High-protein, low-carbohydrate diets have gained significant popularity as a weight loss strategy and for managing certain health conditions. These diets emphasize the consumption of protein-rich foods while restricting carbohydrates. While they can offer certain benefits, it's crucial to understand the potential risks associated with high protein intake, especially for healthy individuals. This article provides a comprehensive overview of these risks, grounded in scientific evidence.
What are High-Protein, Low-Carb Diets?
High-protein, low-carbohydrate diets involve increasing the proportion of protein-rich foods in one's daily diet while limiting carbohydrates, such as grains and starchy vegetables. Many people adopt this dietary approach for weight loss, but these diets are also used to manage health issues like high blood sugar, diabetes, and prediabetes. There are various approaches to these diets, each with different guidelines regarding the types and amounts of carbohydrates allowed.
These diets gained traction in the 1970s, largely due to the popularity of The Atkins Diet, which was heavily promoted as an effective weight loss plan. Other well-known high-protein, low-carb diets include the Paleo, South Beach, and keto diets. These programs typically recommend that individuals obtain 30% to 50% of their total daily calories from protein. In contrast, organizations like the American Heart Association recommend a diet with a smaller protein percentage, suggesting that 10% to 35% of daily calories should come from protein, which translates to about 46 grams for adult women and 56 grams for adult men.
Potential Benefits of High-Protein, Low-Carb Diets
These diets can offer several benefits, including:
- Weight Loss: High-protein diets can promote satiety and reduce cravings, which can lead to weight loss. Some initial weight loss is often attributed to water loss from reduced carbohydrate intake.
- Blood Sugar Control: Low-carb diets can help manage blood sugar levels, benefiting individuals with diabetes and prediabetes.
- Muscle Maintenance and Building: Increasing protein intake while losing weight can help maintain and build muscle mass, which is often reduced in other diets.
Grace Derocha, RDN, CDCES, Spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, notes that many people are drawn to high-protein, low-carb diets as they shift the body's fuel source from carbs and sugars to fats and proteins. This leads to metabolic and appetite changes that can make you stay satisfied for longer after meals, build muscle mass, and lose weight."
Read also: Healthy food access with Highmark Wholecare explained.
Risks Associated with High-Protein Diets
Despite the potential benefits, high-protein diets can pose several risks, especially when followed long-term or by individuals with certain pre-existing conditions.
High Cholesterol and Heart Disease
Some high-protein diets rely on protein sources high in saturated fat, such as fatty cuts of meat and whole dairy products. These foods can elevate cholesterol levels, increasing the risk of heart disease. While some studies, like those on the Atkins diet, have shown a drop in "bad" cholesterol, it's essential to choose lean protein sources to mitigate this risk.
Nutrient Deficiencies
Restricting carbohydrates can lead to inadequate intake of essential nutrients found in fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. This can result in nutrient gaps if the diet is not carefully planned to include a variety of nutrient-dense foods.
Kidney Problems
Excessive protein intake can strain the kidneys, particularly in individuals with pre-existing kidney issues. This added strain can worsen kidney function. People that eat very high protein diets have a higher risk of kidney stones.
Osteoporosis and Kidney Stones
High-protein diets may increase calcium excretion through urine, potentially increasing the risk of osteoporosis and kidney stones. However, the evidence on this is conflicting, and more research is needed.
Read also: Healthy Eating on the Run
Other Potential Risks
Research suggests that long-term consumption of a high-protein diet could be linked with metabolic and clinical problems, such as loss of bone mass and renal dysfunction.
Specific Groups Who Should Avoid High-Protein Diets
Certain individuals should avoid high-protein, low-carb diets due to the associated health risks. These groups include:
- Individuals with Kidney Disease or Issues: High protein intake can further strain the kidneys.
- Individuals with a History of Disordered Eating or Eating Disorders: Low-carb diets can promote restrictive eating patterns.
- Pregnant or Breastfeeding Women: Nutrient-dense diets are crucial during these stages, and restrictive diets may not provide adequate nutrition.
- Individuals with Constipation Concerns: Low-carb, high-protein diets can reduce fiber intake, leading to constipation.
The Science Behind Protein's Effect on Satiety and Weight Loss
High-protein meals and foods are thought to have a greater satiating effect than high-carbohydrate or high-fat meals. The effect of high-protein diets on the modulation of satiety involves multiple metabolic pathways. Protein intake induces complex signals, with peptide hormones being released from the gastrointestinal tract and blood amino acids and derived metabolites being released in the blood. Protein intake also stimulates metabolic hormones that communicate information about energy status to the brain. Long-term ingestion of high amounts of protein seems to decrease food intake, body weight, and body adiposity in many well-documented studies.
Hormonal Mechanisms
Protein intake triggers the release of several gastrointestinal hormones that play a role in satiety:
- Cholecystokinin (CCK): Secreted by duodenal and ileal cells, CCK causes the release of digestive enzymes and bile. It also binds to receptors, leading to a sensation of fullness.
- Peptide YY3-36 (PYY3-36): Mainly secreted by L cells in the distal segments of the gut, PYY3-36 reduces caloric intake and may act at the hypothalamus via vagal pathways.
- Glucagon-Like Peptide-1 (GLP-1): Released in the gastrointestinal tract after food consumption, GLP-1 delays gastric emptying and stimulates insulin synthesis and secretion, suppressing glucagon secretion.
Brain Reward Mechanisms
Besides stimulating satiety centers, protein intake seems to diminish brain reward mechanisms. The central mesolimbic reward system generates a sensation of pleasure and promotes the motivation for food consumption through its activation. However, its inactivation decreases the hunger sensation. Studies have shown that high-protein diets reduce reward-driven eating behavior through the activation of specific brain regions in the corticolimbic system.
Read also: Mobile Dining Revolution
High Protein Intake and Bone Health
Aging leads to progressive bone loss, which may result in osteoporosis. High-protein diets could positively affect calcium and bone homeostasis through their effects on calcium absorption, bone turnover, and production of insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). It has been shown that higher protein consumption increases intestinal calcium absorption.
Another explanation for the increase in calcium absorption can be found in the fact that protein induces gastric acid secretion. The acidic pH in the stomach allows calcium ionization and subsequent absorption. IGF-1 modulates bone homeostasis by promoting osteoblast activity and stimulating renal phosphate resorption.
Protein Intake Recommendations
The ideal amount of protein you should consume each day is a bit uncertain. Commonly quoted recommendations are 56 grams/day for men, 46 grams/day for women. You could get 46 grams/day of protein in 1 serving of low-fat Greek yogurt, a 4 oz. A weight-based recommended daily allowance (RDA) of 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight. For a 140-pound person, that comes to 51 grams of protein each day.
Some experts suggest that these recommendations are all wrong and that we should be consuming more protein, up to twice the standard recommendations. The short answer is yes. As with most things in life, there can be too much of a good thing and if you eat too much protein, there may be a price to pay.
Protein should account for 10% to 35% of your calories. The recommended dietary allowance to prevent deficiency for an average sedentary adult is 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight. Once you're between the ages of 40 and 50, sarcopenia â losing muscle mass as you age â begins to set in. People who exercise regularly also have higher needs, about 1.1-1.5 grams per kilogram. People who regularly lift weights or are training for a running or cycling event need 1.2-1.7 grams per kilogram. If you are overweight, your weight should be adjusted before calculating your protein needs to avoid overestimating.
High Protein Intake and Kidney Stones
Low fluid intake and excessive intake of protein are important risk factors for kidney stones [3]. Protein ingestion increases renal acid excretion, and acid loads, in turn, may be buffered in part by bone, which releases calcium to be excreted by the kidney. This protein-induced hypercalciuria could lead to the formation of calcium kidney stones [4]. Furthermore, animal protein is also the major dietary source of purines, the precursors of uric acid. Excessive intake of animal protein is therefore associated with hyperuricosuria, a condition present in some uric acid stone formers.
Meal Ideas and Food Choices
If you're considering a high-protein, low-carb diet, focus on incorporating lean protein sources and low-carb vegetables. Some examples of high-protein, low-carb foods include:
- Meats (poultry, fish, red meat)
- Eggs
- Healthy fats and oils (avocados, olive oil)
- Low-carb vegetables (broccoli, kale, spinach, cucumbers)
- Cheese
- Nuts
- Cauliflower rice
- Beans, legumes, and lentils
- Greek yogurt
- Tofu and tempeh
- Lower-carb fruits (raspberries, blackberries)
Here are a few meal ideas for high-protein, low-carb diets:
- Breakfast: Omelet with bell peppers, spinach, and cheese; tofu scramble with kale and broccoli; Greek yogurt with blackberries.
- Lunch: Tuna salad with egg, feta, and avocado; chopped salad with shrimp, egg, and avocado; cobb salad with grilled chicken.
- Dinner: Chicken and fried cauliflower rice; lettuce tacos with beef, veggies, and guacamole; spicy salmon nori wraps; salmon and steamed broccoli.
A Note of Caution
While high-protein, low-carb diets can help some people lose weight, they come with risks and can be hard to stick with for long-term benefits. It's important to consult with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian before starting any new diet, especially one that involves significant macronutrient changes. They can help you create a plan that ensures you're getting enough fruits and vegetables and that you're choosing lean protein sources. Remember, sustainable weight loss is usually based on changes you can maintain long-term, rather than a temporary diet.