"Animal," a 2025 documentary, delves into the increasingly popular carnivore diet, presenting a compelling, albeit somewhat controversial, case for its benefits. Written and directed by Josh Feldman, and starring Zane Griggs, Anthony Chaffee, and Steak And Butter Gal, the film attempts to debunk conventional wisdom surrounding diet and health, suggesting a return to a meat-based way of eating can resolve many modern health issues. The documentary, running for 1 hour and 29 minutes, is available digitally and in select theaters as of June 20.
A Deep Dive into the Carnivore Diet
The carnivore diet, often dubbed "The Caveman Diet," centers around consuming primarily animal products, such as meat, butter, and eggs, while excluding or minimizing plant-based foods like carbohydrates and vegetables. "Animal" features doctors, coaches, and internet influencers who advocate for this diet, sharing testimonials of its life-changing effects. These proponents argue that a meat-led diet can lead to significant improvements in both physical and mental well-being.
Unmasking a Century-Long Conspiracy?
The documentary posits that political, economic, and religious forces have conspired to distort our natural relationship with meat, leading to widespread ill health and dependence on the pharmaceutical industry. "Animal" suggests that by returning to a diet rich in animal products, individuals can break free from this cycle and reclaim their health.
Testimonials and Personal Experiences
"Animal" relies heavily on personal testimonials to illustrate the purported benefits of the carnivore diet. For instance, the documentary highlights individuals who have experienced significant weight loss and improved health outcomes after adopting the diet. One reviewer mentioned their adult children lost so much weight in 1 year on the Carnivore Diet and are the healthiest they have ever been, both mentally and physically. Another individual reported losing 85 pounds on the diet. These stories serve to showcase the diet's potential impact on individuals seeking to improve their health.
Regenerative Agriculture: A Key Component
In its final 20 minutes, "Animal" emphasizes the importance of regenerative farming and environmental stewardship. This message underscores the idea that ethical and sustainable meat production is crucial to supporting both human health and the planet. By promoting regenerative agriculture, the film suggests that a carnivore diet can be part of a broader movement towards a more sustainable and environmentally conscious food system.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet: An Autoimmune Solution?
Criticisms and Concerns
Despite its compelling presentation, "Animal" has faced criticism for its perceived lack of balance and reliance on anecdotal evidence. Some critics argue that the film feels like a lengthy infomercial, selectively presenting scientific information to support its claims. One reviewer noted that the film didn't seem to make use of the actual data/literature and that there are tons of data on low-carb/keto diets, with randomized control trials showing their efficacy.
Another criticism is the omission of alternative perspectives and potential drawbacks of the carnivore diet. For example, the film does not adequately address the potential environmental impact of widespread meat consumption or the socioeconomic factors that influence access to quality meat.
Additionally, the film's editing and presentation have been criticized. Some viewers found the camerawork shaky, the color grading inconsistent, and the use of stock footage jarring. These technical issues can detract from the film's overall credibility and impact.
The Importance of Individualized Approaches
It is important to recognize that not all diets work for every individual. Factors such as genetics, lifestyle, and underlying health conditions can influence how a person responds to a particular dietary approach. As one reviewer noted, it is important to note that everyone must do their own research to help themselves be the best version that they can be.
The Keto Diet Experience
The documentary touches on aspects of the keto diet, a low-carbohydrate, high-fat diet that shares some similarities with the carnivore diet. One reviewer shared their personal experience with the keto diet, noting that while they experienced immediate physical results, they found it challenging to sustain in the long term. This highlights the importance of considering individual preferences and lifestyles when choosing a diet.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet's Impact on Sleep
Data and Scientific Evidence
Critics have pointed out the documentary's limited use of scientific data and literature to support its claims. Some argue that the film should have included more information on studies related to low-carb and keto diets, as well as data on the potential risks and benefits of the carnivore diet.
For example, one reviewer cited the Minnesota Coronary Experiment, which involved about 9000 participants and showed that lowering saturated fat in the intervention group resulted in more deaths than in the control group. They also mentioned the Sydney Heart Study, which showed similar results with decreased sat fat as intervention.
Additionally, the reviewer pointed to a 140,000 patient study of all heart attacks, where almost 50% of the group had low blood cholesterol ldl<100. These examples suggest that the relationship between diet and health is complex and that more research is needed to fully understand the effects of the carnivore diet.
The Role of Big Pharma and Processed Foods
"Animal" suggests that the pharmaceutical and processed food industries have a vested interest in promoting unhealthy diets and treatments for diet-related illnesses. While it is easy to agree with the profit-driven motivation of these industries, it’s challenging to accept that organically grown vegetables are trying to poison me. The documentary argues that these industries profit from keeping people sick and dependent on their products.
A Call for Critical Thinking
Ultimately, "Animal" encourages viewers to question conventional wisdom about diet and health and to consider alternative approaches, such as the carnivore diet. Viewers will have to come to their own conclusions based on the information presented, personal health journey, and availability of resources. However, it is important to approach the film with a critical eye, considering both its strengths and weaknesses.
Read also: Troubleshooting Carnivore Diet Diarrhea
Diversity and Representation
One reviewer raised concerns about the lack of diversity in the film's interviewees. The fact that the only two black individuals interviewed are UK residents, a former bodybuilder, and his health coach daughter is glaring. This lack of representation can limit the film's appeal and relevance to a broader audience.
tags: #carnivore #diet #documentary