Losing weight and maintaining a healthy lifestyle are common goals, leading many to explore various dietary approaches. With so many options available, it's essential to understand the potential benefits and drawbacks of different diets before making a commitment. This article explores the pros and cons of various dieting strategies, including meal replacement shakes, intermittent fasting, and restrictive diets like the carnivore diet, to help you make informed choices about your health.
The Appeal of Meal Replacement Shakes
Meal replacement shakes have emerged as a popular option for those seeking a convenient and structured approach to weight loss. Written by Becky Bell, MS, RD on January 11, 2017, these shakes are designed to replace one or two meals per day, offering a pre-portioned and nutritionally balanced alternative to traditional meals. Unlike protein shakes, meal replacement shakes are intended to provide the nutrition of a full meal (1). Most meal shakes contain 200-400 calories and a good amount of protein, fiber and essential vitamins and minerals.
Potential Benefits
- Convenience: Meal replacement shakes are portable and convenient, and they may help you resist the temptation to indulge in unhealthy processed foods. One of the biggest barriers to losing weight is the time it takes to prepare healthy meals. When you are stressed or in a hurry, it’s much easier to grab a processed convenience food or give in to fast food. Meal replacement shakes are easy to drink on-the-go and a significantly healthier alternative to fast foods.
- Nutrient Provision: Meal replacement shakes are designed to provide all of the nutrients that you should consume in a complete meal. When you cut back on calories, it can be difficult to get all of the nutrients you need from your diet. Shakes are often fortified with nutrients, which might fill your nutrient gap while you are cutting back on calories. The best meal replacement shakes contain protein, fiber and essential vitamins and minerals. For example, many commercial shakes are a good source of nutrients such as calcium, potassium, iron and vitamin D, which many people are lacking in their diets.
- Weight Loss Aid: Several studies suggest that replacing one or two meals per day with a healthy meal replacement shake may speed up weight loss (6, 7, 8). One analysis found that participants following a partial meal replacement diet plan lost 5.6 more pounds (2.4 kg) in three months than those following a food-based, reduced-calorie diet (9). Interestingly, fewer people following the meal replacement plan dropped out of the studies. This might be because it was easier to follow.
- Protein Content: Nevertheless, many are high in protein, which is one of the most important nutrients for weight loss. Higher protein diets lead to greater satiety, which can help you eat fewer calories throughout the day (14, 15, 16, 17). One study found that men on a high-protein diet reported fewer cravings and a reduced desire to eat late at night than those consuming a moderate amount of protein (18). Furthermore, high-protein diets have been associated with other benefits, such as increased lean body mass, reduced body fat, less belly fat and improved weight maintenance (19, 20, 21, 22, 23).
Potential Drawbacks
- Unhealthy Ingredients: Plenty of meal replacement shakes are made with wholesome ingredients. Others contain unhealthy ingredients like added sugars, corn syrup, partially hydrogenated vegetable oils, artificial flavors and chemical preservatives. Unfortunately, some shakes that are marketed for weight loss contain more grams of sugar than grams of protein.
- Not a Long-Term Solution: Meal replacement shakes may not be a long-term solution for weight management. While many brands of meal shakes provide important nutrients, they cannot completely replace a healthy diet full of whole foods. In addition to vitamins and minerals, whole foods contain antioxidants, plant compounds and enzymes that are difficult to put into a bottle. Some shakes do contain fiber, although significantly less than the amounts found in whole foods like fruits, vegetables and legumes. Additionally, drinking shakes for meals is not a sustainable lifestyle for many people. It can be a socially isolating practice, since many social events include food.
- Doesn't Fix Unhealthy Eating Habits: Long-term weight loss requires long-term lifestyle changes. While drinking meal replacement shakes can help you lose weight, they don’t force you to change your eating habits. If you simply go back to your old eating habits when you stop replacing your meals with shakes, you will likely regain the weight.
Making Informed Choices About Meal Replacement Shakes
To choose the best meal replacement shake for weight loss, ignore the claims on the front of the package and read the ingredient list on the back. Choose a product with the following qualifications:
- At least 15 grams of protein per serving
- At least 3 grams of fiber per serving
- Less than 10 grams of sugar per serving
- No corn syrup
- No hydrogenated vegetable oils
- At least 33% of the Daily Value for vitamins and minerals
Intermittent Fasting: A Time-Restricted Approach
Intermittent fasting (IF) has gained popularity as a weight-loss strategy that involves cycling between periods of eating and voluntary fasting on a regular schedule. Unlike traditional diets that focus on what to eat, intermittent fasting is about when you eat.
How Intermittent Fasting Works
All diets achieve weight loss through the same equation - you take in less food energy each day than your body burns for normal activity. Intermittent fasting achieves this goal by severely limiting calories during certain days of the week or during specified hours during the day. "One pattern that has become a bit popular is the so-called 5:2 diet," says Dr. Frank Hu, chair of the department of nutrition at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. With this system, you eat normally for five days of the week, but restrict food intake to just 500 to 600 calories on the two fasting days.
Read also: Explore the pros and cons of a high metabolism diet
Potential Benefits
- Weight Loss: At the end of the 12-month study, both diet groups had lost weight compared with the normal eaters.
- Simplicity: "One of my patients felt strongly that he didn't want to be bothered with tracking calories and filling out food records. Instead, he opted for a 5:2 fasting approach, which has worked well for him so far."
- Potential Health Benefits: Part of the fascination with intermittent fasting arises from research with animals showing that fasting may reduce cancer risk and slow aging. "One hypothesis is that fasting can activate cellular mechanisms that help boost immune function and reduce inflammation associated with chronic disease," says Dr. Hu.
Potential Drawbacks
- High Dropout Rate: A notable aspect of this trial was a very high dropout rate (38%) among the people assigned to the fasting regimen. This may reflect a real-life pitfall of fasting as a weight-loss approach.
- Risk of Overeating: "It's human nature for people to want to reward themselves after doing very hard work, such as exercise or fasting for a long period of time, so there is a danger of indulging in unhealthy dietary habits on non-fasting days," says Dr. Hu. In addition, there's a strong biological push to overeat following fasting periods.
- Potential Dangers: Skipping meals and severely limiting calories can be dangerous for people with certain conditions, such as diabetes. People who take medications for blood pressure or heart disease also may be more prone to electrolyte abnormalities from fasting.
The Carnivore Diet: An Extreme Approach
The carnivore diet is a highly restrictive eating plan that involves consuming only animal products, such as meat, fish, poultry, eggs, and some dairy. This diet eliminates all plant-based foods, including fruits, vegetables, grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds.
How the Carnivore Diet Works
On the carnivore diet, you cut carbohydrates and eat nothing but meat and other animal products, like beef, chicken, pork, fish, and eggs. The idea is that by cutting all carbs, your body will burn fat for energy and you’ll lose weight. When you don’t eat carbs, your body instead turns fat into ketones to use for energy.
Potential Benefits
- Weight Loss: Studies of low-carbohydrate diets like the keto diet show that they do help people lose weight quickly. One reason is that they cut out calorie-filled, sugary junk foods like cookies, cake, and sodas. And the high protein and fat content of the carnivore diet should prevent you from feeling hungry, says Zelman.
- Potential Improvements: People in the study reported improvements like: Lower body mass index (BMI), More energy, Better sleep, More strength and endurance, Improved memory and focus. Most people with diabetes in the study were able to lower the dose of their diabetes medicine or go off it entirely. Overall, they said they were happy with this way of eating.
Potential Drawbacks
- Nutrient Deficiencies: By cutting out entire food groups, this diet could leave you short on important vitamins and minerals. For example, vegetables are sources of fiber, potassium, vitamins A and C, and folate. Not getting enough fiber from your diet could cause constipation.
- Side Effects: People who eat this way also complain of headaches, nausea, and a lack of energy.
- Increased Risk of Heart Disease: Animal-based diets are high in saturated fat, which can raise low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol. That’s the unhealthy kind of cholesterol that increases your risk of heart disease and stroke. And processed meats, which the diet allows, are high in salt, which can raise blood pressure.
- Unsustainable: The carnivore diet is too restrictive - and too boring - to follow long-term. Eventually food cravings are going to kick in. “You’re going to want a sandwich. You’re going to want a piece of whole-grain bread. And you’re going to want to have some cereal, some fruit, or a salad,” she says.
Is the Carnivore Diet Safe?
This diet probably won’t hurt you if you’re healthy and you go on it for a short period of time. But it’s not recommended. “It’s certainly not a plan that dietitians or health professionals advocate,” says Zelman. “It’s very restrictive. And it concerns me that there’s so little fiber.” The Dietary Guidelines for Americans and American Heart Association both recommend eating plant-based foods. “That’s because of the nutritional goodness, the phytochemicals, fiber, antioxidants, vitamins, minerals, and micronutrients found in plants. You don’t get all of those in animal products,” says Zelman.
General Tips for Successful Weight Loss
Regardless of the specific diet you choose, there are some general principles that can contribute to successful and sustainable weight loss:
- Consult with a Healthcare Professional: Before you start a weight-loss program, talk with your healthcare professional. Your healthcare professional can guide you to help you choose a program that's right for you. You also can ask for advice on how to exercise safely.
- Focus on Long-Term Lifestyle Changes: Successful weight loss requires long-term changes to your eating habits and physical activity. This means you need to find a weight-loss approach you can embrace for life.
- Choose a Varied and Balanced Plan: A varied plan includes foods from all the major food groups. It includes vegetables and fruits, whole grains, low-fat dairy products, lean protein sources, and nuts and seeds.
- Incorporate Physical Activity: Your weight-loss plan should include physical activity. Exercise also is good for health in many other ways. It can help counter the loss of muscle that happens when you lose weight. Now, with our partnership with Zumba, you can transform your routine with fun, high-energy dance workouts that burn calories, tone your body, and keep you motivated.
- Prioritize Hydration and Rest: When hydration and rest are both optimized, your body is better equipped to regulate appetite, balance hormones, and maintain a higher metabolic rate.
Read also: Menopause diet: What you need to know
Read also: The Truth About 310 Diet Shakes