Vanilla flavor is a popular choice for enhancing the taste of various treats, including cakes, waffles, cookies, and other low-carb desserts. However, with the rising popularity of the ketogenic diet, many people wonder whether vanilla extract is keto-friendly. This article explores the compatibility of vanilla extract with the keto diet, its nutritional content, potential alternatives, and other related aspects.
What is Vanilla Extract?
Vanilla extract is a flavoring agent derived from vanilla beans, which are the fruits of a tropical orchid plant. The American Culinary Federation Education Foundation defines vanilla extract as "a solution made by steeping cured vanilla pods in alcohol until the flavor is infused." Manufacturers grind up the cured beans and add them to alcohol to make vanilla extract. Vanilla extract contains over 200 flavor compounds, which explains why vanilla is one of the most complex flavors in existence.
Is Vanilla Extract Keto-Friendly?
Yes, vanilla extract is generally considered keto-friendly. Most brands of pure vanilla extract contain vanilla beans, alcohol, and water as the sole ingredients. Pure vanilla extract contains zero grams of sugar per serving (about one teaspoon). Because pure vanilla extract is fairly low in carbohydrates, and the amount most recipes call for is relatively minimal, you don’t have to worry about adding unnecessary carbs when using it in your delicious dessert ideas.
Nutritional Information
Pure vanilla extract contains zero grams of sugar per serving (about one teaspoon).
Pure vs. Imitation Vanilla Extract
It is important to distinguish between pure vanilla extract and imitation vanilla. The FDA defines vanilla extract as solutions made with real vanilla beans as the main flavoring ingredient and nothing else. Imitation vanilla, vanilla aroma, and vanilla essence are products that have synthetic vanillin as the main flavoring compound. Synthetic vanillin is produced from wood byproducts and does not have the complexities of natural vanilla.
Read also: Using Vanilla Extract on Carnivore
Imitation vanilla is usually made with water, alcohol, vanillin, caramel color, and preservatives. All of these ingredients have barely any effect on blood glucose levels. Imitation vanilla does not provide the antioxidants and other beneficial compounds of pure vanilla. Although less reliable, also check the color. Real vanilla extract has a deep brown color which comes directly from the vanilla pods. Imitation vanilla, in comparison, is clear.
Homemade Vanilla Extract
Making your own vanilla extract is a simple and economical process. All you need is high-quality spirit such as vodka and vanilla beans. The best spirit for homemade vanilla extract is vodka, because you get pure vanilla flavour. If you use rum or bourbon, the vanilla taste won't be as strong, as these spirits will slightly mask the flavour.
Homemade Vanilla Extract Recipe
Ingredients:
- 4-6 vanilla beans
- 1 1/4 cups high-quality vodka or rum (300 ml/ 10 fl oz)
- Optional: 15-20 drops clear or vanilla stevia or other healthy low-carb sweetener
Instructions:
- Prepare a glass jar you will use for the extract by sterilising it in hot water.
- Cut the vanilla beans lengthwise, place in the glass jar and seal well. The more vanilla beans you use, the more flavour and darker colour you will achieve. Make sure the beans are completely submerged. Opt for really dark oily beans, as these will give the extract the best flavour.
- Infuse for 4-6 weeks. The longer you leave it, the more intense the flavour will be.
- Shake 2-3 times while it's infusing to help release the flavour.
- After about 4 weeks, the extract will become dark and is ready to be used.
Other Considerations
Alcohol Content
The FDA requires vanilla extract to contain at least 35% alcohol and 13.35 ounces of vanilla beans per gallon. Pure vanilla extract, which is made by macerating and percolating vanilla beans in alcohol and water, may be considered not halal by some because of the alcohol content. However, the alcohol evaporates if the vanilla extract is cooked.
Allergens and Dietary Restrictions
In most cases, pure vanilla extract is gluten free. The primary ingredients of vanilla extract are vanilla beans, alcohol, and sometimes sugar. The alcohol is usually distilled from grains like corn or sugarcane that do not contain gluten.
Yes, pure vanilla extract is vegan. It is made by soaking vanilla beans in an alcohol-based solution. There are no animal-derived products involved in the process.
Read also: Ingredients in Diet Cherry Vanilla Dr Pepper
Pure vanilla extract is considered low FODMAP. One tablespoon of this extract contains far less than one gram of FODMAPs, making it safe for individuals following a low FODMAP diet.
Yes, pure vanilla extract is paleo-friendly. It is a natural product made from vanilla beans soaked in alcohol.
Yes, vanilla extract is suitable for vegetarians.
Some brands of vanilla extract are indeed kosher. This depends on whether the company producing it complies with Kosher laws. The vanilla beans and alcohol can both be kosher, yet the process may not be kosher certified.
Because vanilla extract is a fermented product, it can potentially contain some histamine content.
Read also: Decadent Keto Cupcakes
Yes, pure vanilla extract is Whole30 compliant. Whole30 diet guidelines suggest avoiding added sugars and artificial sweeteners, but the alcohol and natural flavors in pure vanilla extract evaporate during cooking, making it compliant. However, it's worth mentioning that not all brands are compliant, as some might add sugars or other non-compliant ingredients.
Cost and Quality
Vanilla is very expensive: it is the second most expensive spice in the world after saffron, although prices have recently dropped. Currently, the minimum export price of vanilla is $250 per kilogram (2.2 lbs). As a result, the average cost of vanilla extract is $20 for an 8oz bottle.
The only way to avoid accidentally adding these sugar-laden ingredients to your baked goods is to read the ingredients list and nutrition facts label.
And lastly, take the price as an indicator of quality.
Versatile Flavor Enhancer
Vanilla is to bakers what salt is to chefs: an essential flavor enhancer. Without it, your favorite cookies and cakes would taste boring. Vanilla extract is a calorie free additive designed to really heighten sweeter keto recipes and baked goods without adding any sugar.
Alternatives to Vanilla Extract
There are several alternatives to vanilla extract. These include vanilla bean (one bean equals about one teaspoon of extract), vanilla bean paste, vanilla powder, and vanilla-flavored liqueurs like bourbon or rum. Spices like nutmeg or cinnamon can also be used for flavor, though they won't precisely replicate the taste of vanilla.