A seemingly innocuous soft drink, Diet Mountain Dew, has recently found itself at the center of a heated debate: is it racist? This question has sparked discussions across social media and news outlets, prompting a deeper look into the brand's history, marketing strategies, and cultural impact. The controversy gained further attention when both vice presidential candidates in the 2024 election professed their love of Diet Mountain Dew, thrusting the beverage into the political spotlight. This article seeks to explore the various facets of this controversy, examining the arguments for and against the claim that Diet Mountain Dew has racist origins or implications.
The Rise of Diet Mountain Dew in the Political Arena
The issue gained national attention when Republican vice presidential candidate JD Vance made a joke tying racism to Diet Mountain Dew. At a rally in Ohio, Vance stated, "Democrats say that it is racist to believe - well, they say it’s racist to do anything. I had a Diet Mountain Dew yesterday and one today. I’m sure they’re going to call that racist, too." This comment, while intended as humorous, sparked confusion and debate, with some questioning the connection between the soda and racism.
Mountain Dew's Appalachian Roots and Stereotypes
To understand the context of Vance's joke, it's essential to delve into the history of Mountain Dew and its association with Appalachia. Created in 1930s Knoxville, Tennessee, by brothers Barney and Ally Harman, Mountain Dew was initially intended as a mixer for whiskey and moonshine, with the name "Mountain Dew" itself being a slang term for moonshine. The original branding featured mountain imagery, including a character named "Hillbilly Willy," and slogans like "It'll tickle your innards," solidifying the soda's association with Southern Appalachia. A historical marker even stands at 1921 E. Magnolia Ave. in Knoxville, commemorating "The Birthplace of Mountain Dew."
However, this association has also contributed to negative stereotypes. In the early 21st century, Mountain Dew underwent a major rebrand, associating itself with sports like skateboarding and video games. However, it also became associated with a phenomenon known as “Mountain Dew Mouth,” a term coined in Diane Sawyer's 2009 documentary Children of the Mountains. "Mountain Dew Mouth" describes severe tooth decay caused by excessive consumption of sugary soda, particularly prevalent in rural and poor Appalachian communities with limited access to medical resources.
JD Vance's personal connection to Appalachia further complicates the issue. His book, Hillbilly Elegy: A Memoir of a Family and Culture in Crisis, explores his childhood in a rust belt community and the challenges faced by those living in poverty. Vance's grandparents were from Jackson, Kentucky, in the Appalachian region, and he often visited them. This connection to Appalachia is central to Vance's political persona, but some argue that his portrayal of the region is an outsider's perspective that oversimplifies the complexities and resilience of Appalachian communities.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
Critics argue that Vance's lens of individual responsibility overlooks systemic issues and the strong sense of solidarity within these communities. Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear, for example, criticized Vance for his perceived shortcomings and for reportedly referring to Trump as "the next Hitler" behind closed doors, despite publicly supporting him.
The "Mountain Dew Mouth" Phenomenon
The term "Mountain Dew Mouth" has been used to describe the severe tooth decay often found in children and adults who consume excessive amounts of sugary drinks, particularly Mountain Dew. This phenomenon has been disproportionately observed in low-income communities, including those in Appalachia, where access to dental care is limited. The association of Mountain Dew with poor oral health has further stigmatized the beverage and its consumers. The link between the drink and its consumers has led to widespread misinformation and stereotypes about the health practices of communities of color.
PepsiCo's Response and Controversial Marketing Campaigns
PepsiCo, the owner of Mountain Dew, has faced criticism for some of its marketing campaigns. In one instance, the company pulled an ad called "Most Racist … In History" after an outspoken social critic, Boyce Watkins, condemned it for relying on "well-known racial stereotypes." The ad, directed by rapper Tyler, the Creator, featured a goat named Felicia in a police lineup with five black men, perpetuating harmful stereotypes about black men and crime. PepsiCo apologized for the ad and removed it from its online channels.
Is Diet Mountain Dew Racist? Unpacking the Arguments
The question of whether Diet Mountain Dew is racist is complex and multifaceted. While the soda itself is not inherently racist, its history, marketing, and associations have contributed to perceptions of racial bias.
Arguments for a racist association:
- Appalachian stereotypes: Mountain Dew's historical association with Appalachia, a region often stereotyped as poor and uneducated, can perpetuate negative stereotypes about its consumers.
- "Mountain Dew Mouth": The term "Mountain Dew Mouth" disproportionately affects low-income communities and reinforces negative stereotypes about their health habits.
- Lack of diverse representation: The lack of diverse representation in Diet Mountain Dew's advertising may contribute to the marginalization of certain racial groups.
- Controversial marketing campaigns: Some of PepsiCo's marketing campaigns have been criticized for perpetuating harmful racial stereotypes.
Arguments against a racist association:
- Broad appeal: Mountain Dew is a popular soda enjoyed by people of all races, economic classes, and geographic regions.
- Evolving marketing: Mountain Dew's marketing has evolved over time to appeal to a broader audience, including Gen Xers, extreme sports enthusiasts, and gamers.
- Individual choice: Consumers ultimately choose whether or not to drink Mountain Dew, and their choices should not be attributed to their race or ethnicity.
The Role of Corporate Responsibility and Inclusive Branding
The controversy surrounding Diet Mountain Dew highlights the importance of corporate responsibility and inclusive branding practices. Companies have a responsibility to ensure that their marketing campaigns do not perpetuate harmful stereotypes or contribute to social inequalities. To promote inclusive branding, companies can:
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
- Incorporate diverse representation: Feature individuals from a wide range of racial, ethnic, and cultural backgrounds in marketing campaigns.
- Provide cultural sensitivity training: Educate employees on cultural sensitivities and biases to avoid perpetuating stereotypes.
- Collaborate with community leaders: Engage with community leaders and cultural experts to gain insights into the potential impact of marketing strategies.
- Maintain transparency and accountability: Be transparent about marketing decisions and their potential cultural implications and be accountable for their impact on society.
The Power of Consumer Advocacy
Consumers also play a crucial role in driving change towards more inclusive branding. By actively engaging with brands, providing feedback, and supporting companies that prioritize cultural sensitivity, consumers can influence corporate behavior and encourage more responsible practices.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP