on Reproductive Health
The long-term effects of a carnivore diet on women's reproductive health are not well-studied. Further research is needed to understand the potential risks and benefits.
Alternative Dietary Approaches for Fertility
The Mediterranean Diet
The Mediterranean diet (MedDiet), characterized by daily consumption of fruits and vegetables, legumes, whole grains, nuts, and olive oil, has shown promising results in improving fertility. Studies have demonstrated a higher percentage of clinical pregnancy and live births in patients undergoing assisted reproductive technologies (ART) with higher MedDiet adherence.
Key Components of the Mediterranean Diet and Their Benefits
- Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids (PUFAs): The MedDiet is linked to higher tissue levels of PUFAs, which act as precursors of anti-inflammatory eicosanoids.
- Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Found mainly in fatty fish, ω-3 fatty acids have been related to a positive outcome in women undergoing ART treatment, showing a significant association with embryo morphology. In males, ω-3 fatty acids act to reduce the risk of asthenozoospermia, improving normal sperm morphology, increasing total sperm count, concentration, motility, and volume, and reducing sperm DNA fragmentation.
- Whole Grains: Consumption of a low-carb MedDiet may be linked to lower sperm DNA fragmentation and increased testosterone levels.
- Plant Protein: Replacing animal protein with vegetable protein may reduce the risk of ovulatory infertility.
- Antioxidants: Vitamin E, vitamin C, lycopene, flavonoids, and polyphenols, commonly found in plant-based foods, act as potent free radical scavengers and antioxidants.
- Fruits and Vegetables: High intake of fruits and vegetables is related to a reduction in miscarriage risk.
The Elimination Diet
The elimination diet offers a systematic way to identify problem foods without the extreme restrictions of the carnivore diet.
Read also: Troubleshooting Carnivore Diet Diarrhea
The Importance of Personalized Nutrition
At Fab Fertile, a personalized approach to nutrition is championed, prioritizing individual needs and scientific evidence. The journey to optimal health is personal, and what works for one individual may not be suitable for another.
The Western Diet and Westernized Diets
The Western diet, characterized by high-glycemic-index carbohydrates, sweets, sweetened beverages, large amounts of animal protein (especially red and processed meat), saturated fatty acids, and trans-fatty acids, negatively affects endocrine metabolisms.
The "Fertility Diet"
A "fertility diet" consists of a lower intake of animal protein with a higher supply of vegetable protein, a high iron content, an increased supply of monounsaturated fatty acids with a simultaneous lower consumption of trans-fatty acids, consumption of high-fat dairy products, and the presence of carbohydrate products with a low glycemic index.
The Role of Body Weight and BMI
Low and high BMI and related metabolic implications are a risk factor for fertility.
- Low BMI: Women who are underweight (BMI < 19 kg/m2) have been shown to have four times longer time to get pregnant than women with correct weight.
- High BMI: Obesity clearly increases women’s risk of miscarriage, poor pregnancy outcomes, and impairment of fetal well-being.
The Impact of Lifestyle Factors
Lifestyle seems to have a major impact on reproductive health, in terms of body weight, body composition, physical activity, and nutrient intake. Both quantitative and qualitative dietary characteristics affect fertility.
The Declining Total Fertility Rate (TFR)
The total fertility rate (TFR) is the average number of children that women would have if they were to live until the end of the reproductive period and if they were subject to the current age-specific fertility rates. This decline is linked to different factors; among them, high-calorie food and more sedentary lifestyles have a great impact on fertility both in high-income countries and in low-income countries.
The Role of Oxidative Stress
The risk of anovulatory infertility is correlated with oxidative stress. For this reason, antioxidants also seem to be important for proper ovulation.
Expert Opinions
While it seems "sensible" to at least try the tactic, Dr. suggests that perhaps it is not the meat that is the problem, but the dietary choices that men who eat bacon make.