For years, the nutrition industry has been dominated by generalized diets and weight loss plans. Zoe, a relatively new nutrition company, aims to revolutionize this space by offering a data-driven, personalized nutrition program designed to optimize gut and metabolic health. Launched in April 2022, Zoe has quickly gained traction, boasting over 100,000 members who rely on its program and related products to inform their dietary choices.
Zoe's Personalized Nutrition: An Overview
The Zoe personalized nutrition program was conceived in 2017 by Jonathan Wolf, George Hadjigeorgiou, and Tim Spector. Spector, a professor of genetic epidemiology at King’s College, London, brings a strong scientific foundation to the company. His most notable study, which involved 14,000 twins over 25 years, demonstrated that even identical twins with the same genes can have different responses to food. This finding became a cornerstone of Zoe's approach, emphasizing the importance of personalized nutrition.
The founding members were clear about leveraging science as the unique selling proposition for their personalized nutrition program. Zoe aims to use individual biological data to predict metabolic responses to food and provide tailored nutritional recommendations.
Zoe Program: A nutrition program with tests to measure your metabolism and a personalized week-by-week meal plan according to your biology.
Daily30+: An energy-boosting whole food supplement with 30+ superplants.
Read also: Victoza: Dosage, side effects, and weight loss results
A Closer Look at Zoe's Program
Before committing to Zoe’s personalized nutrition program, it is important to explore the key service and quality aspects of the platform. These include:
Scientific Validity
Zoe's approach is rooted in its PREDICT research program, one of the largest nutritional studies globally. This program has amassed a vast database consisting of approximately 4 million glucose readings, 56,000 triglyceride readings (blood fat responses), and 12 terabytes of microbiome data.
In theory, Zoe utilizes this biological data to create machine learning models. These models aim to predict an individual's unique metabolic responses to foods and provide nutritional recommendations that support long-term health. While the transparency around the data tested adds a layer of credibility to Zoe’s program, the studies are typically backed by researchers affiliated with the company.
However, external validation of Zoe's claims has been mixed. Dr. Nicola Guess, an academic dietitian and diabetes researcher at the University of Oxford, has pointed out that glucose levels naturally fluctuate in proportion to carbohydrate consumption. She argues that a post-meal glucose spike doesn't necessarily indicate the "healthiness" of a food. Dr. Guess further contends that Zoe's studies don't conclusively prove that its personalized nutrition advice is superior to generic healthy eating tips.
Professor Partha Kar, a diabetes advisor for NHS England, has also cautioned against continuous blood sugar monitoring, suggesting it could lead to eating disorders, particularly among individuals without diabetes.
Read also: Red Mountain Weight Loss: Benefits, Risks, and Results.
Testing Techniques
Zoe’s personalized nutrition program employs three primary testing techniques:
- Blood Sugar Test: This involves wearing a continuous glucose monitor (CGM) for 14 days. Participants must consent to participate in the company’s ongoing clinical study to use this monitor.
- Blood Fat Test: This test is based on a blood sample collected using a finger-prick kit.
- Gut Microbiome Test: This test involves submitting a stool sample for analysis.
Participants receive a ZOE Score indicating their current metabolic health. They are also required to submit samples frequently to track their progress, which some users might find burdensome.
Program Overview
After completing the tests, Zoe's program requires users to log all their meals into the app to receive insights into how food affects them. The app uses artificial intelligence to assign each meal a score from 1 to 100, supposedly indicating how beneficial the food is based on the user's data. The app also provides caloric information, but it does not emphasize calorie counting.
Daily30+ Supplement
Zoe offers a supplement called Daily30+, which contains over 30 superplants and provides 5 grams of fiber per day. It is designed to be sprinkled on savory meals. A clinical trial conducted by Zoe found that 51% of participants reported improved energy levels after using Daily30+, a result that some might find underwhelming.
Waitrose, a grocery store in the United Kingdom, recalled this supplement due to potential contamination with small stones and metal fragments. As of now, it is not available for sale.
Read also: The Nobel Trick: GLP-1 drugs and weight loss.
Pricing Plans
Zoe offers several pricing plans, including a Complete plan with a retest kit. However, many users feel the pricing is high, considering the platform's insights are primarily food scores and recommendations.
Customer Support
While Zoe Nutrition generally has a good rating on Trustpilot, there have been numerous negative reviews, especially starting in late 2024, regarding poor customer support. Common issues include limited availability of human support agents, unsatisfactory chatbot support, unwanted auto-renewals, issues with returns and refunds, delays or unavailability of Daily30+ products, unclear billing and refund policies, lack of blood sample analysis, and misleading testing instructions.
Many customers have reported difficulties in obtaining refunds, as the company's policy considers all sales final and non-cancelable unless the order has not yet been prepared.
The Science Behind Zoe: A Critical Perspective
Zoe’s personalized nutrition program is grounded in the idea that each individual responds differently to the same foods, largely due to variations in their gut microbiomes. The program aims to translate this understanding into tailored dietary advice.
However, some experts argue that the personalization aspect of Zoe may be overstated. As one of our testers noted, "I was disappointed to see that any food I knew to be healthy was highly rated (in the ‘Enjoy freely’ category), and any food I knew would be unhealthy scored poorly (only to be eaten ‘once in a while’). It didn’t feel that these recommendations were personalized to my metabolism - I’d imagine them to be the same for everyone."
The Role of Continuous Glucose Monitoring (CGM)
Zoe utilizes CGMs to allow users to monitor their blood glucose fluctuations in real-time, particularly after meals. The theory is that by identifying foods that cause significant glucose spikes, individuals can adjust their diet to maintain more stable blood sugar levels.
However, many scientists are skeptical about the value of CGMs for individuals without diabetes. Dr. Nicola Guess argues that "Glucose in someone without diabetes is a minuscule part of your overall metabolic health, let alone overall health. There is a lot of interpersonal variability, and one person might have more and bigger peaks than another yet have the same average blood sugar level."
The Gut Microbiome: An Incomplete Picture?
Zoe's program also incorporates stool analysis to assess the composition of the gut microbiome. While the microbiome undoubtedly plays a role in health, experts like James Kinross believe that we do not yet have a complete understanding of what constitutes a healthy microbiome.
Moreover, the concept of "good" and "bad" bacteria is an oversimplification. As Jacques Ravel explains, "There are some E coli that are going to give you major diarrhea, and there are some that are essential for your wellbeing." Therefore, testing for specific bacteria may not provide clinically valid information.
Concerns about Disordered Eating
Some doctors have raised concerns that Zoe’s emphasis on food scores and continuous monitoring could lead to unhealthy obsessions and disordered eating patterns. Shivani Misra, a consultant doctor specializing in diabetes, has seen patients who have become overly anxious about their blood sugar levels and have restricted their calorie intake as a result of using CGMs. "I really worry about that group, because they’ve just become overwhelmed with the data that they’re seeing, which is completely normal."
The Cost Factor
Zoe's program is relatively expensive, with initial testing costing nearly £300 and monthly subscriptions ranging from £24.99 to £59.99. This price point makes the program inaccessible to many people, raising concerns about health equity.
Evidence of Effectiveness
Zoe claims that it is "scientifically proven to work," citing the publication of a peer-reviewed study of its program. This study showed some positive outcomes, including an average weight loss of 2.46kg over four months. However, there were no significant changes in other biomarkers, such as blood pressure, insulin, glucose, and postprandial triglycerides.
The study also compared Zoe participants to a control group that received standard dietary advice and a helpline. Some experts argue that this comparison is not rigorous enough, as individuals who actively log their meals are likely to eat more healthily regardless of the specific program they are following.
Alternative Approaches
For individuals seeking personalized nutrition guidance, genetic testing offers another avenue to explore. Clinical-grade whole-genome DNA health platforms, such as Nucleus, analyze genetic markers to reveal predispositions to various health conditions and traits.
Zoe Nutrition Review: Key Takeaways
While Zoe’s data-backed techniques to support nutrition may work for some users, there is not enough unbiased evidence to measure its efficacy for personalized nutrition. The program’s greatest value comes from the personalized food scores. Still, the high costs and retesting associated may make it an inaccessible option for many users.
The personalization factor in recommendations is also not well-defined. For instance, many health services default to providing familiar advice to users, such as getting enough sleep, eating plant-based or whole foods, and exercising regularly.
The truth is that you need genetic testing for achieving real, long-term personalization in dietary and health choices. You get dozens of illustrative, readymade reports as well as raw data files to check for any specific gene variants you may be worried about.