Metabolic Renewal is a weight loss program designed specifically for women, aiming to boost metabolism by modifying diet and exercise routines based on individual hormone types. It has gained popularity among those seeking enhanced energy levels, curbed cravings, and overall health improvements. However, the scientific basis for its claims remains questionable. This article delves into the pros and cons of Metabolic Renewal to help you decide if it's worth trying.
Overview of Metabolic Renewal
Metabolic Renewal, created by naturopathic doctor Jade Teta, focuses on optimizing women’s metabolism using a "4 M" framework: Mindset, Movement, Meals, and Metabolics. A central concept is the existence of seven distinct hormone types, and the program suggests that identifying your specific hormone type can enhance metabolism.
The program offers a 12-week meal plan with recipes tailored to each hormone type, along with access to 15-minute workouts and guidebooks on balancing hormone levels and eliminating belly fat.
Program Options and Costs
Metabolic Renewal is available in two versions:
- Online Version: Allows you to download or stream workouts on your computer, smartphone, or tablet.
- Online Access with DVDs and Printed Materials: Includes online access, DVDs, and printed materials for $97, plus shipping and handling.
Regardless of the chosen version, Metabolic Renewal costs $97, with an additional fee for shipping and handling for the DVD and printed materials option.
Read also: Unveiling Blue Renew Facial Oil
How Metabolic Renewal Works
Metabolic Renewal customizes nutrition, exercise, and lifestyle strategies to match your metabolic profile, optimizing hormone balance and metabolic function. According to Dr. Teta, every woman can have a specific program developed for their unique, cyclical hormonal signature.
To begin, women take a hormone test to determine their hormone type. The program then uses its "4 Ms Framework" to create a personalized roadmap for long-term success, which adapts as hormone levels change throughout the aging process.
Key Components of Metabolic Renewal (The 4 Ms)
The "4 Ms," also known as the metabolic pyramid, are the cornerstones of Metabolic Renewal's approach to leveraging a woman's natural menstrual cycle to increase metabolism and improve overall health.
1. Mindset
Mindset forms the base of the metabolic pyramid. Cultivating a positive mindset can boost motivation and confidence, reduce negative self-talk, improve mental health, and lower the risk of burnout. Maintaining a positive outlook can help control cortisol levels (a stress hormone) and improve sleep, mood, thyroid function, and metabolism. The program integrates relaxation and recovery to minimize the adverse effects of cortisol.
2. Movement
This component involves regular physical activity through structured exercise plans. Metabolic Renewal includes four 12-week workout phases, each with three different 15-minute workouts per week. These workouts are designed to be high-intensity but short in duration.
Read also: Rejuvenate at Renew Wellness Spa
Metabolic Renewal emphasizes non-exercise activity thermogenesis, claiming it burns twice as many calories. This guided movement is intended to reduce cortisol, improve metabolism, and prevent muscle and bone breakdown. The program asserts that purposeful movements can help burn up to 200 percent more calories, although there is currently no evidence to support this claim.
3. Meals
The meal component of the metabolic pyramid focuses on creating a healthy diet based on hormone cycles to promote better metabolic health, rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. The diet plan emphasizes lean proteins, fresh fruits, and vegetables while reducing high-sugar and high-fat foods that may interfere with metabolism.
4. Metabolics
Metabolics, or working out, is the fourth component. The Metabolic Renewal plan suggests that traditional workouts can stress the female metabolism and make you feel worse. Instead of traditional exercises, the program features Dr. Teta’s "intelligent" three-in-one exercises, which combine cardio, resistance, and fitness training into a 15-minute workout, three times per week.
Dietary Approach
Metabolic Renewal does not eliminate any foods outright but encourages a low-carb, high-protein diet. It promotes a diet rich in unprocessed whole foods, including meat, fish, poultry, and vegetables. These foods are often lower in calories than processed foods and are rich in essential nutrients like vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. Research suggests that a lower intake of processed foods is associated with a decreased risk of obesity.
The program is also low in carbs, with most meals consisting of vegetables and a protein source. Some studies indicate that low-carb diets can promote short-term weight loss and fat loss. Increasing protein intake may also help you feel full for longer, supporting weight loss.
Read also: Renew Spa for skin rejuvenation: A complete guide
Flexibility and Ease of Use
Metabolic Renewal does not require calorie counting, food measurement, or macronutrient tracking. It offers several ways to customize the meal plan, making it suitable for those who prefer flexibility. You can easily swap recipes from the meal plan or create your own meals using the diet's basic principles. The program also offers options for paleo, keto, vegan, and vegetarian diets.
Sample 3-Day Meal Plan
Here is a sample 3-day meal plan for Metabolic Renewal:
Day 1
- Breakfast: Smoothie with protein powder, banana, flax seeds, and spinach
- Lunch: Salad with grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, and carrots
- Dinner: Garlic pork chops with couscous and asparagus
- Snack: Hard-boiled eggs
Day 2
- Breakfast: Smoothie with protein powder, apple, chia seeds, and kale
- Lunch: Cauliflower rice with stir-fried veggies and beef
- Dinner: Baked salmon with broccoli and quinoa
- Snack: Sliced cucumbers with hummus
Day 3
- Breakfast: Smoothie with protein powder, berries, hemp seeds, and beets
- Lunch: Chopped salad with turkey, red cabbage, bell peppers, cucumbers, and tomatoes
- Dinner: Grilled mackerel with sweet potato wedges and sautéed kale
- Snacks: Peanut butter with celery
Pros of Metabolic Renewal
- Recommends an Unprocessed, Whole Foods Diet: The program emphasizes a diet consisting of unprocessed, whole foods, which can improve energy levels, digestion, and metabolic health.
- Simple, Flexible, and Easy to Follow: The program is designed to be easy to follow with resources and tools like meal plans, recipes, and workouts.
- Offers Options for Several Diet Patterns: The program offers meal plans for low-carb, vegetarian, and vegan diets.
Cons of Metabolic Renewal
- Not Based on Sound Science: The idea that there are seven specific female hormone types is not backed by scientific evidence. Most benefits are likely due to the recommended dietary and lifestyle changes, not optimizing female metabolism. Many claims lack a basis in scientific evidence or are based on small studies. There is no evidence that this program can balance hormones or metabolism.
- May Lead to Weight Regain: Metabolic Renewal is a short-term program designed for 12 weeks. Although short-term diets may lead to rapid weight loss, weight regain is likely after resuming a normal diet because brief dietary changes don’t often translate to long-term lifestyle habits.
- Doesn't Offer Much Guidance For Weight Maintenance Post-Program: The program lacks guidance on maintaining weight loss after completion, which can be challenging for those seeking sustainable fat loss.
Alternatives to Metabolic Renewal
If you're looking to lose weight, balance hormone levels, or improve your health, consider these alternatives:
- WW (Weight Watchers): A weight loss program that assigns foods a points value and gives members a PersonalPoints budget. Members can opt for coaching or group workshops.
- Noom: An app-based program aimed at building healthier habits to support weight loss and health. Foods and drinks are categorized based on calorie density, and members are assigned a virtual support team.
- Mayo Clinic Diet: A digital program designed to promote sustainable weight loss, providing meal plans, at-home workouts, and an online food log.
RENEW Weight Loss Intervention for Individuals with Serious Mental Illness
Research has also explored weight loss interventions for specific populations, such as individuals with serious mental illness. One such intervention, the Recovering Energy through Nutrition and Exercise for Weight Loss (RENEW) program, showed modest weight loss results in this population.
Study Design and Methods
- Participants: 136 individuals with serious mental illness from four community mental health programs.
- Inclusion Criteria: Confirmed diagnosis of serious mental illness, age 18-65, BMI ≥ 25, and stable medication (no changes in antipsychotic medications or mood stabilizers for the last 3 months).
- Exclusion Criteria: Intellectual disability or dementia, a diagnosis of an eating disorder, or severe cardiovascular or other physical illness that would limit participation in physical activity.
- Randomization: Participants were randomly assigned to the RENEW intervention or a control condition of treatment as usual.
- Intervention: The RENEW program is a manualized intervention combining evidence-based weight loss strategies and psychiatric rehabilitation principles. Participants received education and practice in modifying nutrition and physical activity.
- Phases: The RENEW program was divided into three phases: an intensive intervention (weeks 1-12), a maintenance intervention (weeks 13-24), and intermittent supports (weeks 25-52).
- Measurements: Measures were administered at baseline, 3 months, 6 months, and 12 months.
Results
- The intervention group experienced a modest weight loss of 4.8 lbs at 3 months and 4.1 lbs at 6 months but regained weight to 1.5 lbs heavier than baseline at 12 months.
- The control group gained 8.5 lbs at 3 months and ended up 6.2 lbs over their baseline at 12 months.
- Significant differences were observed between sites, with two sites showing weight loss ("responders") and two sites showing weight gain ("non-responders").
- The responder sites lost 9.4 lbs at 3 months, 10.9 lbs at 6 months, and 7 lbs at 12 months.
Conclusions
The RENEW study found modest weight loss at 3 and 6 months for the intervention group, with weight gain in the control group. However, site comparisons revealed significant differences, suggesting that the setting in which individuals receive services may impact the success of weight loss interventions. The concept of the obesogenic environment deserves further examination as a factor in the success of weight loss programs.
Dietary Supplements for Weight Loss: A Word of Caution
Many people turn to dietary supplements for weight loss, drawn by the promise of fast and easy results. However, it's crucial to approach these products with caution.
Regulation and Evidence
- Dietary supplements are not medicines and do not require Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval.
- Manufacturers of dietary supplements are responsible for ensuring their safety, but they rarely conduct clinical trials.
Risks and Considerations
- A product isn't safe simply because it's natural. Supplements can have strong effects.
- Some weight-loss supplements have been found to contain unlisted ingredients, such as prescription medicines.
- The key to losing weight is a holistic lifestyle approach that involves eating well and moving more.
Example: Raspberry Ketone
Raspberry ketone is marketed as a weight-loss product with clinical proof. However, trials are often small and short-term, making it difficult to predict real-life results. For example, one trial included 70 adults with obesity who participated in a diet and exercise program. The trial assigned them at random to either a supplement group or a placebo group. While results seemed to favor the supplement group, the trial's small size and short duration (eight weeks) limit the applicability of the results.