The carnivore diet, an eating regimen primarily consisting of animal products, has sparked considerable debate within the health and nutrition communities. This article aims to explore the implications of a carnivore diet on blood work results, drawing upon expert opinions, scientific studies, and real-world examples to provide a balanced and informative perspective.
Introduction: The Carnivore Diet Phenomenon
The carnivore diet stands in stark contrast to conventional dietary advice, which typically emphasizes the consumption of a balanced diet rich in fruits and vegetables. Proponents of the carnivore diet, however, advocate for the elimination of almost all plant-based foods in favor of meat, citing potential health benefits and improved well-being.
Case Studies and Anecdotal Evidence
Mikhaila Peterson's Experience
Mikhaila Peterson, a prominent advocate of the carnivore diet, has publicly shared her blood work results, which she claims demonstrate her good health while adhering to this restrictive eating plan. While some may point to slightly elevated LDL-P (low-density lipoprotein particle) levels, her overall lipid profile, according to Framingham percentiles, places her in the 98th percentile, despite consuming a diet exclusively consisting of beef.
It's worth noting that individual responses to the carnivore diet can vary significantly. One hypothesis suggests that Mikhaila Peterson may possess a genetic predisposition, such as decreased PCSK9 activity, which enhances the clearance of LDL particles from her bloodstream through the liver. PCSK9, a gene targeted by various drugs, influences the number of LDL receptors available to clear cholesterol, with lower activity potentially leading to more efficient LDL clearance.
Ray Hicks' Journey
Ray Hicks, who adopted the carnivore diet for a year, underwent extensive blood tests to assess its impact on his health. His diet primarily consisted of 12 eggs a day, red meat, and slabs of butter. While his red and white blood cell counts were notably strong, some of his results fell outside the normal range.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet: An Autoimmune Solution?
Hicks' creatinine levels, which indicate kidney function, were slightly elevated. However, he remained unconcerned, citing his normal blood urea nitrogen (BUN) levels as reassurance. His cholesterol levels were also elevated, with total cholesterol at 275 mg/dL and LDL exceeding the recommended limit. Despite these findings, Hicks emphasized the importance of the triglycerides-to-HDL ratio, which he believes is a better predictor of heart disease risk. His ratio was .61, which he considered phenomenal and well below the 2 marker.
After following a strict carnivore diet, Hicks began reintroducing fruits, vegetables, and dairy into his diet to see if he could find anything that makes him feel better or worse. The reintroduction of plant-based foods led to some discomfort, including bloating and joint pain.
Expert Opinion on Cholesterol and Heart Disease
Dr. Philip Ovadia, a cardiothoracic surgeon, cautions against relying solely on blood cholesterol markers as predictors of heart disease risk. He emphasizes the importance of considering the environment in which lipoproteins exist and their quality, noting that elevated cholesterol levels in the context of inflammation and insulin resistance may have different implications than those occurring in a healthy metabolic environment.
Scientific Studies and Surveys
Exploratory Study on Carnivore Dieters
An exploratory study was conducted involving 24 individuals following a carnivore-type diet for at least one month. The study collected data through questionnaires and blood panels, comparing pre-diet and on-diet metabolic parameters.
The study found that most participants adopted the carnivore diet for health-related reasons and reported subjective health improvements. The majority (62.5%) were male, with a median age of 46 years. Before the carnivore diet, participants followed various diets, including ketogenic and standard diets.
Read also: The Carnivore Diet's Impact on Sleep
The study revealed no significant differences between on-diet and pre-diet blood parameters, except for total and LDL cholesterol concentrations, which were significantly elevated. This suggests that while the carnivore diet may offer certain benefits, it can also have a notable impact on cholesterol levels.
Motivations and Subjective Changes
The study also explored the motivations behind adopting a carnivore diet and the subjective changes experienced by participants. Health reasons were the primary motivator, with individuals reporting improvements in various health-related categories. The average self-reported daily meat intake was 626 g, with the diet primarily consisting of organs, eggs, dairy products, and fish.
Qualitative interviews conducted with a subset of participants revealed common themes, including naturalness, health, and simplicity and freedom. Participants reported that the carnivore diet simplified their lives, reduced food-related stress, and provided a sense of control over their health.
Potential Risks and Considerations
Elevated Cholesterol Levels
One of the primary concerns associated with the carnivore diet is the potential for elevated cholesterol levels. Studies have shown that total and LDL cholesterol concentrations can increase significantly on a carnivore diet, potentially exceeding reference ranges in some individuals.
While some experts, like Dr. Philip Ovadia, caution against placing too much emphasis on total cholesterol levels, it is essential to monitor lipid profiles closely and consider other factors, such as the triglycerides-to-HDL ratio, to assess heart disease risk comprehensively.
Read also: Troubleshooting Carnivore Diet Diarrhea
Kidney Function
Elevated creatinine levels, as observed in Ray Hicks' case, can indicate potential kidney issues. Creatinine is a waste product filtered out by the kidneys, and elevated levels may suggest impaired kidney function.
Individuals following a carnivore diet should monitor their kidney function through regular blood tests and consult with a healthcare professional if they experience any concerning symptoms.
Nutrient Deficiencies
The carnivore diet's restrictive nature raises concerns about potential nutrient deficiencies. By eliminating plant-based foods, individuals may miss out on essential vitamins, minerals, and fiber.
To mitigate this risk, it is crucial to consume a variety of animal products, including organ meats, which are rich in micronutrients. Additionally, supplementation may be necessary to address any identified deficiencies.
Individual Variability
It is important to recognize that individual responses to the carnivore diet can vary significantly. Factors such as genetics, pre-existing health conditions, and lifestyle choices can influence how the body responds to this eating plan.
What works for one person may not work for another, and it is essential to approach the carnivore diet with caution and under the guidance of a healthcare professional.
Alternative Perspectives and Considerations
The Role of Genetics
Genetic factors may play a significant role in determining an individual's response to the carnivore diet. For example, variations in genes like PCSK9 can influence cholesterol metabolism and LDL particle clearance.
Genetic testing can provide valuable insights into an individual's predispositions and help tailor dietary recommendations accordingly.
The Importance of a Balanced Approach
While the carnivore diet may offer certain benefits for some individuals, it is not necessarily the optimal dietary approach for everyone. A balanced diet that includes a variety of nutrient-rich foods, including fruits, vegetables, and whole grains, is generally recommended for overall health and well-being.
The Impact of Lifestyle Factors
Lifestyle factors, such as exercise, stress management, and sleep quality, can also influence blood work results and overall health. It is essential to consider these factors in conjunction with dietary choices to achieve optimal well-being.
Attia vs. Longo: Protein Preferences
The debate over meat consumption often involves contrasting viewpoints from leading health experts. Dr. Peter Attia believes that meat can be incorporated as part of a healthy diet, while Dr. Valter Longo leans towards a more plant-based approach.
It is important to note that neither physician advocates for a carnivore diet, recognizing the potential risks associated with such a restrictive eating plan.
Metabolizing Protein and the Urea Cycle
Metabolizing protein leaves behind waste in the form of ammonia. If there is too much ammonia in the blood, it may be a sign that you are eating too much protein. Some people do a great job of getting rid of ammonia and urea, however, not everyone is so lucky. Diminished urea cycle metabolism means diminished protein metabolism.
Key Blood Markers to Monitor
LDL Particle Count (LDL-P)
The LDL particle count, or LDL-P, is a crucial marker for assessing heart disease risk. Lipoproteins carry fats around the body, and the more of these âfat taxisâ on the road, the greater chance they crash into an artery wall which triggers the inflammatory reaction that leads to heart disease over the long term.
Trimethylamine-N-Oxide (TMAO)
Trimethylamine-N-oxide, or TMAO, is a gut metabolite that has been linked to heart disease. The microbiome naturally produces TMAO when we eat carnitine, an amino acid found in fish and meat, as well as fats like choline, which is found in high amounts in egg yolks as well as certain supplements.
Insulin-like Growth Factor 1 (IGF-1)
Insulin-like growth factor 1, or IGF-1, is a hormone that plays a role in muscle growth and cell proliferation. Elevated IGF-1 levels have been linked to an increased risk of cancer.
C-Reactive Protein (CRP)
C-reactive protein, or CRP, is a marker of inflammation in the body. High levels of CRP can be a sign of a diverse range of conditions, ranging from chronic infection, to autoimmune conditions like Rheumatoid arthritis, to heart disease.