In recent years, the practice of fasting has garnered increased attention from researchers and the general public alike. Among the various approaches to fasting, circadian rhythm fasting has emerged as a specific type of eating schedule thought to provide multiple health benefits by aligning when you eat with your internal body clock. This article delves into the principles, benefits, potential risks, and practical strategies for implementing circadian rhythm fasting, also known as early time-restricted eating, to achieve weight loss and overall well-being.
Understanding Circadian Rhythms and Chrononutrition
Circadian rhythms are natural, daily cycles that the human body carries out, driven by a master clock in the brain and influenced by external factors such as light and food. These rhythms significantly affect various physiological processes, including sleep schedules, body temperature, hormone levels, and digestion.
Circadian rhythm fasting falls under the realm of chrononutrition, which is the study of how circadian rhythms and nutrition interrelate. Aligning meal times with one's circadian rhythm involves eating when it makes the most sense, considering the daily fluctuations of hormones like cortisol, insulin, and leptin.
Circadian Rhythm Fasting vs. Intermittent Fasting
Circadian rhythm fasting is a subtype of intermittent fasting (IF), but the two terms are not interchangeable. Intermittent fasting involves abstaining from eating for certain hours each day or certain days each week. In contrast, circadian rhythm fasting is a form of time-restricted eating (TRE) specifically aimed at aligning a person’s eating schedule with their natural circadian rhythm.
Unlike other types of intermittent fasting, time-restricted eating does not intentionally restrict the amount of calories a person consumes, only the hours during which they consume them. Different people might carry it out differently, as time-restricted eating does not involve one particular eating schedule.
Read also: Comprehensive Guide to Tea Fasting
How Circadian Rhythm Fasting Works
Circadian rhythm fasting confines meals to the earlier hours of the day, restricting the hours of the day you eat rather than the amount you eat. This practice can synchronize appetite with the circadian rhythm and improve metabolism. A typical circadian rhythm fasting schedule involves consuming all of one's food within a span of hours in the earlier part of the day, often between 8 am and 4 pm.
By aligning meal times with the circadian rhythm, individuals can optimize their metabolism, as meals are consumed at times when hormones related to eating, like ghrelin and adiponectin, are at their peaks. Some researchers hypothesize that an early time-restricted eating schedule could indirectly provide additional benefits by strengthening circadian rhythms.
Potential Benefits of Circadian Rhythm Fasting
While research on the specific benefits of circadian rhythm fasting is still emerging, several potential advantages have been identified.
Improved Weight Management
Even though people engaging in circadian rhythm fasting are allowed to eat as much food as they would like, they often end up consuming fewer calories. Eating within a specific timeframe can help avoid late-night snacking, which often contributes to an excess consumption of calories, a common cause of weight gain. Additionally, studies have found that people who are overweight or obese experience a reduction in appetite when practicing early time-restricted eating.
By "front-loading" calorie intake earlier in the day, individuals may experience better blood sugar control, increased satiety, and improved lipid profiles, all of which can contribute to weight management.
Read also: Benefits of the Fasting Mimicking Diet
Enhanced Metabolic Health
By aligning meal times with one’s circadian rhythm, a person can optimize their metabolism. Meals are consumed at times when hormones related to eating, like ghrelin and adiponectin, are at their peaks. As a result, early time-restricted eating could be a strategy employed to prevent or help manage diabetes, high blood pressure, and high cholesterol.
Blood Sugar Control
Eating a majority of calories earlier in the day can also help with blood sugar control, which in turn helps with weight management.
Improved Sleep Quality
Eating less than an hour before bedtime can increase the likelihood of waking up in the middle of the night, per a 2021 study from the British Journal of Nutrition. Since circadian rhythm fasting requires you to eat a few hours before your likely bedtime, you’re digesting your food before you hit the hay. So, in theory, your sleep could improve from the diet.
Hormonal Balance
“CRF is based on the idea of eating during daylight hours, when the body's metabolic processes are most efficient,” McDaniel says. When you first wake up, your body is surging with cortisol-the hormone is priming you to get moving and operate at full efficiency, according to 2021 research from the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. Circadian rhythm fasting ensures that your eating habits don’t screw with this natural ebb and flow-you eat when your body is already naturally energized, not when it’s winding down, so your body will digest food more efficiently. This can also help balance your hormones, leading to a better mood and higher energy levels.
Potential for Muscle Gain
Some research suggests that eating in alignment with your circadian rhythm may support muscle protein synthesis. The thinking is that, because you’re feeding your muscles when they’re most primed to receive fuel, that would be most conducive and beneficial to muscle growth. However, more research is needed to better understand the full impact of circadian rhythm fasting on muscle growth, McDaniel says.
Read also: Drinking Diet Coke Before Testing
Potential Risks and Considerations
While circadian rhythm fasting offers potential benefits, it's crucial to be aware of potential risks and considerations.
Initial Low Energy Levels
Transitioning to circadian rhythm fasting may result in low energy levels at first due to the time restriction of eating, but eventually most individuals will adapt.
Disordered Eating
Intermittent fasting (and therefore circadian rhythm fasting) can potentially lead to disordered eating because it “involves restricting eating windows, which can trigger unhealthy eating patterns for some individuals,” McDaniel says. So, it’s important to fuel yourself properly during your non-fasting window. “Not consuming enough calories and nutrients during the eating window can lead to nutrient deficiencies, and undesired mood changes, such as irritability,” Callins says.
Cardiovascular Risks
Restricting your eating window to eight hours might up a person’s risk of cardiovascular death, according to a 2024 study from the American Heart Association (although researchers aren’t entirely sure why). However, this study was pretty limited and didn’t take into account what the subjects were eating.
Misalignment with Circadian Rhythm
Setting personal eating times too late in the day could actually cause misalignment with the circadian rhythm. Research suggests that an eating schedule that is misaligned with one’s circadian rhythm can increase a person’s risk of becoming obese or developing metabolic problems, like insulin resistance.
Importance of Nutrient Intake
Not consuming enough calories and nutrients during the eating window can lead to nutrient deficiencies, and undesired mood changes, such as irritability.
How to Start Circadian Rhythm Fasting
If you decide to give circadian rhythm fasting a try, there are a few key considerations to keep in mind:
Consult with a healthcare professional: Talk to your doctor before beginning circadian rhythm fasting or any new eating plan.
Evaluate your lifestyle and relationship with food: An eating plan shouldn’t feel restrictive or stressful. If you know that not having your nightly sweet treat at a certain time of night might make you crave 20 of them, or you have a history of disordered eating, CRF might not be right for you.
Start with a gradual transition: If you are planning to try circadian rhythm fasting, I recommend transitioning your eating window gradually.
Eat intentionally: “Ensure your meals are balanced with healthy fats, lean proteins, carbohydrates, and fiber to keep you satiated and ensure you are meeting your daily calorie and protein needs,” Callins says.
Prioritize hydration: “It is possible for the body to become dehydrated during circadian rhythm fasting if you don’t consume enough hydrating foods or drink enough fluid daily,” says Callins. So, stay hydrated throughout the day and during your fasted hours-that will ensure bodily processes like digestion and body temperature regulation are working properly, she adds.
Time workouts strategically: if you can. This scheduling detail will help ensure you have enough fuel stored to meet the demands of whatever activity you’re about to do, Collins says.
Watch what you drink: Solid foods are not the only things you are avoiding during fasting hours.
Exercise regularly: Following an eating plan alone is not enough to promote good health.
Prioritize your sleep: Optimal sleep is an integral part of health. If you are looking to change your eating habits in order to improve sleep, know that diet and sleep are connected in ways beyond what time of day you eat.
The Gut Microbiome and Circadian Rhythm Fasting
Recent research has turned up new and intriguing connections between the gut microbiome and the circadian cycle. The gut microbiota is also reported to have an important impact on our health, it also appears to have a reciprocal relationship with the circadian rhythm and eating habits. Indeed, ingestion of food was found to alter the inherent diurnal rhythm of gut microbiome, with both the contents of food, and timing of feeding playing a role in this process. Furthermore, an earlier study pointed out that IF promoted white adipose browning and decreased obesity by shaping the gut flora.
Evolutionary Origins of Fasting-Related Health Benefits
The entry into fasting physiology that allows organisms to respond and adapt to starvation conditions first appeared in prokaryotes billions of years ago. This response represents one of the most potent examples of comprehensive cellular reprogramming and appears to be functioning in virtually all organisms.
In circadian rhythm-proficient organisms, the inherent circadian oscillator has programmed a natural cycle of feeding and fasting that occurs with ~24h periodicity. However, even oscillator proficient organisms have retained mechanisms to adapt to a few days of reduced or no energy intake without substantial loss of vitality.
Fasting Mimicking Diets (FMDs)
Understanding the mechanistic link between nutrients and the fasting benefits is leading to the identification of fasting mimicking diets (FMDs) that achieve changes similar to those caused by fasting. When mice, starting at 16 months of age, were switched to the 4 day FMD twice a month, they lost body weight and particularly visceral fat even though they consumed the same level of calories per month as mice in the control diet group.