Have you ever noticed people sporting weighted vests during their walks or gym sessions and wondered about the reason behind it? Weighted vests, sometimes referred to as ruck vests, have become a favored fitness tool, promising to amplify workouts and deliver faster results. But are they truly worth the hype, and more importantly, are they safe to use? This article delves into the research surrounding weighted vests and their potential benefits for weight loss, bone density, and overall fitness.
What is a Weighted Vest?
A weighted vest is essentially a close-fitting garment, reminiscent of a tactical vest, designed either with a fixed amount of weight sewn into it or with pockets that allow for the insertion and removal of weights, depending on the user's needs. Similar to the effect of wearing a weighted backpack, a weighted vest intensifies any workout by adding resistance. However, it offers the advantage of a more balanced weight distribution across the torso.
Potential Benefits of Weighted Vests
According to experts, such as Dr. Sarah N. Harangody, an orthopaedic surgeon and sports medicine specialist at Northwestern Medicine, incorporating a weighted vest into your exercise routine can yield several benefits:
Enhanced Bone Density
One of the most significant advantages of using a weighted vest, particularly during low-impact activities like walking, is the potential to prevent bone density loss. Weight-bearing exercise is known to stimulate bone growth, and a weighted vest simply amplifies this effect.
Weight Loss Assistance
Weighted vests can also be beneficial for individuals aiming to lose weight. When weight loss occurs, bone density often decreases, and the added resistance from the vest can help mitigate this effect while simultaneously increasing the energy expenditure during workouts.
Read also: Weight Loss Guide Andalusia, AL
Strength Building
The additional weight provided by the vest forces the muscles to exert more effort, leading to increased strength, particularly in the legs, buttocks, core, and back. This added resistance transforms regular activities into strength-building exercises.
Improved Cardiovascular Health
As the intensity of a workout increases due to the added weight resistance, the heart rate and oxygen intake also rise. This challenges the cardiovascular system, leading to improvements in overall cardiovascular health.
Time Efficiency
Using a weighted vest allows you to get more out of your workouts in less time. The increased intensity means that you can achieve the same results in a shorter period, making your fitness routine more efficient.
Activities Suitable for Weighted Vests
A weighted vest can be incorporated into various exercises, ranging from low-impact activities to high-intensity training. Some examples include:
- Walking: Wearing a weighted vest during your daily walk can significantly increase the intensity and calorie burn.
- Running: For those who enjoy running, a weighted vest adds an extra challenge, further improving cardiovascular fitness and strengthening muscles.
- Climbing Stairs: This activity becomes even more demanding with a weighted vest, targeting the leg muscles and boosting cardiovascular health.
- Jumping: Exercises like jumping jacks or skipping can be intensified with a weighted vest, enhancing bone density and muscle strength.
- Strength Training: Incorporating a weighted vest into exercises like squats, pushups, pullups, lunges, and planks can amplify the strength-building benefits.
- High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT): A weighted vest can make HIIT workouts even more challenging, maximizing calorie burn and improving cardiovascular fitness.
Important Considerations Before Using a Weighted Vest
Before incorporating a weighted vest into your fitness routine, it's crucial to keep the following points in mind:
Read also: Beef jerky: A high-protein option for shedding pounds?
Proper Fit
Ensure that the vest fits snugly on your torso to ensure ideal weight distribution. It should not be too tight, as this can restrict movement and cause discomfort.
Start Slowly
Begin with a lighter weight and gradually increase it as your body adapts. This approach minimizes the risk of injury and allows you to progressively build strength and endurance.
Weight Limit
The weight of the vest should not exceed 10% of your total body weight. Exceeding this limit can put excessive strain on your joints and increase the risk of injury. For example, a 150-pound individual should start with a vest weighing no more than 15 pounds.
Gradual Progression
If your normal fitness routine involves walking a mile, start by wearing a lighter vest for only a quarter of a mile and gradually work your way up to a full mile with additional weight. This gradual progression allows your body to adapt to the added resistance and minimizes the risk of overuse injuries.
Core Activation
To ensure that your core muscles are properly engaged, focus on maintaining good posture and balance while wearing the vest. This will help stabilize your spine and prevent back pain.
Read also: Inspiring Health Transformation
Consult a Professional
If you have balance problems or any pre-existing injuries or conditions like heart or lung disease, it's essential to consult with a medical professional before using a weighted vest. They can assess your individual risk factors and provide personalized recommendations.
Potential Risks and Drawbacks
While weighted vests offer numerous benefits, it's essential to be aware of the potential risks and drawbacks:
Risk of Injury
If used incorrectly or with too much weight, weighted vests can increase the risk of injury, particularly to the joints, back, and shoulders. It is important to start slowly and gradually increase the weight to avoid overuse injuries.
Discomfort
An ill-fitting vest can be uncomfortable and may restrict movement. Ensure the vest fits snugly but not too tightly.
Cost
Weighted vests can be relatively expensive, depending on the brand and features.
Potential for Overuse
It's tempting to wear a weighted vest throughout the day, but overuse can lead to fatigue and injury. Limit the amount of time you wear the vest, especially when starting.
Scientific Evidence: The Gravitostat Theory
Recent research has shed light on a leptin-independent homeostatic regulation of body weight known as the gravitostat. This theory suggests that the body regulates weight and fat mass based on weight loading.
Human Studies
A randomized controlled trial was conducted to evaluate the efficacy of artificially increased weight loading on body weight in subjects with mild obesity (BMI 30-35 kg/m2). Participants were treated with either a heavy (11% of body weight) or light (1% of body weight) weight vest for eight hours per day for three weeks. The study found that the high load treatment resulted in a more pronounced relative body weight loss compared to the low load treatment (mean difference -1.37%).
Rodent Studies
Similar results have been observed in obese rodents, where increased weight loading reduced body weight and fat mass. This supports the idea that there is a weight loading dependent homeostatic regulation of body weight, the gravitostat, also in humans.
The Gravitostat and Leptin
The gravitostat operates independently of leptin, a hormone traditionally known as the primary regulator of fat mass. Studies using leptin-deficient obese mice have demonstrated that increased loading regulated fat mass independently of fat-derived leptin, revealing two independent negative feedback systems for fat mass regulation.
Weight Loss in Older Adults: A Study
A study published in the Journal of Frailty and Aging examined the effects of weighted vests on weight loss in older adults with obesity. The study found that weighted vest use during dietary weight loss is feasible and safe in well-functioning older adults.
Study Design
Participants aged 65-79 years with a BMI of 30-40 kg/m2 were divided into two groups: a diet-only group and a diet-plus-weighted-vest group. Both groups underwent a dietary weight-loss intervention, without a formal exercise program. The weighted vest group wore a vest with a weight corresponding to a maximum of 15% of their baseline weight for an average of 6.7 hours per day.
Results
Both groups lost a similar amount of weight, with no significant differences between the groups. However, the weighted vest prevented declines in leg muscle power, suggesting this may be a safe and effective method for preserving and potentially improving muscle power during weight loss.
Key Findings
- Weight loss, with or without daily weighted vest use, produced significant decreases in body weight, fat, and lean mass without impacting physical function in older adults with obesity.
- Use of the vest during weight loss was feasible and safe and appears to help preserve lower extremity muscle power.
Long-Term Weight Loss Maintenance: The Role of Gravitational Loading
Another pilot study explored whether gravitational loading during intentional weight loss influences weight regain following treatment. The study found that 24 months after a 6-month weight loss intervention, the weight loss-only group regained nearly twice as much weight as the weight loss-plus-weighted-vest group. Additionally, the use of a weighted vest abolished the reduction in resting metabolic rate (RMR) often seen during caloric restriction.
RMR and Weight Change
The study also found that a change in RMR during active weight loss was modestly and inversely associated with weight change during the follow-up period. This suggests that gravitational loading may play a role in preserving RMR during weight loss, which in turn can help prevent weight regain.
Walking with a Weighted Vest: Enhancing Your Workout
Walking is an excellent way to improve your health, and you can boost the benefits by walking with a weighted vest. However, using a weighted vest when walking also has disadvantages and isn't safe for everyone. A weighted vest increases your body weight, making the muscles you use to walk work harder.
Benefits of Walking with a Weighted Vest
- Increased Intensity: The weight in the vest increases the workload for everyone, increasing the intensity and allowing them to get more for their effort.
- Improved Workout: A weighted vest also improves your workout if your walking speed is limited or you’re starting a new routine.
- Bone Density: The extra weight from a vest puts more stress on the bones, helping to build bone density.
- Calorie Burn: A weighted vest increases the amount of energy spent while walking.
- Cardiovascular Health: The extra weight increases the heart and respiration rates during exercise.
- Balance Improvement: Walking with a weighted vest improves balance by strengthening the muscles around the hips, core, and legs.
- Muscle Building: Weight training exercises build muscle and increase your metabolic rate. Walking with a weighted vest is a type of weight training that makes your muscles work harder.
- Aerobic Intensity: Wearing a weighted vest increases the aerobic intensity of walking-elevating the heart rate and increasing oxygen consumption.
- Agility: A study of young soccer players showed that warming up with a weighted vest improved agility.
- Core Muscle Engagement: Walking uses the core muscles-the abdominal and back muscles.
Weight Loss and Metabolism
To lose weight, you must increase your daily physical activity, decrease your calorie consumption, or combine both. The benefits listed above-intensifying your workout, increasing heart rate, burning more calories, and increasing muscle mass-boost your metabolism and significantly contribute to weight loss. The effect of a weighted vest may also help you burn more calories while at rest.
Disadvantages of Walking with a Weighted Vest
- Risk of Injury: Adding weight to any activity can increase the risk of injury.
- Posture Problems: Wearing a weighted vest may affect your posture.
- Limited Range of Motion: For some people, wearing a weighted vest might limit their range of motion.
- Breathability: Weighted vests add another layer of clothing, and the weight itself does not allow for much breathability.
Who Should Avoid Weighted Vests?
People with certain conditions should avoid wearing weighted vests. It's essential to consult with a healthcare professional before starting if you have any underlying health issues.
Choosing the Right Weighted Vest
- Comfort: A vest should be comfortable throughout your walk. When trying on the vest, make sure it doesn't pinch anywhere. Look for areas that might rub against the skin and cause a blister. Consider whether a vest that goes over or under clothes is best for you.
- Ease of Use: Consider the difficulty of putting on and removing the vest. A vest should easily incorporate into your daily walking routine without much effort.
- Weight: Some vests have a set weight. Others have removable weights, so you can increase and decrease the vest's weight depending on your ability and the desired challenge. Find a vest that works with your fitness level. Most people should aim for a weight that doesn't exceed 10% of their body weight.
- Hindrance to Walking: A vest should not impede your walking ability.
Incorporating a Weighted Vest into Your Routine
Before you use a weighted vest, ensure you have developed good walking posture and technique. When adding a weighted vest to your walking routine, start slowly. At first, you may only be able to walk for five to 10 minutes with the vest.