The Drinking Man's Diet, first published in 1964, has enjoyed enduring popularity, selling 2,400,000 copies in 13 languages. This article delves into the details of this unique approach to weight loss, examining its historical context, core principles, and practical applications.
Historical Context and Origins
In its day the Drinking Man's Diet was revolutionary and played to the finger snapping ethos of the cool guy at the Mad Men bar. Oddly enough, it morphed over time into a glimpse of the low carb Atkins/Paleo diets to come. The Drinking Man's Diet emerged in the 1960s, a period when fad diets were gaining traction in America, even though obesity rates were significantly lower than today. Robert Cameron, a San Francisco cosmetics executive, self-published the book in 1964. Cameron & Co. point out accurately enough that distilled liquors and unfortified wines contain negligible amounts of carbohydrates. Alcohol’s calories, they argue, just don’t count-they somehow disappear in a mysterious metabolic process.
It gained popularity for its focus on moderation and its allowance for alcoholic beverages, a departure from the restrictive diets of the time. The diet's premise was simple: limit carbohydrate intake while enjoying moderate amounts of alcohol.
Core Principles of the Drinking Man's Diet
The diet's central tenet revolves around restricting carbohydrate intake to under 60 grams per day. The premise of this diet is very simple - This is a diet for healthy people - so talk with your doctor first. And yes, you still have to exercise! The Drinking Man's Diet promotes moderation in drinking, as recommended by the Surgeon General of the United States. Under no circumstances does this book advise anyone to take up the use of alcoholic beverages, nor encourage anyone to persist in the use of those beverages if that is a personal problem.
Low Carbohydrate Intake
The cornerstone of the Drinking Man's Diet is the reduction of carbohydrates. This involves carefully selecting foods and beverages to minimize carb consumption.
Read also: Does Baking Soda Help You Lose Weight?
Moderate Alcohol Consumption
Unlike many diets that strictly prohibit alcohol, the Drinking Man's Diet acknowledges its place in social and cultural contexts, advocating for its consumption in moderation.
Balanced Approach
The diet emphasizes a balanced approach to food, encouraging the consumption of protein and fats alongside the restriction of carbohydrates.
Lifestyle Integration
The Drinking Man's Diet aims to integrate seamlessly into a person's lifestyle, allowing for flexibility and enjoyment without compromising weight loss goals.
Dietary Guidelines and Recommendations
The Drinking Man's Diet encourages moderation in drinking, as recommended by the Surgeon General of the United States. Under no circumstances does this book advise anyone to take up the use of alcoholic beverages, nor encourage anyone to persist in the use of those beverages if that is a personal problem. Similarly, nothing in this book should be construed as medical advice. Do not undertake any diet, without consulting your physician, if you are taking any medications or are being treated for any medical problem.
Food Choices
The diet permits a variety of foods. You can have fresh strawberries, eggs, bacon and toast for breakfast. There are plenty of fruits and vegetables allowed -and Roberts walks you thru what is a fairly 'painless' diet that works. Avoid sugar and starchy foods as though they were poison.
Read also: The Truth About Diet Soda
Beverage Selection
The Drinking Man's Diet advocates for consuming alcohol in moderation, defined as no more than one drink per day for women and two drinks per day for men. It’s also important to remember that alcohol can have negative effects on your health if consumed in excess. Drinking too much alcohol can lead to liver damage, high blood pressure, and an increased risk of certain cancers. Cameron & Co. point out accurately enough that distilled liquors and unfortified wines contain negligible amounts of carbohydrates. Alcohol’s calories, they argue, just don’t count-they somehow disappear in a mysterious metabolic process. The truth is that soon after alcohol gets out of the bottle and into a healthy liver, it goes through a series of complex processes, one product of which is a sugar (a carbohydrate). And if it is just used for energy, much of this may be turned into fat.
Sample Meal Plan
The ebook cost me a whopping $2.99 on Amazon. The basis of The Drinking Man’s Diet is similar to most low carb diets (Robert later took issue with the Atkins diet being “revolutionary” as his brilliant idea came first). But unlike the low-carb diets most of us know, there are a few differences: You can eat any meat or cheese you want-no low-fat restrictions here! And instead of avoiding all carbs, you are to limit your carb intake to 60 grams a day. The fact that it’s a set 60 grams, no matter the dieter, is one of many, many red flags. Now, the biggest exception to the low-carb diet is that The Drinking Man’s Diet allows-and promotes even-drinking hard liquor. Robert had a pitch I couldn’t say no to: “Drinkers of the world, throw away your defatted cottage cheese and your cabbage juice, and sit down with us to roast duck and Burgundy.
Potential Benefits and Drawbacks
Potential Benefits
- Weight Loss: By limiting carbohydrate intake, the diet can lead to weight loss through calorie restriction and metabolic changes.
- Flexibility: The allowance for alcohol and a variety of foods can make the diet more sustainable for some individuals.
- Simplicity: The diet's straightforward guidelines can be easy to follow.
Potential Drawbacks
- Nutritional Deficiencies: Restricting carbohydrates may lead to deficiencies in essential nutrients.
- Health Risks: Excessive alcohol consumption can pose health risks, including liver damage and addiction.
- Lack of Scientific Evidence: The diet's claims may not be supported by rigorous scientific research.
- Not Suitable for Everyone: Individuals with certain medical conditions or those who are pregnant or breastfeeding should avoid this diet.
The Drinking Man's Diet vs. Modern Low-Carb Diets
The Drinking Man's Diet probably did not start the low carb diet, but it did make it popular until, that is, Dr. A came along. Actually, the low carb diet first appears in history with the advice of a remarkable physician, William Harvey (not the Harvey who discovered the circulation of the blood, but a London physician) who advised a diet which consisted of "avoiding starch and saccharine matter" -in modern terms LO CARB. The patient lost 50 pounds and so will you. Since this concise wonder of an "indulgent" diet appeared (first published in 1964, ten years before Dr. Atkins came on the low-carb scene) and in stark contrast to Dr. A's copious 500 pages of dull and dry lecturing, it's been acclaimed for its validity. With all the low carb diet hype going on now, leave it to the food industry to find a way to exploit it! I highly recommend reading Roberts book FIRST -If you want a successful, simple, healthy way to use this diet- BEFORE you start buying all the so called low carb 'stuff' that is rapidly appearing on the food market shelves!
Similarities
- Both emphasize reducing carbohydrate intake.
Differences
- The Drinking Man's Diet specifically allows for moderate alcohol consumption.
- Modern low-carb diets often have more detailed guidelines and recommendations.
- The Drinking Man's Diet is less restrictive in terms of fat intake.
Expert Opinions and Scientific Research
Says Dr. Philip L. Some individuals on these low-carbohydrate diets may at first undergo a change in water balance, which might account for a loss of a few pounds.
Read also: Quitting Alcohol: A Path to Better Health