In the complex world of diets, understanding the nuances between different approaches can be challenging. The keto diet and the South Beach Diet are two popular options that focus on reducing carbohydrate intake and increasing the consumption of healthy fats and lean protein. While they share similarities, significant differences exist in their approaches, health benefits, and potential risks. This article provides a comprehensive comparison of these two diets to help you make an informed decision about which one might be best for you.
South Beach Diet: An Overview
The South Beach Diet was developed by cardiologist Arthur Agatston in the 1990s and gained popularity with the publication of his book, "The South Beach Diet: The Delicious, Doctor-Designed, Foolproof Plan for Fast and Healthy Weight Loss," in 2003. The diet aims to help people with prediabetes, diabetes, and obesity lose weight while reducing their risk of heart disease. Agatston's goal was to create a diet that was less heavy in saturated fat than the Atkins diet and included high-fiber foods like certain fruits and whole grains. The South Beach Diet is designed to be high in lean proteins, unsaturated fats, and low-glycemic carbohydrates.
The South Beach Diet is a tiered elimination system that categorizes carbohydrates and fats as "good" or "bad" to facilitate weight loss. It consists of three phases:
- Phase 1: This is a strict two-week period where bread, pasta, potatoes, rice, baked goods, sweets, ice cream, alcohol, sugar, and even fruit are strictly off-limits. The goal is to halt sugar dependence and shift the body into a fat-burning mode. During this phase, you focus on eating lean protein sources such as seafood, skinless poultry, lean beef, and soy products. You can also consume high-fiber vegetables and low- or nonfat dairy products, as well as foods containing healthy unsaturated fats. The diet promises to help you drop 8 to 13 pounds in that first two weeks if you follow it to the letter. It also boasts of improved internal health, with a focus on better cardiovascular health.
- Phase 2: After the initial two weeks, you can begin adding back some carbohydrates, but only the "good" ones, such as brown rice and some fruits. This phase is designed to be somewhat less restrictive, and dieters will stay in this phase until they reach their goal weight. In this phase, dieters can expect to lose about 1 to 2 pounds per week, which lines up with recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention about safe and sustainable weight loss. After the 14th day of phase 2, you can have up to four servings of starchy vegetables, legumes, and whole grains (think peas, sweet potatoes, rutabaga, whole grain pasta, and wild brown rice.) You can also enjoy up to three servings of fruit per day. A serving size is about ¾ cup of berries or grapes or one small piece of fruit. This excludes pineapple, figs, dates, watermelon, and raisins.
- Phase 3: This is a "more liberal" maintenance phase intended for dieters who have achieved their desired weight loss, Agatston writes. This phase is intended to be followed long term and looks a bit like a Mediterranean diet with lots of vegetables and fresh fish, lean meats, and some dairy. Across all phases of the diet, the South Beach approach favors the inclusion of low-glycemic carbohydrates over high-glycemic carbs. Low-GI carbs do not trigger as intense an insulin response in the body, meaning they can help you maintain a steady blood sugar level. A steady blood sugar level eliminates spikes and crashes in blood sugar, which can affect energy levels throughout the day.
The South Beach Diet suggests eating six small meals a day instead of three larger meals. The diet also emphasizes healthy fats, such as monounsaturated fats found in olive oil and avocado, while limiting saturated and trans fats.
Keto Diet: An Overview
The keto diet is a high-fat, adequate-protein, and very low-carbohydrate diet designed to induce ketosis, a metabolic state where the body burns fat for fuel instead of glucose. This is achieved by drastically reducing carbohydrate intake and increasing the ratio of good fats in the diet. The keto diet was initially developed in the 1920s as a means of treating severe epilepsy in children. This diet was composed of 90% fat, 6% protein, and 4% carbohydrates, which helped to quell epileptic seizures. The diet is still used today in people for whom other treatments haven’t been successful.
Read also: Easy Low-Carb Cheese Crackers
In a daily 2,000-calorie diet, the macronutrient breakdown might look like 165 grams of fat, 40 grams of carbs, and 75 grams of protein. Some healthy unsaturated fats are allowed on the keto diet - like nuts (almonds, walnuts), seeds, avocados, tofu, and olive oil. All fruits are rich in carbs, but you can have certain fruits (usually berries) in small portions. Vegetables (also rich in carbs) are restricted to leafy greens (such as kale, Swiss chard, spinach), cauliflower, broccoli, Brussels sprouts, asparagus, bell peppers, onions, garlic, mushrooms, cucumber, celery, and summer squashes.
When you’re in ketosis, your cells burn fat to produce molecules called ketones. Normally, your cells rely on sugar (glucose) for energy. Carb restriction is the key to this fat-burning state. That’s because when you keep carb intake low, your blood sugar stays low. Think of low insulin as the ketosis bat signal. To confirm you’re on track with keto, you can measure ketone levels using blood or urine test strips.
Key Similarities
The South Beach Diet and the keto diet share some key similarities:
- Low-Carbohydrate Approach: Both diets emphasize reducing carbohydrate intake compared to the standard American diet, which is often high in sugar and processed foods.
- Increased Fat and Protein Intake: Both diets encourage a higher intake of healthy fats and lean protein to promote satiety and support weight loss.
- Weight Loss: Both diets can be effective for weight loss, especially in the short term.
- Elimination of Processed Carbs: Both diets limit carbohydrates in the form of processed carbs, making them naturally low in processed, high-sugar foods.
Key Differences
Despite their similarities, the South Beach Diet and the keto diet have several key differences:
- Carbohydrate Restriction: The keto diet is much stricter in its carbohydrate restriction than the South Beach Diet. To remain in ketosis, followers of the keto diet must adhere more strictly to its guidelines, typically consuming fewer than 50 grams of net carbs daily, or in some cases, fewer than 20 grams. The South Beach Diet, while limiting carbs, does not have clear boundaries on carb intake and allows for the reintroduction of whole grains, root vegetables, legumes, and fruits in later phases.
- Fat Intake: The keto diet focuses on a very high fat intake, with fat supplying as much as 90% of daily calories. The South Beach Diet, while encouraging healthy fats, does not require such a high percentage of fat in the diet.
- Ketosis: The keto diet aims to induce and maintain ketosis, a metabolic state where the body burns fat for fuel. The South Beach Diet does not specifically aim for ketosis, although it may occur in phase 1 due to the strict carbohydrate restriction.
- Phases: The South Beach Diet utilizes a phased approach, with different levels of carbohydrate restriction in each phase. The keto diet does not have distinct phases and is typically followed consistently.
- Food Choices: The keto diet allows for a wider variety of fats, including saturated fats like coconut oil and butter, while limiting polyunsaturated vegetable oils like soybean and peanut oil. The South Beach Diet limits saturated fat and focuses on monounsaturated fats like olive oil.
- Long-Term Sustainability: The keto diet can be followed indefinitely, while the South Beach Diet is designed with time-limited phases and is to be followed only until the dieter's desired weight is reached.
- Nutrient Density: The South Beach Diet was designed to be a weight loss plan and does not focus on nutrient density as much as it does macronutrients. The Paleo Diet focuses heavily on nutrient density and food quality. The Paleo Diet also makes things easier on its followers. Instead of sticking to strict measures like keto, or implementing phases like South Beach, The Paleo Diet encourages overall health in a sustainable way. We encourage the 85/15 rule and allow followers to enjoy whatever foods they like about 15% of the time. As long as the diet guidelines are followed 85% of the time, Paleo dieters can expect to reap benefits like weight loss, disease prevention, higher energy, clearer skin, and better sleep-to name a few.
Potential Health Benefits
Keto Diet:
- Rapid Weight Loss: The restrictive keto approach can lead to rapid weight loss, which can help combat obesity.
- Hormone Balance: Some research has indicated that the keto diet can improve hormone balance in some individuals, with less acne and a reduction of symptoms associated with polycystic ovary syndrome being associated with this diet in some women.
- Cancer Research: Studies are ongoing into whether or not a ketogenic diet can slow the growth of cancer or reduce the risk of cancer recurrence. The idea is that many types of cancer cells thrive when growing in a high-sugar environment.
- Appetite Suppression: Because the keto diet features plenty of fat, you may feel less hungry when dieting and consume fewer calories.
- Diabetes Management: There have also been some indications that the diet may be able to help with diabetes management, but long-term data is still limited.
South Beach Diet:
- Cardiovascular Health: The South Beach Diet promises to improve cardiovascular health by reducing body weight, blood pressure, and blood lipids (fat and cholesterol in the blood) in those who follow the plan carefully.
- Improved Blood Sugar Levels: A reduction in body weight has been linked to improved symptoms in some people.
- Conscious Food Intake: The South Beach diet forces people to become "conscious of your food intake" while emphasizing fresh, whole foods.
Potential Health Risks
Keto Diet:
- Keto Flu: A common complaint among people who have recently switched to a keto diet is the so-called keto flu. This is a series of symptoms including fatigue, headaches, muscle aches, and gastrointestinal distress that usually passes within a few days.
- Nutrient Deficiencies: Because the keto diet is restrictive, it can lead to nutrient deficiencies if not carefully planned.
- Eating Disorders: Anyone struggling with an eating disorder, pregnant or nursing women, patients with kidney disease, and people on medication that lowers blood sugar should exercise caution and get supervision.
- Long-Term Effects: Research on the long-term effects of the keto diet is underway, but as of now, data is lacking.
- Dirty Keto: Some people following the keto diet get too caught up in tracking macronutrient ratios and don’t spend enough energy looking for high-quality food. So these individuals "tend to eat poor-quality, processed fats, which will show results in the short term but can lead to serious health issues in the long term. This is called ‘dirty keto’ and should be avoided," which means processed meat products and artificial sweeteners should be limited.
South Beach Diet:
- Restrictiveness: The South Beach Diet can also be quite restrictive, especially in the first few weeks.
- Fat Phobia: Some people may become "fat-phobic," avoiding fats when trying to cut calories.
- Liver and Kidney Concerns: Even with a greater balance of carbs and protein, the South Beach diet is high enough in protein to raise liver and kidney concerns.
- Nutrient Deficiencies: You may also lack fiber and other nutrients if you’re on it long-term and not keeping an eye on all of your nutritional needs.
Cost Comparison
The costs for a do-it-yourself approach to either the keto diet or the South Beach diet are likely to be similar. Both diets rely on fat and protein for the bulk of calories, and carbohydrate sources tend to be less expensive, so both diets can get pricey. Because the South Beach diet tends to include more meat, it can also be a little more expensive than a strict keto diet. If you go the commercial route with the South Beach diet, you can expect to spend about $300 to $380 per month for meal delivery, depending on the plan.
Read also: Keto Calorie Counting: A Detailed Guide
Read also: Magnesium Supplements for Keto