Gua sha, also known as scraping therapy, skin scraping, or spooning, is an ancient East Asian healing technique gaining recognition for its diverse health benefits. This article explores the depths of scraping tool massage, from its traditional roots to its modern applications, providing a comprehensive understanding of its potential to improve overall well-being.
Introduction: The Essence of Scraping Therapy
For centuries, scraping therapy has been a staple in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). It involves the use of a smooth-edged tool to gently scrape the skin, aiming to improve blood flow and reduce inflammation. The underlying principle is that good health relies on the smooth flow of "chi" or energy throughout the body. When this energy becomes blocked, health issues may arise. Scraping is believed to release this stagnant energy, restoring balance and promoting healing.
Gua Sha: A Closer Look at the Technique
Gua sha, pronounced "gwa-shah," is performed by a trained professional who uses a small, smooth-edged tool to firmly stroke the skin in one direction. To prepare you for treatment, your provider will put oil on your body. They’ll then use a stonelike gua sha massage tool to scrape your skin in long, downward strokes. The motion breaks tiny capillaries (blood vessels) under your skin. As a result, you'll see temporary small, red, rash -like dots called petechiae. As the session goes on, your provider may slowly add more pressure to the strokes. They should only apply as much pressure as you’re comfortable with. Gua sha shouldn't be painful. This process may result in the appearance of small, red, rash-like dots called petechiae, which are temporary and indicative of improved blood flow.
The Science Behind the Scraping
Scraping the skin is believed to activate both the immune and nervous systems, triggering a complex chain of events within the body. Studies suggest that when performed correctly, gua sha can release chemicals that improve blood flow, lessen toxins, reduce pain, and promote healing in the treated area. Gua sha is a traditional healing technique that aims to create petechiae on the skin for a believed therapeutic benefit. Scraping marks (petechiae and ecchymoses) are formed when capillaries break open and blood leaks into the subcutis. These marks fade and completely resolve over 2-5 days. Disappearance of petechiae and ecchymoses occurs via erythrocyte lysis.
Haemolysis and the HO System
Cell debris is concurrently removed by microglia/macrophages. Haemolysis is associated with the release of haemoglobin and its catabolic products. Each haemoglobin molecule is made up of four heme groups surrounding a globin group, forming a tetrahedral structure. Haemolysis liberates a large amount of haemoglobin into the bloodstream or tissues that are taken up by macrophages via their scavenger receptor (CD163) with the subsequent induction of haem oxygenase (OH) for subsequent haem degradation. The color of the subcutaneous tissue reflects the physiologic sequences of haemoglobin catabolism and its conversion to bilirubin (BR) and haemosiderin.
Read also: Techniques and Tools for Trigger Point Therapy
Haem (also known as iron protoporphyrin IX) is a large complex, comprising a haem ring (protoporphyrin IX) and an atom of ferrous (Fe2+) iron located at the ring center. Free haem is dangerous in excessive quantities which is why it is quickly removed from tissues. The HO system is responsible for haem degradation, converting haem to biliverdin (BV), during which ferrous iron (Fe2+) is released and carbon monoxide (CO) is emitted. Three isoforms of HO enzymes (HO-1, HO-2 and HO-3) catalyze the initial reaction in haem catabolism. HO-1, with the inducible character and widespread distribution, is regarded as the central part in the HO system. HO-1 is recognized as having major immunomodulatory and antiinflammatory properties, which have been demonstrated in HO-1-deficient mice and human cases of genetic HO-1 deficiency. HO-2 and HO-3 are the constitutive isoforms. HO-2 is expressed basically in neuronal populations and endothelial cells.
Biliverdin and Bilirubin
BV is the primary product of haem degradation, which is then reduced by biliverdin reductase (BVR) into BR. Once BR is formed it would interact with free oxygen radicals, and oxidized back to BV. This reduction and oxidation process will repeat itself by BVR and free oxygen radicals. By the BR -BV redox cycle, physiological low BR concentrations can exhibit a potent antioxidant protection. Meanwhile, BR has been characterized as a potent antioxidant that prevents the oxidative damage triggered by a wide range of oxidant-related stimuli. When plasma protein binding approaches saturation, free unconjugated BR may become neurotoxic. OH-1 catalyzes the oxidative degradation of haem to liberate the central Fe2+ iron, CO, and BV.
Iron Metabolism and Carbon Monoxide
The ferrous Fe2+ iron has been considered to be free labile and metabolically active. It can catalyze the production of free radicals and thus act as a cytotoxic prooxidant. At physiological pH, ferrous Fe2+ iron is rapidly oxidized to the insoluble ferric (Fe3+) form. Transferrin (a blood-plasma glycoprotein), with a high affinity to ferric iron, plays a central role in iron metabolism and is responsible for ferric-ion delivery. Free haem and ferrous iron are strong prooxidant catalysts with the ability to promote oxidative stress and lipid peroxidation. CO, once regarded as a metabolic waste, can act as an endogenous mediator of cellular signalling and vascular function. The main source of endogenous CO is derived from haem catabolism.
The Role of Interleukin-10 (IL-10) and Nitric Oxide (NO)
Interleukin-10 (IL-10) is a vital antiinflammatory cytokine which inhibits the production of inflammatory cytokines (such as IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8 and TNF-α). Nitric oxide, also called nitrogen monoxide or simply NO, is generated from the amino acid L-arginine by the enzyme nitric oxide synthase (NOS). There are three NOS isoforms: Neuronal NOS (nNOS or NOS-1), cytokine-inducible NOS (iNOS or NOS-2) and endothelial NOS (eNOS or NOS-3). NO used to be considered as a molecule relevant to air pollutant. However, NO is now recognized as a potent endogenous vasodilator and plays a role in neurotransmission, platelet aggregation, innate immunity and inflammation.
NO has an extremely short half-life (t½ <4 s), which makes it difficult to store. Low and constant NO production in the skin seems to be responsible for the maintenance of barrier function and the regulation of blood flow rate in the microvasculature. Higher levels of NOS activity, stimulated by skin wounding or ultraviolet light, initiate a cascade of reactions that require various cell types in a variety of coordination of responses. The enhanced NOS activity in skin wounds appears to be crucial in facilitating leukocyte infiltration and inflammation. In response to injury, activation of the constitutive NOS isoforms (NOS-1 and NOS-3) proceeds and overlaps with the expression of inducible NOS isoform (NOS-2).
Read also: Summit Chiropractic: Holistic wellness solutions.
Potential Benefits of Gua Sha
Gua sha is used to treat ailments that cause chronic pain and relieve symptoms of stress.Gua sha may be able to help with issues such as:
- Tight muscles
- Swelling
- Anxiety
- Sinus pressure
- Fatigue
Some studies have explored the potential of gua sha in treating specific conditions:
- Hepatitis B: Gua sha might help lower liver inflammation caused by the hepatitis B virus, though more research is needed.
- Migraines: Gua sha appeared to ease migraine pain as part of a broader hospital treatment, but further studies are necessary.
- Tourette's syndrome: Combined with other therapies, gua sha showed promise in reducing symptoms in one study, but more evidence is needed.
- Neck pain: Gua sha treatment provided significant short-term pain relief for individuals with chronic neck pain in a clinical trial.
- Perimenopausal symptoms: Gua sha used once a week for 8 weeks improved symptoms like irregular periods, hot flashes, sleep issues, and mood changes in one study.
- Breast fullness: Gua sha treatment improved pain and facilitated breastfeeding for individuals experiencing breast fullness.
Muscle Scraping: A Modern Adaptation
In the Western world, physical therapists and chiropractors utilize similar techniques known as instrument-assisted soft tissue mobilization (IASTM). One well-known IASTM method is called the Graston technique. The founder, David Graston, modeled it after gua sha. Instead of gua sha, you might hear it called instrument-assisted soft tissue mobilization (IASTM). A small tool is used to help loosen up tight muscles or areas of scar tissue. There's no mention of chi.
How Muscle Scraping Stacks Up Against Other Recovery Methods
At first glance, muscle scraping might seem similar to gua sha, foam rolling, or deep-tissue massage. And while they all aim to improve soft tissue health, muscle scraping stands out for its use of specialized tools and trained techniques that allow for deeper, more targeted pressure. This precision allows therapists to access stubborn knots, improved range of motion, and better overall recovery, says Pathak.
- Massage vs. muscle scraping: Traditional massage uses hands to knead and manipulate the body, while muscle scraping employs smooth, rigid tools to apply targeted pressure, often reaching deeper layers of tissue with greater precision.
- Gua sha vs. muscle scraping: Both use scraping tools, but gua sha, rooted in traditional Chinese medicine, focuses on promoting overall energy flow (qi) and healing, often using gentler strokes. Muscle scraping, by contrast, uses specific, anatomy-based techniques to address muscle and fascia restrictions directly, says Pathak.
- Foam rolling vs. muscle scraping: Foam rolling is a DIY technique that applies broad pressure to muscles using body weight, while muscle scraping provides pinpointed, controlled pressure guided by a trained therapist.
What A Muscle Scraping Session Looks And Feels Like
During a session, a trained professional uses a smooth, rigid tool-often made of stainless steel-to apply targeted pressure to specific areas, like the shoulders, back, calves, or thighs, says Pathak. The process involves gliding the tool across the skin with varying levels of pressure, focusing on tight or sore spots. A typical session lasts anywhere from 10 to 20 minutes, depending on the treatment area and the individual’s needs.The sensation? Think deep, targeted pressure that feels a bit like a “hurts-so-good” deep-tissue massage, says Pathak. “You might feel a mild burning or soreness in tight areas,” says Pathak, “but it’s short-lived and usually followed by a noticeable improvement in mobility and pain.”Redness (from increased blood flow) or petechiae (tiny red dots from minor blood vessel rupture) may appear post-session, but both fade within a day or two. It’s also normal to feel mild soreness in the treated area for a few days-similar to how you might feel after an intense massage. While most find the experience manageable, pain tolerance varies, so it’s important to let your practitioner know what feels right to you.
Read also: Benefits of Foot Massage in Pleasanton
Choosing the Right Scraping Tool
Gua sha tools come in various forms and materials, each with unique characteristics:
- Gua sha stones: Often made from polished stones like rose quartz or jade, these tools feature a double notch on one side and a long handle on the other, ideal for scraping areas like the eyebrows, jaw, throat, cheeks, and forehead.
- Jade roller: This handheld self-massage tool, resembling a tiny paint roller, is a good choice for your face. It can help cool your skin and reduce puffy areas.
- Natural materials: Traditionally, gua sha might be done with a natural tool, such as a buffalo horn. Sometimes oil is used to help it glide more easily across your skin.
Common materials include:
- Jade: Denser, smoother, and cooler, with benefits for working out tight muscles
- Rose quartz: Softer, more porous, which may provide a lighter massage
- Natural horn: Durable and stronger
- Stainless steel or metal: Durable, stronger, and easier to clean
- Bian stone: Durable, stronger, and able to be heated
- Wood: Softest and most porous
- Plastic: Inexpensive and softer
When selecting a tool, consider its ease of cleaning, durability, and the specific areas you intend to treat.
Performing Gua Sha: A Step-by-Step Guide
Whether you seek professional treatment or opt for self-massage, understanding the proper technique is crucial.
Gua Sha for the Body
A licensed acupuncturist can perform gua sha on different areas of the body to relieve inflammation and pain. They may determine where to use gua sha based on where you’re experiencing symptoms and on acupressure points. These specific points on the body are believed to stimulate qi in Chinese traditional medicine. They correspond to specific ailments, like headaches or anxiety.
Gua Sha for the Face
If you want to try gua sha facial massage, remember to:
- Wash your hands first. Your gua sha tool should be clean, too.
- Hold the tool correctly. It should touch your skin at a 35-45 degree angle.
- Find the right touch. Use light to medium pressure.
- Use even upward and outward motions.
Here's a general guide for facial gua sha:
- Apply lotion or serum on clean skin.
- Starting at your neck, use your tool to make smooth upward strokes from your collarbone to your earlobe.
- Repeat three to five times, then repeat on the other side.
- Next, put the roller or double-edged part of your tool at the center of your chin, then move it along your jawline to your ear.
- Repeat on the other side.
- Slowly, drag the roller or long edge of the tool across your cheekbone to your ear.
- Repeat on the other side.
- Starting under your right eye, gently slide your gua sha tool outward toward your ear. Move it smoothly and in a straight line.
- Repeat on the left side.
- Starting in the middle of your right eyebrow, drag the notched side of your tool or roller outward until you reach your hairline.
- Repeat on the other side.
- Firmly press the roller or long edge of your tool from the top of your right eyebrow to the top of your forehead.
- Repeat on the opposite side.
A few gua sha tips:
- Always scrape from the inside to the outer edges of your face.
- The skin on your face is thinner than on your body, so be careful not to apply too much pressure. This routine shouldn't hurt.
Some experts suggest that trying gua sha two to three times a week will help you see positive results. Talk to your doctor if you have any questions or concerns.
Safety and Precautions
While generally safe, gua sha may cause temporary bruising or skin discoloration. Soreness and tenderness are also possible but usually subside within a few days. To minimize risks:
- Ensure proper cleaning of the gua sha tool between uses.
- Seek treatment from a qualified provider.
Avoid gua sha if you:
- Have diabetes
- Have issues with circulation
- Take blood thinners
- Are pregnant or think you may be
- Have had botulinum toxin or skin fillers injected into your face within the past month
- Have an ongoing skin issue, such as psoriasis or rosacea
If unsure, consult with your doctor before trying gua sha.
The Placebo Effect: A Factor to Consider
There's a lot that's still not understood about gua sha, and it's possible that some benefits are due to a placebo effect. Studies show that when you expect to feel better and see your symptoms improve, it's more likely to happen. Placebo interventions can improve physical disease processes of peripheral organs more easily and effectively than biochemical processes.
Counterirritation
Tissue injury (scraping) results in the release of inflammatory mediators from damaged cells including nitric oxide (NO), histamine, ions, etc., Recruited immune cells release further mediators including cytokines and growth factors. Among the cytokines, IL-10 is an antiinflammatory cytokine that suppresses nitric oxide synthases (NOS1 and NOS2) activity. The suppression of NO production leads to reduction in inflammation-related nociception. The role of NO plays in pain is not simple. Actually, NO offers pain relief in a number of ways. Inflammation causes swelling or oedema and exerts pressure on the nerves. Often the compromised circulation to the nerves is first perceived as pain. A counterirritation is an artificial irritation of the skin at certain body part in order to relieve a morbid irritation (pain) elsewhere. Counterirritation may be explained by the gate control theory.
Mechanoreceptors are sensory receptors that are activated by mechanical pressure or distortion rather than noxious stimuli. Both mechanical (myelinated) and nociceptive (nonmyelinated) signals enter the same neurons in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord. Scientific literature supported that intense manipulation of naturopathic approaches (i.e. Gua Sha, massage or cupping technique) can activate mechanoreceptors to dampen or modulate central (spinal) nociception via the gate-control pathway. Antinociceptive effects of counterirritation on pain perception and spinal nociception have been confirmed by experimental models on functional magnetic resonance imaging.