The journey to weight loss can be complex and multifaceted, especially for Black women. Despite the common advice of "eat less and exercise more," many find it challenging to achieve and maintain a healthy weight. This article explores the unique factors influencing weight management in Black women and provides practical tips for success.
Understanding the Challenges
Four out of five African-American women are overweight or obese, a rate higher than any other group's. A recent study from Columbia University found that more than one in four African-American women will likely die of obesity-related diseases. It's not for lack of trying, as many have experimented with various diets like Atkins, South Beach, and Weight Watchers.
Socioeconomic Factors
For years, it was believed that socioeconomics played a significant role in the higher obesity rate among African-American women. Many live in economically depressed neighborhoods with limited access to safe places to exercise, healthy food choices, and an abundance of fast food options. However, research indicates that African-Americans are disproportionately overweight and obese across all socioeconomic statuses, suggesting that other factors are at play.
The Black Women’s Health Study (BWHS)
The Black Women’s Health Study (BWHS) has been instrumental in understanding weight gain and loss among African-American women. For over 20 years, the Slone Epidemiology Center at Boston University has collected data from 59,000 Black women across various socioeconomic groups and regions.
One of the key findings from the BWHS is the age at which Black women are most likely to gain weight. While most women gain weight in the decade leading up to and after menopause (between ages 35 and 55), the BWHS found that overweight Black women tend to gain the majority of their weight a decade earlier, before age 35. This could be attributed to the fact that 60 to 70 percent of Black women have their first child before age 25, leading to substantial weight gain in the years following childbirth.
Read also: Dietary Habits of Black Phoebes
Stress and Racism
Atlanta health researcher Fleda Mask Jackson, Ph.D., suggests that the stress of racism and sexism in the workforce may also contribute to weight gain. Before their mid-twenties, many African-American women are supported within their communities, but they often face discrimination and stress when they transition into the workforce. This stress can affect their eating habits, sleep patterns, and exercise routines.
Participants in the BWHS were asked about their experiences with racism, and the data was compared with their weight gain over an eight-year period. The study found a higher weight gain in women who perceived the most racism, indicating that the body's response to chronic stress can lead to weight gain and obesity.
Strategies for Weight Loss
Given the unique challenges faced by Black women, a multifaceted approach is essential for successful weight loss.
Building Supportive Communities
“Black women need to be very deliberate about creating supportive communities for themselves,” says Jackson. Joining groups outside of work, such as church groups, sororities, gyms, or volunteer organizations, can provide a space for Black women to connect, share their experiences of racism, and hold each other accountable for their health goals. Research shows that support from friends can lead to more positive health behaviors than support from a spouse.
Addressing Superwoman Fatigue
Black women often juggle multiple responsibilities, including being primary breadwinners and caretakers for children, grandchildren, and elderly relatives. This can lead to fatigue and unhealthy patterns, such as emotional eating, dining in isolation late at night, or skipping meals, which can accelerate weight gain.
Read also: Rhino Diet Overview
Gayle Porter, Ph.D., and Marilyn Gaston, M.D., founders of the Gaston & Porter Health Improvement Center, address this issue in their Prime Time Sister Circles. These groups focus on improving fitness, nutrition, and stress management. Gaston and Porter encourage women to prioritize their health by asking them if they would walk 30 minutes a day to reduce their loved ones' risk of heart attack. If they would do it for their family, they should do it for themselves.
Prioritizing Sleep
Lack of sleep can significantly impact weight. Studies have shown that getting fewer than six hours of sleep a night increases the risk of obesity. A 2013 study from UC Berkeley found that sleep deprivation increases appetite and cravings for sugary and high-fat foods.
Fitness and nutrition expert JJ Virgin advises making sleep a priority by setting a strict bedtime and sticking to a routine. One hour before bedtime, turn off all electronics, and half an hour before, engage in relaxing activities like reading or taking a bath. Ten minutes before bed, practice deep breathing.
Counteracting the Thrifty Gene Hypothesis
The thrifty gene hypothesis suggests that certain genes, which may be more prevalent in African-Americans, respond to calorie-rich foods by storing weight. While this may have been beneficial in times of famine, it can be detrimental in a country with constant access to supersized meals.
Holly Lofton, M.D., director of the Medical Weight Management Program at NYU’s Langone Medical Center, notes that genetics can also determine where fat is stored in the body, which can impact heart health. However, exercise can overcome genetic predisposition and decrease the risk of weight-related health problems.
Read also: The Ultimate Guide to Black Beans and Keto
If you believe you are genetically predisposed to store fat more easily, make simple changes to your diet and increase your physical activity. Stay away from sugary and refined carbohydrates and build your diet around produce and protein. Begin meals with high-volume, low-calorie foods like a large salad to feel full. Identify 250 "negotiable calories" to eliminate from your diet, such as replacing one soda a day with water. Find physical activities that you enjoy and can incorporate into your daily life, such as walking briskly during your child’s soccer game or twerking to music while waiting for the laundry to dry.
Reducing Sugar and Refined Carbohydrates
Gary Taubes, founder of the Nutrition Science Initiative, argues that reducing sugar and refined carbohydrates is more effective for weight loss than simply counting calories. He suggests that a diet high in sugar and carbs is inherently more fattening than a diet with the same number of calories without the carbs.
Taubes maintains that African-Americans may be especially sensitive to the effects of sugar and carbohydrates because these foods have been in their diets for a shorter time than for people of European descent. He recommends eliminating sugar, refined carbs, and processed foods, and eating as much as you want of everything else.
Addressing Childhood Trauma
Nadine Burke Harris, M.D., CEO of the Center for Youth Wellness, emphasizes the impact of childhood trauma on health outcomes, including obesity. The Adverse Childhood Experiences study found that adults who experienced physical, emotional, or sexual abuse, neglect, or household dysfunction as children have a higher risk of being overweight or obese.
Trauma can cause the release of cortisol, leading to weight gain, and impact the pleasure center of the brain, causing individuals to crave high-sugar, high-fat foods.
The Role of Black Feminism and Womanism
Black Feminism and Womanism guide Black women and girls to survive and thrive by considering the role that gender and race play in different issues. Focusing on the full context of Black women’s lives can lead to better overall health. Obesity, specifically, is influenced by multiple factors, and treating obesity requires a focus on holistic health and well-being.
The Limitations of BMI
Body mass index (BMI) is widely used to assess women’s health and plan health improvements, but it is a poor proxy for general health because it fails to account for differences in body composition, fitness levels, and nutritional differences. People can be obese but in good health because of diet and physical activity. Alternatives to BMI include measuring total body fat and percentage of body fat, and measures of fitness over fatness.
The Importance of Physical Activity
Research increasingly points to measures of fitness over fatness as an indicator of health and well-being. People who are overweight or obese and who have good cardiorespiratory fitness have similar mortality rates to people with normal BMI and good cardiorespiratory fitness levels. A moderate level of physical activity can improve health regardless of whether a person loses weight.
Cultural Perceptions of Body Size
Among African American women, a common perception is that big is beautiful. Studies document this social norm, showing that often, although not always, African American women prefer a full and curvier shape than other US women. However, African American women frequently cite health as the most important reason to lose weight.
Community-Based Participatory Research (CBPR)
One approach that focuses on the whole person at all levels is community-based participatory research (CBPR). CBPR is a collaborative approach to research that equitably involves all partners in the research process and recognizes the unique strengths that each brings. The subjective experience of African American women as partners in research is needed to promote their strengths and to address the multiple dimensions that contribute to poor health and chronic disease.
Fat-Burning Foods for Black Women
Incorporating the right foods into Black women’s diets can be a game-changer for maintaining a healthy weight and boosting metabolism. The key to fat burning is choosing nutrient-dense foods that support metabolism, satiety, and energy levels while also complementing cultural dietary preferences.
Here are some fat-burning foods to consider:
- Avocados: Rich in heart-healthy monounsaturated fats and fiber.
- Leafy greens: Loaded with fiber, vitamins, and minerals, including calcium.
- Berries: Rich in antioxidants and fiber.
- Fatty fish: Loaded with omega-3 fatty acids and high-quality protein.
- Sweet potatoes: Have a low glycemic index, preventing spikes in blood sugar and insulin levels.
- Beans and lentils: Excellent plant-based sources of protein and fiber.
- Turmeric: Contains curcumin, known for its anti-inflammatory properties and potential to boost metabolism.
Culturally Adapted Weight Loss Programs
Project Take HEED (Healthy Eating and Exercise Decisions) culturally adapted an evidence-based dietary approach and exercise program to fit the female African-American population. Cultural adaptation included social and spiritual components. However, the treatment group had a high attrition rate. A new study will use at-home Web-based and virtual reality technology (avatars) in an attempt to enhance client motivation to persist in long-term weight management programs.
Key Factors for Successful Weight Loss Maintenance
Weight loss maintainers view positive support from others and active opposition to cultural norms as critical for maintenance. They struggle with weight regain but have strategies in place to lose weight again. Some maintainers struggle with being perceived as sick or too thin at their new weight. Regainers and maintainers struggle with hairstyle management during exercise.