The Harcombe Diet, created by UK nutritionist Zoe Harcombe, proposes a unique approach to weight loss, moving away from traditional calorie counting and focusing on the types and combinations of food consumed. The diet aims to work with your body, not against it, by providing it with the right foods. The core principle revolves around eating real food and ditching fake food. This article explores the principles, phases, and potential benefits and drawbacks of the Harcombe Diet.
Core Principles of the Harcombe Diet
The Harcombe Diet distinguishes itself by asserting that calorie counting is not only a miserable process but also an ineffective long-term weight loss strategy. Instead, the diet emphasizes working with your body by providing it with nutrient-dense, whole foods. The diet is designed to become a sustainable lifestyle choice, enabling individuals to maintain their desired weight indefinitely. Unlike some diets that focus on restricting the amount of food, the Harcombe Diet focuses on the quality of food.
The Importance of Nutrient Density
The Harcombe Diet emphasizes the importance of nutrient-dense foods, aiming to provide the body with the 13 vitamins and 15 minerals it needs to be healthy. This focus on nutrient density helps combat cravings and ensures the body receives the necessary building blocks for optimal function.
Real Food vs. Fake Food
The cornerstone of the Harcombe Diet is the distinction between real and fake food. Real foods are those found in their natural state, while fake foods are processed and contain artificial ingredients. The diet advocates for consuming foods in the form that nature provides them, avoiding processed foods with lengthy ingredient lists that resemble a chemistry set.
Avoiding the Carb-Fat Combination
One of the key principles of the Harcombe Diet is avoiding eating fats and carbohydrates in the same meal. The rationale behind this is that when carbs and fats are consumed together, the body utilizes the carbs for energy and stores the fat, leading to weight gain. Eating fats alone, however, allows the body to use them for energy and cell repair, without storing them as body fat.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
The Three Phases of the Harcombe Diet
The Harcombe Diet is divided into three distinct phases, each with its own set of rules and objectives.
Phase 1: Kick-Starting Weight Loss
Phase 1 is the most restrictive phase, lasting for only five days. It is designed to kick-start weight loss and combat candida overgrowth. During this phase, you can eat as much fresh, unprocessed, and unsmoked fish and meat as you want, including chicken, pork, beef, duck, lamb, bacon, ham, salmon, mackerel, tuna, prawns, and shellfish. Tinned fish is allowed, provided there are no added ingredients other than oil or salt. You can also eat as many eggs as you want and almost any vegetables except mushrooms and potatoes. Natural live yogurt is permitted, along with water, herbal tea, and decaffeinated tea and coffee (without milk). A limited amount of brown rice or oats (up to 50g a day, or 150g for vegetarians) is also allowed.
During Phase 1, you must avoid mushrooms, potatoes, fruit, cake, biscuits, confectionery, cheese, milk, alcohol, fruit juice, and anything pickled or processed.
Meal Planner Ideas for Phase 1:
- Poached eggs and bacon
- Steamed white fish with salad and a lemon and olive oil dressing
- Roast chicken with garlic and vegetables
Phase 2: Continued Weight Loss with More Variety
Phase 2 is a less intense version of Phase 1, designed to continue the weight loss process with a more varied and enjoyable diet. This phase lasts for as long as you need to lose weight. In Phase 2, fruit, dairy, baked potatoes, and whole grains are reintroduced.
There are three primary rules for Phase 2:
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
- Don't eat processed foods: Stick to real foods in their natural form, such as brown rice, wholemeal pasta and bread, fresh, unprocessed meats with no added ingredients, and potatoes instead of chips.
- Don't eat fats and carbs in the same meal: Follow the principle of consuming either fat proteins (foods from animal sources) or carb proteins (foods from trees and the ground) in each meal.
- Don't eat foods that cause cravings: Identify and avoid foods that trigger cravings and overeating.
Meal Planner Ideas for Phase 2:
- Ham omelette
- Tuna Nicoise with salad and balsamic dressing
- Strawberries and natural live yogurt
Phase 3: Lifelong Weight Maintenance
Phase 3 is designed to be a lifelong weight maintenance plan. You should enter this phase when you have reached your natural weight in Phase 2. In this phase, you can eat pretty much what you want at almost any time, but you must follow the rules that you shouldn't cheat too often, shouldn't cheat too much, and you must stay in control. The goal is to continue avoiding processed foods, but you can indulge in a calorific dessert on a special occasion or something you really fancy, just not too often.
Harcombe's Dietary Advice: A Deeper Dive
Zoe Harcombe's dietary advice aims to enable individuals to obtain the nutrients they require from food and to attain and maintain a healthy body weight. Her approach emphasizes the importance of consuming essential fats and proteins, while minimizing the intake of processed carbohydrates.
Essential Nutrients
- Essential Fats: The body requires omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in a healthy ratio (between 1:1 and 1:4-6 in favor of omega-6).
- Essential Proteins: These are the amino acids that the body cannot produce and must obtain from food.
- Vitamins and Minerals: The body needs 13 vitamins and approximately 15 minerals for optimal function.
Food Categories
Harcombe categorizes foods into three groups:
- Pure Carbohydrates: Sucrose (table sugar) is the only 100% carbohydrate food, lacking essential fats, complete protein, vitamins, and minerals.
- Pure Fats: Oils (olive oil, sunflower oil, coconut oil) and lard are entirely fat and may not be considered natural foods in their extracted form.
- Carb Proteins and Fat Proteins: Nature tends to provide foods that are either carbohydrate proteins (from trees and the ground, suitable for vegans and vegetarians) or fat proteins (from animal sources like meat, fish, eggs, and dairy).
The Carb-Fat Combo
Harcombe advises avoiding nuts and seeds when trying to lose weight due to their combination of carbohydrate, fat, and protein. This carb-fat combo is considered uniquely fattening and is prevalent in processed foods.
The Role of Insulin and Glucagon
To understand weight loss, it's essential to understand the roles of insulin and glucagon. Insulin is a hormone that lowers blood glucose levels by allowing glucose to be transported into muscles and stored as glycogen. Glucagon, on the other hand, is a hormone that puts glucose back into the blood stream and accesses fuel. These two hormones are antagonists, and they are not in play at the same time.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
Weight loss occurs when the body breaks down body fat for fuel. This happens when glucose stores are depleted, and the body needs to access other fuel sources. To achieve this, it's necessary to consume far less carbohydrate than current dietary guidelines advise and to eat less often.
The Impact of Alcohol
Alcohol can hinder weight loss efforts because the body prioritizes getting rid of alcohol over regulating blood glucose levels. This can lead to low blood glucose levels and increased hunger, often resulting in unhealthy food choices.
Potential Benefits of the Harcombe Diet
- Focus on Real Food: The diet encourages the consumption of whole, unprocessed foods, which are naturally rich in nutrients and fiber.
- No Calorie Counting: The diet eliminates the need for calorie counting, which can be a tedious and unsustainable practice for many people.
- Emphasis on Food Combinations: The diet's focus on food combinations may help regulate blood sugar levels and promote satiety.
- Three-Phase Approach: The three-phase approach allows for a gradual transition from a restrictive diet to a more sustainable lifestyle.
- Potential for Weight Loss: By reducing carbohydrate intake and focusing on nutrient-dense foods, the diet may lead to weight loss.
Potential Drawbacks of the Harcombe Diet
- Restrictive Nature: Phase 1 of the diet can be quite restrictive, which may be difficult for some people to adhere to.
- Lack of Scientific Evidence: Some of the diet's claims, such as the impact of food on Candida infections, have been refuted by leading microbiologists.
- Potential Nutrient Deficiencies: If not carefully planned, the diet may lead to nutrient deficiencies, particularly in calcium and fiber.
- Long-Term Sustainability: The long-term sustainability of the diet may depend on individual adherence to the principles of Phase 3.
- Expert's Mixed Feelings: DietDoc has mixed feelings about this diet, saying that although it appears to be yet another low-Âcarb, high-Âprotein, high-Âfat diet, there are some positives to this diet.
Zoe Harcombe: The Expert Behind the Diet
Zoe Harcombe is a researcher, author, blogger, and public speaker in the field of diet and health. Her areas of expertise include public health dietary guidelines, nutrition, and obesity. She holds a BA and MA from Cambridge University and a Ph.D. in public health nutrition. Harcombe is known for her examination of the evidence base for dietary fat guidelines and her dissection of scientific papers related to diet and health. She has authored several books on diet and weight loss, including "Why do you overeat?" and "Stop Counting Calories & Start Losing Weight."