The rights and accommodations for people in jail and correctional facilities have garnered increasing attention in recent years, with dietary preferences being a significant point of discussion. This article delves into the complex issue of vegan diets in prison, exploring the legal rights, challenges, and potential benefits for vegan inmates.
Understanding the Landscape
Veganism is a philosophy and way of living that seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing, or any other purpose. This extends to promoting the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of humans, animals, and the environment. A vegan diet excludes all animal products, including meat, fish, milk, eggs, and honey.
Legal Rights and Dietary Preferences
Legal issues surrounding food preferences can be complicated, with varying degrees of protection for food choices depending on location. The right to a vegetarian or vegan diet often falls under the broader category of dietary accommodations for religious or medical reasons. Veganism has been found to come within the scope of international human rights provisions, and vegans in the UK are protected under human rights and equality law. However, this protection is not absolute, nor does veganism have legal protection everywhere in the world.
Challenges in Correctional Facilities
Correctional facilities face particular difficulties when catering to inmates' nutritional choices. Prisons and jails often operate within limited financial and logistical resources, making it challenging to provide special meals, especially in facilities with a large inmate population. Security concerns and the need to prohibit illegal substances can also complicate matters.
Challenges Faced by Vegan Inmates
Vegan inmates often encounter several obstacles in accessing adequate nutrition within correctional facilities.
Read also: Vegan Diet for Diabetes Management
Limited Food Options
One of the major challenges is the shortage of suitable food options. Many jails rely on mass-produced, standardized meal plans that may not adequately accommodate dietary restrictions. As Caitlin Watkins writes, prisoners equate the environment of the prison dining hall to that of a Concentrated Animal Feed Operation (CAFO) in which animals are force-fed industrially processed commodity food items like corn and soy.
Cross-Contamination Risks
Cross-contamination is an important issue for inmates with special dietary restrictions. The risk of unintentional exposure to animal products is high in facilities with shared kitchen spaces and equipment, potentially violating the dietary principles of vegan inmates. Kitchen organization and food service also need to be considered, ensuring no cross-contamination between vegan and non-vegan food.
Nutritional Issues
Ensuring proper nutrition is important for inmates' health and well-being. While carefully planned vegan diets can be nutritionally balanced, there is concern that inmates may not receive the necessary nutrients if their dietary preferences are not accommodated. It’s recommended that everyone in the UK uses a vitamin D supplement during autumn and winter as a minimum, and vegans also need to ensure reliable intakes of vitamin B12, iodine and selenium. Although vitamin B12, iodine and selenium can be obtained from carefully selected foods, it may not be possible in a prison setting, so using a specially designed supplement like The Vegan Society’s VEG 1 is a particularly good idea for vegans in prison.
Dietary Accommodation in Jails
The availability of vegetarian and vegan meals varies highly among correctional facilities. Some institutions have robust programs in place to accommodate dietary preferences, while others may provide limited or no options.
Procedures for Requesting Accommodation
Many facilities allow inmates to request special dietary accommodations. This usually entails submitting a formal request through the administrative channels of the facility. The effectiveness and responsiveness of these procedures, however, can vary. First, try to resolve the problem by speaking to a relevant member of the staff e.g. Wing/Landing Officers, Senior Officers or Catering Manager. It is a good idea to keep an accurate note of any instances you wish to complain about, including details of dates, times and who was present. Complaint forms should be issued to you within seven days of applying and a reply should be received usually within five days of completion. If you’re not happy with the response, the next step is to fill in an appeal about your complaint and then appeal to the Governor. Using form COMP1A, this must be made within a week of receiving the first response. If you require assistance, you can speak in confidence to your prison’s Independent Monitoring Board. You can also contact the Prisoners’ Advice Service.
Read also: Vegan Diet for Bodybuilding
Meal Options
Vegetarian and vegan meal options in jails, where available, may be different in quality and variety. Some facilities provide balanced vegetarian and vegan options, but others may offer limited options that are nutritionally deficient. Ensure that your service offers a variety of balanced vegan meals. Consider them available to anyone because they can be enjoyed by most people, helping them to hit their fibre and 5-a-day targets and limit saturated fat. You can keep menus simple by serving vegan options as standard. Ensure meals contain a vitamin C source, such as pepper, broccoli, cabbage, Brussels sprouts, kiwi fruit, oranges, strawberries, pineapple, grapefruit or orange juice. A daily vegan menu should contain at least two portions of really calcium-rich food per day.
The Victor Valley Medium Correctional Facility
The Victor Valley Medium Correctional Facility in Adelanto, California, offers a unique approach. When new inmates arrive at Adelanto, they attend an orientation that describes two distinct programs. One option is the traditional program followed by most correctional facilities, while the other, the NEWSTART Program, focuses on vegan meals, bible study classes, an anger management program, job training, and psychological counseling. Those selecting the NEWSTART Program are fed a vegan diet, except for the weekend when desserts such as cakes or puddings with milk and eggs are brought in. These inmates receive no meat, fish, chicken, dairy products, eggs, or sugar with their weekday meals. Doug Anglen, director of food service, notes that prisoners find the vegan food tasty. Anglen detailed some of the health improvements of the vegan inmates, describing how diabetics were able to rid themselves of medications, a good number saw their skin conditions improved, many lost excess weight, and most felt more energetic. In the four years the prison has operated, only 30 to 40 of the NEWSTART inmates have returned, compared to a 70 to 80% rate of recidivism among the non-vegetarian inmates.
How to Get Vegan Food in Jail
For vegan inmates navigating the prison system, there are several steps they can take to advocate for their dietary needs.
Communicating Dietary Requirements
It is critical to communicate your dietary preferences and requirements in a clear and timely manner. Make sure to follow the facility’s vegetarian or vegan meal request procedures. If you’re not happy with the response, the next step is to fill in an appeal about your complaint and then appeal to the Governor. Using form COMP1A, this must be made within a week of receiving the first response. If you require assistance, you can speak in confidence to your prison’s Independent Monitoring Board. You can also contact the Prisoners’ Advice Service.
Seeking Legal Recourse
If your dietary requirements are not consistently met, you may have legal recourse. Consult with an inmate rights attorney to discuss your options.
Read also: Lose Weight with Veganism
Canteen and Retail Options
Canteen sheets are usually issued on a weekly basis in order for prisoners to order food, toiletries and other requirements. Prison Retail should make every effort to stock food, toiletries and other items for which there is a demand. The National Product List contains a list of products from which the local Prison Retail Team chooses products they would like to stock. If there is a product you would like to buy but which is not on the National Product List, you should speak to your Diversity Manager or Residential Governor.
Ethical Considerations and Potential Benefits
Beyond the legal and logistical aspects, there are ethical considerations and potential benefits associated with providing vegan options in prisons.
Ethical Treatment of Animals
Providing vegan meals aligns with the ethical principles of veganism, which seeks to minimize harm to animals. Veganism is a philosophy and way of living which seeks to exclude - as far as is possible and practicable - all forms of exploitation of, and cruelty to, animals for food, clothing or any other purpose; and by extension, promotes the development and use of animal-free alternatives for the benefit of humans, animals and the environment.
Environmental Sustainability
Vegan diets have a lower environmental impact compared to diets that include animal products. It’s better for the environment.
Health Benefits
Well-planned vegan diets can support healthy living in people of all ages. In fact, Anglen detailed some of the health improvements of the vegan inmates. He described how diabetics were able to rid themselves of medications, a good number saw their skin conditions improved, many lost excess weight, and most felt more energetic.
Behavioral Impacts
Interestingly, some studies suggest a link between vegetarian diets and reduced aggression. Anglen echoed Dr. Barnard's comments about vegetarians on high fiber diets being less violent. The NEWSTART prisoners are housed together in one section of the building. "When there is a violent outbreak, 90% of the time it's on the non-vegetarian side of the facility," says Anglen. "There is a noticeable difference in the personalities of the vegetarian inmates. They smile more, are fully racially integrated, attend religious classes and anger management classes eagerly," he told VIP.
Cost-Effectiveness
Research has shown that plant-based meals rich in complex carbohydrate foods (such as beans, lentils, grains, potatoes, pasta, and oranges) are less expensive than meals featuring animal proteins. In April 2015, a jail in Arizona went vegetarian and the prison saved $200,000 by spending money on meatless food in the first year of the program.