In a world increasingly focused on optimizing performance, metabolism, and longevity, Health Via Modern Nutrition (H.V.M.N.) introduced Ketone-IQ, a product designed to tap into the power of ketones for a cleaner, more efficient fuel source. Celebrities like Steven Bartlett endorse it, and the energy shots promise a new era of energy, including improved athletic performance and sharpened focus. But do ketone supplements actually work? This article dives deep into Ketone-IQ, examining its ingredients, purported benefits, and scientific backing to help you make an informed decision.
What are Ketones?
Ketones are organic compounds produced by the body when it breaks down fat for energy. This process occurs when glucose, the primary energy source for cells, is scarce. Unlike fat, ketones can cross the blood-brain barrier, offering both the brain and body a potentially more efficient form of energy compared to glucose or fat. Ketosis, the state of elevated ketone levels, can be induced through a ketogenic diet, intense exercise, or prolonged fasting.
Understanding Ketone-IQ
H.V.M.N. claims to have worked with the military and top universities to develop Ketone-IQ, a drinkable form of ketones intended to help users return to an optimized metabolic state. The company suggests that this product is suitable for anyone looking to improve their metabolic health, not just those following a keto diet.
Ketone-IQ Ingredients
Ketone-IQ primarily contains R-1,3-Butanediol, a natural ketone created through a fermentation process. Depending on the version, the energy drink may also include caffeine from green tea (approximately 100mg in the caffeinated version) and vitamins like Vitamin B6 and Vitamin B12, which support brain function and mood. Ketone IQ shots are vegan, gluten-free, and sugar-free, and third-party tested.
The Promise of Ketone-IQ
Ketone-IQ is marketed as a way to provide clean, sustainable energy, boost metabolism (through added caffeine), and enhance mental acuity. The manufacturer suggests that ketones can act as fuel for the brain, helping users achieve and sustain peak mental performance.
Read also: Easy Low-Carb Cheese Crackers
Examining the Claims: Does Ketone-IQ Work?
While Ketone-IQ offers an interesting concept for those seeking a boost in metabolic health or looking to fuel their body with ketones, the scientific evidence supporting its effectiveness is not definitive.
Personal Experiences
One individual's experience with Ketone-IQ revealed no noticeable differences in workouts or energy levels after trying a 6-pack. The taste was also a significant deterrent, requiring multiple attempts to consume the small serving size. This led to the conclusion that Ketone-IQ might be more of a placebo effect for some users.
Scientific Studies and Research
The benefits of R-1,3-Butanediol supplementation specifically have not been extensively studied, making it challenging to draw definitive conclusions about Ketone-IQ effectiveness.
- One small study (12 healthy volunteers) found that R-1,3-Butanediol supplementation immediately before exercise improved anaerobic performance on a cycle ergometer test. However, one of the authors was associated with the Ketone-IQ manufacturer, raising potential bias concerns.
- A 2019 study found that combined carbohydrate and 1,3-butanediol supplementation lowered blood lactate concentration, indicating better recovery, but did not enhance 5 km running performance.
- Ellie Abraham, PhD in plant biology and a chief scientific officer at Centera Bioscience, suggests that raising blood BHB levels can temporarily lower blood glucose and potentially serve as an alternative fuel source, potentially leading to smoother and more sustained energy levels. However, she notes that well-designed athletic performance studies haven't consistently supported this conclusion.
Addressing Specific Claims by H.V.M.N.
H.V.M.N. makes several claims on their product page, citing research to support them. However, a closer look reveals potential issues with their interpretations.
- Claim 1: "28% more efficient in generating energy than glucose alone." The source for this claim is a 1995 study done in rats with mitochondrial damage. This study is not directly relevant to healthy humans.
- Claim 2: "15% Mean power output improvement after recovery." The source is a 2019 paper published in the Journal of Physiology. This study focused on how a ketone ester supplement affected subjects in a state of functional overreaching (an early stage of overtraining). While the ketone ester group had a higher average power output during a 120-minute time trial, the study wasn't designed to see if ketones improve performance in general. Furthermore, the ketone ester group consumed more calories on average, potentially contributing to the performance difference.
- Claim 3: "2% improved athlete’s endurance." The source is a 2016 paper from the Journal of Cell Metabolism. While this study showed a 2% improvement in distance pedaled during a 30-minute time trial after 60 minutes of steady-state work, other studies have yielded different results. A systematic review of multiple studies on ketone supplementation and endurance performance shows mixed results, with some showing impairments and others showing improvements.
The Importance of Context and Comprehensive Research
It's crucial to consider the broader body of research when evaluating the effectiveness of any supplement. Cherry-picking studies that support a product while ignoring the rest of the research can be misleading. A systematic review of available data, including 16 different performance outcomes, showed that ketone supplementation resulted in no change in performance in most cases, with some showing improvements and others showing impairments. This equivocal evidence makes it difficult to definitively claim any performance benefits from ketone supplementation.
Read also: Keto Calorie Counting: A Detailed Guide
Potential Side Effects
Users of ketone supplements, including Ketone IQ, have reported side effects such as nausea, bloating, diarrhea, and stomach pain, especially with ketone salts. There are also risks of hypoglycemia, especially if supplementation is combined with carbohydrate restriction or exercise. Newer studies on 1,3-Butanediol suggest that its supplementation may cause nausea, dizziness, and headache, but these side effects are mild and infrequent and similar to those caused by other ketone supplements.
Who Might Benefit from Ketone-IQ?
- Individuals following a strict low-carb diet: Ketone-IQ might be a good fit for those already in a state of ketosis and looking to further elevate their ketone levels.
- Those who experience benefits from elevated ketone levels: Some individuals may find that elevated ketone levels improve their mental clarity or energy levels.
- Endurance athletes and those practicing intermittent fasting: These individuals might find it useful for maintaining energy levels without relying on carbohydrates, though this is a contested point.
It is important to note that endurance athletes do not necessarily need to reduce their carbohydrate intake.
Who Should Avoid Ketone-IQ?
- Those expecting an immediate and noticeable difference in energy or performance: The effects of Ketone-IQ may be subtle and not noticeable for everyone.
- Those sensitive to the taste: The taste of Ketone-IQ has been described as unpleasant, and it may be a barrier to consistent use.
The Bigger Picture: Training, Nutrition, and Marginal Gains
It's important to remember that performance is a complex system made up of many different elements. Training, resting, and nutrition are still at the base of the pyramid. They’re the most critical pieces of the puzzle. Then comes the marginal gains, those smaller pieces that sit at the top of the pyramid. Pro teams use them successfully because they treat the basics savagely well. For amateurs, on the other hand, marginal gains don't have the same ROI as they have for pros.
Read also: Magnesium Supplements for Keto