Unveiling the Truth About Weight Loss Supplements: Are They Safe and Effective?

In a society that often equates thinness with health and beauty, the allure of a quick fix for weight loss is strong. Weight management supplements have surged in popularity, promising remarkable, scientifically-proven weight reduction with minimal effort. However, with a plethora of products on the market, it’s challenging to discern which ones are genuinely effective and safe. This article delves into the reality of weight loss supplements, uncovering their potential benefits and drawbacks to provide a well-rounded perspective.

Understanding the Appeal of Weight Loss Supplements

Many people are drawn to weight loss supplements because of the promise of quick results. These aids often contain a combination of ingredients like caffeine, green tea extract, or herbal additives that claim to be metabolism boosters, fat burners, or suppress cravings. Some studies suggest that these compounds can increase metabolic function by around 3-4%, aiding in fat breakdown.

The Promise of Quick Results vs. Long-Term Goals

While the effectiveness of these aids is still being researched, a 12-week trial published in the Journal of Nutrition reported a slight weight reduction associated with green tea extract. When evaluating such products, it's crucial to consider long-term goals and a broader range of health benefits. It’s about combining methods, such as finding the right balance of diet and exercise, rather than relying solely on supplements.

Potential Risks and Side Effects

Weight loss aids and products come with inherent risks. The safety and effectiveness of such supplements can vary greatly due to the lack of strict oversight. Potential side effects of weight loss pills range from minor issues like occasional headaches or stomach discomfort to severe conditions like liver damage or heart-related problems. When it comes to monitoring dietary supplements, FDA regulation is not as rigorous as with prescription drugs.

The Importance of a Balanced Diet and Regular Exercise

Research findings on the efficacy of weight loss supplements have sparked debate. While some studies support their benefits, opposing research highlights potential risks. However, the scientific community is united in agreement: a balanced diet and regular exercise outweigh quick fixes. When it comes to losing weight, it’s important to understand that quick fixes like diet pills won’t provide a long-term solution.

The Foundation of a Healthy Lifestyle

When it comes to eating, it’s important to have a well-rounded meal that includes a mix of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, lean meats, and good fats. Calorie counting can help to keep portion sizes in check to avoid overindulging. It’s also a good idea to cut back on sugary drinks and snacks and steer clear of processed foods that lack nutrition but are high in calories. By following these guidelines, you can ensure that your diet becomes the foundation of a healthy and balanced lifestyle.

The Role of Physical Activity

Whether it’s taking a stroll in the park, diving into a refreshing swim, or busting a move on the dance floor, find the physical activity that brings you joy. Consistency in fitness and weight loss plans is the key to success. Aim to engage in approximately 150 minutes of moderate activity or 75 minutes of vigorous exercise each week. Building strength is incredibly important for effective weight loss.

Additional Factors for Maintaining a Healthy Weight

Getting a good night’s sleep is key to maintaining a healthy weight. Poor sleep can disrupt the hormones that control hunger and fullness. If you’re feeling stressed, try incorporating mindfulness or other relaxation techniques into your routine.

A Closer Look at Specific Weight Loss Supplements and Ingredients

While many supplements and functional foods are marketed with bold claims of aiding in weight loss, it is essential to approach these products with a critical eye. Here's a breakdown of some common ingredients and their purported effects, along with available scientific evidence:

Green Tea Extract

Scientific Evidence: Green tea extract is rich in antioxidants, particularly catechins, which have been shown to boost metabolism and increase fat burning. Early studies suggest it may lead to modest weight loss, but more research is needed. Natural Medicines states that there is not enough good research to decide if it is effective. Experts warn that large doses could cause liver damage. Signs may include yellowing of the skin or eyes, nausea and stomach pain.

Garcinia Cambogia

Scientific Evidence: This tropical fruit extract contains hydroxycitric acid (HCA), which is believed to inhibit fat production and suppress appetite. However, studies on its effectiveness are mixed.

Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA)

Scientific Evidence: CLA is a type of fatty acid found in meat and dairy that claims to reduce body fat. Some suggests that for some people, 1.8 to 6.8 grams of CLA per day may:Curb body fatBoost muscle. But other research shows it doesn't help you shed pounds.Natural Medicines says that CLA is "possibly effective" for weight loss.Some researchers warn that long-term use, especially if you're obese, may raise insulin resistance, which makes it more likely you'll get type 2 diabetes. It might lower "good" cholesterol in your blood, as well, which raises the risk of heart problems.In some people, CLA may cause side effects such as:Upset stomachNauseaLoose stoolsFatigue

Glucomannan

Scientific Evidence: This dietary fiber, derived from the root of the konjac plant, expands in your stomach to promote a feeling of fullness, thereby reducing food intake. Very early studies suggest it might be helpful, but other evidence shows it doesn't work.Natural Medicines says there is "insufficient evidence" to rate how well glucomannan works for weight loss. If you take glucomannan in the tablet form of the supplement, you could choke or get a blockage in your:ThroatEsophagus (tube that connects the throat to the stomach)Intestine. It appears to be somewhat safer if you take this supplement as a powder or a capsule.Glucomannan also may make it harder for your body to absorb medications. So take your medicine either 1 hour before or 4 hours after you use glucomannan.

Chia Seeds

Scientific Evidence: Rich in fiber and omega-3 fatty acids, chia seeds can help increase satiety and reduce calorie intake.

Apple Cider Vinegar

Scientific Evidence: Apple cider vinegar is touted for its ability to reduce appetite and promote fat burning.

Quinoa

Scientific Evidence: Quinoa is a high-protein, high-fiber grain that can help control hunger and support weight loss.

Chitosan

This is a sugar that comes from the hard outer layers of lobsters, crabs, and shrimp. Enthusiasts say it can block fats and cholesterol from getting absorbed by your body.Does it help you lose weight? Natural Medicines, an independent group that analyzes research on supplements, says there isn't enough reliable evidence to rate it. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health states that chitosan has not been shown to be effective for weight loss.Chitosan usually causes no side effects, but some people get an upset stomach or constipation. If you are allergic to shellfish, you should not take chitosan, because it is made from shellfish.

Chromium

Chromium is a mineral that enhances insulin, a hormone that's important for turning food into energy. Your body also needs it to store carbohydrates, fats, and proteins.There are claims that chromium supplements can:Lower your appetiteHelp you burn more caloriesCut your body fatBoost your muscle mass. But a review of 24 studies that checked the effects of 200 to 1,000 micrograms of chromium a day found that there aren't any significant benefits. Natural Medicines says that chromium is "possibly ineffective" for weight loss.At less than 35 micrograms a day, chromium supplements are typically safe for adults. Higher doses can cause:InsomniaIrritabilityProblems thinkingHeadache. Also, some people have developed kidney damage when taking chromium. You shouldn't use it if you have kidney problems.

Green Coffee

Early studies suggest it may lead to modest weight loss, but more research is needed. Natural Medicines states that there is not enough good research to decide if it is effective.Few people have side effects, but because of the caffeine in green coffee it may cause:HeadachesStomach upsetNervousnessInsomniaAbnormal heart rhythms

Guar Gum

This comes from the seed of the guar plant. Like other dietary fibers, it may prevent fats from being absorbed into your body and helps you feel full.Guar gum has been studied much more than other fibers for weight loss, and most researchers say it's not effective.Natural Medicines agrees and rates guar gum as "possibly ineffective."Side effects may include:GasDiarrhea

Hoodia

This is a plant that grows in the Kalahari Desert in Africa. According to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, the stem of the root was traditionally used by Bushmen to cut their hunger and thirst during long hunts. It's now marketed as an appetite suppressant.Hoodia contains P57, an ingredient that's said to curb appetite by helping you feel full. But there's no credible evidence that it's safe or effective.Natural Medicines says it lacks evidence to rate whether hoodia works.

7-Keto-DHEA

This is found naturally in your body. It may help you lose pounds by boosting your metabolism so you burn more calories throughout the day. In a couple of small studies, people who took 7-keto-DHEA -- along with moderate exercise and a reduced-calorie diet -- lost significantly more weight than those who were given a placebo (a dummy pill). But Natural Medicines says there still isn't enough reliable evidence to rate how well it works.

Ephedra

This is an herb that's also known as ma huang. This is a different plant from a related species that grows in North America. Ephedra contains the stimulant ephedrine.It is very closely related to these manmade compounds found in some drugs:PseudoephedrinePhenylpropanolamine. The FDA banned supplements with ephedra after the herb was linked to serious side effects, including:Heart attackArrhythmiaStrokePsychosisSeizuresDeath. The FDA's ban doesn't apply to traditional Chinese herbal remedies or to products such as herbal teas.According to the FDA, there is little evidence that the herb helps except for short-term weight loss. The agency says the health risks outweigh any benefits.Natural Medicines says ephedra is "likely unsafe."

Bitter Orange

The bitter orange tree is native to Africa and tropical Asia. It's also grown in the Mediterranean, California, and Florida.Bitter orange fruit rind contains synephrine, a stimulant related to ephedrine. It supposedly works by raising the number of calories burned.After the FDA banned weight loss products containing ephedra, many makers switched to bitter orange, but it's not clear if it's safer.Natural Medicines says that bitter orange is "possibly unsafe" when taken by mouth as a supplement, and there's not enough evidence to know if it works for weight loss.Some studies show bitter orange supplements can raise your blood pressure and heart rate. There have been reports that they may have had dangerous side effects in people who took bitter orange alone or combined with other stimulants such as caffeine. The risks include:StrokeIrregular heartbeatHeart attackDeath. The FDA says bitter orange may not be safe to use as a dietary supplement. You should especially avoid it if you have a heart condition, high blood pressure, or other medical problem.

Probiotics

Probiotics are beneficial bacteria that live in your gut and help break down and digest food. One 2018 review of 15 well-designed trials found that probiotics, either in foods or in supplements, helped overweight and obese people reduce their body weight and body fat. Some manufacturers are combining probiotics with prebiotics, a type of fiber that feeds gut bacteria. Although few studies have examined the safety of probiotics, they have a long history of safety, particularly in healthy people, according to the NIH. Side effects: If you have a weakened immune system, rare side effects may occur from taking probiotics.

Caffeine

Caffeine is a stimulant found in tea, guarana, yerba mate and other herbs that is often added to weight loss supplements. “It is an excellent lipolytic agent,” Willis says. “By that I mean it helps liberate fatty acids from our fatty tissues, especially for cardiovascular exercise. Studies have shown only a moderate weight loss effect, however. Willis says caffeine and other fat-burning supplements need to be accompanied by changes to diet and lifestyle. “If your diet and lifestyle isn’t going to be conducive to losing fat, fix that first,” he says. Many people experience side effects from caffeine such as a rise in blood pressure and heart rate, sleep problems, anxiety or jitteriness or gastrointestinal problems. In high doses, caffeine can cause vomiting, heart palpitations and seizures. Side effects: People with high blood pressure or heart problems should check with their health care provider before taking a supplement with caffeine.

Berberine

Early research also indicates berberine could help with weight loss. Side effects: GI symptoms such as nausea, diarrhea, bloating, and constipation. Berberine may also interact with prescription medications.

The Role of Caffeine in Weight Management Supplements

Caffeine (1,3,7-trimethylxanthine) is one of the most frequently consumed dietary bioactive substances across the globe. It is known as a central nervous system stimulant and is also proposed to increase thermogenesis and fat oxidation. Most caffeine intake is from beverage sources, including brewed coffee (56-100 mg caffeine/100 mL), instant coffee and tea (20-73 mg caffeine/100 mL), and cola soft drinks (9-19 mg caffeine/100 mL). Caffeine is generally recognized as safe (GRAS) for use in cola-type beverages by the FDA. As a supplement, the ODS identifies sources of added caffeine as guarana, kola nut, yerba maté, and other herbs.

Safety of Caffeine Consumption

The safety of caffeine has been the focus of many federal agencies and scientific and non-governmental organizations over the past several decades. In 2003, Health Canada conducted a comprehensive review concluding that an intake of ≤400 mg caffeine/day was not associated with adverse effects in healthy adults . Additionally, Health Canada concluded that the consumption of ≤300 mg/day for pregnant or lactating women as well as those planning to become pregnant, and 2.5 mg/kg/day for children is not associated with adverse effects. Similarly, the EFSA has also indicated that ≤400 mg caffeine/day does not lead to safety concerns for non-pregnant adults, but identified a limit of 200 mg/day for pregnant women. In 2017, an updated extensive systematic review also found consumption of ≤400 mg/day in healthy adults is not associated with overt, adverse cardiovascular, behavioral, reproductive, and developmental effects, acute effects, or bone status. Additionally, the review found that the consumption of ≤300 mg caffeine/day in healthy pregnant women is generally not associated with adverse reproductive and developmental effects.

The DGA 2020-2025 addressed caffeine intake and, noting that the FDA has identified ≤400 mg/day of caffeine as the amount not generally associated with dangerous, negative effects, and indicated that caffeine can be consumed ≤400 mg/day. The DGA also reviewed the evidence of caffeine consumption by pregnant and lactating women. Small amounts of caffeine can pass from the mother to the infant through breast milk, but a review of the evidence indicated that consumption of ≤300 mg/day (equivalent to about 2-3 cups of coffee) by the mother does not adversely affect the infant. No safe limits have been established for children aged 2 years or younger.

When used according to the manufacturer’s instructions, most weight management supplements provide caffeine within the recommended amount of ≤400 mg caffeine/day. However, concern has been raised over the consumption of caffeine at higher intake levels. Acute intake of caffeine > 500 mg/day potentially results in various untoward events such as headache, jitteriness, agitation, anxiety, dizziness, and tinnitus . In a review of safety data, the FDA has noted that caffeine metabolism is slowed after consumption of >500 mg, with adverse effects, such as tachycardia, ventricular arrhythmia, and seizures, at consumptions > 1200 mg. Responses are variable and likely depend on individual sensitivity to caffeine, the existence of co-morbidities, and intake of concomitant medications or supplements.

Fatality due to caffeine poisoning is rare, and caffeine’s lethal dose is unclear. Reviews by Health Canada, ILSI, and FDA have concluded that there is a potential for death following acute exposures of ~10 g of caffeine for adults and adolescents. However, due primarily to uncertainty in the estimates of exposure and the high risk of bias (e.g., use of case reports), there is low confidence in this evidence base. The FDA has recognized that pure or highly concentrated powdered and liquid caffeine has the potential to deliver higher amounts and thus has moved to restrict the sale of these highly concentrated items.

The Effect of Caffeine on Weight Management

Caffeine has been used as an approach in weight management because of its ability to stimulate both noradrenaline and dopamine secretions, which, in turn, may decrease BW and body fat (BF), as well as increase thermogenesis in brown adipose tissue via an unknown mechanism(s). A meta-analysis of 13 studies providing 60-4000 mg caffeine/day for 4-36 weeks showed that caffeine intake led to a reduction in BW, BF, and body mass index (BMI), and that this effect is dose-dependent. However, all but three of the 13 included studies provided caffeine with other substances with potential weight loss properties. Of the three with only caffeine, one study in normal weight and one in overweight/obese subjects reported modest weight loss, whereas another in overweight/obese subjects did not. Taken together, there may be a modest effect of caffeine on weight management, but more clinical evidence with caffeine alone is needed for confirmation.

Caffeine and Blood Glucose Levels

Observational evidence suggests that caffeine may be protective against T2DM , which has led to further investigations in this area, but results from clinical studies have been mixed. A meta-analysis of seven randomized clinical trials with primarily male normal weight participants consuming caffeine from 3-6 mg/kg , and a trial with healthy men and women found significantly decreased insulin sensitivity indexes compared with a placebo, suggesting caffeine might possess a hyperglycemic activity by acutely impairing insulin action in adipose and muscle tissue. The hyperglycemic impact of caffeine may also extend to adolescents ; however, more research is needed on the long-term effect of caffeine consumption on glycemic status .

Conclusion on Caffeine

Caffeine has been extensively researched and various reviews on caffeine safety, including from regulatory and authoritative sources, indicate that consumption of ≤400 mg/day for adults is safe with minimal risk of adverse events. The majority of supplements providing caffeine are within the recommended amount of ≤400 mg caffeine/day. Recommendations also indicate that pregnant and lactating women can safely consume ≤300 mg caffeine/day. Current evidence supports a beneficial effect of acute caffeine consumption on cognition, particularly on attention , as well as a benefit on exercise performance . The evidence on the effect of caffeine on weight management is mixed, with some data suggesting caffeine might have benefits in supporting healthy blood glucose levels.

The Dangers of Unregulated Supplements

Weight loss supplements may appear as a quick fix for shedding those stubborn pounds. However, delving into the details uncovers a much more intricate story. While they may offer temporary benefits, the market for these products lacks proper regulation. The mixed bag of research and potential undocumented risks suggests they may not be the optimal choice for sustainable weight management.

FDA Regulations and Oversight

Supplements are not regulated by the FDA in the same way that food and drugs are. The FDA does not review these supplements for safety or efficacy before they hit the market. Companies that make supplements must make sure they're safe. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) doesn't need to approve dietary supplements. You might be surprised to learn that makers of dietary supplements rarely do clinical trials.

Hidden Ingredients and Dangerous Stimulants

Some weight-loss supplements have been found to have ingredients that aren't listed on the label, such as prescription medicines. The Food and Drug Administration banned Pai You Gou, a dietary supplement sold for weight loss, after detecting at least two banned pharmaceutical compounds, sibutramine and phenolphthalein, in this product. Sibutramine and phenolphthalein have serious and well-documented side effects. Dangerous stimulants are often found in widely available supplements for weight loss and muscle building. When one stimulant is banned, supplement makers often continue using the banned substances, or replace them with a related chemical. Researchers found N,α-DEPEA, in a widely available muscle-building supplement. N,α-DEPEA is a banned and potentially dangerous designer stimulant closely related to methamphetamine. Another DMAA substitute, 1,3-dimethylbutylamine (DMBA), has also been banned by the FDA. Despite the ban, researchers found at least a dozen supplements to contain DMBA in dosages ranging from 13 to 120 mg per serving.

Risks for Specific Populations

Teens use dietary supplements for weight loss and muscle building-even though doctors say they shouldn’t. The American Academy of Pediatrics is strongly opposed to the use of supplements for weight loss and muscle building in adolescents. Diet pills could be abused by people with eating disorders. In anticipation of the release of alli (the brand of orlistat now available over the counter), researchers expressed concerns regarding the potential for alli to be abused by people with eating disorders. Their concerns are based on documentation of adult and adolescent eating disorder patients frequently abusing supplements sold for weight loss, as well as the possibility that alli’s FDA approval would make it more appealing than other products sold for weight loss.

Potential Long-Term Health Consequences

Muscle-building supplements may lead to increased risk of testicular germ cancer in men. A study of nearly 1000 men found that men who developed testicular germ cancer had used more muscle-building supplements than similar men who did not develop testicular germ cancer. Many supplements whose labels say they contain “pro-hormones,” “natural steroids,” or “testosterone boosters” actually contain designer anabolic steroids-with dangerous consequences. Use of these compounds through dietary supplements is widespread. In younger men, these supplements may be a common cause of liver injury, problems with bile secretion, testicular disorders, growth of breast tissue, and infertility. Authors advise against dietary supplement use, especially those known or suspected to contain designer steroids.

Interactions with Medications

Diet pills may block the function of other drugs, including cancer treatments. Research suggests that the diet drug orlistat limits the function of a kind of protein, CES2, needed to activate a common cancer drug, PPD. Orlistat has also been associated with gastrointestinal issues, as well as liver toxicity.

Vitamin Deficiencies

Diet pills may decrease users’ vitamin D levels. Researchers found that adolescent participants’ vitamin D levels decreased after one month of taking orlistat, despite participants also taking a multivitamin daily. Vitamin D is important for bone health, cell growth, and immune function.

A Path to Wellness

Ready to embark on your weight loss journey? Whether you’re considering incorporating weight loss supplements, nutritional supplements, or seeking expert advice, our clinic, HealthCore, has got your back. We provide personalized consultations with exercise and diet tips that consider your unique needs, ensuring the best and enduring results.

tags: #weight #loss #supplements #effectiveness #and #safety