Green tea and coffee are two of the most widely consumed beverages globally, each boasting a unique set of properties and purported health benefits. Both have garnered attention for their potential role in weight management, leading to the question: which one is superior for weight loss? This article delves into a comprehensive comparison of green tea and coffee, exploring their individual characteristics, mechanisms of action, and overall impact on weight loss.
Introduction: A Tale of Two Beverages
Green tea, celebrated for centuries, has gained prominence in the weight loss arena. Coffee, the energizing beverage of choice for many, also boasts potential weight-loss benefits. Understanding the nuances of each beverage is crucial to making an informed decision about incorporating them into a weight management plan.
What is Green Tea?
Green tea originates from the Camellia sinensis plant, the same source as other teas. However, unlike black tea, green tea leaves are not fermented. Instead, they undergo a steaming process at high temperatures to preserve their polyphenol content. Polyphenols, potent antioxidants, contribute to reducing inflammation and edema within the body. Green tea is especially rich in four catechins: epicatechin (EC), epigallocatechin (EGC), epicatechin gallate (ECG), and epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG). Of these four, EGCG is the most abundant, and it is thought to contribute most to the many health benefits of tea, according to a review.
What is Green Coffee?
Green coffee beans are essentially unroasted regular coffee beans. This lack of roasting preserves chlorogenic acid, a compound believed to stimulate metabolism and regulate blood sugar levels.
Green Tea vs. Green Coffee: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Antioxidant Content
Both green tea and green coffee are rich in antioxidants, which combat oxidative stress caused by free radicals in the body. Green tea is abundant in catechins, particularly epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), while green coffee boasts a high concentration of chlorogenic acid (CGA). These polyphenols contribute to the beverages' potential anticancer effects. For instance, EGCG may hinder tumor growth and spread, and it may lead to tumor cell death. Its anti-inflammatory effect may help prevent the chronic inflammation involved in the onset of cancer. On the other hand, CGA appears to inhibit tumor growth and promote cancer cell death.
Read also: Arizona Diet Green Tea Caffeine Levels
Caffeine Content
Caffeine, a stimulant drug naturally found in both coffee and tea, is a key factor in their effects on energy levels and metabolism. However, coffee generally contains more than three times the amount of caffeine than green tea. An 8-ounce (240 mL) serving of coffee provides 96 mg of caffeine, while the same amount of green tea provides 29 mg. Caffeine is one of the most studied substances, due to its multiple beneficial health effects. These include increased energy levels, alertness, attention, and wakefulness, lowered mental and physical fatigue, quickened reaction times and improved accuracy, enhanced exercise performance, improved memory and mood.
Flavor Profile
Green tea has a strong and bitter taste, while green coffee offers a milder flavor with an herbal sensation, lacking the harsh aftertaste of green tea.
Impact on Weight Loss
Both green coffee and green tea have a strong track record in terms of weight loss. Green tea's antioxidants and anti-inflammatory characteristics made it a popular weight-loss beverage in the past, but green coffee has recently taken over. Green coffee can help you lose weight faster without the need for a crash diet or a lot of exercise. The chlorogenic acid in green coffee is the key component that helps you lose weight and improve your overall health.
Coffee’s CGA and green tea’s EGCG, together with caffeine, provide both drinks with weight loss properties. Animal studies show that CGA may lower insulin, blood cholesterol, and triglycerides in the blood, as well as reducing weight and visceral fat. Visceral fat is the fat stored inside the abdomen around the organs. It’s linked to an increased risk of heart disease and diabetes. Similarly, animal studies show that EGCG also leads to weight loss and reduced visceral fat by promoting fat breakdown. It also helps promote the growth of beneficial bacteria in the gut, which help burn fat and improve insulin sensitivity, among other beneficial effects.
The Science Behind Weight Loss: How Tea and Coffee Work
Research suggests that tea may also play a direct role in weight loss. “Teas contain catechins, which can increase metabolism by stimulating the body to break fats down more quickly and burn more calories,” Koszyk says.
Read also: Why choose Green Massage?
Green Tea and Metabolism
The combination of caffeine and EGCG in green tea is believed to enhance metabolic rate, enabling the body to burn calories more efficiently. Some studies suggest that green tea can contribute to modest weight loss, particularly when the catechins and caffeine it contains join forces.
Green Tea and Fat Oxidation
Green tea may promote fat oxidation, further aiding in weight management.
Green Tea and Appetite Regulation
Some research indicates that green tea could subtly influence hunger hormones, leading to increased feelings of satiety.
Coffee and Calorie Burning
Caffeine, a natural stimulant present in coffee, can enhance metabolic rate, leading to increased calorie burn.
Coffee and Hunger Curbing
Coffee can suppress hunger, potentially reducing overall calorie intake.
Read also: Is a Massage Green Spa Membership Right for You?
Coffee and Workout Performance
Coffee can boost workout performance, enabling individuals to exercise more effectively and burn more calories.
Additional Benefits of Green Tea and Coffee
Green Tea
Evidence shows that green tea is associated with a reduced risk of stroke, diabetes, and depression. L-theanine is an amino acid naturally present in tea, including green tea. This compound is known to affect the brain, increasing feelings of calm alertness.
Coffee
Coffee is linked to reduced heart disease mortality.
Potential Downsides
Green Tea
Consuming too much caffeine is one potential downside of green tea, and may come with several detrimental effects. Regularly adding sugar to your tea may also lead to health issues. High-dose green tea extracts, often found in supplements, can pose a risk to the liver. Some cases of liver damage have been reported, particularly when consuming large amounts. Finally, green tea can interact with certain medications. For example, it might affect blood thinning medications due to its vitamin K content or alter how your body absorbs other drugs.
Coffee
Consuming too much caffeine is one potential downside of coffee, and may come with several detrimental effects. Regularly adding sugar to your coffee may also lead to health issues. There’s evidence that oils naturally present in coffee, including cafestol and kahweol, may increase blood cholesterol levels.
How to Prepare a Healthy Cup
Green Tea
Adding lemon juice to your tea. Test tube and animal studies show that adding lemon juice to your green tea may make its antioxidants more available to your body.
Coffee
Use a coffee filter. Paper filters help reduce the amount of cafestol from coffee, which is linked to increases in blood cholesterol levels. Switch your full fat milk or creamer to low fat milk. Making this simple change will help reduce your drink’s total calorie and fat content. Skip the sugar. Adding too much sugar, honey, syrups, or other sweeteners to your coffee or tea may turn them into less nutritious drinks. Add cinnamon or nutmeg to your coffee. Instead of using sugary syrups for flavor, add cinnamon or nutmeg to your coffee. These spices may help prevent and treat type 2 diabetes and obesity.
Dosage and Safety Considerations
Green Tea
Vázquez Cisneros et al. (2017) recommended a daily dose of 100-460 mg of epigallocatechin gallate plus 80-300 mg of caffeine a day over the course of 12 and more weeks. Yang et al. (2016, 2018) recommended 3-4 cups of strong tea (600-900 mg of catechins) a day for at least 8 weeks minimum.
Coffee
Metabolic effect is achieved at daily intake of minimum 510.6 mg of chlorogenic acid and 121.2 mg of caffeine (Sarriá et al. 2018). In Canada, considered a safe dose for adults are 400 mg of caffeine for one-time dose (Doepker et al. 2018).
Green Tea vs. Other Weight Loss Aids
Garcinia Cambogia
When considering safety and effectiveness, green tea tends to be a gentle option, especially when consumed as a brewed beverage. Then there’s Garcinia cambogia, a popular supplement known for its hydroxycitric acid, which some claim may help curb appetite and impede fat production.
Incorporating Green Tea and Coffee into Your Diet
Incorporating green tea into your daily routine can be both simple and enjoyable. Aim to consume one to three cups a day for a balanced approach. Morning or early afternoon may be ideal times, providing a gentle energy boost without disrupting your sleep later on. To keep your green tea experience as beneficial as possible, avoid sweeteners and creamers that can sneak in extra calories. Start your day with coffee to kick things into gear, then unwind with a calming cup of tea in the evening.