The English muffin stands as a versatile and beloved breakfast staple, finding its place in many morning routines. Its appeal lies in its adaptability, serving as a canvas for a wide array of toppings, from sweet jams and creamy cheeses to savory eggs and avocados. Even a simple spread of butter or nut butter can transform it into a satisfying snack. The key to a truly exceptional English muffin lies in its texture, characterized by those signature nooks and crannies that capture and hold melted butter, enhancing each bite. This article explores the landscape of English muffins, evaluating various brands and types to identify the healthiest and most delicious options available.
What Makes a Good English Muffin?
Before diving into specific brands, it's essential to define the characteristics of a high-quality English muffin. Several factors contribute to the overall experience:
- Texture: A good English muffin should possess a distinct lightness while maintaining the structural integrity to support toppings. The signature pockets are crucial, allowing butter or sauce to seep into the crevices without causing sogginess.
- Flavor: A balanced flavor profile with a hint of saltiness is desirable, setting it apart from other bread products. The flavor should be inoffensive yet distinctive, complementing both sweet and savory toppings.
- Structure: The muffin should be easy to split, preferably fork-split, with a well-defined structure that holds its shape when toasted and topped.
- Ingredients: For health-conscious consumers, the ingredient list is paramount. Whole grains, minimal additives, and absence of artificial ingredients are indicators of a healthier choice.
English Muffin Brands Review
Dave's Killer Bread English Muffins
Dave's Killer Bread consistently delivers high-quality baked goods, and their English muffins are no exception. They strike a harmonious balance between a soft, bread-like interior and the characteristic crispness of an English muffin. The nooks and crannies are perfectly formed, ensuring optimal butter retention. The aroma is enticing, boasting both yeasty and wheat notes. The flavor profile is complex yet approachable, featuring a blend of nutty and savory notes derived from five different grains. Although pricier than other brands, the superior flavor and consistency make them a top contender.
Thomas' Original English Muffins
Thomas' Original English Muffins are a classic choice, renowned for their consistent quality and readily available nature. These muffins feature the signature "nooks and crannies" that have become synonymous with English muffins. The aroma is reminiscent of a preferment, with a yeasty and fresh scent. When raw, the muffin has a sticky texture, almost as if the dough is unfinished. The light color and softness suggest that it is sold par-baked, requiring toasting to complete the cooking process. The cornmeal coating tends to detach easily. The flavor is subtly sweet and yeasty, providing a blank canvas for various toppings.
Thomas' Sourdough English Muffins
For those seeking a tangier flavor, Thomas' Sourdough English Muffins offer a delightful twist on the classic. The sourdough imparts a subtle sourness that elevates the overall taste profile. These muffins are also notably moist, addressing the dryness that can sometimes plague other English muffin varieties. The slightly sour taste gives these an edge over a lot of regular English muffins in the flavor department. “I think sometimes English muffins are a little dry for my taste,” Jordan said. “This isn’t dry at all.
Read also: Healthy Butter Choices
Trader Joe's English Muffins
Trader Joe's English Muffins offer a rustic appeal with crispy edges and a chewy interior. They possess a touch of tang, enhancing their flavor complexity. The nooks are just begging to become little pools of butter. We liked how rustic they seemed, despite clearly being mass produced by a major grocery store chain (TJ’s is good like that sometimes). They have nice crispy edges and a nice chewy interior. These aren’t sourdough, but they do have a touch of tang, which we like in an English muffin.
Kroger Sourdough English Muffins
Kroger's sourdough English muffins stand out for their moist texture and subtle tang, offering a budget-friendly alternative to name brands. Like other sourdough English muffins, they have just a touch more flavor than your standard English muffin and are pleasantly moist too, even without butter.
Bays English Muffins
Bays English Muffins are a nonconformist option with less pronounced nooks, making them ideal for slathering with peanut butter or using as hamburger buns, particularly for veggie burgers.
365 Whole Foods Market English Muffins
The muffins from Whole Foods house brand 365 have a texture that is chewy in a good way. “This one is chewy in a good way,” another taste tester said. Okay, this might be off-putting, but one of our taste testers said like the way these muffins from Whole Foods house brand 365 “tore apart like meat.”
Aldi's L'Oven Fresh English Muffins
Aldi's L'Oven Fresh English muffins offer an affordable option with a perfectly airy texture and ample pockets. Each bite is fresh and light, yet sturdy enough to hold toppings. The flavor is slightly sour, complementing butter or other spreads. However, they can be a bit dry, potentially due to being pre-frozen and thawed.
Read also: Achieving Optimal Health
Nature's Promise English Muffins
Nature's Promise, the organic wing of Stop & Shop's brand, offers sturdy and easy-to-split muffins. While not particularly special in flavor, they provide a reliable and organic option.
Old Fashion Hearth English Muffins
Old Fashion Hearth's muffins are wheat-based and have an attractive appearance. The strong, fresh smell of wheat is prominent, but the flavor of wheat can overshadow the other attributes of the muffin. If you like things that taste "healthy," this is a product that would be a great fit for your breakfast routine. Throw some organic, grass-fed Irish butter on it or slather it with some mashed avocado, and you've got yourself a deal.
Stop & Shop English Muffins
Stop & Shop's English muffins are considered too bready and lack the distinguished pockets of classic English muffins. The texture is doughy and mushy, though the saltiness improves the flavor.
Great Value English Muffins
Great Value English muffins have a good, classic English muffin structure with some nooks and crannies. However, they are more fluffy and airy than they should be and lack flavor, with a slight sourness.
Glutino's Gluten-Free English Muffins
Glutino's Gluten-Free English Muffins are a surprising find, with a cornmeal-like color and consistency. They are easily fork-split and have a taste that falls between cornbread and a normal English muffin. The corn-forward flavor limits the softness and lightness, and the mouthfeel is scratchy.
Read also: Comprehensive Weight Loss
Ezekiel English Muffins
Ezekiel English muffins are grainy and coarse, resembling Ezekiel bread products. The flavor is dense, woody, and under-salted. They lack nooks and crannies.
Panera Bread English Muffins
Panera Bread English muffins are tall but difficult to open and not perforated. The inside is bread-like with no pockets for butter. They lack flavor and are not a pleasant eating experience.
Canyon Bakehouse Gluten-Free English Muffins
Canyon Bakehouse Gluten-Free English Muffins are soft, fluffy, and ready to be crisped to perfection. They are made with a blend of gluten-free flours, seeds, and sweeteners.
Trader Joe's Gluten-Free English Muffins
These muffins have nice chew, and are exactly as soft and as fluffy as you’d want them to be. You could make a really good breakfast sandwich with these, minus the belly bloat.
Handmade English Muffins from Boston
According to the package, these English muffins are handmade in Boston, which makes it seem like they were made by a baker wearing a tricorn hat during the American Revolution. And that’s what they taste like, too. I was so dubious that these would be good because they’re really light on nooks and crannies. They don’t look impressive, but the taste and texture are a really pleasant surprise. They’re super soft and buttery in the center, almost doughy. It gives them chew and makes them taste super indulgent, which isn’t typical when it comes to English muffins.
Trader Joe's Big & White English Muffins
The look: Big and white, these English muffins were thick as bagels and seemed dense, with fewer holes than is optimal. The taste: Biting in, these tasted too bready and bland. They didn’t have a distinct flavor, and they were way too thick.
TJ’s English Muffins
TJ’s describes its English muffins as savory, soft, and slightly spongy. The taste: Slathered with butter, they tasted just okay. There was nothing objectionable about them, and they would be decent receptacles for any toppings.
Dave’s Killer Bread English Muffins
The look: Darker in color than all of the other English muffins I tried, these had a more wholesome, healthful appearance. The taste: Since I’m a fan of Dave’s other breads, I was a bit disappointed that this one did not wow me. It was very thick and chewy, with a slightly sour aftertaste.
Artisanal English Muffins from Boston
These artisanal English muffins are handmade by a company in Boston. The look: I was surprised that there were only four of these muffins per bag. They were very thick and golden and looked more like biscuits than English muffins. The taste: Thick, chewy, and buttery. These were delicious, but they definitely tasted more like thick biscuits.
English Muffin with giant crater-like holes
This option comes pre-sliced, which is nice. The look: They were round with giant crater-like holes to hold the butter. The taste: With a texture that looked like the surface of the moon, this English muffin did its best to deliver a buttery, bready bite that was not too doughy.
Gluten-Free Options
For individuals with gluten sensitivities or celiac disease, finding a palatable gluten-free English muffin can be a challenge. However, several brands have successfully created gluten-free versions that offer a satisfying experience.
- Canyon Bakehouse Gluten-Free English Muffins: These muffins are soft, fluffy, and ready to be crisped to perfection. They are made with a blend of gluten-free flours, seeds, and sweeteners.
- Trader Joe's Gluten-Free English Muffins: These muffins have nice chew, and are exactly as soft and as fluffy as you’d want them to be. You could make a really good breakfast sandwich with these, minus the belly bloat.
- Glutino's Gluten-Free English Muffins: Glutino's Gluten-Free English Muffins are a surprising find, with a cornmeal-like color and consistency. They are easily fork-split and have a taste that falls between cornbread and a normal English muffin. The corn-forward flavor limits the softness and lightness, and the mouthfeel is scratchy.
tags: #healthiest #english #muffins