When considering weight loss, individuals often envision achieving an "ideal" body weight or an ultimate weight-loss goal. However, scientific evidence demonstrates that even modest weight loss, as low as 5-10% of initial body weight, can yield significant health improvements. This article delves into the specific benefits associated with such weight reduction, highlighting the impact on various health markers and conditions.
The Power of 5-10% Weight Loss: A Clinically Meaningful Amount
A 5% weight loss from baseline is generally accepted as a “clinically meaningful” amount. The 2013 Obesity Guidelines recommended weight loss of 5-10% as the goal for medically supervised weight loss. Further, the US Food and Drug Administration Draft Guidance for medications for management of obesity has as one of the criteria for approval, that the medication achieve an average weight loss of 5% or greater than a placebo.
Understanding the Link Between Weight and Health
A BMI above 25 kg/m2 is associated with increased risk for mortality and cardiometabolic diseases, and the relationship demonstrates increasing risk with increasing BMI. Current thinking about how excess adiposity drives health risk is through several mechanistic pathways. Excess physical burden of body weight can play a role, especially in lower extremity arthritis and pain and in sleep apnea. Fat tissue itself is an active endocrine organ, secreting a number of adverse cytokines, including pro-inflammatory and pro-thrombotic molecules, among others. The “portal hypothesis” also maintains that free fatty acids released from visceral fat stores directly into the portal vein bathing the liver and contributing to the abnormal lipid profile and insulin resistance characteristic of metabolic syndrome. Circulating free fatty acids can also affect muscle insulin sensitivity.
Specific Health Benefits of Modest Weight Loss
1. Improved Glycemic Control and Diabetes Prevention
The health benefit of modest weight loss is best exemplified clinically in the relationship between weight loss and diabetes prevention. Even one or two kg of weight loss in persons at risk for developing type 2 diabetes (i.e. those with prediabetes) can have health benefits. The relationship between modest weight loss and improvement in glycemia is powerful and it is not limited to diabetes prevention. Improvement in fasting glucose and hemoglobin A1c is observed beginning at only ≥2<5% weight loss. Of course, greater weight loss was associated with greater benefit to glycemic outcomes in a direct and linear fashion. It must be noted that these benefits to glycemic measures were achieved alongside reductions in antidiabetic medications.
For individuals with impaired glucose tolerance, every kilogram of weight lost is associated with a 16% reduction in risk for progression to diabetes. After approximately 10 kg of weight loss, further reduction in diabetes risk is negligible.
Read also: Weight Loss & Excess Skin: Surgery Costs
2. Enhanced Cardiovascular Health
Data from the Look AHEAD Study also showed that health benefits of modest weight loss are not limited to glycemic measures. Improvement in triglycerides and systolic blood pressure begins with ≥2<5% weight loss. For diastolic blood pressure and HDL cholesterol, improvement begins at ≥5<10% weight loss. All of these risk factors improved in a direct and linear fashion with greater weight loss being associated with greater risk factor benefit. However, for LDL cholesterol, the relationship is less strong and in the Look AHEAD study, where baseline LDL was 100 mg/dl, there was no reduction in LDL. However, there was a reduction in use of lipid lowering medications in the modest weight loss group (average −8.7% at year 1) in this study.
A 5-10% weight loss can result in a five-point increase in HDL cholesterol, lowering the risk of heart disease. It can also decrease triglycerides by an average of 40 mg/dl. By losing 5-10% of one’s weight, blood pressure, both systolic and diastolic, decrease by 5 mmHg on average.
3. Alleviation of Sleep Apnea Symptoms
The Look AHEAD Study incorporated a substudy of sleep apnea, called Sleep AHEAD. More than 80% of the participants with type 2 diabetes in four sites of Look AHEAD had at least mild obstructive sleep apnea. Weight loss can be a major modifier of symptoms of obstructive sleep apnea as measured by the apnea hypopnea index, but 10% or more should be the goal to impact clinical symptoms. This larger amount of weight loss required for improvement may relate to the physical impingement on airway by excess body fat and it may take more proportional weight loss to impact symptoms.
A 5-10% weight loss may improve sleep apnea, potentially allowing individuals to wean off CPAP machines.
4. Reduced Risk of Certain Cancers
One study showed that older women who lost at least 5% of their body weight lowered their chances of breast cancer by 12%. There’s no such clear proof that losing weight protects you from other types, but some changes that happen when you shed pounds hint that it might. For example, overweight people who slim down have lower levels of some hormones linked to cancer, like estrogens, insulin, and androgens.
Read also: Adding Turmeric to Coffee
5. Improved Mobility and Reduced Joint Pain
Osteoarthritis of the knee is closely linked to obesity as a risk factor and is quite common. Nearly half of Americans are projected to experience osteoarthritis of at least one knee in their lifetime. Knee joint loads were also assessed in those patients and the investigators found that each pound of weight lost resulted in a 4-fold reduction in the load exerted on the knee per step during daily activities. Accumulated over thousands of steps per day, a reduction of this magnitude would appear to be clinically meaningful.
Each extra pound of weight adds four pounds of pressure on the knees and other lower body joints. Losing even a small amount of weight can ease these effects and reduce the likelihood of developing arthritis later in life.
Additional Benefits and Considerations
Beyond the specific improvements mentioned above, modest weight loss can also lead to:
- Enhanced mood and self-esteem: Weight loss may help chase your blues away. Scientists are still trying to work out why, but better body image and improved sleep may be part of the reason. In one study, depressed people who were very overweight felt better after they lost an average of 8% of their body weight.
- Increased energy levels and better sleep: Some studies have shown that not getting enough ZZZs can make you more likely to be obese. Others show that losing at least 5% of excess weight can lead to better sleep.
- Reduced inflammation: Fat cells, especially those around the belly, can release chemicals that irritate and inflame tissues all over the body. This is linked to health problems like arthritis, heart disease, heart attack, and stroke. Work toward a 10% weight loss goal, and you can lower the amount of these substances and cut your chances of having a serious illness.
- Improved sexual function: When you’re overweight, you typically have less sex. It might be because you just don’t feel good about your body. But it also may be that you have less desire and that even when you’re in the mood, your body doesn’t respond as well.
It is important to remember that individual results may vary. For some comorbid conditions, more weight loss is needed - 10% to 15% - to translate into clinical improvement. This is true with obstructive sleep apnea, and non-alcoholic steatotic hepatitis. There is a graded improvement in improvements in measures of quality of life, depression, mobility, sexual dysfunction, and urinary stress incontinence, whereby improvements are demonstrable with modest weight loss (5-10%) and with further weight loss there are further improvements. For polycystic ovarian syndrome and infertility, modest weight loss (beginning at 2-5%) can bring improvements in menstrual irregularities and fertility
Achieving Modest Weight Loss: A Practical Approach
Weight-loss starts with lifestyle changes: diet and exercise. The first step is to talk to your healthcare provider. They will help choose the diet that is most appropriate. To attain and maintain any amount of weight-loss, exercise is mandatory. Generally, an average of at least one hour, five days a week is needed. Scientists have shown over and over again that lifestyle changes that include an appropriate healthy diet and the right exercise regimen will help attain a 5-10 percent weight-loss. In addition, any legitimate weight-loss program should promote these lifestyle changes as the first step in attaining weight-loss.
Read also: Is Options Medical Weight Loss Affordable?
Here are some practical steps to consider:
- Consult with a healthcare professional: Discuss your weight loss goals and any underlying health conditions with your doctor.
- Set realistic goals: Aim for a 5-10% weight loss initially, focusing on sustainable lifestyle changes.
- Adopt a healthy eating plan: Focus on whole, unprocessed foods, including plenty of fruits, vegetables, and lean protein.
- Engage in regular physical activity: Aim for at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity exercise per week.
- Seek support: Connect with friends, family, or a weight loss group for encouragement and accountability.
Even Less Than 5%: Exploring the Benefits of Low-Level Weight Loss
While a 5% weight reduction is often seen as a key threshold, research suggests that even losing less than 5% of body weight can have positive effects on health outcomes. A systematic review of relevant literature showed that a majority of studies reported improvements in various health markers with less than 5% weight loss.
Improvements were noted in metabolic markers, cardiovascular markers, anthropometric measures, quality of life indices, inflammatory biomarkers, renal and hepatic markers, psychosocial and behavioural measures, and pulmonary function. These findings highlight the potential benefits of even small amounts of weight loss, particularly for individuals living with obesity.