The pursuit of rapid weight loss has led to a proliferation of fad diets, often promoted through various advertisements claiming fast and easy results. These diets, while seemingly appealing, often lack scientific backing and can pose health risks.
What are Fad Diets?
Fad diets are weight loss plans that promise quick and dramatic results. Several claims have been made in the print and visual media about losing weight fast and maintaining a low weight with the help of a specific diet. They typically involve restrictive eating patterns or unusual combinations of foods. While initial weight loss may occur, these diets are generally difficult to sustain and may lead to nutrient deficiencies.
These diets are typically low in calcium, fibre, and plant proteins.
Examples of Fad Diets
Numerous fad diets have emerged over the years, each with its own unique approach and promises. Some common examples include:
The South Beach Diet: This diet focuses on controlling insulin levels through carbohydrate restriction.
Read also: The Hoxsey Diet
The Complete Scarsdale Medical Diet: A very low-calorie diet that limits fat intake.
The Grapefruit Diet (Magic Mayo Diet or Mayo Clinic Diet): This diet revolves around consuming grapefruit with every meal, based on the unproven belief that it has fat-burning properties.
The 3-Day Diet: An extremely low-calorie diet that promises quick weight loss in just three days.
The Dr. Atkins Diet Revolution: Advocates a high protein, high fat diet with low carbohydrates. One of the major problems with this diet, apart from the dangers of high protein diets, is that it places no limit on the amount of saturated-fat-laden products. This raises risk of heart disease.
The Pritikin Diet Plan and Save-Your-Life Diet: These claim to supply all nutrients needed at a controlled calorie level of around 400 calories.
Read also: Walnut Keto Guide
Miscellaneous Diets: Cider Vinegar, Lecithin, Vitamin B6 Diet, Kelp, Zen Macrobiotic Diet etc.
Dangers of Fad Diets
While fad diets may offer the allure of rapid weight loss, they often come with significant drawbacks:
Nutrient Deficiencies: Fad diets may be unhealthy - these diets often do not provide all the nutrients essential for survival. Many fad diets are low in essential nutrients like calcium, fiber, and plant proteins. This can lead to health problems over time.
Unsustainable: The restrictive nature of fad diets makes them difficult to follow for the long term. People often regain the weight they lost once they return to their normal eating habits.
Health Risks: Further rapid weight loss of over 3 pounds a week after the first few weeks increases risk of complications like gall stones and ketosis. Some fad diets, like the Dr. Atkins Diet, may increase the risk of heart disease due to their high saturated fat content. Low carb high protein diets are thus particularly harmful. Carbohydrates are the body’s main source of fuel and energy.
Read also: Weight Loss with Low-FODMAP
False Advertising: Marketers of fad weight-loss products often use deceptive advertising claims to peddle their products. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has taken action against companies making unsubstantiated weight-loss claims.
Misconceptions about Weight Loss
Many misconceptions surround weight loss and dieting. It is important to dispel these myths to promote healthy eating habits:
Skipping Meals: It is a myth that skipping a meal may help lose weight. Skipping meals may only serve to make one hungrier and lead to overeating at the next meal.
Expensive Healthy Eating: It is a wrong notion that healthy eating needs to be expensive. Eating better may sometimes be less expensive than unhealthy eating. However, canned or frozen fruits and vegetables are just as healthy and may be a low cost option.
"Low-Fat" or "Fat-Free" Foods: It is not true that all fad diets that recommend low fat or fat free foods can be low in calories. Many processed low-fat or fat-free foods have just as many calories as the full-fat versions of the same foods or may have more calories.
Weight Loss Without Exercise: A healthy or unhealthy fad diet without sufficient expenditure of calories in the form of regular physical exercise fails to reduce body weight.
Unhealthy Fast Foods: Fast foods need not be unhealthy - although many fast foods are unhealthy, a wise choice of these foods may be included in diet. Small portion size, nutrient rich and low in calories foods may be chosen for optimum diet plans. For example, a fresh fruit item or a non-fat yogurt for dessert is a good option. Toppings are best avoided. These include extra cheese, bacon, mayonnaise, salad dressings, tartar sauce, chocolate sauce etc. Further steamed or baked items may be chosen over fried ones.
Harmful Meat and Dairy: Meat is not harmful for health. Eating lean meat in small amounts can be healthy in fact. Similarly dairy products need not be fattening and unhealthy.
The Role of Diet Culture
Diet culture is so ubiquitous and normalized that many people accept it as truth and adopt dieting as a standard way of life. Diet culture discriminates against and oppresses people that don’t fit the narrow standard and disproportionately affects people with marginalized identities.
Examples of diet culture:
Extreme Celebrity Diets: Celebrities often turn to extreme and harmful measures to prepare for red carpet events in order to fit into designer clothing.
Influencer Promotions: Influencers (often with no credentials) that endorse weight loss supplements, detox teas, or meal replacement products, etc.
Lunchroom Diet Talk: Co-workers fixating on their diets, calories, or “good” vs.
"Clean Eating" Initiatives: These promote dietary styles that eliminate certain foods labeled as “impure” or “unhealthy.” Often not based on scientific evidence but rather on fear-mongering, these initiatives use emotionally charged, ambiguous claims to subtly impose moral judgments about food choices.
Wedding Weight Loss Pressures: The pervasive expectation that individuals, especially brides, must lose weight to fit into their wedding attire, often promoted through bridal magazines, fitness boot camps, and crash diets for weddings.
Identifying Diet Culture
It is important to be able to identify examples of diet culture in your life and why it’s important to recognize and challenge it. “Good” vs. Fear-Based Food Messaging: Identify messages that instill fear about certain types of foods or ingredients, suggesting that avoiding them is crucial for health.
On a societal level, by challenging diet culture, we work to dismantle the systems of oppression it upholds and pave the way for a more just and equitable world where all bodies are respected and valued beyond appearance.
Examples of Misleading Advertising
The advertising industry often employs deceptive tactics to promote food products, leading consumers to make unhealthy choices. Here are some examples:
Quaker Apples & Cinnamon Instant Oatmeal: The ad claims it's "heart-healthy," but it contains more sugar than apples.
Clif Bar: Marketed as a source of "wholesome" energy, but each bar has 250 calories and 16 grams of added sugar.
Land O’Frost Premium Meat: Advertised as "healthy protein," but processed meats are high in sodium and increase the risk of cancer.
Nature’s Bounty Advanced Hair, Skin & Nails Gummies and Jelly Beans: Claims to make you "shine from the inside out," but contains high doses of biotin that can interfere with lab tests.
Oui by Yoplait French Style Yogurt: Marketed as "subtly sweet," but contains more cane sugar than strawberries.
Truly Hard Seltzer: Claims to be made with "real fruit juice," but contains only 2 percent juice.
Knorr Pasta and Rice Sides: Advertised as "real meals" with no artificial flavors or preservatives, but are mostly cheap white rice or pasta with high sodium content.
Slice Soft Drink: Touts having 10 percent fruit juice, but the rest of the ingredients are questionable.
McDonald’s Supersized Meals: Promoted larger portions that contribute to overeating.
Tab Soft Drink: Marketed as sugar-free, but contains artificial sweeteners that can cause gastrointestinal distress.
Pringles: Emphasizes the addictive nature of processed and fried foods.
Caffeine-Free 7 Up: Focuses on the absence of caffeine, but caffeine has benefits for physical and mental performance.
Wendy’s: Raises questions about the quality and source of beef in fast food burgers.
Heinz Salad Cream: A high-calorie and high-fat salad dressing.
Sugar-free Jell-O: Contains sugar substitutes that can deepen cravings for sweets.
Josta Energy Drink: An early energy drink that has potential health risks.
Crystal Pepsi: A short-lived product that did not live up to its promise.
Spam Lite: Promotes the idea that fat is unhealthy, which is now known to be false.
tags: #fad #diet #advertisements #examples