In a world saturated with quick-fix solutions, magnetic rings for weight loss have emerged as a tempting option. This article delves into the science, or lack thereof, behind these products, exploring their purported benefits, potential risks, and ultimately, their effectiveness in achieving sustainable weight loss. We will analyze data from studies using wearable biometric monitoring devices (WBMD) and behavioral modification interventions to provide a comprehensive overview of the weight loss landscape.
The Allure of Wearable Biometric Monitoring Devices
Wearable biometric monitoring devices (WBMD) hold promise as a means to improve health and prevent disease through increasing accountability. By regularly providing real-time quantitative data regarding activity, sleep quality, and recovery, users may become more aware of the impact that their lifestyle has on their health. Refined sensory technology is also rapidly advancing within the medical device field. At times, these devices have demonstrated a profound positive impact on health behaviors, such as exercise, sleep, and more. Wearables are uniquely capable in that they leverage the users data to provide motivation and accountability. During sleep deprivation, wearables can encourage the user to get adequate sleep. By corollary, during extended periods of inactivity, they can remind you to increase your activity level. Commonly, wearables include a screen interface or mobile application to augment intrinsic behavior-regulating strategies, such as goal setting, associations, and self-monitoring.
However, the use of many devices tends to result in only short-term adoption and temporary changes in motivation and behaviors. User surveys have shown that low levels of compliance are associated with discomfort, the inconvenience of wearable devices, and a lack of activity specificity that is important for goal setting and reinforcement. Thus, perhaps smaller, lighter, and more inconspicuous wearables that require less frequent charging may mitigate some compliance issues.
Understanding Magnetic Rings and Their Claims
A quick search for “magnetic rings weight loss” reveals a variety of magnetic products claiming to help shed pounds. These include magnetic bracelets, toe rings, earrings, patches, and even "seeds" worn on the outer ear. The premise behind these devices is that they assist in weight loss by impacting metabolism, hunger and satiety, and circulation. They are purported to increase your metabolism through the north pole of the magnet. Some proponents also suggest that the rings and bracelets can be used in combination with acupressure, an alternative therapy technique based on stimulating certain points on the body to lead to changes within the body.
Debunking the Magnetic Weight Loss Myth: No Solid Evidence
Despite the marketing claims, there is no solid evidence that magnetic therapy will help you lose weight. Experts emphasize that there is zero evidence to suggest that magnetic rings, or similar magnetic devices, aid in weight loss. A fast or “high” metabolism allows you to burn more calories at rest and when you exercise.
Read also: Weight Loss Guide Andalusia, AL
While some research suggests that noninvasive electromagnetic brain stimulation, combined with increased exercise and reduced calorie intake, can help people with overweight lose weight, this is not the same as wearing static magnetic jewelry.
The Cornerstone of Weight Loss: A Holistic Approach
The Department of Agriculture (USDA) emphasizes that weight loss can be achieved by a combination of:
- Setting a realistic goal
- Engaging in a reduced calorie, nutritionally balanced eating plan
- Regular physical activity
- Other behavior changes to help you keep on track with your goals
It is generally recommended for adults to engage in moderate-intensity aerobic activity for 150 minutes each week, but to lose weight you’ll likely need more or to cut calorie intake. Creating an individualized weight loss plan with the help of a doctor is highly recommended.
Potential Harms and Interactions of Magnetic Rings
While magnetic rings may seem harmless, there are potential risks to consider. They might interact with imaging tests and medical devices. Wearing acupressure magnets (or any magnet) can be very harmful or compromise test results if you have a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) test. There are very strict rules regarding magnets in the scan room because of the possibility of creating a magnetic projectile, combined with risk to the machine.
Magnetic rings may also be harmful to people who wear devices such as pacemakers, which regulate heart rhythm. It is crucial to speak with your doctor if you have any medical devices before trying any magnetic jewelry. Any kind of small magnet, including magnetic jewelry, may pose a hazard to small children if swallowed.
Read also: Beef jerky: A high-protein option for shedding pounds?
The Role of Lifestyle and Behavioral Changes
Positive lifestyle habits, such as regular exercise and adequate sleep, profoundly affect one’s mental and physical health. A sedentary lifestyle is one of the prominent modifiable contributors of mortality and disease globally. It undoubtedly plays a central role in increasing the risk of developing chronic health conditions, such as cardiovascular disease, hypertension, metabolic syndrome, obesity, cancer, and depression, and serves as a major predictor of hospitalization and mortality. Despite a widespread understanding of the beneficial aspects of physical activity, roughly half of American adults fail to meet the minimum guidelines for recommended exercise. Similarly, short sleep duration, coupled with deficits in sleep quality or restfulness, predisposes individuals to obesity, mental health conditions, neuroendocrine dysfunctions, and cardiovascular disease. A significant portion of adults do not regularly get enough restful sleep, defined as at least seven hours per night.
Behavioral modification interventions can empower positive lifestyle and behavioral changes by improving health education, increasing motivation, and providing actionable goals.
A Study on Biometric Tracking Rings and Behavioral Modification
A year-long randomized, placebo-controlled study examined the efficacy of a personalized behavioral modification protocol informed by data from a biometric tracking ring. Participants were recruited and enrolled from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) campus and the surrounding Los Angeles area.
Inclusion criteria included:
- Men and women aged 18-55years
- Little to no exercise in the past 3months (<4x/month)
- Willingness to wear a ring continuously for the duration of the study (i.e., 12months)
- Willingness to refrain from engaging in any new activity outside of the study requirements of walking, jogging, or running.
Exclusion criteria included:
- Any significant medical diagnoses, including cardiovascular or pulmonary disease, that may limit the ability to exercise or increase the cardiovascular risk of exercising
- Failing to meet the criteria for low or moderate risk of exercise participation as defined by American College of Sports Medicine Guidelines.
Participants were randomly allocated (1:1) to receive either a behavioral modification intervention with daily GTF (INT group) or a non-directive, equal attention wellness education placebo-controlled program (CON group). After 3months, those in the INT group were further randomized (1:1) to receive either daily GTF for the entire 12months (long-term GTF, LT-GTF group) or no further GTF (short-term GTF, ST-GTF group).
The weekly behavioral modification intervention entailed twelve, 30-min digitally interactive whiteboard and screencasting presentations embedded into a smartphone app. Each presentation covered a different topic related to reducing stress, enhancing relaxation, or improving sleep, and provided individualized recommendations for implementation. The behavioral modification program focused on altering the key mediators of behavior change, including self-efficacy, social support, and motivation.
Read also: Inspiring Health Transformation
The exercise intervention focused on increasing leisure-time physical activity - walking in particular - as well as encouragement to accrue incidental activity through daily tasks, such as household chores and active transport. All participants were instructed to walk or jog at least 150 to 300min per week in accordance with the American College of Sports Medicine Physical Activity and Center for Disease Control Physical Activity Guidelines.
Measuring Outcomes and the Oura Ring
All outcomes were measured in-person at the lab or remotely using a multisensory wearable sleep and activity tracker. The primary outcome measure for this study was Sleep Quality measured by Sleep Onset Latency and Total Sleep time. All study participants visited the laboratory and were tested for anthropometrics (weight and percent body fat) and cardiovascular fitness. Cardiovascular fitness (or aerobic capacity; VO2max) was determined via an incremental, symptom-limited maximal treadmill exercise test.
Prior to study initiation, each participant completed a detailed, step-by-step instructional tutorial on how to use the Oura ring (2nd generation), a commercially available multisensory wearable sleep and activity tracker. The OURA ring detects pulse rate, variation in inter-beat-intervals, and pulse amplitude from the finger optical pulse waveform (i.e., infrared photoplethysmography). The ring also measures motion via triaxial accelerometry and skin temperature that uses a negative temperature coefficient thermistor. The manufacture asserts to use these physiological signals (a combination of motion, nocturnal heart rate and heart rate variability, and pulse wave variability amplitude), in combination with sophisticated machine learning-based methods, to compute deep (PSG N3), light (PSG N1+N2), and rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep as well as sleep/wake states.
Study Results: The Power of Personalized Feedback
Over the first 3months, the INT group had significant (p<0.001) improvements in sleep onset latency, daily step count, % time jogging, VO2max, body fat percentage, and heart rate variability (rMSSD HRV) compared to the CON group. Over the next 9months, the LT-GTF group continued to improve significantly (p<0.001) in sleep onset latency, daily step count, % time jogging, VO2max, and rMSSD HRV.
The study concluded that using a WBMD concomitantly with personalized education, encouragement, and feedback, elicits greater change than using a WBMD alone.
The Vibration Machine Alternative: A Closer Look
Vibration machines, also called shaking machines or shaking platforms, use whole-body vibrations to force your muscles to contract reflexively. They’re available in some gyms and people can buy them for home use. People may perform exercises like squats, pushups, or crunches on these machines, as some older studies suggest they may help with weight loss and muscle gain. However, more research is required to understand how effective they might be compared with traditional exercise.
Some studies suggest whole-body vibration machines may help people lose weight and build muscle. A 2019 review of studies found that whole-body vibration led to a significant amount of fat loss but didn’t cause a significant change in body fat percentage in studies that lasted fewer than 6 months. A 2012 study noticed a significant improvement in the participants’ standing long jump scores, which is a measurement of lower body power.
In a 2016 study, researchers looked at the effects of vibration training on the body composition of middle-aged women with obesity, which they assigned into three groups: dieting only, dieting and vibration training, and dieting and aerobic exercise. All three groups lost body fat, but the second and third groups lost more fat than the first. The researchers concluded that vibration training combined with a diet program was equally as effective as an aerobic program with a diet program over 9 months.
When the platform of a vibration machine shakes, your muscles reflexively contract rapidly. Even though this isn’t under your conscious control, it still requires energy and causes you to burn calories. The amount of energy your body burns depends on the frequency and strength of the vibrations.
Vibration machines are generally safe, but they may not be suitable for some people. People who are at a high risk of falling may want to stick to exercises they can perform while lying on their back or sitting down, as opposed to standing.
Some potential exercises you can perform on a vibration machine include: pushups, crunches, squats, calf raises, lunges, and planks.
It’s not clear how effective vibration machines are compared with traditional weight loss techniques, and they aren’t a substitute for regular exercise and a healthy diet. Many other factors also affect weight loss, including changes in your metabolism.
tags: #weight #loss #ring #effectiveness