Obesity is a global health crisis, contributing to approximately four million deaths annually worldwide. Weight loss, achieved through creating an energy deficit, is often recommended as a primary treatment for overweight and obese individuals. While many embark on weight loss journeys, achieving optimal results can be challenging. This article explores the various factors that may hinder weight loss despite maintaining a calorie deficit, offering insights and potential solutions for those facing this frustrating situation.
Understanding the Basics of Weight Loss
The Energy Balance Equation
The cornerstone of weight loss is the principle of energy balance. Weight loss occurs when energy expenditure exceeds energy intake, forcing the body to tap into its energy reserves, primarily fat stores. This is achieved by either reducing calorie consumption through diet or increasing energy expenditure through physical activity, or a combination of both.
Defining "Not Losing Weight"
Before delving into the reasons for weight loss plateaus, it's important to define what constitutes "not losing weight." While there's no universally accepted definition, one approach defines individuals as not losing weight if they fail to lose 10% of their initial body weight.
Factors Affecting Weight Loss
Biological Factors
Genetic predisposition plays a significant role in obesity, with heritability estimated at 40-70%. Genetic variations can influence energy expenditure and/or intake, affecting weight loss outcomes. Genes like FTO, MC4R, PPARG, and MTIF3 may play a role.
Anthropometric factors, such as height, weight, body composition, size, and BMI, also influence weight loss. Taller or heavier individuals with more fat-free mass typically have a higher basal metabolic rate, potentially facilitating quicker weight loss.
Read also: Diet Before Bariatric Surgery
Metabolic adaptation, where resting metabolic rate drops in response to an energy deficit, can also hinder weight loss. This is a survival mechanism that reduces energy expenditure disproportionately to body mass reduction.
Hormonal changes after significant weight loss can also trigger appetite and reduce satiety, promoting positive energy balance.
Medical Conditions and Medications
Certain medical conditions and medications can impede weight loss efforts. Hypothyroidism, characterized by thyroid hormone deficiency, can affect metabolism. While the link between hypothyroidism and obesity is not fully clear, treatment of hypothyroidism has been shown to affect weight loss or related markers.
Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) can also contribute to weight gain and hinder weight loss in genetically predisposed individuals. While some studies suggest no significant difference in weight loss between women with and without PCOS, psychological factors like depression and low self-control may play a role.
Insulin therapy in diabetic individuals can trigger appetite, cause hypoglycemia, and increase body fat, affecting weight loss. Antidepressants have also been linked to obesity in observational studies, but further investigation is needed to determine their causal role and effect on weight loss outcomes. Bariatric surgeries and other major surgeries restricting movement, such as knee replacement surgeries, are also reviewed. The loss of weight after bariatric surgery might be due to the anatomical exclusion of the foregut which may lead to a hormonal upregulation of pancreatic peptide YY, glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) and gastric inhibitory polypeptide hormones. These factors will improve satiety and reduce hunger, as well as downregulate ghrelin with a subsequent decrease in food intake. As time proceeds, there will be changes in the levels of ghrelin, leptin and incretins diminish, resulting in weight regain as well as insufficient weight loss. Elderly patients will not lose as much weight as younger patients due to aging. Studies on other surgeries, like knee replacement surgeries that limit movement, were found to track weight gain, while the weight loss intervention results are very limited in this field.
Read also: Complete Guide to 1500 Calorie Vegan Meals
Studies indicate a negative correlation between higher BMI/body fat and lower vitamin D concentration. A placebo trial among overweight or obese women with vitamin D deficiency showed no significant difference in weight loss between those receiving oral vitamin D3 and the placebo.
Lifestyle Factors
Adherence to dietary and exercise recommendations is crucial for weight loss success. Studies have shown a significant association between self-reported adherence and weight loss. However, adhering to lifestyle interventions can be challenging, with adherence rates often declining over time. Factors such as lack of knowledge, insufficient education about diet, inability to afford healthy food, limited awareness of the benefits of dietary recommendations, stress, unrealistic weight loss expectations, poor self-confidence, and reduced motivation can negatively impact adherence.
Insufficient sleep is also linked to an increased risk of obesity. Sleep deprivation can increase appetite and alter the reward center of the brain, affecting self-control and leading to increased food intake.
Inadequate hydration can also hinder weight loss efforts. Studies have shown that drinking water before a meal can lead to a reduction in food intake.
Excessive alcohol consumption can also contribute to weight gain, as alcoholic beverages often contain empty calories and added sugar.
Read also: Healthy Vegetarian Eating
Stress raises levels of cortisol, which is linked to weight gain. A study on the effect that stress has on metabolic rate found that those who reported a higher number of stressors burned fewer calories at rest (resting energy expenditure) compared to those who reported fewer stressors. Investigations found they also had higher levels of both cortisol and insulin. Raised levels of insulin can lead to weight gain as the hormone regulates the absorption of sugar which the body will convert to fat when overloaded in the bloodstream.
Intervention-Related Factors
The intensity of the energy deficit can impact weight loss outcomes.
Short-term fluctuations in weight are also common and can be influenced by factors such as hormonal fluctuations, menopause, the time of day, and changes in diet, such as salt intake.
Environmental Factors
Environmental factors can also play a role in weight loss.
Common Reasons for Not Losing Weight in a Calorie Deficit
Calorie Intake Miscalculation
One of the primary reasons for not losing weight despite being in a calorie deficit is miscalculation of calorie intake. This can occur due to:
- Not counting calories at all: Underestimating the calorie content of healthy foods.
- Inaccurate food portion logging: Failing to weigh food and accurately identify serving sizes.
- Missing out on hidden calories: Neglecting to account for condiments, oils, added sugars, and sauces.
- Not tracking liquid calories: Overlooking the calorie content of beverages like soda and sugary drinks.
Overestimating Calorie Expenditure
Another common mistake is overestimating calorie expenditure, often relying on inaccurate fitness tracker outputs. Non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT), the energy spent on daily activities outside of exercise, can also decrease when dieting, leading to an overestimation of overall calorie expenditure.
Metabolic Adaptation
Prolonged calorie restriction can lead to metabolic adaptation, a reduction in energy expenditure that makes it harder to lose weight. This plateau occurs when the body tries to conserve energy and prevent further fat loss.
Hormonal Fluctuations
Hormonal levels can significantly impact weight. Hormones that encourage fat accumulation can hinder weight loss efforts. In women, hormonal fluctuations due to menstrual cycles can also affect weight.
Water Retention
Water retention can also mask weight loss. Factors such as insufficient liquid intake, excessive sodium and carbohydrate consumption, and hormonal fluctuations can cause water retention.
Medical Conditions
Certain medical conditions, such as PCOS, endometriosis, hormonal imbalances, and hypothyroidism, can influence fat storage and weight retention. Mental health issues like depression and anxiety can also contribute to food cravings and lower energy levels. Certain medications can also impact appetite and metabolic functions.
Unrealistic Expectations
Unrealistic expectations can lead to discouragement and abandonment of weight loss efforts. It's important to remember that quick results are unhealthy, ups and downs are normal, and weight fluctuations are expected.
Practical Tips to Overcome Weight Loss Plateaus
Reassess Energy Expenditure
Accurately assess your basal metabolic rate (BMR) and daily activity levels to determine your true energy expenditure.
Define Proper Calorie Goals
Set clear calorie goals that align with your energy expenditure, subtracting up to 500 calories per day to stimulate weight loss.
Improve Tracking Accuracy
Use a reliable calorie tracking app to log everything you eat and drink, including hidden calories. Invest in kitchen scales to measure portions accurately.
Reconsider Food Choices
Opt for healthy, nutrient-dense foods instead of junk food. Focus on foods with high protein and fiber content to satisfy your appetite.
Integrate Regular Exercise
Implement regular workouts to boost your metabolism and ensure fat loss while preserving muscle mass.
Adjust Daily Habits
Evaluate your lifestyle and habits, addressing factors such as stress, inadequate sleep, and lack of hydration. Incorporate self-care rituals to combat stress and food cravings.
Seek Medical Assistance
Consult with a healthcare provider to rule out any underlying health conditions that may be hindering weight loss.
Set Realistic Expectations
Understand that weight loss is a gradual process, and aim for a healthy rate of 1-2 pounds per week. Be aware of natural weight fluctuations and plateaus.
The Importance of Body Composition
Scale weight alone does not reflect overall health status. Body composition, which measures body fat percentage and muscle mass, provides a more accurate picture of health risks. Excess body fat, particularly abdominal fat, is strongly associated with increased risks of cardiovascular diseases, type 2 diabetes, and certain cancers. Therefore, focusing on improving body composition rather than solely on reducing scale weight is crucial.