In today's fast-paced world, meal replacement subscription services have emerged as a convenient solution for individuals seeking to streamline meal planning, save time, and achieve specific dietary goals. These services offer a variety of options, ranging from pre-portioned ingredients with step-by-step recipes to fully prepared meals that require minimal effort. This article provides a comprehensive comparison of several leading meal replacement subscription services, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and suitability for different lifestyles and dietary needs.
Understanding Meal Delivery Services
Meal delivery services can be broadly categorized into two main types: meal kit services and prepared meal services. Meal kit services provide pre-portioned ingredients and recipes, allowing users to cook meals from scratch with reduced prep time. Prepared meal services, on the other hand, offer fully cooked meals that simply need to be heated and consumed.
Top Meal Kit Delivery Services
Marley Spoon: A Culinary Adventure
Marley Spoon stands out for its diverse menu and emphasis on providing a real cooking experience. The service partners with Martha Stewart to offer carefully tested recipes from her archives, as well as new, original recipes designed to be prepared in under 30 minutes.
Pros:
- Meals encourage cooking and eating outside of one's comfort zone.
- Impressive meal add-ons, including items from well-known food brands.
- Easy to select meals with varying levels of prep time.
- High-quality ingredients that closely match those found in grocery stores.
- Recipes regularly riff on standard comfort foods in fun, tasty ways, like Mediterranean nachos that feature dill, feta, and olives.
- Recipes utilize ingredients that just don’t show up in lots of other meal kits like tteok bokki (Korean rice cakes) or berbere spices.
- Prepared add-ons, like frozen pizzas or jarred bolognese, improve weekly meal plans.
Cons:
- May not be the best option for those with strict dietary restrictions, although vegetarian and vegan plans are available.
- Some instances of leakage during shipping have been reported.
Best for: Meal kit customers who want their meal kits to offer a real cooking experience.
Pricing: Meals start at $8.69, with shipping at $11.99.
Read also: Meal replacement guide for women
Availability: Nationwide, excluding Alaska and Hawaii.
HelloFresh: Simplicity and Skill-Building
HelloFresh is a popular meal kit service that focuses on providing good recipes with pre-portioned ingredients. It offers three plans: classic, vegetarian, and family-friendly.
Pros:
- Recipes are easy to follow and help less experienced home cooks improve their skills.
- Ingredients are vacuum-sealed to prolong freshness and offer flexibility in meal planning.
- Vegetarian meals are easy and satisfying.
- Instructions are very helpful, the sort of rundown that could really help a budding home cook just out of college learn some technique.
Cons:
- The cooking process may not be significantly easier than using recipes from other sources.
- Vegetarian options are preset, limiting choices for vegetarians.
Best for: Individuals interested in learning to cook, regardless of their current skill level.
Pricing: Meals start at $8.99 per serving.
Availability: Nationwide and abroad.
Read also: Low-Carb Meal Ideas
Home Chef: Customization and Convenience
Home Chef offers a high degree of customization, allowing users to adjust protein options, meal types, and serving sizes. It provides classic kits, express kits (ready in 30 minutes or less), oven-ready meals, and fully microwavable options.
Pros:
- Highly customizable, with options to adjust protein, serving sizes, and the number of meals per week.
- Variety of meal types available, including classic kits, express kits, oven-ready meals, and microwavable options.
- Add-ons like lunches, desserts, breakfasts, and La Colombe latte cans are available.
- Caters to a number of personal nutrition preferences and dietary restrictions with recipes that are vegetarian, keto-friendly, Mediterranean-diet-inspired, and more.
Cons:
- Recipes may become repetitive over time, with similar ingredients and formats appearing frequently.
Best for: Busy individuals who want to take the guesswork out of dinner and enjoy customizing their meals.
Pricing: Meals start at $9.99 per serving.
Availability: Delivers to 98% of the United States (enter your zip code when signing up to ensure your area is in the delivery zone).
Green Chef: Organic and Sustainable
Green Chef is the first USDA-certified organic meal-kit company, focusing on bringing top-quality ingredients to its customers. It offers plans that cater to specific dietary preferences and restrictions, such as keto, vegan, low-carb, and gluten-free.
Read also: Vegan Diet for Bodybuilding
Pros:
- Offers plans compliant with dietary preferences and restrictions, such as keto, vegan, low-carb, and gluten-free.
- Offers bi-monthly or monthly subscriptions.
- Provides instructions for sustainably disposing of shipment packaging.
- Creative flourishes in each recipe have a nice way of uniquely elevating the flavor profile, like adding umami stock to a chicken and orzo skillet, for example.
Cons:
- Pricier than many meal kits.
- Options may feel monotonous over time.
- Recipe cards are designed for two servings, requiring adjustments for larger formats.
- Seasoning and sauce packets may be generously portioned, requiring caution for those sensitive to salt.
Best for: Beginner cooks who prioritize high-quality ingredients and sustainable packaging.
Pricing: Meals start at $11.99 per serving.
Availability: Nationwide, excluding Alaska and Hawaii.
Blue Apron: Culinary Education and Quality Ingredients
Blue Apron focuses on teaching users how to prep ingredients before cooking, providing detailed instructions and high-quality proteins. It offers a signature plan, a vegetarian plan, and a wellness plan with nutritionist-approved, carb-conscious recipes.
Pros:
- Detailed instructions that teach users how to prep ingredients.
- High-quality proteins, such as salmon and cod fillets.
- Offers nice proteins. The highlight for was the quality fillets of salmon or cod that arrived each week.
- Offers really nice proteins. We even tried scallops in one "premium" basket.
- Offers over 30 pre-made meal options per week.
Cons:
- Requires some cooking skills.
- Does not cater to many dietary restrictions or specific dietary plans like gluten-free and keto.
Best for: Beginner cooks who hope to “learn from the beginning and hone their basic skills.”
Pricing: Varies based on the chosen plan.
Availability: Delivery is available to the contiguous United States.
EveryPlate: Affordability and Simplicity
EveryPlate is a budget-friendly meal delivery service that offers simple and delicious meals with filling portions and fresh ingredients. It offers a Calorie Smart plan with meals around 650 calories or less per serving.
Pros:
- Affordable meal kits.
- Calorie Smart plan offers recipes under 650 calories.
- Good for beginner cooks.
- Easy to customize meals and skip weeks. When I think of “meal kit” my brain goes right to HelloFresh, and I would argue that many Americans would agree.
- Tasty and quality meals.
- Helpful instructions with pictures.
Cons:
- Items don't come as organized as other services.
- Not every dish is low calorie.
- Limited lower calorie options each week.
Best for: Beginner cooks and families looking for affordable and easy-to-prepare meals.
Pricing: $5.99 per serving + $10 shipping fee.
Availability: Delivery to the majority of the continental United States.
Dinnerly: Simple, Affordable, and Family-Friendly
Dinnerly is a simple and affordable meal delivery service with a large weekly menu of over 100 recipes. Most meals can be made in 30 minutes or less, and there are options that cater to a calorie-conscious lifestyle at 650 calories or less per meal.
Pros:
- Affordable and delicious meals.
- Calorie Smart plan offers recipes under 650 calories.
- Good for beginner cooks.
- Large portion sizes, delicious flavor and easy-to-follow recipes.
- Items don't come as organized as other services.
Cons:
- Items don't come as organized as other services (but the quality of ingredients is still great).
Best for: Families and beginner cooks who want simple, affordable, and tasty meals.
Pricing: $4.99 to $8.49 per serving + $11.99 shipping fee.
Availability: Delivery to most of the contiguous United States.
Top Prepared Meal Delivery Services
CookUnity: Restaurant-Quality Ready-Made Meals
CookUnity reimagines ready-made meals by offering recipes from renowned chefs and using sustainably sourced, high-quality ingredients. It caters to various diets, including vegetarian, vegan, keto-friendly, and Paleo.
Pros:
- Flavors are impressive for heat-and-eat meals.
- Texture is consistently good.
- A returnable bag program helps cut down on packaging waste in select markets.
- The convenience is unbeatable - the meals show up at my door at the beginning of the week, and knowing all I need to do to cook dinner is pull the wrapper off a meal and warm it up makes my evenings totally stress-free.
- Offers plenty of meals for specific diets (including vegetarian, vegan, keto-friendly, Paleo, Whole30, gluten-free, dairy-free, low-sodium, low-carb, and/or low-calorie diets).
Cons:
- Not everything works well as a reheated meal; fried items should be avoided.
- Some more prep work involved than other services she’s tried.
Best for: People who think heat-and-eat meals can’t be interesting.
Pricing: Meals start at $13.49 per meal.
Availability: Delivers to most of the United States.
Factor: Health-Conscious and Dietitian-Approved
Factor focuses on nutritious prepared meals specifically designed for weight loss and catering to different medical conditions. The meals are designed by registered dietitians and chefs, and the service offers a complimentary nutrition consultation.
Pros:
- Meals are designed with registered dietitians.
- Offers a complimentary nutrition consultation.
- Calorie Smart plan features meals with 550 calories or less.
- Factor is incredibly reasonably priced for the quality of health-oriented food they offer.
- The meals' high protein counts stood out to me and also helped keep me full - dishes felt substantial and hearty, and that was a key takeaway in my consultation with Factor's dietitian.
Cons:
- Meals can be high in saturated fat.
- Some of the meals, especially the keto-compliant ones, can be high in fat and sodium.
- Department of Labor is investigating HelloFresh and hiring agency Midway Staffing over claims that migrant children were working at a Factor facility in Illinois.
Best for: Individuals serious about weight loss and those with specific dietary needs.
Pricing: Meals range from $11.49 to $13.99, with shipping at $11 per delivery.
Availability: Delivery in the contiguous United States.
BistroMD: Medically Designed Weight Loss Meals
BistroMD focuses on nutritious prepared meals specifically designed for weight loss, and also has plans catering to different medical conditions like diabetes, heart health, and menopause. The service even has a team of in-house registered dietitians that can create a custom diet program for you.
Pros:
- Over 150 meals to choose from on their Signature Program.
- Prepared meals are ready in five minutes or less.
- All plans cater to weight loss.
- I love that BistroMD meals are balanced, satisfying and science-backed.
- Good quality of food, interesting variety and good taste.
- Plus, I actually lost weight.
Cons:
- $19.95 shipping fee.
Best for: Individuals serious about weight loss and those with specific dietary needs.
Pricing: $10.99 to $14.99 per meal, plus a $19.95 shipping fee.
Availability: Delivery to the contiguous United States.
Splendid Spoon: Healthy and Convenient Plant-Based Meals
Splendid Spoon offers over 50 healthy ready-made meals and snacks that include smoothies, soups, noodle bowls, and dishes - and everything is gluten-free.
Pros:
- Offers over 50 healthy ready-made meals and snacks.
- Everything is gluten-free.
- Smoothies were filling, tasted delicious and easy to store in my fridge.
- They taste as healthy as they are, which is a downside for some and a bonus for others.
- The selection of juices and smoothies and the convenience of thawing one at a time.
Cons:
- Not as flavorful as some other services.
- You can’t pick the number of meals you get per plan like most other delivery services.
Best for: Anyone who wants healthy meals in a flash.
Pricing: Varies based on the chosen plan.
Availability: Delivery is available to the contiguous United States.
Trifecta: Macro-Focused Meals for Active Lifestyles
Trifecta is popular in the CrossFit community and offers prepared meals with curated macros depending on the specific goal. All meals are developed by a team of dietitians, chefs, and doctors.
Pros:
- Variety of meals.
- Convenience.
- Portions were satisfying.
- Having access to healthy meals made their week "stress-free."
- Meals are developed by a team of dietitians, chefs and doctors.
- Offers five different plans to choose from: clean, Paleo & Whole 30 friendly, keto, plant-based and GLP-1 friendly.
Cons:
- Meals aren't the most flavorful we've tried.
Best for: Those trying to manage their weight and stay active.
Pricing: Meals are about $15 each. Flat $9.99 shipping fee for all states except Alaska and Hawaii.
Availability: Delivery everywhere in the United States including Alaska and Hawaii.
No-Subscription Meal Delivery Services
For those who prefer flexibility and don't want to commit to a subscription, several meal delivery services offer no-subscription options.
tags: #meal #replacement #subscription