The "Eat Right 4 Your Type" diet, also known as the blood type diet, suggests that tailoring your diet and lifestyle to your specific blood type can lead to improved health, weight management, and potentially slow down the aging process. This concept was popularized by naturopathic physician Dr. Peter J. D’Adamo in his book "Eat Right 4 Your Type," initially published in 1996. Since then, Dr. D’Adamo has released additional books expanding on the diet's principles, including "Live Right 4 Your Type" and "Change Your Genetic Destiny."
The Core Theory Behind the Blood Type Diet
The fundamental idea behind the Eat Right 4 Your Type diet is that blood types have evolved throughout human history, with each type being suited to different dietary patterns. According to this theory, the earliest humans predominantly had type O blood and were hunter-gatherers who consumed a diet rich in animal protein.
How the Blood Type Diet Works
Dr. D’Adamo's theory centers around lectins, which are protein components found in food. He suggests that these lectins can bind to antigens on blood cells, leading to blood cell clumping, or agglutination. By avoiding foods containing lectins that are incompatible with their blood type, individuals can supposedly improve their health, manage their weight more effectively, and reduce their risk of developing heart disease and cancer.
Liz Weinandy, RD, at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, notes that while lectins can be harmful in large amounts, their effects are often overstated. She explains that the potential harm from lectins can be minimized by properly preparing foods, such as soaking and boiling dried beans to eliminate lectins.
The blood type diet outlines specific dietary recommendations for individuals with blood types A, B, AB, and O. It also encourages exercise and healthy habits, such as adequate water intake. However, the diet's strict limitations on food choices for each blood type can be restrictive.
Read also: Learn about the multifaceted benefits of massage
Is There Scientific Evidence?
While the Eat Right 4 Your Type diet may lead to weight loss due to calorie restriction, there is limited scientific evidence to support the claim that it offers more significant health benefits than other dietary approaches. Critics argue that there is little scientific basis for the theory that eating according to blood type can improve health.
David Grotto, RD, questions the connection between clumping blood cells and weight, stating that while there may be a link to heart disease and blood clots, there is no scientific support for the connection between agglutination and obesity or cancer. Liz Weinandy agrees, noting that many of the book's claims are not scientifically proven.
One study found no evidence to support the blood type diet's claims that adherence could improve health and lower the risk of chronic disease. The researchers analyzed surveys from 1,455 participants and found that while some people benefited from following a particular diet, this was independent of their blood type. For example, individuals following the type A diet tended to have a lower body mass index (BMI) and blood pressure, regardless of their blood type.
Food Lists for Each Blood Type
For those interested in exploring the Eat Right 4 Your Type diet, here is an overview of the recommended foods for each blood type:
Type O
Individuals with type O blood, approximately 46% of the population, are advised to avoid wheat, dairy, caffeine, and alcohol. Instead, they should focus on consuming fruits, vegetables, and lean, organic meats. The type O diet is a high-protein diet that resembles something closer to the paleo diet.
Read also: Risks and Benefits of Dermaplaning on the Nose
Type A
People with type A blood are encouraged to follow a vegetarian diet that includes soy proteins, grains, and vegetables. They are also advised to eat organic and fresh food in its most natural state.
Type B
Those with type B blood are considered omnivores who can eat a variety of foods. However, they should avoid certain foods, such as corn, wheat, buckwheat, lentils, tomatoes, peanuts, sesame seeds, and chicken. Instead, they should opt for goat, lamb, mutton, rabbit, green vegetables, eggs, and low-fat dairy products.
Type AB
Individuals with type AB blood should choose tofu, seafood like mahi-mahi and salmon, dairy like yogurt and kefir, and green vegetables like kale and broccoli. They should avoid caffeine, alcohol, and smoked and cured meats and try to eat more small meals throughout the day.
Sample One-Day Menu for Each Blood Type
Here is a sample one-day diet for each blood type, based on D’Adamo’s recommended recipes:
Type O
- Breakfast: Two slices of organic bread with almond butter, vegetable juice, and a banana
- Lunch: A spinach salad with roast beef and fruit slices
- Snack: Fruit
- Dinner: Lamb stew with a variety of vegetables
- Dessert: Fruit salad
Type A
- Breakfast: Buckwheat pancakes topped with maple syrup, tahini, jam, or lemon juice
- Lunch: Curried peanut tempeh with carrots, celery, and broccoli
- Snack: Trail mix
- Dinner: Rice pasta with feta and greens
- Dessert: Crumb apple pie
Type B
- Breakfast: Oatmeal with unsalted butter or ghee
- Lunch: Indian curry salad
- Snack: Kale chips
- Dinner: Apple-braised lamb shoulder chops
- Dessert: Carob fudge
Type AB
- Breakfast: Silken tofu scramble with carrots and zucchini
- Lunch: Cream of mushroom soup
- Snack: White bean hummus with celery sticks
- Dinner: Grilled cod and veggies over apricot-walnut couscous
- Dessert: Flourless almond butter and raisin cookies
Potential Benefits of the Blood Type Diet
David Grotto acknowledges that the blood type A recommendations align with a plant-based diet, which is generally beneficial. He also notes that the Eat Right 4 Your Type diet can help people reduce calories and lose weight. Additionally, he mentions that some patients have reported feeling better after following the diet.
Read also: Diet Soda and Tooth Discoloration: What You Need to Know
Can the Blood Type Diet Help With Certain Conditions?
While there is some evidence that individuals with certain blood types may be more prone to specific illnesses, there is no scientific support for the theory that eating a diet tailored to a certain blood type has any effect on these conditions.
For example, individuals with type O blood may be at a greater risk for duodenal ulcers, while those with type A blood may have an increased risk for atrophic gastritis. However, Dr. David J.A. Jenkins states that there is no evidence to support the theory that eating a diet tailored to a certain blood type has any effect on these conditions.
Is the Blood Type Diet Safe?
There are concerns that the Eat Right 4 Your Type diet for those with blood type O may be too protein-heavy. Excessive consumption of animal protein, especially red meat, has been linked to health problems, such as heart disease and colorectal cancer.
Dietitians also suggest that individuals may experience nutritional deficiencies when following the eating plan. Amy Jamieson-Petonic notes that the diet recommends calcium supplements for type O and type A individuals who cannot consume dairy. However, she points out that calcium absorption from supplements is limited, and individuals may not obtain sufficient vitamins and minerals if they follow the diet for an extended period.
Another potential long-term issue with the blood type diet is the restrictive nature of the diet that can lead to boredom. David Grotto states that when favorite foods are eliminated, it can be detrimental to any dietary program, regardless of its scientific basis. He also suggests that the diet places too much emphasis on blood type and fails to consider individual differences.
Should You Try the Blood Type Diet?
Liz Weinandy emphasizes that any weight loss approach should be sustainable in the long term. While the blood type diet may work for some individuals, its restrictive nature may make it difficult to adhere to over time, potentially hindering long-term weight management.
For those curious about the potential benefits of the blood type diet, Weinandy suggests trying it for a short period. However, she stresses the importance of consuming wholesome, unprocessed foods and often recommends a Mediterranean diet or a DASH diet for overall health and weight loss.
Blood Type Diet vs. Genetic Diet Plan
The blood type diet is often compared to a genetic diet plan, with many people confusing the two. In the book, Eat Right 4 Your Type, Dr. Peter D'Adamo states that the optimal diet for any individual depends on that person's ABO blood type. He claims that each blood type represents genetic traits that our ancestors evolved to thrive on.
A genetic diet plan, on the other hand, uses your DNA as a science-backed guide for what you eat based on how you metabolize certain macronutrients, micronutrients, and substances. It is focused on eating as an individual-for your body, in particular.
How Does Eating for Your Genes Work?
Our bodies each have at least slightly varying needs, as we all respond differently to the world around us and metabolize nutrients differently. Studies say we can personalize nutrition based on our genetic health instead of taking a one-size-fits-all approach. This can be done by taking a look at our individual genetic variations.
These genetic variants and their outcomes have been thoroughly researched. After you’ve undergone a genetic health screening, you’ll have a better idea of which foods can provide the maximum benefit.
Disadvantages of Eating for Your Genes
The biggest shortcoming that comes with a genetic diet plan is that DNA test reports do not account for epigenetics or medical conditions. Thus, you should always combine this genetic diet plan with any additional medical information you have-such as blood test results-to determine your ideal diet.
A-Positive Blood Type Diet
According to Dr. D’Adamo, the A-positive blood type became prevalent during the early years of the agricultural age. He theorizes this is why people with this blood type can readily digest vegetables and carbohydrates, but have a difficult time digesting animal protein and fat. The A-positive blood type diet is primarily vegetarian. Dr. D’Adamo believes people with this blood type have less-than-robust immune systems and are prone to anxiety. His diet plan promises: weight loss, disease prevention, more energy, and better digestion.
Foods to Eat
- Soy protein, such as tofu
- Certain grains, such as spelt, hulled barley, and sprouted bread
- Walnuts, pumpkin seeds, and peanuts
- Olive oil
- Certain fruits, such as blueberries and elderberries
- Certain kinds of beans and legumes
- Certain vegetables, especially dark, leafy greens, such as kale, Swiss chard, and spinach
- Garlic and onions
- Cold-water fish, such as sardines and salmon
- Limited amounts of chicken and turkey
- Green tea
- Ginger
Foods to Avoid
- Beef
- Pork
- Lamb
- Cow’s milk
- Potatoes, yams, and sweet potatoes
- Certain vegetables, such as cabbage, eggplant, tomatoes, peppers, and mushrooms
- Lima beans
- Certain fruits, such as melons, oranges, strawberries, and mangos
- Poultry other than chicken and turkey, such as duck
- Venison
- Fish, such as bluefish, barracuda, haddock, herring, and catfish
- Some grains and grain products, such as wheat bran, multigrain bread, and durum wheat
- Refined sugar
- Refined carbohydrates, such as white flour and white bread
- Oils other than olive oil
- Artificial ingredients
- Most condiments
Medical Conditions
Medical conditions which D’Adamo states are associated with this blood type include: cancer, diabetes, anxiety disorders, and cardiovascular disease. However, there’s no scientific evidence that the blood-type diet works or that it alleviates any specific health conditions.
Is A+ Blood Special?
Having A-positive blood simply means that you’ve inherited it from your parents from various possible combinations. The positive marker is related to the presence of certain antigens in your blood along with a protein known as the rhesus (Rh) factor. There’s no scientific evidence that having A-positive blood is anything unique. In fact, it’s quite common. However, because it occurs in 36% of Americans, it means that it’s one of the types most easily to find or donate for a transfusion.
Can Blood Type A Eat Sugar?
The A-positive diet recommends avoiding refined sugar and foods that are high in sugar. There’s no evidence there’s a specific benefit from doing this for people with A-positive blood. That said, this is a common recommendation in other diets and by many nutritionists that is likely to benefit anyone.
Are Eggs OK for Blood Type A?
The A-positive diet also recommends limiting eggs. Eating them in small amounts during breakfast is optimal, according to the diet. There are some known risks associated with eating eggs. First, they may increase cholesterol, and eating one egg or more daily may be associated with the chance of developing certain cancers according to some research, however, these results were based on studies in a hospital setting.
That said, as with sugar, there is no evidence that eating or avoiding any food is specifically beneficial to a person with a particular blood type. Eggs are still a nutritious food that can be a good source of protein in any diet. In most cases, eating 1-2 eggs daily isn’t likely to be harmful for most young, healthy adults.