The HCG (Human Chorionic Gonadotropin) diet is a controversial weight loss plan that combines a very low-calorie diet (VLCD) with the administration of the hormone HCG. This hormone is naturally produced in large quantities during pregnancy. The diet was first introduced by British physician A.T.W. Simeons in 1954. It promotes fast weight loss, but its safety and effectiveness have been widely debated and questioned by health professionals.
History and Origins
The HCG diet was conceived by Dr. Albert T. W. Simeons, who published his theories in a 1954 medical journal article. Simeons' initial idea stemmed from his work with young boys suffering from Fröhlich syndrome, a rare hormonal disorder leading to obesity. In 1971, he further detailed his approach in a book titled "Pounds & Inches: A New Approach to Obesity." The diet experienced a resurgence in popularity in 2009, fueled by increased online attention.
Dr. Simeons, born in London and a summa cum laude graduate of the University of Heidelberg in Germany, had extensive experience in tropical medicine and obesity. During his time in India between 1931 and 1949, he observed that undernourished women were still able to give birth to healthy babies, attributing this to the high levels of HCG in their bodies, which he believed facilitated the breakdown of fat reserves to nourish the fetus. This observation led him to experiment with low doses of HCG in combination with a restricted diet, noting significant weight loss in his patients with minimal hunger or side effects.
What is HCG?
Human Chorionic Gonadotropin (hCG) is a hormone naturally produced in the human placenta. It is composed of alpha and beta sub-units. The alpha sub-unit is essentially identical to the alpha sub-units of the human pituitary gonadotropins, lutenizing hormone(LH) and follicle-stimulating hormone(FSH). It is also similar to the alpha sub-unit of thyroid stimulating hormone(TSH). The beta sub-units of these hormones differ in amino acid sequence.
During pregnancy, the placenta produces hCG in large amounts, making it the hormone detected by pregnancy tests. Outside of pregnancy, hCG is used to treat medical conditions like infertility and hormone imbalances. However, lab-made versions of hCG are also found in weight loss products like lozenges, drops, and sprays, marketed with claims of boosting metabolism, reducing hunger, and promoting rapid weight loss when paired with a very low-calorie diet.
Read also: Is Elizabeth Taylor's Diet Book Worth It?
The HCG Diet Protocol
The HCG diet typically involves the following components:
- HCG Administration: Daily injections, sublingual drops, tablets, or sprays of HCG.
- Very Low-Calorie Diet (VLCD): A severely restricted diet, typically around 500 calories per day.
The diet is usually divided into three phases:
- Loading Phase: Lasting 2 days, this phase involves taking HCG while consuming high-calorie, high-fat foods. The intention is to "rev up" the metabolism and prepare the body for the subsequent weight loss phase.
- Weight Loss Phase: This is the most restrictive phase, lasting 3 to 6 weeks. It involves continuing HCG administration while limiting calorie intake to approximately 500 calories per day. The diet typically consists of two meals per day (lunch and dinner) with specific food choices.
- Maintenance Phase: Lasting 3 weeks, this phase involves discontinuing HCG and gradually increasing food intake while avoiding sugar and starch. The goal is to stabilize weight and establish new eating habits.
Dietary Restrictions and Preferences
The HCG diet imposes strict dietary restrictions during the weight loss phase. A typical meal plan includes:
- Protein: One portion of lean protein such as chicken breast, fish, lean beef, veal, lobster, crab, or shrimp (prepared by broiling or grilling without fat). Salmon, eel, tuna, herring, and dried or pickled fish are prohibited. The diet recommends 100 grams (about 3.5 ounces) of lean meat at lunch and dinner. All visible fat must be meticulously trimmed from the meat before cooking.
- Vegetables: One serving of specific vegetables like spinach, chard, chicory, beet greens, green salad, tomatoes, celery, fennel, onions, red radishes, cucumbers, asparagus, and cabbage. These vegetables can be eaten raw, steamed, or lightly sautéed in a small amount of water or sodium-free broth, never in oil or butter.
- Bread: One breadstick or one piece of Melba toast.
- Fruit: One serving of fruit, such as an orange, an apple, a handful of strawberries, or half a grapefruit.
- Beverages: Unlimited water, coffee, and tea. Up to 1 tablespoon of milk per day is allowed. Sugar substitutes (but not sugar) can be used to sweeten drinks. Butter and oils are strictly prohibited.
These restrictions can make it difficult for individuals with specific dietary preferences or needs to follow the diet. For example, vegetarians and vegans may find it challenging to obtain sufficient protein from approved sources.
Claims and Controversies
Proponents of the HCG diet claim that it offers several benefits, including:
Read also: Comprehensive guide to anti-inflammatory recipes
- Rapid weight loss (1-2 pounds per day) without hunger.
- Targeted fat loss from specific areas of the body (e.g., hips, belly, thighs).
- Preservation of lean muscle mass.
- Increased metabolism and energy levels.
- Reduced appetite and cravings.
However, these claims are largely unsupported by scientific evidence. Numerous studies have shown that any weight loss achieved on the HCG diet is primarily due to the severe calorie restriction, not the HCG hormone itself.
Scientific Evidence and Studies
Many studies have investigated the effectiveness of the HCG diet. A 1995 analysis of 24 studies found no evidence that the diet helps reduce hunger, promote weight loss, or trim fat from specific areas. Other research has shown that placebo injections are as effective as HCG injections for treating obesity.
One German study conducted in 1981 by Rabe et al. involved 82 premenopausal women who were randomly assigned to a diet with or without HCG injections. The study found significant weight reduction in both groups, but no differences in body weight, body proportions, or feelings of hunger between the HCG and non-HCG groups.
These studies consistently demonstrate that the HCG hormone does not provide any additional benefit beyond that achieved by calorie restriction alone.
FDA's Stance
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not approved HCG for weight loss. The agency warns against using over-the-counter (OTC) HCG products, stating that they are unregulated, contain unknown ingredients, and have not been proven safe or effective for weight loss. The FDA also considers the homeopathic claim on many of these products to be illegal.
Read also: A deep dive into the Suzanne Somers Diet.
Potential Risks and Side Effects
The HCG diet carries several potential risks and side effects, stemming from both the HCG hormone and the extremely low-calorie diet:
- Side Effects of HCG Injections: Allergic reactions, mood changes, acne, facial hair growth, headache, swelling of the breasts, penis, or testes, nausea, vomiting, and upset stomach, pelvic pain, and bloating.
- Side Effects of Extreme Calorie Restriction: Gallstones, electrolyte imbalance, abnormal heartbeat, fatigue, headaches, depression, and nutritional deficiencies.
The very low-calorie nature of the diet also makes it difficult to meet nutritional needs without supplementation. Consuming less than 1,200 calories a day can lead to vitamin and mineral deficiencies.
One case study from 2014 reported a 64-year-old woman on the HCG diet who developed blood clots in her leg and lungs, suggesting a potential link between the diet and thromboembolic events.
Safer Alternatives for Weight Loss
Given the lack of evidence supporting the efficacy and safety of the HCG diet, healthcare professionals recommend choosing safer and more sustainable weight loss methods. These include:
- Balanced Diet: A well-balanced diet that provides all essential nutrients without excessive calorie restriction.
- Regular Exercise: Physical activity helps burn calories, build muscle mass, and improve overall health.
- Lifestyle Changes: Making gradual and sustainable changes to eating habits and activity levels.
- Medical Supervision: Consulting with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian to develop a personalized weight loss plan.
For individuals who are obese and have medical conditions such as high blood pressure, doctors may sometimes recommend a very low-calorie diet (under 1,000 calories per day). However, these diets must be carefully supervised by a doctor to minimize the risk of complications.