The Ultimate Carnivore Diet Review: Benefits, Risks, and What You Need to Know!

The carnivore diet, a dietary approach centered exclusively on animal products, has garnered significant attention and sparked considerable debate in recent years. This article aims to provide a comprehensive review of the book "The Carnivore Diet" by Shawn Baker, offering a balanced perspective on its strengths, weaknesses, and overall contribution to the understanding of this controversial dietary regimen.

Introduction to the Carnivore Diet

The carnivore diet is a dietary regimen that involves consuming only animal products. It excludes all plant-based foods, meaning no fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, grains, or legumes are consumed. The primary components of the diet are meat, fish, eggs, and sometimes dairy. Proponents suggest it can lead to weight loss, improved mental clarity, and reduced inflammation, while critics raise concerns about nutrient deficiencies and long-term health risks.

Overview of "The Carnivore Diet" by Shawn Baker

In "The Carnivore Diet," Baker (2019) presents a comprehensive exploration of this dietary approach, drawing upon historical accounts, scientific studies, personal triumphs, and anecdotal evidence. The book comprises 11 chapters, an introduction, an epilogue, an appendix, and a list of references. It delves into various aspects of the carnivore diet, including evolutionary inputs, the nutritional value of meat, the potential downsides of plant toxins, practical guidance on getting started, character studies, anecdotal evidence, perspectives on veganism, environmental considerations, and additional resources.

Strengths of the Book

Comprehensive Resource for Beginners

"The Carnivore Diet" serves as an excellent resource for individuals considering adopting a carnivore diet. Whether motivated by health concerns or weight management goals, the book thoroughly explains the potential benefits, provides guidance on initiating the diet, and outlines what to expect during the transition. The book provides information that is easy to read and inspiring. Also includes resources at the end of the book that address various cuts of meat and safe cooking temperatures.

Addressing Common Concerns and Myths

Baker effectively addresses common criticisms and concerns associated with a meat-only diet. He debunks many myths about fiber, cholesterol, vitamin and mineral deficiencies that come along with people who question this specific lifestyle, in addition to the myth that vegetables are good for you. He goes into oxalates, lectins, phytic acid, and more - which are critical to avoid, especially for gut and kidney health. By providing counterarguments and scientific insights, Baker encourages readers to critically evaluate preconceived notions about nutrition.

Emphasis on Meat Quality

The book stresses the importance of eating the right kind of meat. While not explicitly detailed in the provided text, this likely refers to sourcing high-quality, nutrient-rich animal products, such as grass-fed beef or wild-caught fish, to maximize the potential benefits of the diet.

Personal Testimony and Anecdotal Evidence

One of the book’s strengths is Baker’s personal journey with the carnivore diet. His transformation, both in terms of health and athletic performance, provides a compelling narrative that will resonate with many readers. The testimonials and anecdotes are interesting, and the overall tone of the book is "since everything you've tried before was complicated and didn't work, why not try eating some steaks?".

Simplicity of the Diet

The carnivore diet, at its core, is simple: eat only animal products. Baker does a commendable job of explaining the nuances and potential benefits of this approach without overwhelming the reader with jargon.

Weaknesses of the Book

Potential Bias

As a staunch advocate of the carnivore diet, there are moments in the book where Baker’s enthusiasm might come across as bias. The author admits when he doesn’t have all the answers. It is easy to read, easy to follow and well written. While Baker cites various studies and research papers to support his claims (there are pages and pages of sources), a more balanced presentation of conflicting evidence might enhance the book's credibility.

Limited Scientific Rigor in Certain Areas

For some of the controversial topics, the author doesn’t provide strong evidence to support or refute a position and ultimately asks the reader to decide for themselves (e.g., eating raw versus cooked meat; nose-to-tail versus muscle meat; grass-fed versus grain-fed). The anecdotal stories are interesting but lack the scientific studies behind them.

Overemphasis on Combating Veganism

There is a lot of information to combat veganism, which seems excessive and overdone at times. While addressing the arguments against veganism can be relevant, dedicating a significant portion of the book to this topic may detract from the primary focus on the carnivore diet itself.

Not for Everyone

While the book does a good job of highlighting the benefits of the carnivore diet, it’s essential to note that this approach might not be suitable for everyone. Individual health conditions, dietary needs, and ethical considerations may make the carnivore diet an inappropriate choice for some individuals.

Key Principles of the Carnivore Diet According to Baker

Baker outlines several key principles for individuals embarking on the carnivore diet:

Take one day at a time: Focus on short-term goals and adjust the diet as needed based on individual responses. Find out what it takes for you to feel and function your best (p. 94).
Enjoy the process: Embrace the dietary change and find satisfaction in consuming animal products.
Eat enough: Consume sufficient quantities of meat to meet caloric and nutritional needs. Men should aim for approximately 2 pounds of meat per day, while women should consume around 1.5 pounds per day.
Don’t make comparisons: Recognize that every individual's experience with the carnivore diet is unique and avoid comparing progress to others. Every person’s journey is unique.
You’re eating for you: Prioritize personal dietary choices and avoid feeling pressured to defend them to others. Don’t feel you have to defend your dietary choices.
Focus on feasting: Emphasize consuming nutrient-dense animal products in abundance.
Not everything is diet related: Acknowledge that various factors beyond diet can influence health and well-being.

Foods to Include and Avoid

The carnivore diet emphasizes the consumption of animal products, including:

Beef, lamb, goat, chicken, turkey, deer, bison, fish, shellfish, pork, caribou, eggs
Primarily ruminant red meat and water

Foods to avoid include:

Non-animal foods (i.e., sugar, vegetable oils, soy, gluten, MSG, vegetables, fruits, etc.)
Limit alcohol
Limit coffee/tea

Dairy and spices are not predictable and may cause issues.

Insights and "Golden Nuggets" from the Book

Baker presents several thought-provoking insights throughout "The Carnivore Diet," including:

The limitations of observational studies: Baker quotes Professor John Ioannidis, MD, who notes that observational studies, which rely on self-reported dietary information, are often unreliable and can lead to misleading conclusions. Page 26, “The biggest problem is that the vast majority of studies are not experimental, randomized designs. Simply by observing what people eat-or even worse, what they recall they ate-and trying to link this to disease outcomes is moreover a waste of effort. These studies need to be largely abandoned. We’ve wasted enough resources and caused enough confusion” (Professor John Ioannidis, MD, 2018).
The acidity of human stomach acid: Baker highlights the highly acidic nature of human stomach acid, suggesting that it is well-suited for digesting meat and potentially scavenging. Page 37, “The stomach acid in a normal, healthy human is around 1.1 to 1.5, which is incredibly acidic and on par with scavenging animals such as the vulture and the hyena…Maintaining this super acid capacity requires a significant amount of energy resources, and it’s not likely that it occurred randomly in humans; there must be a reason for it…In addition to scavenging, it’s very likely that early humans also ate meat that they preserved via various methods…”
Vitamin C absorption on a carnivore diet: Baker argues that vitamin C absorption is more efficient on an all-meat diet, reducing the body's overall requirement for this nutrient. Page 51, “The upshot is that when you’re on an all-meat diet, vitamin C absorption is more efficient, and your body’s requirements for it go down. You get a sufficient amount of the vitamin from the food (meat) you eat, and you don’t get scurvy.
Unique nutrients in meat: Baker emphasizes that meat is rich in unique compounds, such as carnitine, carnosine, creatine, taurine, retinol, and vitamins B12, D3, and K2, which offer significant health benefits. Page 69, “Meat is rich in several unique compounds found exclusively, or almost exclusively, in animal-based foods. These compounds include carnitine, carnosine, creatine, taurine, retinol, and vitamins B12, D3, and K2. These compounds offer some tremendous benefits.”
The limited benefits of whole fruits and vegetables: Baker cites studies suggesting that whole fruits and vegetables may offer limited or no significant health benefits. Page 79, “There are about two dozen studies that look at actual trials on humans in which fruits or vegetables in their whole form were examined rather than an isolated plant compound being investigated in an epidemiologic or animal/cell culture study. The overall result of these studies is that whole fruits and vegetables show only limited or no significant benefit. In some cases, the effects are slightly deleterious, with vegetables being worse than fruits.”
The flaws of nutrition science: Baker criticizes nutrition science for its over-reliance on epidemiology and its tendency to confirm rather than refute initial findings. Page 79, “Nutrition science continues to make the same mistakes over and over again; we rely heavily on epidemiology and then merely try to use further study to confirm the findings rather than refute them.”
Leaky gut and its causes: Baker identifies plant oils, medications, supplements, grains, legumes, nightshade plants, dairy, and sweeteners as potential contributors to leaky gut syndrome. Page 85, Leaky gut is the most problematic due to (1) plant oils, medications, supplements; (2) grains, legumes, nightshade plants, dairy, and sweeteners
The positive effects of the carnivore diet: Baker notes that a carnivore diet can lead to reductions in blood pressure, insulin resistance, inflammation, and body fat. Page 85, “One of the most striking patterns that I see when people embark upon a carnivore diet is a reduction in blood pressure, insulin resistance, inflammation, and body fat. In general, improving all these factors reduces your risk for almost any disease.”
The importance of appetite control: Baker emphasizes the goal of achieving natural appetite control rather than relying on arbitrary numbers or fasting windows. Pages 94-97, Steps to get started, Page 100, How much to eat, Page 109, “Remember, your ultimate goal is to be in a position where appetite and eating are naturally controlled, and you’re not constrained by some arbitrary number or a predetermined fasting window.”
Cholesterol levels on a carnivore diet: Baker acknowledges that total and LDL cholesterol levels may be elevated on a carnivore diet but suggests that clinical function often remains good. Page 121, “When we look at the lipid number for a carnivore dieter, we often see elevated total and LDL cholesterol; this is not always the case, and often LDL/total cholesterol will be largely unchanged or even lower.”
Thyroid hormone levels on a carnivore diet: Baker notes that thyroid hormone levels, particularly T3, may appear low but that clinical function is typically unaffected. Page 124, “One interesting thing to note is that thyroid hormone, particularly T3 levels, may seem to be low, but the clinical function is noted to be good.

Alternative Perspectives: "Carnivore Diet Made Simple"

Another book, "Carnivore Diet Made Simple: The Ultimate Beginners Guide to Thriving on Meat-Based Diet," offers a similar perspective on the carnivore diet, emphasizing its potential to address issues such as fatigue, bloating, and cravings. This guide challenges conventional dietary wisdom, arguing that plants may be the "real enemy" due to their anti-nutrients.

Key Arguments of "Carnivore Diet Made Simple"

Meat as the most nutrient-dense food: The book asserts that meat is the most nutrient-dense food on Earth. Why Meat Is The Most Nutrient-Dense Food On Earth (Yes, Really)
The truth about anti-nutrients in plants: It highlights the potential harm of anti-nutrients in plants, such as lectins, oxalates, and phytic acid, which can cause gut irritation, hormonal imbalances, and inflammation. The Truth About Anti-Nutrients In Plants (And How They Sabotage Your Gut)
Practical guidance for starting the diet: The book provides practical advice on how to start the carnivore diet without shocking the system. How To Start The Carnivore Diet Without Shocking Your System
Meal plans and recipes: It includes a complete 7-day meal plan and meat-based recipes to help readers get started. A Complete 7-Day Meal Plan And Drool-Worthy Meat-Based Recipes To Get You Started
Addressing common objections: The book addresses common objections to the carnivore diet, such as concerns about fiber, vitamins, and heart health.

Community Reception and Reviews

Reviews of "The Carnivore Diet" and related books reveal a range of opinions and experiences. Some readers have found the book to be life-changing, reporting improved energy levels, weight loss, and overall well-being. Others appreciate the book's challenge to conventional nutrition wisdom and its emphasis on personal experimentation.

However, some reviewers express concerns about the book's potential bias, lack of scientific rigor in certain areas, and overemphasis on combating veganism. Some readers also find the anecdotal evidence unconvincing and prefer a more balanced presentation of the scientific literature.

Practical Considerations for Implementing the Carnivore Diet

For individuals considering the carnivore diet, it is essential to approach it with careful planning and consideration. Here are some practical tips:

Consult with a healthcare professional: Before making significant dietary changes, it is crucial to consult with a doctor or registered dietitian to assess individual health needs and potential risks.
Prioritize nutrient-dense animal products: Focus on consuming high-quality, nutrient-rich animal products, such as grass-fed beef, wild-caught fish, and organ meats, to maximize nutrient intake.
Monitor health markers: Regularly monitor blood pressure, cholesterol levels, and other relevant health markers to assess the diet's impact on overall health.
Address potential nutrient deficiencies: Be aware of potential nutrient deficiencies, such as vitamin C and certain micronutrients, and consider appropriate supplementation if necessary, under the guidance of a healthcare professional.
Listen to your body: Pay attention to individual responses to the diet and adjust as needed.

tags: #carnivore #diet #book #review