Diet sodas have long been marketed as a healthier alternative to their sugar-laden counterparts, offering the allure of sweetness without the caloric baggage. However, emerging research is prompting a re-evaluation of their purported benefits and potential health implications. This article delves into the complex and often contradictory landscape of diet soda research, exploring the effects of these beverages on various aspects of health.
The Rise of Diet Sodas and Artificial Sweeteners
Driven by growing concerns about the harmful health effects of sugar consumption, the use of artificial sweeteners has surged in recent decades, leading to increased advertising and consumption of artificially sweetened beverages (ASBs). The global diet soda (DS) market is projected to reach US$ 5.17 billion by 2025, reflecting the widespread adoption of these drinks. The first artificial sweetener, saccharin, was synthesized in 1879, followed by the discovery of aspartame in 1965. Newer artificial sweeteners include sucralose, acesulfame K, neotame, Stevia (rebaudioside A), and tagatose.
Contradictory Findings: A Closer Look at the Research
While diet sodas are often perceived as a healthier option, scientific evidence presents a mixed picture. Some studies suggest that ASBs are linked to increased abdominal circumference, incident diabetes, and cardiovascular events, much like sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs). However, other researchers have not found the same metabolic associations, leading to ongoing debate and controversy.
The Importance of Comprehensive Research
Given the conflicting findings, experts agree that excessive consumption of diet sodas should be avoided due to the unknown and understudied impacts on health beyond metabolic aspects. Recent research has begun to explore the broader effects of artificial sweeteners on various organ systems, mental health, and other health outcomes.
Recent Studies and Potential Health Impacts
A comprehensive literature search was conducted across 11 databases, including PubMed, Cochrane, and MEDLINE, to gather information on the health effects of diet soda consumption. The review considered cross-sectional studies, retrospective or prospective cohort studies, case-control studies, and randomized controlled clinical trials published within the last 10 years. Studies focusing solely on sweetened beverages, efforts to reduce soda consumption, economic studies, or specific approaches without direct health impacts were excluded.
Read also: Principles of Diet Planning
Mental Health
Several studies have explored the relationship between ASB consumption and mental health, with a focus on depression and eating disorders. Studies involving large groups of patients, predominantly women, found a statistically significant association between depression and ASB consumption. Additionally, cross-sectional studies revealed that diet soda drinkers were more likely to report binge eating and purging behaviors compared to regular soda drinkers and non-soda drinkers.
Child Neurodevelopment
A prospective cohort study examined the impact of maternal ASB consumption during pregnancy on child cognitive development. The findings indicated that maternal diet soda consumption may adversely affect child cognition, with children's cognitive scores inversely proportional to their mothers' SSB and ASB consumption.
Cardiovascular Impact
Research has identified potential cardiovascular risks associated with diet soda consumption. A cross-sectional study measuring cardiac remodeling in SSB and DS consumers found that diet soda consumption was associated with higher left atrial dimension (LAD) and left ventricular mass (LVM), compared to no soda consumption.
Diabetic Retinopathy
One study investigated the relationship between diet soda consumption and diabetic retinopathy in diabetic patients. The results showed that diet soda consumption was associated with higher glycosylated hemoglobin (HbA1c) and retinopathy, challenging the notion that diabetics can consume diet soda without harm.
Urogenital Implications
Associations between diet soda and the genitourinary system have also been explored. A prospective cohort study found that higher consumption of diet soda was associated with an increased risk of end-stage renal disease (ESRD). Another study suggested that caffeinated ASBs increased lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) in women.
Read also: Alternatives to Fad Diets
Carcinogenesis
A prospective cohort study examined the potential carcinogenic properties of diet soda. The study found that in men, consumption of more than one daily serving of diet soda increased the risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and multiple myeloma compared to men who did not consume diet soda.
Fatty Liver Disease
Studies evaluating the relationship between diet soda consumption and fatty liver disease incidence have yielded mixed results, necessitating further research.
Autoimmune Disease
The relationship between ASB consumption and rheumatoid arthritis (RA), a common autoimmune inflammatory disease, remains uncertain. One prospective cohort study found a significant association between SSB consumption and increased risk of RA in one cohort of women, but not in another, and no remarkable association between DS consumption and risk of RA in either cohort.
Hip Fractures
A large cohort study found that increased soda consumption of all types, including diet soda, may be associated with an increased risk of hip fracture in postmenopausal women.
Other Health Impacts
Additional studies have explored the association of ASB intake with fecundability, telomere length, and dental erosion, with varying results. One randomized controlled trial confirmed that mixing alcohol with diet beverages can result in higher breath alcohol concentrations (BrAC) compared to mixing the same amount of alcohol with sweetened beverages.
Read also: Energy Consumption and Diets
Limitations and Considerations
The studies included in the review may have potential information biases due to the way results were measured. Inter-study variability in the assessment of outcomes and the lack of blinding in many studies could lead to results with a magnitude greater than the real one. The overall quality of the included studies was classified as moderate.
Sugary Drinks: A Broader Perspective
Sugary drinks include any beverage with added sugar or other sweeteners. These drinks are at the bottom of the list of beverages that are best for our health because they provide so many calories and virtually no other nutrients. The average can of sugar-sweetened soda or fruit punch provides about 150 calories, almost all of them from added sugar. Routinely drinking these sugar-loaded beverages can increase the risk of type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and other chronic diseases.
Weight Gain and Obesity
Research indicates that people who drink sugary beverages don’t feel as full as if they had eaten the same calories from solid food, and they also don’t compensate for the high caloric content of these beverages by eating less food. Reducing sugary drink consumption can lead to better weight control among those who are initially overweight. Studies have found a significant link between sugary drink consumption and weight gain in children.
Diabetes Risk
People who consume sugary drinks regularly have a greater risk of developing type 2 diabetes. Increasing total sugary beverage intake has been associated with a higher risk of type 2 diabetes.
Heart Disease
Studies have found a link between sugary beverage consumption and heart disease. The adverse effects of the high glycemic load from these beverages on blood glucose, cholesterol fractions, and inflammatory factors probably also contribute to the higher risk of heart disease.
Other Health Risks
Consuming a can a day of sugary drink has been linked to a higher risk of gout in women. Higher amounts of sugar-sweetened beverages have been linked to an increased risk of liver cancer and death from chronic liver diseases. Drinking sugary beverages has also been linked with an increased risk of premature death.
Trends in Sugary Drink Consumption
Although sugary drink consumption has decreased in the past decade, half of the population consumes sugary drinks on a given day. Calories from sugary beverages increased by 60% in children ages 6 to 11 from 1989 to 2008.
Marketing and Policy
Beverage companies spend billions of dollars marketing sugary drinks. Studies funded by the beverage industry are more likely to show a finding favorable to industry than independently-funded studies. A significant portion of sugary drink marketing is typically aimed directly at children and adolescents.
Making Healthier Choices
When it comes to our health, it’s clear that sugary drinks should be avoided. If you’re a frequent soda drinker, try sparkling water, naturally flavored sparkling water, or water with a splash of juice, sliced citrus, or fresh herbs.
Low-Calorie Sweeteners
Low-calorie sweeteners (LCS) are sweeteners that contain few to no calories but have a higher intensity of sweetness per gram than sweeteners with calories. These include artificial sweeteners, such as Aspartame and Sucralose, as well as extracts from plants like steviol glycosides and monk fruit. The health effects of LCS are inconclusive, with research showing mixed findings.
The Diet Soda - Diabetes Connection
Regular consumption of diet beverages has been linked to a range of potential health risks, including cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and obesity.
Substituting Diet Beverages with Water
In an 18-month study, researchers evaluated the impact of substituting diet beverages with water among adult women with type 2 diabetes and obesity or overweight. Results showed significant improvements in weight loss and type 2 diabetes in the water group.
Additional Considerations
While diet soda has few, if any, calories, some research shows that people who drink diet beverages consume significantly more calories from food than people who drink sugar-sweetened beverages, like regular soda. Some artificial sweeteners are several hundred times sweeter than sugar and may create changes in your body and brain that make you crave other sweet foods.