The weight loss industry is flooded with products and programs promising quick and easy results. GOLO, LLC is a health and wellness brand that offers proprietary diet plans, weight loss solutions, and health-focused cookbooks. They market a program centered around their Release supplement and a balanced approach to diet and exercise. However, GOLO has also faced scrutiny and legal challenges, raising questions about the validity of its claims and the safety of similar weight loss products.
GOLO's Offerings and Claims
GOLO promotes a holistic approach to weight loss, emphasizing metabolic health and insulin resistance. Their program includes:
- Release Supplement: A proprietary formula designed to target stubborn fat, reduce hunger and cravings, enhance energy and stamina, and support healthy insulin metabolism.
- GOLO for Life Plan: A lifestyle plan focused on good nutrition, potentially reducing muscle loss during weight loss.
- Ready-to-Eat Meals: Nutrient-packed meals crafted with 16 superfoods, delivered directly to your door.
- Wellness Scale App: An app that displays simple-to-understand data based on user trends and results.
- AeroTrainer®: An inflatable exercise tool designed to make at-home fitness easier.
- Recipe Books: Recipe books offering healthy meal ideas.
GOLO claims that their approach can help individuals manage cravings, overcome diet challenges, and achieve steady fat loss and better metabolic health. They emphasize the role of insulin resistance in weight gain and related health conditions. They claim that their products are designed to provide effective and fast-acting results. They also state that Release is safe for use alongside medications, including those for type 2 diabetes.
Testimonials on the GOLO website showcase individuals who have experienced significant weight loss, such as Sholeh, who lost 75 lbs, Michael, who lost 62 lbs, and Kevin, who lost 152 lb. These testimonials highlight improvements in overall health and well-being.
The company offers a 60-day money-back guarantee for their supplements and AeroTrainer®.
Read also: Are Keto Gummies right for you?
Legal Challenges: GOLO, LLC v. Amazon.com Services LLC
GOLO initiated legal action against Amazon, alleging trademark infringement, counterfeiting, unfair competition, false advertising, dilution, and violation of the Delaware Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA). GOLO claimed that Amazon offered GOLO counterfeits for sale and used its marketing tools to divert customers to purchase those imitations.
Amazon responded with a counterclaim for violation of the DTPA, asserting that GOLO falsely advertises the health benefits of its products, including claims that they are “clinically proven” to deliver weight loss, nutritional, and disease-preventative benefits.
Court's Decision on Amazon's Counterclaim
The court addressed GOLO's motion to dismiss Amazon's counterclaim for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. The court found that GOLO’s claims centered on Amazon’s conduct with respect to Amazon’s sponsored products, and the counterclaim was about GOLO’s conduct with respect to GOLO’s products.
The court determined that the claims did not share a "common nucleus of operative fact." GOLO’s claims concerned Amazon’s “infringing and counterfeiting [of] GOLO’s trademarks,” Amazon’s marketing statements, Amazon’s products, and Amazon’s algorithmic search engine practices. The counterclaim concerned GOLO’s marketing statements and GOLO’s products.
The court noted that the evidence required to prove each side's claims further illustrated the discrepancy. Amazon propounded 82 new discovery requests, nine new interrogatories, and four new subpoenas after introducing the Counterclaim to the action - having previously served 65 requests in defending GOLO’s claims. The court found that this doubling of discovery volume signaled that the issues were “quite distinct.”
Read also: The Truth About Weight Loss Patches
The court rejected Amazon's argument that GOLO had affirmatively placed its advertising at issue, stating that advertising expenditure - not accuracy - is a relevant metric for "marketplace recognition enjoyed by the mark." The court concluded that the proper inquiry was how strong GOLO's brand equity is in the minds of its clientele, not whether GOLO's products are scientifically effective.
The court acknowledged that both sides asserted false advertising claims about products in the wellness sector and the veracity of the advertising statements designed to sell them. However, the court stated that the "mere tangential overlap of facts is insufficient" to confer supplemental jurisdiction. The court concluded that the nexus was no more than "tangential," "loose," or "peripheral" and dismissed the counterclaim for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
Court's Decision on Affirmative Defenses
GOLO moved to strike two of Amazon’s affirmative defenses: unclean hands and laches. The court agreed to strike the unclean hands defense but disagreed on the laches defense.
The court stated that the conduct alleged must have an immediate and necessary relationship to the equity which the plaintiff seeks to obtain. Amazon’s ninth affirmative defense stated that Plaintiff’s claims are barred in light of its false and misleading claims regarding its GOLO-branded products and services that purportedly compete with products available for sale on Amazon and that form the basis of its claims.
The court had already ruled that GOLO’s alleged false advertising, which “form[s] the basis of [Amazon’s] counterclaim,” was not sufficiently related to GOLO’s claims. For the same reasons, Amazon’s unclean hands affirmative defense was not “immediately related” to the conduct at issue, and the court struck it.
Read also: The Truth About Speedy Keto ACV Gummies
Amazon’s eighth affirmative defense stated that Plaintiff’s claims arising under Delaware state law are barred in part by the statute of limitations and/or laches and Plaintiff’s claims arising under the Lanham Act are barred in part by laches. The court found that Amazon’s laches defense was adequately alleged.
The Broader Context: Hidden Ingredients in Weight Loss Products
The legal battle between GOLO and Amazon highlights the importance of scrutinizing the claims and ingredients of weight loss products. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued numerous public notifications about weight loss products found to contain hidden drug ingredients.
These hidden ingredients can pose serious health risks. Some of the commonly found substances include:
- Sibutramine: A controlled substance that was previously used as an appetite suppressant but was withdrawn from the market due to cardiovascular risks.
- Phenolphthalein: A chemical previously used as a laxative but no longer used due to concerns about potential carcinogenicity.
- Other prescription drugs: Weight loss products have been found to contain undeclared prescription drugs, which can interact with other medications and cause adverse effects.
The FDA maintains a list of tainted weight loss products that have been found to contain hidden ingredients. Consumers are advised to exercise caution and consult with healthcare professionals before using any weight loss product, especially those marketed with exaggerated claims or those purchased from unregulated sources.
Understanding Insulin Resistance
GOLO emphasizes the role of insulin resistance in weight gain and metabolic health. Insulin resistance is a condition in which the body produces insulin but does not use it effectively. This can lead to elevated blood sugar levels, increased fat storage, and an increased risk of developing pre-diabetes and type 2 diabetes.
Several factors can contribute to insulin resistance, including:
- Unbalanced diet: A diet high in processed foods, sugary drinks, and unhealthy fats can impair insulin sensitivity.
- Lack of physical activity: Regular exercise helps improve insulin sensitivity and glucose metabolism.
- Excess weight: Obesity, particularly abdominal obesity, is strongly associated with insulin resistance.
- Genetics: Some individuals may be genetically predisposed to insulin resistance.