The blood type diet, also known as the blood group diet (BTD), gained popularity in 1996 with Dr. Peter D’Adamo’s book, “Eat Right 4 Your Type.” This diet suggests that your ABO blood group determines the best foods for you to eat, promising improved health and a decreased risk of chronic diseases. However, the scientific community largely views these claims with skepticism due to a lack of substantial supporting research.
The Core Principles of the Blood Type Diet
Dr. D’Adamo posits that each blood type reflects the genetic traits of our ancestors, indicating the diet they evolved to thrive on. This forms the basis for categorizing foods according to blood type:
- Type A (Agrarian): A predominantly vegetarian diet is recommended.
- Type B (Nomadic): A diet high in dairy is encouraged.
- Type AB (Enigma): A mix of type A and B diets is suggested.
- Type O (Hunter): A diet high in animal protein is considered ideal.
The diet also considers factors beyond food choices, such as condiments, spices, and exercise regimens, tailored to each blood type. For example, individuals with type O blood are advised to consume high-protein foods, including meat, vegetables, fish, and fruit, while limiting grains, beans, and legumes. Those with type A blood are encouraged to eat fruit, vegetables, tofu, seafood, turkey, and whole grains, but avoid meat. Type B individuals are recommended a diverse diet encompassing meat, fruit, dairy, seafood, and grains, while type AB individuals should focus on dairy, tofu, lamb, fish, grains, fruit, and vegetables.
The Lectin Theory
A central theory of the BTD revolves around lectins, proteins that bind to carbohydrate molecules. Plant-based lectins, sometimes called antinutrients, may cause adverse effects such as nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and abdominal pain. The BTD theory suggests that consuming the wrong types of lectins can target specific ABO blood types, causing red blood cells to agglutinate or clump together, potentially increasing the risk of disease. While some research indicates that a small percentage of lectins in raw, uncooked legumes may have blood-type-specific agglutinating activity, most agglutinating lectins react with all ABO blood types. This suggests that lectins in the diet may not be as blood-type specific as the BTD claims, except for a few varieties of raw legumes.
Examining the Evidence: Does the Blood Type Diet Work?
While many diets promise health benefits, the BTD's claims require careful scrutiny. Research on ABO blood types has advanced significantly, revealing associations between blood types and various diseases, such as hepatitis, thrombosis, cardiovascular diseases, cognitive disorders, circulatory system diseases, infections, and tuberculosis. However, no studies suggest that these associations are related to diet.
Read also: Is the Type O Diet Effective?
Minimal research supports Dr. D’Adamo’s claims that specific foods benefit or harm certain blood groups. A 2014 study involving 1,455 participants found that eating a type A diet of fruits and vegetables was associated with better health markers. However, this effect was seen in all participants following the type A diet, not just those with type A blood. Similarly, a 2018 study of 973 adults with overweight found that matching a participant’s blood type with the respective recommended BTD did not impact the link between BTD and markers of cardiometabolic disease. Furthermore, a 2020 study involving 68 participants of different blood types who ate a low-fat vegan diet for 16 weeks found no major differences in cardiometabolic changes between any of the groups.
These studies suggest that any health benefits observed on the BTD may be due to the emphasis on real, healthy foods rather than processed foods, rather than any specific interaction with blood type. In fact, the BTD removes the majority of unhealthy processed foods.
Criticisms and Counterarguments
Despite the lack of scientific support, the BTD has its advocates. Some argue that the absence of evidence does not prove ineffectiveness. Others claim to have experienced improved energy levels and resolution of chronic health problems after following the diet. It is important to note that such subjective experiences are not scientific evidence.
Critics also point out the restrictive nature of the diet. Eating based on your blood type requires you to know your blood type and then follow a restrictive diet. Personal preferences might be a problem: a vegetarian with type O blood may struggle to stay on the assigned diet, and people who love red meat may be disappointed to learn they have type A blood. Recommended supplements are not cheap; neither are the recommended organic foods.
Some proponents of the BTD argue that it can explain why some people succeed on high-protein fad diets while others fail (Type O individuals need more meat), or why the extremely low-fat vegetarian diet championed by Dr. Dean Ornish can be a good fit for one but not all four modern blood types (Type A's are the perfect candidates to eat a vegetarian diet).
Read also: Microneedling with PRP Explained
However, mainstream nutritionists emphasize that there is no one-size-fits-all diet. Individual genetic predispositions to cancer or heart disease are undeniable, but these are not necessarily linked to blood type.
A Subjective Experience
Some individuals who have tried the blood type diet have reported positive experiences. One reviewer noted a significant increase in energy levels within two days of changing their diet, along with improved sleep and a sense of clarity. They attributed these changes to avoiding foods on their "Avoid" list and focusing on foods on their "Highly Beneficial" and "Neutral" lists.
Another reviewer, who detested tomatoes, found that the BTD's explanation of why type A blood groups can't digest tomatoes due to insufficient stomach acid resonated with them. They also reported feeling much better after giving up milk, which the BTD identifies as an antigen that provokes the immune system.
These subjective experiences highlight the importance of bio-individuality in nutrition. What works for one person may not work for another, regardless of blood type.
Foods to Eat and Avoid
The BTD provides lists of foods to eat and avoid for each blood type. For example, type O individuals are advised to eat beef, lamb, seafood, broccoli, spinach, olive oil, and walnuts, while avoiding wheat, corn, kidney beans, cabbage, and dairy products. Type A individuals are encouraged to eat soy, grains, vegetables, pineapple, and olive oil, while avoiding beef, pork, dairy products, lima beans, and eggplant. Type B individuals are recommended to eat lamb, mutton, venison, dairy products, green vegetables, eggs, and olive oil, while avoiding chicken, corn, lentils, tomatoes, and peanuts. Type AB individuals are advised to eat seafood, tofu, dairy products, green vegetables, and olive oil, while avoiding beef, pork, kidney beans, corn, and caffeine.
Read also: Review of Diet Coke's flavor revamp
The Importance of Professional Guidance
Given the conflicting information and the lack of scientific consensus, it is crucial to consult with a healthcare professional before making significant dietary changes. A registered dietitian or nutritionist can help you develop a personalized nutrition plan based on your individual needs, health status, and preferences.
Blood Type Personality Traits
Some proponents of the BTD extend its claims beyond diet to include personality traits associated with each blood type. For example, type O individuals are described as healthy, confident, and leaders, with a deep-seated memory of a time when resources were abundant. Type A individuals are characterized as calm, cooperative, and organized, reflecting the need for harmony in agrarian societies. Type B individuals are seen as balanced, flexible, and creative, representing the nomadic lifestyle. Type AB individuals are described as rare, fascinating, and mysterious, embodying a combination of opposing traits.
However, these associations are not scientifically validated and should be regarded as speculative.