Bright Line Eating Exposed: The Ultimate Critical Review You Can’t Miss!

Bright Line Eating (BLE), a weight loss approach developed by Susan Peirce Thompson, Ph.D., has garnered attention for its structured and rigid rules. This article examines the principles, potential benefits, and drawbacks of BLE, offering a comprehensive review for those considering this dietary approach.

What is Bright Line Eating?

Bright Line Eating is a diet and program created by Susan Peirce Thompson, who holds a Ph.D. in Brain and Cognitive Sciences. Thompson's approach is detailed in her 2017 book, "Bright Line Eating: The Science of Living Happy, Thin and Free.” BLE is rooted in the idea that “the brain blocks weight loss,” and its solution is to remove that obstruction. The program operates on the premise of establishing "bright lines" regarding food choices, aiming to eliminate willpower-dependent decisions.

The Four "Bright Lines"

The Bright Line Eating program has four main rules:

No Sugar: Foods containing any form of sugar, sweeteners, artificial sweeteners, or concentrated fruit juices are strictly forbidden.
No Flour: Also forbidden are foods containing any type of flour, including whole wheat flour, and flour made from any other grains, seeds, or nuts.
Three Meals, No Snacking: You must eat exactly three meals a day, absolutely no snacking, and no exceptions.
Weigh and Measure: You must weigh or measure every single thing you eat, forever. Heading to a restaurant? Pack your scale.

Components of a Bright Line Eating Meal

Bright Line Eating does provide guidance on what a day of meals looks like.

Breakfast: A protein, a grain, and a fruit
Lunch: A protein, vegetables, fruit and fat
Dinner: A protein, vegetables, salad and fat

Whole grains such as oats or brown rice are in bounds on this plan. Potatoes and sweet potatoes are also counted as a grain in the BLE universe. Grains should be limited to one ounce when measured dry. Proteins can include plant-based proteins such as tofu and tempeh, Greek yogurt, seeds, cheese, eggs, beef, chicken and any other animal protein, except bacon. Thompson says that when handling cooked proteins, you should measure your food after it’s been cooked, as meat can shrink by 25% to 50% during cooking. She also recommends checking the package carefully before using any processed meats such as hot dogs, sausage or bacon because sugar or flour is often added to these products. Fruit should be measured at about 6 ounces for a serving. Approved fruits include apples, kiwi, bananas, grapefruit, grapes, oranges, berries, apricots, pineapple and many others. Vegetables can include virtually any kind of vegetable, whether cooked or raw. If you’re cooking them, weigh your portion afterward because they often shrink during cooking. Canned or frozen veggies are fine, but check the package to be sure there’s no added sugar. When making an 8-ounce salad, start with about 2 to 3 ounces of lettuce and add another 5 to 6 ounces of various vegetables on top. Croutons and other flour-based crunchy additions are banned, and don’t add dried fruit or salad dressings that contain sugar or flour. If you’re using olive oil or another fat in your cooking, be sure to measure that out and count it as your fat serving for the meal. One tablespoon is a serving.

The Science Behind Bright Line Eating

Thompson cites research on social science and brain research studies, as well as her own academic background in cognitive science, to support her theories. She says that many people struggle with the cycle of yo-yo dieting because their brains block their efforts in three key ways which include the willpower gap, leptin resistance and overpowering cravings.

The Willpower Gap

Willpower, according to Thompson, is housed in the anterior cingulate cortex which runs on glucose, or blood sugar, and is highly sensitive to fluctuations in the levels of sugar in the body that it can draw on for energy. As you make decision after decision all day long, which uses up brain power and thus the body's energy, your blood sugar levels get depleted. In terms of dieting, this is when you might say "forget it" and give in to temptation. Learning to overcome that gap between waning willpower and the constant temptations of modern society creates the Thompson-termed willpower gap. Glucose, as well as prayer and meditation, social connection, sleep and gratitude, can help restore your brain’s ability to make healthy decisions, she argues.

Leptin Resistance

Insatiable hunger, or the drive to eat even when you’re already full, is linked to leptin resistance, Thompson notes. Leptin is a hormone that signals when you’re full, and when that signal isn’t transmitted properly, it can lead to overeating. Leptin resistance is also related to higher levels of insulin in the blood, which she says block the uptake of leptin in the brain stem, aka the “lizard brain,” where the base needs of survival are grounded. This puts the drive for survival in charge, which leads those who are susceptible to such urges to overeat.

Overpowering Cravings

Thompson writes that overpowering food cravings occur when the bingeing mechanism in the brain is triggered. This particular challenge originates in the nucleus accumbens, a section of the brain where pleasure resides. Over time, overindulging causes the nucleus accumbens to downregulate. In people with substance dependencies, this is when tolerance increases and you need more and more of the stimuli to elicit the desired effect. Eventually, the desired effect disappears all together, and the brain demands more and more of the stimulus just to maintain a sense of normal. The same thing happens with food addiction, Thompson argues.

Additional Components of the BLE Program

The BLE program also encourages detailed journaling of your daily food journey, both in planning for what to eat the next day and in recording what you did today. In addition to the books Thompson has written, there’s also a membership component to the Bright Line Eating approach, which provides access to all BLE courses and coaching and an online community of BLE followers. Video tools, written resources, meal plans, shopping lists and one-on-one calls are also available to members. Membership costs $39.99 per month on the monthly plan or $399.99 per year on the annual plan.

Evaluation of Bright Line Eating

Potential Benefits

Weight Loss: Many dieters have found weight loss success with BLE, as Thompson shows with various testimonials and case studies throughout her book. Participants in one study experienced 6.5% weight loss (SD = 5.2) with no significant difference across age groups (F = 1.5, P = 0.15).
Improved Psychosocial Factors: After completing the BLE Boot Camp program, 54.3% reported improved quality of life, 46.6% reported higher energy levels, and 60.4% described increased life satisfaction. Percent weight loss was associated with improvements in all of psychosocial factors that we examined (z = 13.8, P < .000; z = 13.5, P < .000; z = 12.4, P < .000).
Structure and Elimination of Decision Fatigue: The program's strict rules remove the need for constant decision-making about food, which can be beneficial for individuals who struggle with impulse control or find themselves overwhelmed by food choices. This is intended to bridge the willpower gap.

Criticisms and Drawbacks

Rigidity and Restriction: Many find BLE to be "extremely rigid”. The strict rules, such as eliminating entire food groups (sugar and flour) and adhering to a rigid meal schedule with no snacking, can be difficult to maintain long-term. The inflexibility of the program does not allow for any exceptions regarding portions or meal times.
Potential for Disordered Eating: Critics argue that BLE promotes disordered eating behaviors. The National Eating Disorder Association identifies characteristics of disordered eating. Many of the rules of BLE fit those characteristics. These include preoccupation with weight, food, calories, carbohydrates, fat grams, and dieting, refusal to eat certain foods, progressing to restrictions against whole categories of food (e.g., no carbohydrates, etc.), appearing uncomfortable eating around others, food rituals (e.g. eats only a particular food or food group [e.g. condiments], excessive chewing, doesn’t allow foods to touch), skipping meals or taking small portions of food at regular meals, any new practices with food or fad diets, including cutting out entire food groups (no sugar, no carbs, no dairy, vegetarianism/veganism), withdrawal from usual friends and activities, frequent dieting, extreme concern with body size and shape, and frequent checking in the mirror for perceived flaws in appearance and extreme mood swings.
Unsustainability: Imposing strict rules such as prohibiting snacks and added sugars isn’t sustainable or enjoyable. Labeling certain foods as prohibited will make us want them more, which simply defeats the purpose of a diet that is designed to address food addiction. The author admits that she created this Bright Line Eating Community in the last few years and then fell off the wagon so many times that she wondered if she should still lead the community. The program has a component called "Rezoom" which stands for "Resume" where you fall off the wagon and have to recommit.
Lack of Long-Term Data: Although the BLE program claims to have resulted in more weight loss for people than other methods, long-term data doesn’t even exist. The book came out in 2017, and the program and idea were developed just before that. The program is still in the honeymoon phase of the diet.
Contradictory Stance on Exercise: The BLE plan includes no specific requirements for exercise. In fact, Thompson writes that she discourages people from adopting a new exercise program within the first four or five months of being on the BLE program because it can drain your willpower levels. She also notes that some Bright Liners have struggled with exercise addiction in the past. She’s found that among people who’ve attended her Boot Camp sessions, “the people who insist on continuing to exercise lose the least amount of weight. They’re overtaxed. They can’t keep their lines bright, and it all unravels from there.”
Food Addiction Concept: The entire Bright Line Eating philosophy leans hard on the concept of food addiction. The idea that people can become literally addicted to food is highly controversial. Just because the taste of something sweet activates the same area of the brain that lights up in response to cocaine, it does not follow that this creates psychological or physiological dependence.
Cost: The BLE program has a membership component to the Bright Line Eating approach, which provides access to all BLE courses and coaching and an online community of BLE followers. Video tools, written resources, meal plans, shopping lists and one-on-one calls are also available to members. Membership costs $39.99 per month on the monthly plan or $399.99 per year on the annual plan.
Unhealthy Relationship with Food: This diet completely rejects your body’s internal cues and replaces them entirely with external rules. Thompson pushes the concept of a ‘right sized body’. We all exist within a range, and to call it ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ isn’t acceptable. If I gain 10 pounds, am I now ‘wrong’? Thompson tells followers that they need to achieve ‘food neutrality’, meaning neutral feelings about food. As in, no more being excited about eating.
Misleading Marketing: Brightline Eating is a marketing machine. All the online blog reviews of it contain multiple affiliate links, are obviously biased, and perhaps sponsored. The Amazon reviews of the book are overwhelmingly positive but when you look closely, many of them were written on the same exact date. And, although there are free videos of Thompson speaking her truths, you then need to pay to have access to everything else. This diet is endorsed by charlatans like Mark Hyman and Gary Taubes.

Is Bright Line Eating Right for You?

Bright Line Eating may appeal to individuals seeking a highly structured approach to weight loss with clear-cut rules. It may also appeal to those who feel they are addicted to certain foods. However, it is essential to consider the potential drawbacks, especially the risk of developing disordered eating patterns and the long-term sustainability of such a restrictive diet.

Before starting BLE, consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian is crucial, especially for individuals with a history of eating disorders or other health conditions. A more balanced and sustainable approach to weight management typically involves making gradual lifestyle changes, focusing on whole foods, and incorporating regular physical activity.

Alternatives to Bright Line Eating

Most dietitians suggest making small, incremental changes that can last a lifetime. Instead of slashing calories to drop weight as quickly as possible, they recommend you lose weight slowly and combine a healthy diet with plenty of physical activity. This approach tends to be a more sustainable way of losing weight and keeping it off for good.

Intuitive Eating: Intuitive Eating and food freedom does sometimes have the incorrect reputation of “only eat fun foods like fries and donuts,” it does mean that you’re allowed to have them whenever you want. Full permission means that you’ll end up wanting them sometimes, and fruits and veggies sometimes. Food freedom is having the foods that you want, when you want them.
Lifestyle Habits: Instead of focusing on weight loss as a goal, focus on lifestyle habits that are evidence-based to boost health and wellness. Eating fruits and veggies is a great idea, but that doesn’t mean that doughnuts or cookies are evil or should be banned. And just as important as what you eat, your relationship with your body, your eating, and letting go of food rules. Plus how much you sleep on a regular night, your stress levels, doing movement that you enjoy, time with friends and family, time in nature, and so on. You truly can be healthy at any size. And you can have unhealthy behaviors and beliefs at any size.
Balanced Diet with Physical Activity: A more balanced and sustainable approach to weight management typically involves making gradual lifestyle changes, focusing on whole foods, and incorporating regular physical activity.

Read also: Risks of Junk Food Consumption

tags: #bright #lines #diet #review